WrittenFromUtopia
Puritan Board Graduate
In presenting the true gospel to people, they often find many ideas troubling or confusing, especially in regards to God's sovereignty as it relates to man's responsibility, the eternal decree by God of all things, etc.
In discussing soteriology with a non-Calvinist, I have encountered many times an objection when I am defending and presenting the Biblical gospel. The objection relates to the issue of total depravity/inability.
In essence, people often object that if we are totally depraved, completely sinners through and through, and not capable of willing to perform any good and holy work, how is it that so many pagans do "good deeds" all the time? For example, many pagans love their children and would give up their lives for them. Is this not a good deed? The list could go on and on, obviously.
For a while, I had a hard time answering this objection, other than simply saying "well, when sinners do good things, it is not considered righteous to God" with the simple Biblical defense that our best righteousness is dirty menstrual rags to the Lord.
However, as I was reading through Calvin's Institutes tonight on a plane to Memphis, I realized just why these seemingly "good deeds" - even things that are directly fulfilling the Law in some way and should, by all means, be holy and acceptable to the Lord - can be, in a sense, "evil" deeds. The heart.
If an unbeliever does a "good deed" towards another or towards the Lord, unless they are regenerate, they are not doing this deed for the Lord. In other words, this deed is not an act of loving obedience to God and for His glory, but it is a selfish action.
Without doing things, even God's Law, with a regenerate heart, the end result will always be evil in the eyes of the Lord. We are not capable, in any way, of pleasing the Lord unless we are at peace with Him through Christ. When we are at peace with God through Jesus Christ, we do things out of our love for Him, and with a heart inclined to please Him and to do His commandments.
It is truly possible to do God's law and be doing an evil action. I don't think it is going too far to call it a form of idolatry or self-worship, either. This is the fundamental difference between an unregenerate person doing a good work and a believer in Christ Jesus doing a good work - One works for himself, and the other works for the Lord.
Thoughts?
In discussing soteriology with a non-Calvinist, I have encountered many times an objection when I am defending and presenting the Biblical gospel. The objection relates to the issue of total depravity/inability.
In essence, people often object that if we are totally depraved, completely sinners through and through, and not capable of willing to perform any good and holy work, how is it that so many pagans do "good deeds" all the time? For example, many pagans love their children and would give up their lives for them. Is this not a good deed? The list could go on and on, obviously.
For a while, I had a hard time answering this objection, other than simply saying "well, when sinners do good things, it is not considered righteous to God" with the simple Biblical defense that our best righteousness is dirty menstrual rags to the Lord.
However, as I was reading through Calvin's Institutes tonight on a plane to Memphis, I realized just why these seemingly "good deeds" - even things that are directly fulfilling the Law in some way and should, by all means, be holy and acceptable to the Lord - can be, in a sense, "evil" deeds. The heart.
If an unbeliever does a "good deed" towards another or towards the Lord, unless they are regenerate, they are not doing this deed for the Lord. In other words, this deed is not an act of loving obedience to God and for His glory, but it is a selfish action.
Without doing things, even God's Law, with a regenerate heart, the end result will always be evil in the eyes of the Lord. We are not capable, in any way, of pleasing the Lord unless we are at peace with Him through Christ. When we are at peace with God through Jesus Christ, we do things out of our love for Him, and with a heart inclined to please Him and to do His commandments.
It is truly possible to do God's law and be doing an evil action. I don't think it is going too far to call it a form of idolatry or self-worship, either. This is the fundamental difference between an unregenerate person doing a good work and a believer in Christ Jesus doing a good work - One works for himself, and the other works for the Lord.
Thoughts?