Unshaven and anonymous
Who is Dreher and why should we care what he writes? Or, for that matter, who is Poe and why should we care what he likes or dislikes?who is Aitken and why should we regard him and what works he condemns and endorses
If this had been a serious question, the answer would be the quality of his work. If he assimilates good information and makes reasoned and thoughtful points on it, that is of value no matter what else is true about him.