Baptism in a Liberal Church

[jawyman]

I have a question with regards to the recognition of only baptism. If a person is baptised in a liberal church and say, by female clergy, is that baptism valid?

 

[Reformed Covenanter]

I have a question with regards to the recognition of only baptism. If a person is baptised in a liberal church and say, by female clergy, is that baptism valid?

Does the church have an orthodox confession?

 

[jawyman]

Let's use either the United Methodist Church or the United Church of Christ.

 

[Pilgrim]

I have a question with regards to the recognition of only baptism. If a person is baptised in a liberal church and say, by female clergy, is that baptism valid?

I'm thinking that those who take the position that Roman Catholic baptism is invalid would have to say no to be consistent, whether the clergy is female or not. Those who accept RC baptism would likely say such a baptism is irregular but not invalid so long as the church does not deny the trinity, etc.

 

[Reformed Covenanter]

Let's use either the United Methodist Church or the United Church of Christ.

Not being from the USA, I don't know the lie of the land; so have these churches enshrined damnable heresy in their Confessions?

 

[Southern Presbyterian]

Wasn't this at least partly discussed in this thread?

 

[SRoper]

Let's use either the United Methodist Church or the United Church of Christ.

Not being from the USA, I don't know the lie of the land; so have these churches enshrined damnable heresy in their Confessions?

I don't know about the UMC, but I was baptized in the UCC which is congregationalist. The church I went to has written, "While we have never standardized dogmas and doctrines, preferring to operate from a simple Covenant of Church Membership, our traditional view has been that children are born into the world quite acceptable to God..."

 

[Reformed Covenanter]

Let's use either the United Methodist Church or the United Church of Christ.

Not being from the USA, I don't know the lie of the land; so have these churches enshrined damnable heresy in their Confessions?

I don't know about the UMC, but I was baptized in the UCC which is congregationalist. The church I went to has written, "While we have never standardized dogmas and doctrines, preferring to operate from a simple Covenant of Church Membership, our traditional view has been that children are born into the world quite acceptable to God..."

That is Pelagianism written into its official documents; therefore, I would say its not a true church of Christ, and its baptism is invalid.

 

[Ron]

I have a question with regards to the recognition of only baptism. If a person is baptised in a liberal church and say, by female clergy, is that baptism valid?

Wasn't circumcision valid in apostate Israel? And they crucified the Lord of Glory.

Ron

 

[Kevin]

I have a question with regards to the recognition of only baptism. If a person is baptised in a liberal church and say, by female clergy, is that baptism valid?

If in the name of the tiune God and with water, then yes. Although very irregular.

 

[beej6]

I too prefer "irregular" to answer the OP, since we know not the specific church (though one was suggested in a later post). I might characterize a Mormon baptism as "invalid."

 

[Pilgrim]

I too prefer "irregular" to answer the OP, since we know not the specific church (though one was suggested in a later post). I might characterize a Mormon baptism as "invalid."

Yes, Mormon, JW, Christadelphian, etc. are invalid.

Some churches in liberal denominations are more sound than others, and some are still basically orthodox. Evidently there are still some RCA congregations, for example, that are sound. Also you have the Southern Baptist Convention and other more "evangelical" churches some of which, ecclesiological issues aside, are quite sound and others, even in the Deep South, that are essentially as liberal as what you'd expect with the NCC/WCC churches. So if we are going to go down this road, it would necessitate not only examining the denomination in which a prospective member was baptized, but also the particular church as well as the minister.

 

[Reformed Covenanter]

I have a question with regards to the recognition of only baptism. If a person is baptised in a liberal church and say, by female clergy, is that baptism valid?

Wasn't circumcision valid in apostate Israel? And they crucified the Lord of Glory.

Ron

Good question, here are two answers:

1. Israel was not officially divorced from Christ until 70 AD; hence the apostles could worship in the temple and synagogue.

2. As circumcision was a physical sign, there is no way that you could not accept it.

 

[etexas]

I have a question with regards to the recognition of only baptism. If a person is baptised in a liberal church and say, by female clergy, is that baptism valid?

If in the name of the tiune God and with water, then yes. Although very irregular.

...I was Baptized UMC, but when I brought it up with my PCA Pastor, he told me that since the Trinitarian formula was invoked the Baptism was valid.

 

[Reformed Covenanter]

I have a question with regards to the recognition of only baptism. If a person is baptised in a liberal church and say, by female clergy, is that baptism valid?

If in the name of the tiune God and with water, then yes. Although very irregular.

...I was Baptized UMC, but when I brought it up with my PCA Pastor, he told me that since the Trinitarian formula was invoked the Baptism was valid.

So tell me, if someone was standing on the street throwing water over people in the name of the Trinity would that count as a valid baptism?

 

[etexas]

If in the name of the tiune God and with water, then yes. Although very irregular.

...I was Baptized UMC, but when I brought it up with my PCA Pastor, he told me that since the Trinitarian formula was invoked the Baptism was valid.

So tell me, if someone was standing on the street throwing water over people in the name of the Trinity would that count as a valid baptism?

The argument is absurd Daniel, that is not a "baptism" and we both know it! Further my Pastor is a member of the PB! If you wish to argue the validity of my Baptism I can PM his "handle" to you and you can hash it out with him!

 

[Reformed Covenanter]

...I was Baptized UMC, but when I brought it up with my PCA Pastor, he told me that since the Trinitarian formula was invoked the Baptism was valid.

So tell me, if someone was standing on the street throwing water over people in the name of the Trinity would that count as a valid baptism?

The argument is absurd Daniel, that is not a "baptism" and we both know it! Further my Pastor is a member of the PB! If you wish to argue the validity of my Baptism I can PM his "handle" to you and you can hash it out with him!

So it might seem, but what is the difference between that and a baptism in an apostate church?

Neither "baptism" has been carried out by a minister of Christ in a true Christian church.

 

[Pilgrim]

I was sprinkled at age 11 or 12 in the United Methodist Church and later, when laboring under baptistic beliefs, immersed in a Wesleyan church that was sounder in its preaching than probably any Southern Baptist church in that area (I was a 5 pointer at that time as well). Both churches have essentially classic Wesleyan/Arminian statements of faith with the former being "liberal" and the latter being "conservative". It appears that at least one poster in this thread would say that both baptisms are invalid. For what it's worth I say such a belief is anabaptistic and more fitting with a Landmark Baptist (if not Donatist) mentality than an historic Reformed one.

 

[etexas]

So tell me, if someone was standing on the street throwing water over people in the name of the Trinity would that count as a valid baptism?

The argument is absurd Daniel, that is not a "baptism" and we both know it! Further my Pastor is a member of the PB! If you wish to argue the validity of my Baptism I can PM his "handle" to you and you can hash it out with him!

So it might seem, but what is the difference between that and a baptism in an apostate church?

Neither "baptism" has been carried out by a minister of Christ in a true Christian church.

I was Baptized by an Ordained Pastor in a Church, the fact that the Pastor was Arminian points more towards being irregular than "Apostate".

 

[Pilgrim]

The Sins of Adult Rebaptism and Leaving One's Bapties Unbaptised
Calvin On the Validity of "Romish" Baptism
Catabaptism in the Presbyterian Church in America

 

[RamistThomist]

So tell me, if someone was standing on the street throwing water over people in the name of the Trinity would that count as a valid baptism?

The argument is absurd Daniel, that is not a "baptism" and we both know it! Further my Pastor is a member of the PB! If you wish to argue the validity of my Baptism I can PM his "handle" to you and you can hash it out with him!

So it might seem, but what is the difference between that and a baptism in an apostate church?

Neither "baptism" has been carried out by a minister of Christ in a true Christian church.

That was one of James White's arguments against Doug Wilson. I forgot what Wilson said in reply. The debate in whole was misleading--it was supposed to be over FV related issues but turned into a baptism debate.

 

[Reformed Covenanter]

The argument is absurd Daniel, that is not a "baptism" and we both know it! Further my Pastor is a member of the PB! If you wish to argue the validity of my Baptism I can PM his "handle" to you and you can hash it out with him!

So it might seem, but what is the difference between that and a baptism in an apostate church?

Neither "baptism" has been carried out by a minister of Christ in a true Christian church.

I was Baptized by an Ordained Pastor in a Church, the fact that the Pastor was Arminian points more towards being irregular than "Apostate".

I agree with you there. Sorry for any misunderstanding, not knowing the US church to well, I don't know who the apostates are, so I presumed that when you mentioned that group they were officially apostate.

 

[etexas]

So it might seem, but what is the difference between that and a baptism in an apostate church?

Neither "baptism" has been carried out by a minister of Christ in a true Christian church.

I was Baptized by an Ordained Pastor in a Church, the fact that the Pastor was Arminian points more towards being irregular than "Apostate".

I agree with you there. Sorry for any misunderstanding, not knowing the US church to well, I don't know who the apostates are, so I presumed that when you mentioned that group they were officially apostate.

I could never stay mad at you Daniel! Remember my bit of Irish blood!