Justification & Sanctification?

Status
Not open for further replies.

thistle93

Puritan Board Freshman
Would you say it is Biblical to state that justification is purely monergistic while sanctification is synergistic? Obviously it is the power of the Holy Spirit that gives us ability in our sanctification but there seem to be many verses in Scripture that speak to the will of the regenerate believer to obey, act and choose to live holy.

Philippians 2:12-13 is a perfect example of the tension:

Therefore, my beloved, as you have always obeyed, so now, not only as in my presence but much more in my absence, work out your own salvation with fear and trembling, for it is God who works in you, both to will and to work for his good pleasure. (ESV)

Not that we can take any credit for our sanctification but I do see where many expect God to just magically sanctify them and they set back and wait passively, which I believe is unbiblical.


For His Glory-
Matthew
 
Synergy is a tricky term. When it comes to talking spiritual merit, we should shun it. Salvation is monergistic from beginning to end.

In justification, we are dead prior, and alive after. No input from us.

In sanctification, we begin alive and grow in grace like a newborn babe. None of our input counts as growth.

An infant takes in food, it is "active" and it wiggles. Is it "trying" to grow? No, it's just growing; that's what live babies do. The energy all comes from outside.

There's no real tension in the spiritual picture. "Sanctification is a work of God's free grace," not our working, that enables us to do things that can be seen as evidence of our living and growing in Christ.

If we understood "synergism" purely to mean this paired human activity (work, of a sort) entirely resulting from and dependent on the activating work (energy, nourishment) of God--correlated yes, but not strictly cooperative--that finely defined, perhaps we could use the term. I suppose that's the sense I recall RC Sproul using it.

But in the space of two-to-three decades, we have found the enemies of free justification using this synergistic language to force works into a "final justification" scheme, a move that is fatal to the recoveries of the Protestant Reformation. If our so-called cooperation is ever counted as "meritorious," or "worthy," sanctification collapses into justification.

Better to divide the monergists and the synergists entirely, and take the side of the former in everything related to salvation. We do not contribute (work together) with God to achieve either our initial or our ongoing renovation. Neither are we in the least glorified on account of anything up till then done by our own strength.

But we should enjoy some of the exercises and triumphs of our growth in grace, acknowledging the tears too. Who ever heard of a healthy couch-potato? There's plenty of "semblance of life" in the church.
 
The WLC speaks of "infuse[d] grace" when describing sanctification in contrast to justification. That seems like an important distinction.
 
Monergism relates to "regeneration," in which the person is passive. Having been regenerated the man becomes active. The exercise of faith in receiving the righteousness of Christ for justification is the person's own act. Strictly speaking, therefore, not even justification is monergistic. It is best to restrict the terms monergism and synergism to the controversy over regeneration.
 
The Oxford dictionary defines synergy this way:

the interaction or cooperation of two or more organizations, substances, or other agents to produce a combined effect greater than the sum of their separate effects

If we go by this definition, I think Bruce is spot on, since the sum total of our work adds nothing to God.
 
If we go by this definition, I think Bruce is spot on, since the sum total of our work adds nothing to God.

On that definition there are no synergists. We could not speak of Melanchthon becoming a synergist. At which point, the term has become meaningless in theological discussion.
 
I always appreciate the clarity Rev. Winzer's precision brings to the topic. One doesn't have to fight over the propriety of certain words if he rightly assesses the context and uses terms correctly to begin with.

It's a reminder of the exceeding breadth of the theological domain; and that a real master of the discussion is ever cognizant of the relation the locus has to the whole, so that he may avoid inartful use of the language.

There's help (mine? maybe? depends). Then there's real help, such as MW has brought.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top