Does Refusing to Defend Oneself = Murder

Discussion in 'The Law of God' started by AlexanderHenderson1647, Sep 18, 2012.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. Jerusalem Blade

    Jerusalem Blade Puritan Board Post-Graduate

    Right you are, Tim. That would be a whole other matter.
  2. AlexanderHenderson1647

    AlexanderHenderson1647 Puritan Board Freshman

    Thanks for sharing that story of godly courage. It reminds me of John Paton and some of the threats and trials he endured. Thank the Lord that he providentially preserved you from that situation!
  3. Tim

    Tim Puritan Board Graduate

    Right, but I do acknowledge your dilemma at the time. I have often thought how people would perceive pastors and missionaries who defend themselves (as if they don't have as much right as anyone!).
  4. Alan D. Strange

    Alan D. Strange Puritan Board Junior

    I think that Steve notes an important consideration that is additional to all the qualifiers of Christopher in the OP: the question of whether one is acting as a private person (and thus defending loved ones and oneself) or whether one is acting in the office of, say, minister, in which one, as an ambassador of Christ, determines to act in the way that Steve did.

    At any rate, we should always seek to de-escalate a situation if possible (we are called to be peacemakers), turning the other cheek and doing the sorts of things commanded in the Sermon on the Mount. In other words, we should never repay evil for evil, returning insult for insult, that devolves to fisticuffs or more serious violence. Yes, we may defend ourselves and there are situations--home invasion, for example--in which we should be as savvy and wise about it as possible. But most of us, in most of our lives, do not encounter lethal force, but more likely encounter the kind of thing that we should not seek to meet in kind but rather dial back--a soft answer turneth away wrath. We have to be careful to not let our mindset of "we can meet lethal force with lethal force" influence our much less deadly encounters and prompt us to seek to "hold our ground" with our friends and colleagues by returning unkindness for unkindness, insult for insult. That is quite contrary to the spirit of the gospel and Steve is to be commended for his Christ-like way of handling a situation that he assessed as a minor kerfuffle and not one involving lethal force.

  5. Tim

    Tim Puritan Board Graduate

    Wise words, Dr. Strange. De-escalation can often be the best way.

    Yes. Deadly encounters are indeed rare and there are many more opportunities to turn the other cheek. Using deadly force is the last resort. And last really does mean last.
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page