dudley
Puritan Board Post-Graduate
I had a discussion with a Roman catholic teacher at school this week during lunch. He is interested in learning about Protestantism and asked me questions because he knows I left the RCC and became a Protestant. He said however that he thinks it is silly that Roman Catholics and Protestants have not been able to reconcile their differences after so many centuries. He believes the Protestant reformation is over…I said it is not over and he believes that someday Roman Catholics and Protestants will reconcile their differences and come to together again…I disagreed and said that it would never happen. I said to him that the main source of the diametrically opposed differences between the Roman Catholic Church and historic Protestantism rests in authority. Reconciliation and reunion between historic Protestants and Roman Catholics would require either that Catholics abandon the papacy and its traditions, or that Protestants surrender their bedrock conviction that Scripture is the only infallible rule of faith and practice. I said as a Protestant I now believe the issue of authority leaves no room for compromise. There can be no middle ground or appeasement.
I brought in the WCF the next day and showed him that in the Westminster Confession of Faith it clearly states the historic Protestant position on the question of authority:
The whole counsel of God concerning all things necessary for his own glory, man's salvation, faith and life, is either expressly set down in Scripture, or by good and necessary consequence may be deduced from Scripture: unto which nothing at any time is to be added, whether by new revelations of the Spirit, or traditions of men. (Westminster Confession of Faith, 1.6).
I told him that the additions to which the authors of the Confession refer to include not only the traditions of the papacy, but also the papal institution itself.
I said as long as Protestants and Catholics appeal to two different authorities, an unbridgeable abyss separates us.
I concluded my statements saying that I believe now the papacy is an evil institution and as a Protestant I renounce it , and the pope as well as Roman Catholicism. I would never concede to living under papal authority again.
I invited him to come with me to the third session of a six week course being given in my Presbyterian church on How Presbyterians are governed this Wednesday evening. I also invited him to join me at my bible class on Thursday night again taught in my Presbyterian church where we just stated the letters of Paul. We just started Romans. I a hoping he comes to the bible class, I think he will hear there that we are saved by faith alone. I know it is something he has never heard inn the RCC.
I am hoping he comes. He reiterated to me he believes the Protestant Reformation is over and we should all join in Ecumenical dialogue. I also told him I believe the Protestant Reformation is not over it is continuing in the 21st century. What do my PB brothers say and do you agree with my position?
I brought in the WCF the next day and showed him that in the Westminster Confession of Faith it clearly states the historic Protestant position on the question of authority:
The whole counsel of God concerning all things necessary for his own glory, man's salvation, faith and life, is either expressly set down in Scripture, or by good and necessary consequence may be deduced from Scripture: unto which nothing at any time is to be added, whether by new revelations of the Spirit, or traditions of men. (Westminster Confession of Faith, 1.6).
I told him that the additions to which the authors of the Confession refer to include not only the traditions of the papacy, but also the papal institution itself.
I said as long as Protestants and Catholics appeal to two different authorities, an unbridgeable abyss separates us.
I concluded my statements saying that I believe now the papacy is an evil institution and as a Protestant I renounce it , and the pope as well as Roman Catholicism. I would never concede to living under papal authority again.
I invited him to come with me to the third session of a six week course being given in my Presbyterian church on How Presbyterians are governed this Wednesday evening. I also invited him to join me at my bible class on Thursday night again taught in my Presbyterian church where we just stated the letters of Paul. We just started Romans. I a hoping he comes to the bible class, I think he will hear there that we are saved by faith alone. I know it is something he has never heard inn the RCC.
I am hoping he comes. He reiterated to me he believes the Protestant Reformation is over and we should all join in Ecumenical dialogue. I also told him I believe the Protestant Reformation is not over it is continuing in the 21st century. What do my PB brothers say and do you agree with my position?