Bible commentary

Status
Not open for further replies.
Timobe

Timobe

Puritan Board Freshman
Hello everyone,

I want to buy a full Bible commentary and I'd appreciate to have help from you all. I checked a site called "bestcommentaries" and that showed me a look around.

In fact, I'm a student of theology and I'm interested in languages, exegetic, good establishment of the text,... For example, I don't like NICOT because it doesn't have any establishment of the text... And I like to compare the versions LXX-Vulgate-MassoreticText for the OT and the manuscripts for the NT.

I know WBC and found that they are good and technical but the textual notes are really short. Then, I know also AB and there, I've found great textual notes but the commentaries on the text are not so good (and the site "bestcommentaries" doesn't seem to like AB !). What would be the best combination according to you ?

Plus, I'm really hesitating between real books or informatics books... Because, for example WBC (full 60 volumes) is sold at 449$ right now ! It's less costly, practical,... But I like to have the books in hands tough...

Thanks for your advices !
 
Hi Timobe,

Often the advice here is to skip the commentary sets due to uneven quality/value of research and content. The counter-advice is to purchase 1 or 2 of the best individual commentaries for each particular book. These range from standalone works to individual volumes of a set.

Ligonier has a list of recommended commentaries here: Top Commentaries on Every Book of the Bible by Nathan W. Bingham | Ligonier Ministries Blog

And our own Rev. Lane Keister (who has apparently read every commentary on the planet! :)) has several posts on his blog with his own recommendations, which may be accessed here: www.puritanboard.com/f78/one-two-best-commentaries-each-book-bible-in my opinion-28056/

Calvin, Henry, Poole, etc. are typically the exceptions to that advice.

Grace to you as you seek to know more of Christ through his precious Word.
 
Thank you very much for the advices and the encouragement reaganmarch ! These two links will be for sure helpful in my decision. And yes it seems that Rev. Lane has read every commentary on planet earth ! :)
 
Another thought regarding individual commentaries: consider buying as you go along. You may find your needs changing over the years, plus what's available will change. If you're looking to get a unifying picture, a good book on Biblical theology will do that for you.
 
I've purchased several commentaries based on Pastor Keister's recommendations and have been quite satisfied. I like purchasing individual books because you can get good specific commentaries for the specific book you are currently studying. Also, obviously it's much more cost effective this route. If you absolutely must buy a set, I'd probably suggest Calvin. You can always find Matthew Henry for free online.
 
Gill is an old standby. Gill frequently references the Vulgate, the LXX, and other early translations. I also consult Matthew Henry, and Jamieson, Fausset and Brown, and, less frequently, Calvin. I like Matthew Poole but have not found him on-line in a searchable format.
 
Mr. Yeutter,

Poole is available freely through e-Sword Bible software (along with Gill, Calvin, Henry, JFB, and a host of other conservative Reformational/Puritan commentaries).
 
reaganmarsh said:
Mr. Yeutter,

Poole is available freely through e-Sword Bible software (along with Gill, Calvin, Henry, JFB, and a host of other conservative Reformational/Puritan commentaries).
Click to expand...
Ja, I know; but I am a tightwad and do not want to purchase e-Sword when I already own the hardback edition of Poole. We are returning to the States in May. When I come back to Thailand, Poole will be in my suitcase.
 
kainos01 said:
reaganmarsh said:
Poole is available freely through e-Sword Bible software (along with Gill, Calvin, Henry, JFB, and a host of other conservative Reformational/Puritan commentaries)
Click to expand...
I don't think Poole's or Calvin's commentaries are available for free on e-Sword - but the ICR is free.

yeutter said:
I am a tightwad and do not want to purchase e-Sword
Click to expand...

e-Sword is free!
Click to expand...

Brothers, for your edification: Latest e-Sword Downloads, Modules, Utilities, and News - e-Sword News, Downloads, and Forums - www.BibleSupport.com

Enjoy. :)

(And I'm with you -- I much prefer my hardback edition of Matthew Poole! What a blessing to have such a fine work available to learn more of the meaning of the Scriptures!)
 
Have you considered H.A.W. Meyer? I've been told his NT commentary requires 30-40 hours a week of dedicated greek study. I plan to purchase the set sometime down the road but for now I just read it online.

In Christ,
Stu
 
kainos01 said:
reaganmarsh said:
Brothers, for your edification: Latest e-Sword Downloads, Modules, Utilities, and News - e-Sword News, Downloads, and Forums - Latest e-Sword Downloads, Modules, Utilities, and News - e-Sword News, Downloads, and Forums - www.BibleSupport.com

Enjoy. :)
Click to expand...

Great! Thanks, Reagan, I had only been looking at the "Download" link from within e-Sword. You just opened up a whole new source - I've already downloaded Calvin and Poole!
Click to expand...

I have found some gems on there...the problem can become, "What do I have time to read this week?" A good problem to have, for sure!

Grace to you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

B
  • Locked
what is the best linguistic bible commentary?
Replies
3
Views
3K
greenbaggins
greenbaggins
Reformed Covenanter
  • Locked
John Trapp's Commentary on the Holy Bible
Replies
7
Views
11K
VirginiaHuguenot
V
A.Hudson
  • Locked
Hermeneutics/Commentary
Replies
13
Views
4K
A.Hudson
A.Hudson
Gwallard
Inspired Commentary list
Replies
3
Views
600
Gwallard
Gwallard
S
  • Locked
Best commentary series?
Replies
13
Views
11K
Somerset
S
Back
Top