No Name #5
Puritan Board Freshman
Something I always wind up struggling with when arguing a topic or evangelizing to a skeptic is the issue of competing language games in communicating our points. It appears that if each interlocutor does not first concede to the same premises - even if it's merely for the sake of argument - the whole dialogue inevitably becomes fruitless, with each interlocutor continually speaking past each another until one of them finally gets too exhausted and calls it a day. Case in point: at bottom, a socialist would maintain that equal wealth distribution is the "right" of the populace, whereas a capitalist would maintain that it is something that simply must be earned. Or a Catholic will stubbornly insist that for a theological point to be valid, the Catholic Church must first confirm it, whereas a Reformer would term that idolatry because, of course, their premise is Sola Scriptura.
This might be asking a lot, but is there any argumentative technique which would at least enable this ambiguity in communication to become a bit clearer? Does anyone think there is there an effective way we can at least *somewhat* break down this communication barrier? At this point, I typically just pray, hoping the Holy Spirit will convict (if the point is theological). But what if the point is political, for example?
Thanks!
This might be asking a lot, but is there any argumentative technique which would at least enable this ambiguity in communication to become a bit clearer? Does anyone think there is there an effective way we can at least *somewhat* break down this communication barrier? At this point, I typically just pray, hoping the Holy Spirit will convict (if the point is theological). But what if the point is political, for example?
Thanks!