Edward
Puritanboard Commissioner
Preliminary ruling (subject to post trial briefing and a final determination) - Not guilty on all charges.
Quick takeaway - the presbytery comes out looking really bad as to how they handled things throughout the process. Some of the Central Illinois presbyters appear to be deserving of discipline.
I found the discussion of Charge 4 particularly interesting in its discussion on when litigation is appropriate against fellow believers. Folks here not particularly interested in intramural PCA politics might find meat for discussion on that point alone (starts on page 15). Please recall that a PB brother was involved in the process, and may not be in a position to defend or discuss things at this stage of the proceedings.