Philip A:
Two Kingdoms, two nations, two peoples, two covenants, one Abraham.
Where is there a mention of "two" kingdoms in the NT? None that I know of.
We do, however, see that the Kingdom of GOD (His people, in covenant with Him) can be compared to:
- A Vine with branches; Branches that don't produce fruit (but are ON THE VINE AND PART OF SOMETHING) are
cut off and thrown in the fire at the end of the age! They were part of the covenant, the kingdom of God, and then cut off for not producing fruit.
- A field of wheat with tares sown in by the enemy; The tares are separated from the wheat at the END OF TIME when the angels throw the tares (who were all along part of the kingdom, visibly and in covenant with God) into the fire.
- A group of 12 disciples, one of them being a traitor and covenant breaker/apostate; Christ, knowing this, still gives him the CUP OF THE NEW COVENANT IN HIS OWN BLOOD!; I guess Jesus Christ was in error to include an apostate/covenant breaker, unregenerate person in His covenant?
There's many more examples that could be given, but your simple reduction of the Abrahamic covenant doesn't hold up, as the line of "the flesh" is referring to what we now know as the Muslim nation; Are you saying that the Muslims are in covenant with God? I would hope not. They are the line of the "flesh" because they are turned over to the law as a curse, being separated from God. Those who are of the line of the "promise" are those who are in covenant with God. We all know that Scripture clearly teaches us that only those who persevere and endure will be saved, and that this is the work of God in the hearts of men. We are also told to make our "calling and election" sure. Why be told these things unless there are many who are in covenant with God, yet not saved? Hebrews makes this idea very clear, as well. Chapter 10 is the most compelling evidence for covenant breaking in all of Scripture, aside from the very words and teachings of Jesus Christ Himself...
Hagar is associated with Sinai (the giving of the Law), because, as we all know, Paul's issue at hand in Galatians is justification by FAITH IN Christ ALONE apart from external works of the Law. Those who live by the law die by the law as a curse. Hagar and her seed are associated with Sinai because they are NOT in covenant with God, they are left to the law as a curse, with the rest of mankind outside of God's covenant of grace. The law was only a blessing to the elect, as it pointed them and their faith towards the work of Christ.
You are taking Galatians 3-4 way out of context to justify your presuppositions about what Paul should be saying according to your misreading of the Abrahamic covenant.
Grace and peace,
Gabe