PB thread record

[chbrooking]

Anybody know the longest PB threads on record?
Most views/replies
Longest running
That sort of thing

 

[OPC'n]

I don't know but can't we take bets who was in it?

 

[Calvinist Cowboy]

The ultimate thread (most replies) was this one...http://www.puritanboard.com/f52/how-many-posts-until-you-graduate-puritanboard-freshman-44766/.
*sigh* that was a good thread.

 

[OPC'n]

Are you sure? I thought there was one that had over 1200 replies...

 

[Calvinist Cowboy]

Really? I'm betting it was either an RPW or baptism thread. (not that I would ever bet...)

 

[OPC'n]

Not sure....might have been the number a views that I saw.

 

[Jesus is my friend]

The ultimate thread (most replies) was this one...http://www.puritanboard.com/f52/how-many-posts-until-you-graduate-puritanboard-freshman-44766/.
*sigh* that was a good thread.

Those were the good old days!

 

[Montanablue]

Don't threads automatically close after a certain period? I've looked up a lot of really old threads (when I've been curious about a certain issue etc) and it seems like they're all closed - and most of them aren't heated, so it seems like they're automatically being closed. Am I crazy or does this happen?

 

[Beth Ellen Nagle]

Don't threads automatically close after a certain period? I've looked up a lot of really old threads (when I've been curious about a certain issue etc) and it seems like they're all closed - and most of them aren't heated, so it seems like they're automatically being closed. Am I crazy or does this happen?

Oh, you're just losing it.

 

[forgivenmuch]

The ultimate thread (most replies) was this one...http://www.puritanboard.com/f52/how-many-posts-until-you-graduate-puritanboard-freshman-44766/.
*sigh* that was a good thread.

That was a good thread. It got weirder and weirder the longer and longer it got.

 

[Puritan Sailor]

Don't threads automatically close after a certain period? I've looked up a lot of really old threads (when I've been curious about a certain issue etc) and it seems like they're all closed - and most of them aren't heated, so it seems like they're automatically being closed. Am I crazy or does this happen?

For the last couple years, the threads are closed about 6 months after the last post. Before that, some old threads were resurrected by new folks, and know one remembered the context, so it was kinda weird, to pick up the conversation again, and usually end up going down a rabbit trail. Now we have to stay more specific in the threads.

I believe the longest thread was about 5 years ago, a debate over Theological Traditionalism, but for some reason it's not showing up on the search function. Perhaps more rivals are some of the older threads on Baptism, Theonomy, and Amil/Postmil, and more recent threads on Creation and EP.

 

[NaphtaliPress]

I don't recall the cut off, but inactive threads are closed after a period of time. The thread Patrick noted seems to be one of the longest at 539, but short of the when do I graduate thread with 579 posts.
http://www.puritanboard.com/f59/dreaded-concept-theological-traditionalis-2342/

Don't threads automatically close after a certain period? I've looked up a lot of really old threads (when I've been curious about a certain issue etc) and it seems like they're all closed - and most of them aren't heated, so it seems like they're automatically being closed. Am I crazy or does this happen?

For the last couple years, the threads are closed about 6 months after the last post. Before that, some old threads were resurrected by new folks, and know one remembered the context, so it was kinda weird, to pick up the conversation again, and usually end up going down a rabbit trail. Now we have to stay more specific in the threads.

I believe the longest thread was about 5 years ago, a debate over Theological Traditionalism, but for some reason it's not showing up on the search function. Perhaps more rivals are some of the older threads on Baptism, Theonomy, and Amil/Postmil, and more recent threads on Creation and EP.