To my understanding, Luther was never completely against the idea of having Protestant monastaries. In fact, I think he was planning on instituting some until at the end of his life he decided that it would be too difficult of a conception since the idea of monastaries is Romanized.
Now, this, in my opinion was a great aspect of the early church. It was entirely called for during the period (due to cultural situations etc.). But this is not the ideal for the entire church age. In fact, if our time in history does not call for it, we would be regressing and not fulfilling the cultural mandate that we have to reform society (and not stay behind walls).
But, if the time is right, monasticism can reform culture. I don't think this is the time though. We need Christian intellectuals to infilterate secular universities. And for Christian political thought to be active outside of our churches.
This is not the best time to withdraw from culture. But this is definitely a time to contemplate American culture. Or for the entire Western world for that matter. The impact of True Religion upon all of life is not at an all time high right now.
With the technology we have today, this (what I am about to say) may not be necessary (and that can be a powerful argument against what I am about to say), but could it be helpful for the Protestant world to develope places of study, maybe adopting some of the ideas from monastic antiquity?
By this, I mean, not the average seminary... But developing ancient themes of Christian life into a community of believers for a given amount of time... Certainly devoting your whole life to live by yourself somewhere is a waste. But I am talking from a time range of 1-10 years.
Is the average stay at a modern seminary enough? I would say absolutely not! I don't see anything wrong with allowing future ministers to stay in isolation (though still going into the world) for a space of time. This could be very benificial for developing the thought and lives of future ministers.
And not only for ministers, but for all those who wish to devote themselves to the contemplation of the Divine for a certain period of time, while putting off the immediates of life until heavenly things are taken care of. This can be seen throughout the church in the OT. There were always people devoting themselves to this life for a period of time.
thoughts??
Rembrandt
Now, this, in my opinion was a great aspect of the early church. It was entirely called for during the period (due to cultural situations etc.). But this is not the ideal for the entire church age. In fact, if our time in history does not call for it, we would be regressing and not fulfilling the cultural mandate that we have to reform society (and not stay behind walls).
But, if the time is right, monasticism can reform culture. I don't think this is the time though. We need Christian intellectuals to infilterate secular universities. And for Christian political thought to be active outside of our churches.
This is not the best time to withdraw from culture. But this is definitely a time to contemplate American culture. Or for the entire Western world for that matter. The impact of True Religion upon all of life is not at an all time high right now.
With the technology we have today, this (what I am about to say) may not be necessary (and that can be a powerful argument against what I am about to say), but could it be helpful for the Protestant world to develope places of study, maybe adopting some of the ideas from monastic antiquity?
By this, I mean, not the average seminary... But developing ancient themes of Christian life into a community of believers for a given amount of time... Certainly devoting your whole life to live by yourself somewhere is a waste. But I am talking from a time range of 1-10 years.
Is the average stay at a modern seminary enough? I would say absolutely not! I don't see anything wrong with allowing future ministers to stay in isolation (though still going into the world) for a space of time. This could be very benificial for developing the thought and lives of future ministers.
And not only for ministers, but for all those who wish to devote themselves to the contemplation of the Divine for a certain period of time, while putting off the immediates of life until heavenly things are taken care of. This can be seen throughout the church in the OT. There were always people devoting themselves to this life for a period of time.
thoughts??
Rembrandt