Grillsy
Puritan Board Junior
Grillsy said:I am not sure why Lewis is given so much slack on the PB. Considering certain things about his personal life that he was unapologetic about or considering certain theological views.
If by "personal life" you are referring to the alleged inappropriate relationship with Mrs. Moore, I have done research on the subject and, to my mind, I have found no evidence that the relationship was anything but appropriate. To say otherwise is to read a Freudian interpretation into what was, in essence, a filial relationship rather than a sexual one.
As for theology, I tend to be forgiving of Lewis largely because theology was not his area of expertise (as he himself admitted). He was more of an expert on Christianity and culture, Christian behavior, and literature. Besides, he's a calvinist now, isn't he?
On topic, Till We Have Faces is, in my opinion, one of Lewis's greatest works, only outranked by That Hideous Strength and The Great Divorce. It's also his only work of fiction published after Joy Gresham's death, making its points about the nature of love and possession (themes througout Lewis's writings) that much more personal.
Actually I studied under one of the nations foremost Lewis experts. If you had read any of the newer Lewis biographies by those who have read his personal letters and those of his associates you would unquestionably that the relationship was sexual and therefore inappropriate.
That being said. The man held to certain aberrant theological positions yet we still recommend him? Perhaps we could recommend the works of the classical Arminians because they believe in total depravity?
-----Added 7/30/2009 at 10:17:18 EST-----
I am not sure why Lewis is given so much slack on the PB. Considering certain things about his personal life that he was unapologetic about or considering certain theological views.
Fine author, I just think that we could be a little more cautious about our open endorsements.
Hi, do you read fictional novels by non-Christians?
I am not sure why Lewis is given so much slack on the PB. Considering certain things about his personal life that he was unapologetic about or considering certain theological views.
Fine author, I just think that we could be a little more cautious about our open endorsements.
I actually openly endorse any number or literary talents, and most of them are, sadly for their sake, not Christians. I think this book was wonderful. I could not have personally written it, because my conscience squirms at even pretending for literature's sake that any other god was God; for instance, I could not have written Narnia, b/c Aslan is not the real Christ. I would have felt conflict at that.
However, I can and do appreciate authors who could use the idea of God or the idea of Christ, and in a fictitious manner, give an allegory. I actually might prefer in a work of fiction a representation that says, "I am Christ," not be used--since our knowledge of Christ is limited to what's revealed in the Bible. Lewis sought out true themes of God, by using a fictitious account of a fictitious god, and I think that was a good way to explore true themes. I would have been much more uncomfortable reading this book had Lewis named Ungit "Yahweh" and Ungit's son, "Christ." For I would consider that to be adding to the Bible (a la Anne Rice).
I probably sound defensive, and I don't mean to♥. I just don't personally have a problem with reading even unChristian authors, so it's hard to feel bad endorsing a work written by a Christian.
I do read fictional novels by non-Christians. However I usually don't try to use them to teach people about the faith like some do with the writings of Lewis.
Please understand that I recognize Lewis' talent. I have read more than my fair share of Lewis and fail to understand how his aberrant theology is ignored or pushed aside by the Reformed. I read Lewis as I am sure most of you do, as literature and not as theology. However, his books are too often being used as catechisms in certain churches. That is my worry and that is why I voiced my concerns.