Advice please- Historical Fiction Books

Discussion in 'The Literary Forum' started by lynnie, May 13, 2017.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. lynnie

    lynnie Puritan Board Senior


    My darling niece Hallie fell and broke her t2,t3, and t4 vertebra. She is in a neck and torso brace but is expected to make a full recovery, thank God. She was showing somebody a birds nest and fell.

    Hallie is 12, from a lovely Christian family, and is a voracious reader and very smart. Her Mom said she loves historical fiction. She has probably read the most well known books that come to mind, but if you have any ideas it would help me get her a present. Thanks!
    • Like Like x 1
    • Praying Praying x 1
    • List
  2. greenbaggins

    greenbaggins Administrator Staff Member

    Assuming that she has already read quantities of Henty and Ballantyne, I would go with Taylor Marshall's stuff. Pillar of Iron, Christie, etc.
  3. Romans922

    Romans922 Puritan Board Professor

    The Betrayal by Bond and Duncan's War by Bond are good historical fiction books.
  4. Edward

    Edward Puritan Board Doctor

    Gone with the Wind. She would learn more real history from that than she would in a college course. She might be a bit young for The Clansman - good history but poor science. Parental review would probably be needed for the second to see if she is mature enough for the issues discussed. The Sherlock Holmes series.
  5. BayouHuguenot

    BayouHuguenot Puritan Board Doctor

  6. lynnie

    lynnie Puritan Board Senior

    Thanks! I will run these past her Mom in case she read any. Will check out a few for me too :)
  7. TheOldCourse

    TheOldCourse Puritan Board Sophomore

    I second Scott, I've read probably six or seven of his books. It's fantastic historical fiction with much more value as literature than most modern works. The ones set in the highlands (like Rob Roy) can be a bit difficult to follow due to the heavy use of local dialect but there is a glossary in most of the books which is necessary for us Americans. Waverly is good, Ivanhoe is a classic, and I'd also recommend Quentin Durward, Rob Roy, and, with some reservation, Old Mortality which is regarded as his work with the greatest literary achievement. I would note with respect to Old Mortality that Scott was a "moderate Presbyterian" and could be quite critical of the covenanters and their strictness. In Old Mortality in particular his depiction of the covenanters and a sympathetic portrayal of the royalists is somewhat skewed from a historical perspective. Thomas M'Crie wrote a fairly scathing review of Old Mortality to that effect. It's still good literature, however, and a window, if an imperfect one, into the life of Scots of the time.
    Last edited: May 14, 2017
  8. BayouHuguenot

    BayouHuguenot Puritan Board Doctor

    Would Jane Austen count? Or are those more period pieces?
  9. ZackF

    ZackF Puritan Board Senior

  10. Timotheos

    Timotheos Puritan Board Freshman

    This book!

  11. Hamalas

    Hamalas whippersnapper

  12. Jack K

    Jack K Puritan Board Post-Graduate

    My son enjoyed Douglas Bond books at that age, but my daughter found them too boyish. She adored the Mysterious Benedict Society books. Those aren't really historical fiction, but they seem to appeal to smart pre- and young teens who like to read smart stories.
  13. lynnie

    lynnie Puritan Board Senior

    Many thanks to all.
  14. greenbaggins

    greenbaggins Administrator Staff Member

    The other advantage of the Mysterious Benedict Society books is that they are so thoroughly G-rated, that you don't have to worry about them. I would also recommend Brandon Sanderson's Alcatraz books, though they are not historical fiction, but fantasy lit. They are very entertaining, I have read them all to my kids out loud (he is writing a sixth book, which is good, as the fifth one does not seem like a good ending to the series).
  15. mgkortus

    mgkortus Puritan Board Freshman

    I whole-heartedly agree. My favorite is The Thunder on John Knox.
  16. Darlene N. Böcek

    Darlene N. Böcek Puritan Board Freshman

    Historical Fiction for an avid reader who is 12 years old? My kids like Jane Austen, and of course Jane Eyre was one of my favorites when I was a girl. Frankenstein is actually a deep, thought-provoking novel of the same time frame as Austen's books, which my teenage daughters also really liked. By the way, speaking of the classics, has free audiobook downloads for many books, including classics--we listened to Frankenstein thanks to LibriVox. Perhaps since she's laid-up this might be a way to keep her mind busy when her eyes get tired.

    I hesitate to say this, since I wrote it, but Trunk of Scrolls: A Family Adventure is made for older boys and girls and adults. You can see Goodreads for reviews. If she's reading Austen she'll be able to read this, since it's not young YA at all. But it's written from a Reformed perspective, dealing with the problem of pain and suffering and "where is God when it hurts." This might be what your granddaughter needs right now. Here's the link to find out more about the book: Trunk of Scrolls

    Trunk of Scrolls is endorsed by Dr. Michael Horton and Joel Beeke, among others.

    I hope your niece is feeling better soon. Sorry to hear about her breaking her neck. How frightening that must have been! May God bring about quick healing and a special time for her in the meanwhile.
  17. Logan

    Logan Puritan Board Junior

    Glad I'm not the only one who admits to thinking those books hilarious :)
  18. TheologiaCrucis

    TheologiaCrucis Puritan Board Freshman

    Robert Graves "I, Claudius" and "Claudius the God" are among the best historical fiction pieces written. It chronicles, as if written by the Emperor Claudius himself, his family history beginning with Augustus through his own death. It's incredible. Another marvelous book, that does the same sort of thing in a different context, is "I, Elizabeth" by Rosalind Miles. It does what Graves did with Claudius, except it traces the history of the Tutors from the perspective of Elizabeth. Both of these authors are/were historians and scholars in their topic, and their works are top-notch.
  19. Warren

    Warren Puritan Board Freshman

    Anne of Green Gables by Montgomery is probably more wholesome than Jane Eyre.

    Maybe she's ready for Master and Commander.
  20. LadyCalvinist

    LadyCalvinist Puritan Board Junior

    Has she read Treasure Island or Kidnapped by R.L. Stevenson? Also, Charlotte M. Yonge, a devout member of the Church of England in the nineteenth century, wrote a number of books that she might like. Dove in the Eagle's Nest, the Little Duke, and the Caged Lion are all books she might enjoy. Also, Anthony Hope wrote the Prisoner of Zenda which I enjoyed reading.
  21. lynnie

    lynnie Puritan Board Senior

    I sent this link to her Mom, and realized that I now have a great list for my own summer reading for several summers. So many good ideas.

    "I hesitate to say this, since I wrote it " I am glad you did, it got wonderful reviews and I am going to order one.
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page