Ballet dancing and physically intimate

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yeah I can see how people who can appreciata art would be to fare gone to fix, so thank you

So now because some sinful female nurses/pole dancers abuse the term artistic we are not allowed to use it anymore, is that your point?

No, that's not it at all. 'Artistic' as a term is fine when applied properly. p0rnography is considered artistic by many but I know that no one on this thread/board would ever try to justify the misuse of that term. It's the pre-certified cultural acceptance of the action that is causing the problem here (not to mention the additional issue that it is viewed as high-brow culture).
 
So when you pay to go see "nudie pictures" by the great masters in the museums like forexample pictures of a half naked John the baptist what do you call that
 
So another word for american football would be Gay-guy-wrestling, trust me touching of crutches is involved and they wear tight pants

But for the majority of the men playing or watching, it does not make them stumble. A scantily clad girl dancing with a boy, may make him stumble. Therefore, we are asking, would you want your daughter to be dancing with him?
 
So now because some sinful female nurses/pole dancers abuse the term artistic we are not allowed to use it anymore, is that your point?

Brother, there are people who believe that pole dancing is artistic. Google it if you don't believe me :p If a woman is scantily clad and pole dancing as a form of art, similar to how other women perform ballet in immodest clothing in many circumstances, is there really a difference between the two situations?

NOTE: I do not intend to argue against child ballet as described in the OP. I do think child ballet can be innocent, pure, and quite beneficial; the immodesty of adult ballet that is overlooked because of artistic value is what I mean to discuss.
 
So when you pay to go see "nudie pictures" by the great masters in the museums like forexample pictures of a half naked John the baptist what do you call that

For the most part, I call it hedonism.
 
NOTE: I do not intend to argue against child ballet as described in the OP. I do think child ballet can be innocent, pure, and quite beneficial; the immodesty of adult ballet that is overlooked because of artistic value is what I mean to discuss.

Agreed. We stopped it in part because of the road that lay ahead, not so much because of the here and now.

-----Added 3/13/2009 at 11:37:07 EST-----

If I wanted to keep my daughter away from sexually active and sinful people I would have to make her leave this world as Paul told us

She should not leave the world, but why thrust her into such a risque part of it? Why not have her play ball or skip rope in the red light district in Amsterdam? (Again, we're not talking when she's a little girl, but when she matures.)
 
So another word for american football would be Gay-guy-wrestling, trust me touching of crutches is involved and they wear tight pants

But for the majority of the men playing or watching, it does not make them stumble. A scantily clad girl dancing with a boy, may make him stumble. Therefore, we are asking, would you want your daughter to be dancing with him?

If we are going to discuss this I need a definition of sinful touch from your side of the camp, because from what I have heard from you guys suddenly almost every interaction can be made sexual, and if that is what we are aiming to avoid we will have to leave this world like Paul told us.
Still granted if you feel specifically tempted by it, do not do it, but you can not make it a general rule
 
This is Elizabeth, Mark's wife, posting on his account.

I have been involved in classical ballet for twenty years, and though I will not attempt to respond to all the comments posted here, I would like to clear up a few misconceptions (on both sides) and also to speak directly to the OP.

I'll address the misconceptions first, just to get them out of the way and to get us all on the same page.

First let me say that there is NO move or lift in classical ballet that involves anything so vulgar (and inelegant) as "crotch-to-crotch" anything. Those who brought this up might have seen something like this in modern dance, which is a competely seperate form of dance without a set of "rules" which unfortunately allows it to sometimes sink into lewdness. Ballet is so clearly defined that you can look up any step in a ballet dictionary - I can guarantee there is no such move listed. If someone was doing something crotch to crotch, it was not classical ballet. Since this discussion is about classical ballet, that move is irrelevant.

On the other hand, there are some moves that to put the ballerina in a compromised position. The ballerina is lifted one handed over the man's head, his hand is by necessity under her crotch (that's just the physics of it). That is by far the worst, the others are much less intrusive.

As to the other side, where women are saying that there is no temptation unless a guy is perverted, and that because it's art there isn't any real sin issue, I disagree. There is temptation, and certain moves can be inappropriate. I've heard it from the lips of nice Christian male dancers. Don't bash these guys because they're being honest.

I hope that's cleared a few things up. Now I'd just like to address the OP.

I think that the key in protecting your daughter is not in this case to keep her from ballet. I think instead the key is to train her up in the ability to distinguish right from wrong, and to be chaste and discerning in any situation. As a ballerina I grew up in Vermont, in a VERY secular studio, but because I had my parents teaching, the Word of God, and the Holy Spirit's guidance, I was able to make decent decisions and keep from doing stupid things. I decided early on which partnering moves were inappropriate (it's pretty easy - if it makes you blush, don't do it!). I didn't dance with partners that I didn't trust or those I felt any chemistry with (that's pretty easy too - if he makes you blush, don't dance with him!). Also, though it's no guarantee, unless your daughter is a prima ballerina, she's not going to be doing much partnering. Even the best dancers are usually just in the corps de ballet. I did fairly well in dance, but simply chose roles that didn't involve partnering - for example, I was the lilac fairy instead of sleeping beauty. If I had been in that role I would have made it very clear what moves I would not do. To summarize, being a classical ballerina does not mean that you are forced to partner or do anything you're uncomfortable with. You always have a mind with which to make good choices. Also, there are many Christian ballet companies that your daughter could be involved with when she's older that steer clear of anything indecent, and would respect a dancer's ethical boundaries.

I know I haven't responded to everyone's comments, but especially to those that are honestly stuggling with this, especially the OP, I hope that this has helped. I'd be happy to continue this dialogue with the OP if you have anything else you'd like to ask about this.

Thanks, Elizabeth
 
So another word for american football would be Gay-guy-wrestling, trust me touching of crutches is involved and they wear tight pants

But for the majority of the men playing or watching, it does not make them stumble. A scantily clad girl dancing with a boy, may make him stumble. Therefore, we are asking, would you want your daughter to be dancing with him?

If we are going to discuss this I need a definition of sinful touch from your side of the camp, because from what I have heard from you guys suddenly almost every interaction can be made sexual, and if that is what we are aiming to avoid we will have to leave this world like Paul told us.
Still granted if you feel specifically tempted by it, do not do it, but you can not make it a general rule I think we are trying to prevent others from feeling tempted by it with our daughters. I don't think any of the guys here are about to join ballet, but are themselves tempted, so cannot. We're looking out for our children.

Sinful touch would have the same definition on our side of the camp as yours.
Every interaction probably can be made sexual, if the sinner tries hard enough. I think we are just saying that for older girls, when they do start dancing with boys, the sinner may not have to try so hard to make the event sexual. I don't get what you are arguing against. The OP said
I personally don't like it (with many dances) that an unmarried boy and girl as dancing partners are so physically intimate with eachother during performance.

Any thoughts ?
Most of us, "on our side of the camp," are understanding his hesitance in sending his daughter to have a boy dancing partner. I am also pretty sure that we are all qualifying the impropriety factor of ballet with if there are, in fact, boy partners at this age. If not, then some would still caution against sending her down this road where that will inevitably be the scene.

As far as I can tell, the argument on this side is something like:
1)If your five year old is dancing with boys, then we understand your hesitance;

However

2)If she would not have male partners, then this is not yet a sexual issue;

However

3)It is almost definite what her future in ballet would look like, so decide now if you will be able to stop it before she is 13 and being manhandled by a 13 year old boy, because that, we think, would not be able to remain a pure situation, at least for her partner.

So

The question remains, despite the most definite artistic nature of ballet; despite its potential for beauty; despite its agility training; would you personally want YOUR 13 year old daughter wearing leotards and dancing with boys?

If that does not seem like something you would mind, then I would see no problem starting her at ballet when she is five.

If you would mind that, then the five year old decision is a little bit trickier.
But as far as I can tell, no one has tried to make that decision for the OP.

You might counter with you would mind the manhandling, but don't believe that an adolescent boy dancing with a scantily clad adolescent girl has to mean impure thoughts are abounding.
Now is this where the argument is? I have never been a 13 year old boy, so I cannot say for sure, but knowing that even one boy might be excited by that, I would not wish for my teenage daughter to be dancing with any boy, while she's wearing a tutu.

Edit: After reading Elizabeth's post, I have learned that very little boy-girl ballet would exist and that a girl is able to choose what moves and what partners she'll use. I did not know this, so my post may be wrong. But I'll leave it, because it is what I think the argument is, and I'm wondering what Martin does not agree with.
 
First let me say that there is NO move or lift in classical ballet that involves anything so vulgar (and inelegant) as "crotch-to-crotch" anything. Those who brought this up might have seen something like this in modern dance, which is a competely seperate form of dance without a set of "rules" which unfortunately allows it to sometimes sink into lewdness. Ballet is so clearly defined that you can look up any step in a ballet dictionary - I can guarantee there is no such move listed. If someone was doing something crotch to crotch, it was not classical ballet. Since this discussion is about classical ballet, that move is irrelevant.

I'm not feeling reassured. This move occurred in the first video I saw on youtube - Sleeping Beauty at the Paris Opera, and multiple others.
 
Elizabeth says:

Even if there were such a move, see the last paragraph in my previous post. You are not required to perform or practice all partnering moves.

If you can refer me to a video with a move like you described, I'd be happy to look at it.
 
It seems alot of assumptions are being made concerning those in ballet who are older. From what i have been reading it makes it seem like anyone over the age of 10 will fall to the intense sexual temptation that the ballet brings.

Not everyone is a rabid lust puppet. It is entirely possible to preform with partners with out caving to or generating any sexual desire.

It almost seems to imply to me that the male and female meeting in these situations are almost destined to fall to "temptation" but what is being overlooked is all the variables that create sexual tension or attraction. Its not simpily meeting the opposite sex or interacting with them that would create this.

There are some people that are machines about this kind of stuff and its all about nailing the perfect performance or not being nervous in front of a crowd.

That fact that were even discussing this when the topic was about a 5 year old blows my mind.
 
It seems alot of assumptions are being made concerning those in ballet who are older. From what i have been reading it makes it seem like anyone over the age of 10 will fall to the intense sexual temptation that the ballet brings.

Not everyone is a rabid lust puppet. It is entirely possible to preform with partners with out caving to or generating any sexual desire.

It almost seems to imply to me that the male and female meeting in these situations are almost destined to fall to "temptation" but what is being overlooked is all the variables that create sexual tension or attraction. Its not simpily meeting the opposite sex or interacting with them that would create this.

There are some people that are machines about this kind of stuff and its all about nailing the perfect performance or not being nervous in front of a crowd.

That fact that were even discussing this when the topic was about a 5 year old blows my mind.

Iam sorry if i made myself not clear.
With the age of 5 years old is not issue of being tempted, but what about the fact if she wants to keep diong ballet and she comes older that is what i mean. I would feel sorry if i let her do Ballet from age of 5 years old, and shen becomes for example 15 years old that i have to say "well it is not proper to do this dancing because of the physical intimacy with a male partner".
 
It was very helpful of Elizabeth to explain what constitutes classical ballet. Some parents have been deceived by dance studios who advertise their program as "ballet" when it is very much modern dance.

Well over ten years ago, I was out on our deck looking down at the neighbor girls performing one of their recital pieces in the yard below. My husband came home from work and joined me on the deck. He looked down and said, "so what bizarre mating ritual is this?" I looked back at the girls and they had their backs to us and were leaning over with their hands on their knees, bouncing up and down and looking over their shoulders at us. I was horrified. Later, I asked the mom next door if she was comfortable with the dances they did. She replied she didn't really watch the dancing. It was all she could do to get the hair and makeup right and afford the costumes. She and her husband were very conservative Christians, and told people that their daughters were in "ballet".

Did the parents make a good decision about this activity for their daughters? I do not think they did. What were the results of this decision? I don't know. The last I heard, all three girls who participated are happily married and all the families attend the parents' church.

All I know is that: 1. It is a bad idea to fly in the face of God's commands. 2. God does have mercy on sinners. 3. It is a bad idea to "straddle the line" and count on God's mercy. 4. It is a bad idea to make pronouncements about the future because we don't know where God's judgments and mercies will lie, regarding our own lives and in the lives of others.

I understand you parents here are putting a lot of thought and prayer in how to educate and nurture your children. As a member of your Christian family, I will rejoice with you in the successes your children experience and I will cry with you when they sin and disappoint you. I will laugh exuberantly when you exclaim over God's bounteous provision for your lovely child and I will put my arm on your shoulder and sit with you when you sob that you didn't think they would ever be like this.

Whether it is ballet, sports, or education education choices, it makes me glad to read that you are making those decisions thoughtfully, prayerfully, and with the aim of glorifying God.

Bless you all!
 
I have performed in sleeping beauty myself, as I said in my post, but despite this, just to be doubly sure, I looked at all the pas de deux in sleeping beauty on youtube that smhbbag referenced. To the untrained eye (no offence meant, you understand) it understandably may look like there are crotches touching in one particular movement. They are not. As I thought, this is the original, traditional choreography that goes with Tchaikovski's music, and at no point do crotches touch! :) If they were to touch, 1. it would be incorrect form, and 2. If she were leaning into him that much she would fall over or at least get wobbly. But even if, hypothetically, there were such a move, my main point remains - no one can make her do it. This is a free country, after all. Hope that helps. Elizabeth
 
Watch the Acrimony

[Moderator]I understand that such questions always tend to rouse a lot of emotion on the part of the participants, but everyone needs to keep it calm and pleasant in here. I've cleaned the thread up once, but if it starts going downhill again I will lock it.[/Moderator]
 
I think what we need to keep in mind here is that it is not the act or art itself that is sinful.
In this case it is more the beholder of the act and what his mind will do with it that makes it sin for him.
So by all means if ballet makes you commit sexual sin in your mind, stay away from it.
But your sinful mind is the problem not the ballet.

Great post, Martin - I think this is exactly right. If someone is tempted or led to sinful thoughts by watching and/or performing ballet, then they should avoid it. If it's not a stumbling block, then there's no reason to stop.

Many posts on here convey the idea that certain states of dress or undress or certain types of dance are inherently sinful. Yet there is no biblical support for this. Modesty is an important biblical concept, but the definition varies greatly according to culture and context. Wearing tights that ballet dancers wear may not be appropriate walking down the street, but it is appropriate in the context of ballet rehearsals or performances. The same goes for swimmers wearing Speedos - in the pool it makes sense, walking down the street seems out of place.

So in the right cultural and contextual setting there is nothing wrong ballet, or most forms of art for that matter. Yet if any of it causes someone in the audience to sin, that person should simply skip the performance and use their time for something else.
 
I agree with Mason. Different consciences will draw the line in different places. This doesn't mean that there is no fixed line beyond which a Christian may not go. But, having watched a fair bit of ballet, I can testify that the line does not exist, or is pretty far out in classical ballet. Elizabeth mentions that there is just about one move that is inappropriate. I watched ballet as a teen. Being a red-blooded American male, you can be sure that if there was any temptation for lust, I would have been very aware of it. There simply was not. I think the main reason for this is the intention behind classical ballet, which certainly is not to arouse, but to dazzle with the physical prowess, and the artistic grace with which the bodies move, and to say something beautiful about art. Mason also has good points about costume. The analogy with bathing suits is well-placed. Even modest bathing suits are immodest if we take them out of their appropriate context.
 
I have performed in sleeping beauty myself, as I said in my post, but despite this, just to be doubly sure, I looked at all the pas de deux in sleeping beauty on youtube that smhbbag referenced. To the untrained eye (no offence meant, you understand) it understandably may look like there are crotches touching in one particular movement. They are not. As I thought, this is the original, traditional choreography that goes with Tchaikovski's music, and at no point do crotches touch! If they were to touch, 1. it would be incorrect form, and 2. If she were leaning into him that much she would fall over or at least get wobbly. But even if, hypothetically, there were such a move, my main point remains - no one can make her do it. This is a free country, after all. Hope that helps.

My eye is untrained, but I knew their crotches weren't touching, and I know they are not supposed to. It does not matter one bit - there is no meaningful difference between having a foot of space and no space.

In my mind, it also does not matter that no dancer is forced to do the move. You are forced to be there and watch it, whether as an audience or fellow cast member. And I maintain my skepticism of any claim (especially by a male) that someone can continually see those "dances" and remain unaffected.
 
It seems like only a tiny fraction get to the point of being in some lead role with the rest being in the dance version of "the chorus." This discussion is somewhat like worrying about your 5-year-old musician and whether or not she could handle the fame when she's a world-class performer.

I took a ballet class in college. It took an amazing amount of concentration, discipline and control. If you can do all that and think about the opposite sex, more power to you. The final was choreographing and performing a two-minute dance. That was an eternity and took more work than most of my 5-hour academic credits.
 
Would you allow your daughter to walk down the street in a bodysuit with a frill at midriff? I don't think there is anyone who would say that this is appropriate wear for the outdoors.

Would you apply the same logic to swimsuits or tennis outfits that you apply to ballet outfits?
 
I agree with Mason. Different consciences will draw the line in different places. This doesn't mean that there is no fixed line beyond which a Christian may not go. But, having watched a fair bit of ballet, I can testify that the line does not exist, or is pretty far out in classical ballet. Elizabeth mentions that there is just about one move that is inappropriate. I watched ballet as a teen. Being a red-blooded American male, you can be sure that if there was any temptation for lust, I would have been very aware of it. There simply was not. I think the main reason for this is the intention behind classical ballet, which certainly is not to arouse, but to dazzle with the physical prowess, and the artistic grace with which the bodies move, and to say something beautiful about art. Mason also has good points about costume. The analogy with bathing suits is well-placed. Even modest bathing suits are immodest if we take them out of their appropriate context.


The idea of individual consciences deciding holds merit.

As the oldest of 3 children, the younger two both being girls, I grew up going to ballet recitals. I even danced a waltz with my youngest sister in Beauty and the Beast her senior year. That said, I don't remember a time throughout the raging hormone years, that I was moved to sin watching ballet. I think many of the sexual questions about ballet have more to do with the individuals mind than ballet it self. For example, if you have a perverted choreographer, obviously the dance will have sexual connotations. The dancers who dance and choreograph dances to honor the Lord, do so.

My sister has since joined a Christian ballet company. They dance Classical ballet, not the interpretive movement stuff. The dances they do are quite worshipful, always to God glorifying lyrics. While I don't think I agree with it being in a worship service, going to one of their shows defiantly points to the glory of God and accentuating the lyrics they are dancing to.

I see classical ballet in the same light as fine art. The dedication and skill it takes to make it happen adds to the appreciation.

For the OP, I watched it develop some serious discipline in my youngest sister. Much like a sport would.
 
Why would you want to put impressionable young kids into something that you say well now it is OK because you are little but later would say it is wrong??

And certainly anything more than folk dancing where there is not much touching or body contact is a temptation of the flesh.

Why not have them get in an exercise class or tap dance or gymnastics or something that is not a partner intimate contact activity.

Remember 1 Tim 4:8 For bodily exercise profiteth little: but godliness is profitable unto all things, having promise of the life that now is, and of that which is to come.
9 This is a faithful saying and worthy of all acceptation.KJV

Now I recognize we are a sedentary society unlike our ancestors so some exercise may be worthwhile, but not co-ed dancing. So why start one out on it an confuse them.

Physical touch is such a dangerous thing. Many people are so sensual and needy for touch they can become addicted easily. Why don['t we give kids alcohol? Why do we protect kids from many things? Just as some people take one hit of a drug and are addicted why put a child in a situation where they can.
So though it seems innocent and safe enough for the preteens, how do you later tell them they must stop because it isn't good for teens or co-ed? I'd rather have them do Yoga or martial arts and tell them not to get into the philosophy just stretch.

And this verse doesn't say except at the beach and on stage; how far we have fallen from purity. 1 Tim 2:9 in like manner also, that the women adorn themselves in modest apparel, with propriety and moderation, not with braided hair or gold or pearls or costly clothing, 10 but, which is proper for women professing godliness, NKJV
 
Why would you want to put impressionable young kids into something that you say well now it is OK because you are little but later would say it is wrong??

And certainly anything more than folk dancing where there is not much touching or body contact is a temptation of the flesh.

Why not have them get in an exercise class or tap dance or gymnastics or something that is not a partner intimate contact activity.

Remember 1 Tim 4:8 For bodily exercise profiteth little: but godliness is profitable unto all things, having promise of the life that now is, and of that which is to come.
9 This is a faithful saying and worthy of all acceptation.KJV

Now I recognize we are a sedentary society unlike our ancestors so some exercise may be worthwhile, but not co-ed dancing. So why start one out on it an confuse them.

Physical touch is such a dangerous thing. Many people are so sensual and needy for touch they can become addicted easily. Why don['t we give kids alcohol? Why do we protect kids from many things? Just as some people take one hit of a drug and are addicted why put a child in a situation where they can.
So though it seems innocent and safe enough for the preteens, how do you later tell them they must stop because it isn't good for teens or co-ed? I'd rather have them do Yoga or martial arts and tell them not to get into the philosophy just stretch.

And this verse doesn't say except at the beach and on stage; how far we have fallen from purity. 1 Tim 2:9 in like manner also, that the women adorn themselves in modest apparel, with propriety and moderation, not with braided hair or gold or pearls or costly clothing, 10 but, which is proper for women professing godliness, NKJV

Because in the younger children's classes, there isn't the body contact.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top