Go Tankless?

Status
Not open for further replies.

NaphtaliPress

Administrator
Staff member
Quite an afternoon; the 50 gallon hot water heater broke. Happily, not a lot of water, and none that I can see got outside the laundry room. Any one have any objections to tankless water heaters? It makes sense not to be heating water all the time; but we're also used to 'instant' hot water throughout the house. Any problems with these tankless heaters that folks know of? Plumbers on his way; I know some still try to sell you on the tank route.
 
I haven't heard of any problems with them. I have a few friends that love them. The only problem is the up front cost but it eventually pays for itself.
 
NaphtaliPress;

I haven't heard anything negative about them either...my husband wants to get one when we replace the current hotwater heater..
 
Thanks. The plumber said they were 2 or 3 times the cost, and if I go that way I'd want it mounted on the backside of the house; that requires maybe ten feet of piping for gas and water to get there. Anyone have any ideas on that? More opinions would be welcome; I told the plumber I'd take till Monday to decide which way to go. He did say if something broke it might take a week or two if you need a to replace a part. I figure that will change as they become more common.
 
"mounted on the backsideof the house" - sounds great. Here the tankless ones are are gas-fired and installed indoors. The pilot light will on occasion go out, filling the house with gas and killing the whole family. So if you're looking for caveats, there's one.
 
I have installed 'em before. If you can afford it, its the way to go. non stop supply! No tank to leak.
 
My plumber has basically told me that the technology is just not there yet to make it worthwhile. You may require mulitiple units depending on how many showers you have in the house. For example, a house with more than 2 showers will require at least 2 units which will run in sequence so as not to burn out 1 unit too quickly. You will spend thousands in upfront costs and may not realize an economic benefit for several years. Ie. $2000 in upfront costs versus $400 for a new water heater (self-installed), you may save $50 a month it will take 3 years to recoup the cost.

The biggest drawback to a tankless water heater is the price, averaging around $1,300 for the unit itself. This technology also requires larger gas lines, different exhaust vents and water treatment, creating additional installation expense.

Most tankless heaters have to be vented to the outside, much the same as your hotwater heater.

For that reason, tankless water heaters aren’t cost-effective for an existing home. But in a newly-constructed home, you can expect to have your investment paid back in energy savings in about five to seven years.

Another consideration is the maximum flow rate – if you have a large family, you might not have enough capacity to take two showers and run the clothes washer and dishwasher simultaneously.
 
My dad and stepmom are moving soon and they want to get a house that has one or have one installed. They sound pretty neat.
 
"mounted on the backsideof the house" - sounds great. Here the tankless ones are are gas-fired and installed indoors. The pilot light will on occasion go out, filling the house with gas and killing the whole family.

Just a minor inconvenience. :doh:
 
My plumber has basically told me that the technology is just not there yet to make it worthwhile. You may require mulitiple units depending on how many showers you have in the house. For example, a house with more than 2 showers will require at least 2 units which will run in sequence so as not to burn out 1 unit too quickly. You will spend thousands in upfront costs and may not realize an economic benefit for several years. Ie. $2000 in upfront costs versus $400 for a new water heater (self-installed), you may save $50 a month it will take 3 years to recoup the cost.

The biggest drawback to a tankless water heater is the price, averaging around $1,300 for the unit itself. This technology also requires larger gas lines, different exhaust vents and water treatment, creating additional installation expense.

Most tankless heaters have to be vented to the outside, much the same as your hotwater heater.

For that reason, tankless water heaters aren’t cost-effective for an existing home. But in a newly-constructed home, you can expect to have your investment paid back in energy savings in about five to seven years.

Another consideration is the maximum flow rate – if you have a large family, you might not have enough capacity to take two showers and run the clothes washer and dishwasher simultaneously.


These are great units! :up: :up: :up:

Actually the tchnology is there. We installed just one in new construction and can run at least 3 things a once (showers, dish washer, clothes washer). We have a family of 6. We have never seen it not keep up with our needs. But often was the time the 50 gal tank ran out when we all wanted showers or shower right after a few loads of laundry.

These things NEVER run out of water - as long as they can keep up with the demand. So we can have all 3 showers running all day!!!

We bought a Tekagi T-K1S. [Example site]. That brand and Rennai are the best (from what we understood last year). The others mostly use older tech. Also, keep in mind that Japan and Europe have used these for 50 years - its not new.

Cost. Ours was about $1200. But last year there was a $300 tax credit (not a deduction - actually $300!). So there is more up front. But they typically last 3 times as long (over 20 years). [Yes some tank heaters last longer than the average 7 years but we are talking averages. Ours may last much over 20 - who knows.]

Background. We are on propane. We live on the same property that we have been on for 8 years but were in a mobile home had a site-built home completed 9 months ago. So, same family, same place, same propane tank for comparison.

Savings: We are seeing our usage is about half! These units save most when gas fired (you can get electric but the savings is not as great). We use gas (propane) for the water heater and the stove. We have a dishwasher that we did not have before. We also now have a whirlpool jacuzzi tub in the master that needs more than the 50 gals just to fill up - not a problem now!

The only thing I noticed, as we did with the old tank, and has nothing to do with either - is water pressure. The more you have going on in the house the pressure drops some (at least out here). So, sometimed I have to turn the water up when I am in the shower - but there is hot water to be had.

"mounted on the backsideof the house" - sounds great. Here the tankless ones are are gas-fired and installed indoors. The pilot light will on occasion go out, filling the house with gas and killing the whole family. So if you're looking for caveats, there's one.

Ours has an pilot-less system (like new stoves), so no pilot light to go out.


Suggestions:
Find a plumber that has installed them and likes them - you'll get a different perspective.

Decide what is most cost effective - mounting in or out. Ours is inside on the back wall of our utility room where the the roof low - so minimal venting which is expensive.


If you want more info or expereince let me know.
 
You may have me sold. Our utility room is off the kitchen under the high point of the roof so, that, and simply because it is safer, I'd prefer it outside. Also, getting rid of the tank and putting the tankless outside frees up space in a very small room that houses the furnace and a stacked washer dryer unit.

The only question I have is can you get recirculating hot water with a tankless? My thought would be no. We have recircuating so the one bathroom farthest away has hot water pretty quick.

I would lean toward rennai at this point I think. What are the specs on your unit? I don't think we'd be running any more things at once than you do at your house. My brother told me not to overbuy and get a larger unit than we would need. There are two of us in the house now, but that could change in future or if the house is sold. Thanks again.

These are great units! :up: :up: :up:

Actually the tchnology is there. We installed just one in new construction and can run at least 3 things a once (showers, dish washer, clothes washer). We have a family of 6. We have never seen it not keep up with our needs. But often was the time the 50 gal tank ran out when we all wanted showers or shower right after a few loads of laundry.

These things NEVER run out of water - as long as they can keep up with the demand. So we can have all 3 showers running all day!!!

We bought a Tekagi T-K1S. [Example site]. That brand and Rennai are the best (from what we understood last year). The others mostly use older tech. Also, keep in mind that Japan and Europe have used these for 50 years - its not new.

Cost. Ours was about $1200. But last year there was a $300 tax credit (not a deduction - actually $300!). So there is more up front. But they typically last 3 times as long (over 20 years). [Yes some tank heaters last longer than the average 7 years but we are talking averages. Ours may last much over 20 - who knows.]

Background. We are on propane. We live on the same property that we have been on for 8 years but were in a mobile home had a site-built home completed 9 months ago. So, same family, same place, same propane tank for comparison.

Savings: We are seeing our usage is about half! These units save most when gas fired (you can get electric but the savings is not as great). We use gas (propane) for the water heater and the stove. We have a dishwasher that we did not have before. We also now have a whirlpool jacuzzi tub in the master that needs more than the 50 gals just to fill up - not a problem now!

The only thing I noticed, as we did with the old tank, and has nothing to do with either - is water pressure. The more you have going on in the house the pressure drops some (at least out here). So, sometimed I have to turn the water up when I am in the shower - but there is hot water to be had.



Ours has an pilot-less system (like new stoves), so no pilot light to go out.


Suggestions:
Find a plumber that has installed them and likes them - you'll get a different perspective.

Decide what is most cost effective - mounting in or out. Ours is inside on the back wall of our utility room where the the roof low - so minimal venting which is expensive.


If you want more info or expereince let me know.
 
The only question I have is can you get recirculating hot water with a tankless? My thought would be no. We have recircuating so the one bathroom farthest away has hot water pretty quick.

To have recirculating hot water you will need an additional 20 gallon hot water that is used for storage along with the recirculating pump. Otherwise your tankless will run non-stop.
 
"mounted on the backsideof the house" - sounds great. Here the tankless ones are are gas-fired and installed indoors. The pilot light will on occasion go out, filling the house with gas and killing the whole family. So if you're looking for caveats, there's one.
I don't know whether to tell if you are kidding, but I find it difficult to believe that when a pilot light goes out the gas would continue to flow, since there are safeties to prevent it from doing so. My fireplace and my water heater have had their respective pilots go out several times. Had the gas continued to flow we would have met our maker from the explosion when the furnace fired up.
 
I would lean toward rennai at this point I think. What are the specs on your unit?

From the web site I provided a link to above:

Takagi T-K1S Specifications
Power input Natural Gas 15,000 - 190,000 BTU
LP Gas 17,000 - 190,000 BTU
Water Pressure Minimum 15 PSI / Maximum 150 PSI
Gas Connection 3/4" NPT
Water Connection 3/4" NPT
Gas Pressure Natural Min. 5" WC / Max. 10.5" WC
Gas Pressure LP Min. 11" WC / Max. 14" WC
Manifold Pressure Natural 2.6" WC / LP 3.4" WC
Electrical Supply AC 120 Volts
60°F Temp. Rise 4.7 GPM
70°F Temp. Rise 4.2 GPM
90°F Temp. Rise 3.5 GPM
Dimensions 24" x 16.5" x 8"
Ignition Electronic Ignition

This site lists the gallons per minute (gpm) at of 7.2.

My understanding is that you need 1.5 to 2 gpm per running fixture (shower, washer, etc) so this unit should be able to handle 3 (4.5-6gpm). This also does depend on how warm the water in going into the unit and hot you want the water to be. We have ours set to output at 122F.

Also see Takagi's web site.
 
Nope, not kidding. We had an expat American here die from CO poisoning a few years ago in this sort of incident, at which time people started telling us these other horror stories. It is apparently quite common here. I'm sure that when you pay $1200 for one of these things, there are all sorts of safeties. But when it's $50 new, you just don't get the same quality...
 
Nope, not kidding. We had an expat American here die from CO poisoning a few years ago in this sort of incident, at which time people started telling us these other horror stories. It is apparently quite common here. I'm sure that when you pay $1200 for one of these things, there are all sorts of safeties. But when it's $50 new, you just don't get the same quality...
That seems quite unusual, although as you say a $50 unit probably doesn't have the same reliability as a more expensive one. CO is caused by incomplete combustion of the natural (or propane) gas, so if someone died from CO poisoning then something had to be burning. Either gas by itself would not cause that, although you might succumb to oxygen deprivation.

The articles from Wikipedia on natural gas and propane gas are quite interesting.

BTW, I went to a renewable energy house that used the solar collectors to pre-heat the water that went into a whole house tank-less water heater. That was a very nice setup. My next house is going to have something along that line, deo volente.
 
Last edited:
Ah, perhaps that was it, the poor venting + combustion. Places do go boom and people do die of the gas poisoning, but the biggest recommendation in most places is not a smoke detector, but a CO detector. in the countryside, there are a lot of kangs, heated stone beds (fires burn beneath them to warm them) and there's a big problem out there with CO deaths.
 
Thanks all. Looks like I'm not going tankless. The person with the bathroom at the end of the line likes the recirculating system and not waiting for hot water, and the difficulties to match this with the tankless are not worth it at this time.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top