Can the Church petition magistrates?

Corey Powell

Puritan Board Freshman
Posting here here because I don't have access to P&G and, this is both an apologetic and "spirituality of the church" issue.

On Wednesday last week, my church has Equal Protection South Carolina (EPSC) come to our church to present information about their work towards abolishing abortion in SC. I very much appreciated it and found it helpful and instructive on how to help work towards this goal, including talking to our representatives.

The next day, I saw our governor-elect put up a link to take suggestions. He is pro-life but explicitly anti-EP. I asked my pastor in private if I could share the link and suggest the men in our church to suggest to the governor to abolish abortion, but I was shut down.

Apparently, at least one in the church thought the call to reach out to polititians was inappropriate.
The pastor said he doesn't think HE can do it, but he can bring in others to say it.
I have trouble agreeing with either, I think the church SHOULD instruct its people to influence society towards righteousness, particularly in moral-law (non-prudential) issues. Its not like were suggesting a change in tax code, were saying "make murder illegal." (Though personally I did also ask Wilson to get rid of property tax...)

So what is the biblical position? The Church as the Church and its minsiters:
  1. Must not in any way promote a political position or suggest political action, even in cases of clear moral evil.
  2. Ought not to do so directly, but may promote it through men acting as private persons/external organization.
  3. Ought to call its people to engage in society/politics to further justice in our land, yet not binding the conscience on things which Scripture does not such as prudential matters and voting for specific candidates.
  4. (For kicks) Must promote engagement in society for all things they consider to be justice, even merely prudential matters..
Trying to be unbiased/steelman the phrasing here.

what do you think? I was pretty bothered that there would be a problem with this, because I thing the Church's reluctance to speak out regarding theses things is a significant factor in the rapid spread of such evil in our land. It seems to me that people fear my position (3) is the same as or quickly devolves into the extreme (4) and so retreat to the opposite extreme (1).

My thoughts go to the fact that telling magistrates to stop being evil is one of the earliest Christian traditions, as from the early church to the Reformation and beyond, pastors wrote and spoke directed at the government. It seems like an over-reaction to liberal transformationalism and kuyperianism.
 
Last edited:
I agree with you, I would take position 3 as Christ himself advocated for the protection of the vulnerable, weak, and poor, so I think it is appropriate on these kinds of issues for the church to promote action. The main thing I see as problematic is evangelicals (in the modern sense) idolizing the Republican Party and trump, and acting like it is a grave sin for someone to vote for the left/Democratic Party, so I would just be cautious about the line between objective moral issues (like abortion, murder, etc) and subjective opinions or applications of objective moral issues (like saying that for there to be less murder, your congregants have to vote against gun control, or something like this).
 

We should try to influence the government for good.

I thought of another question that pretty much answers the question.

Name one great Christian (Jewish) leader who did not come face to face with the highest powers that be on earth. And there was no mincing of words.
 
WCF Chapter 31 might be helpful: "Synods and councils are to handle or conclude nothing but that which is ecclesiastical: and are not to intermeddle with civil affairs which concern the commonwealth, unless by way of humble petition in cases extraordinary; or by way of advice, for satisfaction of conscience, if they be thereunto required by the civil magistrate." (§5, emphasis added) I believe a call to end murder to be extraordinary (ie. not a relatively mundane issue such as taxation).

In democratic societies, all are free to petition the government. I do not believe an individual should do so as a representative of a church or congregation - it should be coming from the highest court of the Church. The Covenanters used to do this in the US quite frequently.
 
the main thing is that things such as sexuality, abortion, and murder are not "civil affairs" but rather philosophical issues that go beyond simply civil matters, so I would agree that these are extreme cases. something more foundational though would be that I believe that church has an active role in teaching/discipling, the nations, not just individuals within the nation but actually discipling and guiding the magistrates and civil government, this was more clearly reflected in the original versions of the Westminster confession and Belgic confession, so I do think that the church actually has a responsibility to advocate for godliness and justice.
 
Positions that spurn the church speaking to the magistrate appear contrary to Scripture-example.
Ps. 2:10 "Now therefore, O kings, be wise"
Ps. 119:46 "I will also speak of your testimonies before kings"
Luke 3:19-20 "But Herod the tetrarch, who had been reproved by him for Herodias, his brother's wife, and for all the evil things that Herod had done, added this to them all, that he locked up John in prison"
Acts 9:15 "But the Lord said to him, 'Go, for he is a chosen instrument of mine to carry my name before the Gentiles and kings and the children of Israel.' "

OT and NT examples both involve ministers speaking to rulers. So what is the basis for any aversion to doing so?
 
I would say, in fact, it is the duty of the Church as the Church to call the magistrate as the magistrate to repentance, since God brings wrath upon nations, and the Church must warn them of the impending judgment.

Psalm 2:12 “Kiss the Son, lest He become angry, and you perish in the way, for His wrath may soon be kindled.”
 
Posting here here because I don't have access to P&G and, this is both an apologetic and "spirituality of the church" issue.

On Wednesday last week, my church has Equal Protection South Carolina (EPSC) come to our church to present information about their work towards abolishing abortion in SC. I very much appreciated it and found it helpful and instructive on how to help work towards this goal, including talking to our representatives.

The next day, I saw our governor-elect put up a link to take suggestions. He is pro-life but explicitly anti-EP. I asked my pastor in private if I could share the link and suggest the men in our church to suggest to the governor to abolish abortion, but I was shut down.

Apparently, at least one in the church thought the call to reach out to polititians was inappropriate.
The pastor said he doesn't think HE can do it, but he can bring in others to say it.
I have trouble agreeing with either, I think the church SHOULD instruct its people to influence society towards righteousness, particularly in moral-law (non-prudential) issues. Its not like were suggesting a change in tax code, were saying "make murder illegal." (Though personally I did also ask Wilson to get rid of property tax...)

So what is the biblical position? The Church as the Church and its minsiters:
  1. Must not in any way promote a political position or suggest political action, even in cases of clear moral evil.
  2. Ought not to do so directly, but may promote it through men acting as private persons/external organization.
  3. Ought to call its people to engage in society/politics to further justice in our land, yet not binding the conscience on things which Scripture does not such as prudential matters and voting for specific candidates.
  4. (For kicks) Must promote engagement in society for all things they consider to be justice, even merely prudential matters..
Trying to be unbiased/steelman the phrasing here.

what do you think? I was pretty bothered that there would be a problem with this, because I thing the Church's reluctance to speak out regarding theses things is a significant factor in the rapid spread of such evil in our land. It seems to me that people fear my position (3) is the same as or quickly devolves into the extreme (4) and so retreat to the opposite extreme (1).

My thoughts go to the fact that telling magistrates to stop being evil is one of the earliest Christian traditions, as from the early church to the Reformation and beyond, pastors wrote and spoke directed at the government. It seems like an over-reaction to liberal transformationalism and kuyperianism.
I'm not in any way familiar with PCA BCO, which it appears we are both in the same Denomination, but your pastor's distinction between "bringing someone in to talk about it" and encouraging the congregation to end "abortion" is key here.
The way you're framing the question might be the problem. There's a difference between saying that the Church should seek to end murder by society (which is a true moral principle that every Christian should except) and encouraging the congregation to vote one way or the other on a piece of legislation and/or politician (which could be construed as binding the conscience).
The first one, I agree with the second one I don't. Bringing someone in to talk about it is a little dicey. I mean it could be construed as binding the conscience by virtue of the fact that it gives the appearance of the Church endorsing something legislative.
The trick with legislation is that it's almost never as simple as "this bill will simply end murder in society". For one thing laws don't end immoral actions in general but specific acts by an individual. And corporations are legally considered individuals.
Plus, although I'm not familiar with this bill, what else is in the bill? The fine print you know. Plus what other powers will this law give the state as a consequence of it's passing? Those are political questions not simply moral questions. And the "Spirituality of The Church" (as I understand it and believe it) is the Church may petition the government over moral issues that the Bible is against but not particular political positions. That oversteps her boundaries in my opinion.
So that may be the "reasoning" that your pastor is looking at in his answer.
 
WCF Chapter 31 might be helpful: "Synods and councils are to handle or conclude nothing but that which is ecclesiastical: and are not to intermeddle with civil affairs which concern the commonwealth, unless by way of humble petition in cases extraordinary; or by way of advice, for satisfaction of conscience, if they be thereunto required by the civil magistrate." (§5, emphasis added) I believe a call to end murder to be extraordinary (ie. not a relatively mundane issue such as taxation).

In democratic societies, all are free to petition the government. I do not believe an individual should do so as a representative of a church or congregation - it should be coming from the highest court of the Church. The Covenanters used to do this in the US quite frequently.
I agree with you my friend. My only scruple would be to make a distinction between "ending murder" (that we both agree is a moral truth) and supporting or not supporting a particular piece of legislation. Otherwise excellent post and we may agree on this too.
Excellent reply and thank you for quoting the confession on this.
 

Here's a good article about the nuts and bolts of this issue. By that I mean bringing an abstract moral principle down into the concrete reality of law and tax exempt status. As I said it's never as simple as "this will simply abolish this moral evil", ethics is complicated in its application to real world events. I mean how complicated is the legal code?
 
I agree, this is why I dont believe it is right for churches to condemn socialism as heresy or anything like this (even though I might personally disagree)
 
Back
Top