The Epic of Gilgamesh

Status
Not open for further replies.

RamistThomist

Puritanboard Clerk
The Epic of Gilgamesh. Trans. N. K. Sandars. New York: Penguin Books, 1972.

The story is fairly straightforward. What is more interesting is exploring how many parallels to Noah, Hercules, and Nimrod they are. In that exploration we will see new light shed on the nature of Nephilim, giants, and the common interface between Hebrew, Greek, and Assyro-Babylonian cultures.

Gilgamesh is a kind of apkallu. The apkallu were the guardians of esoteric knowledge, seven in number. They are similar to the Watchers in the Aramaic and Enochian traditions. But Gilgamesh is only ⅔ apkallu. This makes him more like a Nephilim than a Watcher.

That raises another question: is Gilgamesh an analogue to Hercules or Nimrod? It’s hard to prove (or disprove!) that, but it is not an impossible supposition.

Did Moses copy the Gilgamesh epic? Even critical scholars today are backing off that. For one, it’s very difficult, especially regarding ancient material, to pinpoint a 1:1 plagiarism. Nonetheless, we shouldn’t ignore the similarities and their polemical value. Brian Godawa does a great job summarizing Gordon Wenham’s research:

1. Divine decision to destroy

2. Warning to flood hero

3. Command to build ark

4. Hero’s obedience

5. Command to enter

6. Entry

7. Closing door

8. Description of flood

9. Destruction of life

10. End of rain, etc.

11. Ark grounding on mountain

12. Hero opens window

13. Birds’ reconnaissance

14. Exit

15. Sacrifice

16. Divine smelling of sacrifice

17. Blessing on flood hero

Notes from the text:

It is interesting there are vampiric elements in this culture, as Enkidu relates his dream to Gilgamesh: “His was a vampire-face” (92).

Gordon J. Wenham, “The Coherence of the Flood Narrative,” Vetus Testamentum 28, no. 3 (1978)
 
This new english version is a delight to listen to: https://www.audible.com/pd/Gilgames...a7-13cef5d729fe&pf_rd_r=SD1M3KQSJ5E79ZG0NJ0X&

My son and I listened to it.

We've already decided that the next dog we get we are going to name Humbaba.

Do you think Gilgamesh was a real person? And that he might have met Noah in his old age?

In the Sumerian king list, Gilgamesh is listed as the fifth king ruling after the flood.

This is a great book that gives a good perspective on these earlier myths
https://tentsofshem.wordpress.com/2018/02/26/review-the-great-inception-satans-psyops/
 
Annus, Amar. 1999. “Are there Greek Rephaim? On the Etymology of Greek Meropes and Titanes.” Ugarit-Forschungen 31:13-30.

–. 2010. “On the Origin of Watchers: A comparative study of the antediluvian wisdom in Mesopotamian and Jewish Traditions.” Journal for the Study of Pseudipigrapha 19 (4): 277-320.

Toon, K. van der. “Nimrod Before and After the bible.” Harvard Theological Review 83: 1-29.
 
One of my favorite books is a Gilgamesh verse narrative by Herbert Mason. I haven't reread it in a few years but I remember that it spoke to me especially about this hope of overcoming death, for which the hero was inadequate -- the isolation even of God when fellowship is fleeting through death -- and how Gilgamesh turns his focus on building (what will ultimately also be subject to decay -- but like Ecclesiastes: work is a gift to keep us occupied so we aren't overcome with the sense of our mortality). Do you think this is something Mason conveyed from the original or brought from his own experience? I know he wrote his version working through an experience of loss.
 
This is a great book that gives a good perspective on these earlier myths
https://tentsofshem.wordpress.com/2018/02/26/review-the-great-inception-satans-psyops/
I just read that book. I liked it.

My guilty pleasure is buying bible prophecy and conspiracy books.

Maybe we ARE all going to be Micro-chipped for the New world Order and demons will return posing at ETs and (the Nephilim, just as in the days of Noah) will come at the end of the world....

...I remain speculative about eschatology, but watching the news does sometimes lead me to think about Hal Lindsey-esque scenarios.


...p.s. chem-trails are real, by the way! The gov't is seeding our sky with metals and chemicals.
 
My guilty pleasure is buying bible prophecy and conspiracy books.

Derek is a good guy. While he has some seemingly goofy tangents, he is remarkably up-to-date on recent biblical scholarship. He is also willing to listen to the other side and admit when he was wrong.

I don't think old-school Nephilim are coming back. I do think we will see satanically-charged transhumanism and transgenics. Nephilim were giants and useful in battle. In today's warfare size isn't as important. Other augmentations are.
 
When speaking with Atheists they sometimes use the Gilgamesh Epic as proof that Moses plagiarized the Noah account. I assumed that it was a story passed down that was distorted overtime. On the answers in Genesis site, they have found other cultures across the world who speak of global floods and find amazing parallels.

How do you address the argument that Moses plagiarized the Gilgamesh epic. Have you heard of other proofs beyond what I mentioned?
 
I believe the ancient tales buttress and strengthen, rather than weaken, the Bible. If there are 400-plus Great Flood tales all over the world...then it probably happened. And furthermore, we'd expect a variance in these tales if they were told by pagans and not preserved by the Holy Spirit.

Plus, Satan's tool is not downright lying, but counterfeiting the truth. Satan loves to use 90% of the truth and then just twist it a little bit.
 
I believe the ancient tales buttress and strengthen, rather than weaken, the Bible. If there are 400-plus Great Flood tales all over the world...then it probably happened. And furthermore, we'd expect a variance in these tales if they were told by pagans and not preserved by the Holy Spirit.

Plus, Satan's tool is not downright lying, but counterfeiting the truth. Satan loves to use 90% of the truth and then just twist it a little bit.

Exactly. When you have an overwhelming corroboration of witnesses spanning thousands of years and the entire globe, then the event probably happened.
 
Exactly. When you have an overwhelming corroboration of witnesses spanning thousands of years and the entire globe, then the event probably happened.

And some of these universal tales are: (1) a good creation put under a curse, (2) giants/gods waging war and oppressing mankind and breeding with women, (3) The interference of various lesser God in the early affairs of man, (4) an abundance of wickedness until there was a Flood, (5) And often a spreading out of mankind purposefully or a scattering/division.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top