Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
How would you respond to the following question:
If innerancy applies to the autographs, which we do not have access to, does innerancy matter?
I would say that it matters because it says something about God. If one believes in inspiration of the originals but does not believe in inerrancy then one is saying that God has erred.
There are some articles regarding inerrancy that are linked from Theopedia.
Using binary numbers I can represent how the original can be deduced. This is just a way to figure out what a correct rendering might be.
A subjective weight for each considering age and number of copies will be attached. The weights would be based on studying examples where the autograph was known and how variants surfaced in later copies.
Autograph: xxxx
a: 1001 1000 copies: weight = 10; later copies weight = 2
b: 1000 200 copies: weight = 2; old copies weight = 5
c: 1000 500 copies weight = 5; mid age copy weight = 3
So using a crude formula (if it were accurate) the rendering that carries the most weight would be the b and c if the weights might be multiplied and added.
If God preserved a and it is without error, the case is closed.
If that is not known, some type of study has to weigh copies against each other.
For NT textual criticism, the spread of textual variants is like a shot gun blast whose BBs stayed tight together over a long range. The range is narrow with many BBs right on target. Some lined right behind the other. You trace the projectory back to the source (the barrel of the shot gun). We do this by seeing where all the BBs were in space and time working backward.
Never knew about Theopedia...cool site.
OK. So granting that one cannot have inspiration without innerancy, what practical reason does it serve? If I have a million dollars that I can't access, the million dollars is still spendable, but...I can't spend it. Yes, God is trustworthy and God accomplishes his purposes through his Word...but it is not the original inspired autographa through which he accomplishes those purposes...it is through translations of extant manuscripts.
With that in mind, what good does innerancy do, especially when God's character is not at stake in the discussion?
That's not necessarily an illogical statement. For example...The multiplicity of texts are errant, but the message is inerrant.
Kevin,
That's not necessarily an illogical statement. For example...
errant text: My n4me is Larry
still holds an inerrant message.
Do you believe in the verbal plenary preservation of the autographs?
My point was simply that you could have a statement where the words are errant but the meaning is still conveyed without any errancy.
I have a dog
I have an dog
these statements each convey the exact same inerrant message, but the one is errant in its text.
I don't disagree, as far as it goes. All I'm saying is that the only reason the second statement makes any sense is because we have a standard by which to compare it ... the first. And the only reason we can understand the first is because we have a working knowledge of the language. Hence the idea that a group of errant texts can give birth to an inerrant message is illogical.
I agree that a group of errant texts can't reveal an inerrant message only if we have no working knowledge of the language that it is written in.
Still more is required ... the belief that inerrancy is a possibility.
Good point.
If i'm not mistaken the formalizing of the inerrancy doctrine did not come about until B.B. Warfield. In the 16-17th centuries the Scriptures are generally referred to as inspired and infallible, but many seem to count the apographs with the same regard. Then Warfield made inerrancy of autographs a point of reference.
Sounds like you've been reading Letis. I thought the world of him. I once had a conversation (not a debate) wherein he pointed out to me Warfield's use of inerrancy, and thought it unfortunate. I was still studying the issue when he unfortunately died.
However I ended up disagreeing with him based on 2 Timothy 3:16-17. Like the word "Trinity," or the phrase "justification by faith," the actual word(s) do not have to be present so long as the teaching is contained in the text. Between thopneustos, ophelimos, artios, and exartizo, inerrancy is both affirmed and taught.
Yes, i have read him and enjoyed the reading. I just let my pastor borrow that book so we could discuss the issues that Letis brings to the table.
I agree with the doctrine of autographic inerrancy simply because referring to the immediately inspired text speaks to God's character. I guess the real question is can we claim inerrancy in the apographs.
My question then would be: What's authoritative for you ... the autographs, or your understanding of God's character?
My question then would be: What's authoritative for you ... the autographs, or your understanding of God's character?
I think this question hits the nail on the head. To the extent God's character is unknown via general revelation, I would think the autographs would have to take primacy. In other words,, the attributes of God's character such as trustworthiness / faithfulness, whereby His Word is rendered infallible / inerrant are known by the translation of those autographs and cannot be known from any other source of revelation...or so it would seem to me.
However, circularity must entail because we trust the Bible because it says it is theopneustos and we we trust theopneustos because the Bible tells us to do so.
Sorry for the thinking out loud! I do believe Kevin's question captures the essence of the discussion.
First, there are no translations of the autographs, we don't have them. To my knowledge the autographs were never part of the canon itself (brought together in one book).
Second, i think there is more to it than we trust the Bible because it tells us it is inspired. It is only by the inner testimony of the Holy Spirit that we come to believe in the Bible as God's word.
If we are speaking of God's mind before the Scriptures were even written then the autographs and apographs did not exist at all.As James White asks: Was there a canon in God's mind before the church drew up a canon? If not then the whole Reformation endeavor is useless and we all return to Rome and shut up. If yes, then we must ask what role the autographs (and apographs) play in His design.
I do not think it possible to have a non-believer adhere to the Bible's inerrancy. I believe that only comes to believers by the illumination of the Spirit.Rome also claims the "inner testimony of the Spirit" for its own authority, as well as Mormons, JWs (and probably Scientologists). Yes, there is testimony of the Spirit, but it is not "only", not by itself. Especially when speaking with skeptics, we must take into consideration both the internal witness of the Scriptures to themselves, and external (secular) evidence that lends itself to inerrancy.
Can you tell me where the Catholic church speaks of the inner testimony of the Holy Spirit for its authority as opposed to the Church for its authority??It was by the apostolic Tradition that the Church discerned which writings are to be included in the list of the sacred books. This complete list is called the canon of Scripture. It includes 46 books for the Old Testament (45 if we count Jeremiah and Lamentations as one) and 27 for the New.
our full persuasion and assurance of the infallible truth and divine authority thereof, is from the inward work of the Holy Spirit, bearing witness by and with the Word in our hearts.
If we are speaking of God's mind before the Scriptures were even written then the autographs and apographs did not exist at all.
If we are speaking of the role that God has for the autographs - it would seem not much of a role as they probably were not in existence for too long after created. And when God worked to canonize the Scriptures into a book they were not used. In that sense i think God has more of a role for the apographs.
I do not think it possible to have a non-believer adhere to the Bible's inerrancy. I believe that only comes to believers by the illumination of the Spirit.
The Catholic catechism says this of the canonization of Scripture (4.120)...
Can you tell me where the Catholic church speaks of the inner testimony of the Holy Spirit for its authority as opposed to the Church for its authority??
The WCOF claims this (1.5)...
In God's mind the canon would have existed along with everything else, but i don't think it could be considered a canon in that medium. To me the canon is a group of books being brought together into one book as the word of God. So i would say "no" in a technical sense. Just as I would say that i didn't exist before my conception even though i was in the mind of God.You didn't answer the question. Look again at what White asks: Did God have a canon prior to the church's canon?
Staphlobob,
I think i understand a little better of where you are coming from in regards to external sources backing up the Bible, and i think i agree with you on that.
In God's mind the canon would have existed along with everything else, but i don't think it could be considered a canon in that medium. To me the canon is a group of books being brought together into one book as the word of God. So i would say "no" in a technical sense. Just as I would say that i didn't exist before my conception even though i was in the mind of God.