There were a number of things that stood out to me, but one in particular about this version in contrast to the original: the lack of keeping the listeners interest. The 1/8 note rythym of the acoustic guitar was never "broken up" by anything interesting. The original was chock full of guitar double stops, slides, chorus/delay effects, cool and appropriate drum beat changes, bass fills.....all things to make a song interesting and demonstrate mature song-writing/execution. The Eagles live Hell Freezes Over DVD demonstrates the very best execution of this of which I'm aware......
I agree with Edward....they arent vocally mature enough to have the vocal pull of the interest.......Small Potatoes did this well....