Two Incomes Necessary?

Ezekiel

Puritan Board Freshman
I heard that we ought to have two incomes because of inflation.

Maybe it is not the same, but my great-grandfather and mother were really poor, and they had seven children (only he worked).

May I ask, are two incomes actually necessary, or is inflation simply being used as an excuse?
 
They are only necessary if you need them. This is the danger, ironically, of socialist thinking (not saying you are a socialist). It's very difficult to look at someone else and say what is "necessary" for them (beyond housing, food, etc.).
 
It is hard to respond without knowing the full context of what was said and who they said it to.

Certainly the current set up in the USA, and I am sure other Western countries, has made it more difficult on single income households. What was possible in the past is more challenging today.

Can families do so? Certainly. But that also is dependent on a number of factors. What income does the single earner make? Where do they live? What kind of debt have they accumulated? A couple may desire to live off a single income but maybe they both have student debt they are paying off. Maybe the husband has a career plan but needs to attend school and so both husband and wife are working some to make that work.

You could have dual income because the couple wants a fancier house, better cars, and more vacations. In that situation a discussion with church elders would be prudent.

At the end of the day, without knowing a couple and their situation, it would be hard to evaluate if they should have one or two incomes.
 
I am confused. Do you mean inflation is just being used as an excuse?
No. I am not judging whether someone needs two incomes. If you have trouble making ends meet on one income, then you need to get another (or get rid of things you don't need). It's as simple as that. I pick up a few side hustles in the summer. Both my wife and I work, but she works as a secretary at the church, which allows her to homeschool our daughter.
 
There are many ‘less desirable’ areas that tend to be affordable. I say this as a life long Midwest guy. But it does take wisdom and letting go of certain worldly pleasure that seem necessary.

Plus, the math actually normally doesn’t add up - you may only end up netting 10k more with two incomes over a single income. And I would argue 10 is probably not worth the stress that having two full time workers brings.

The best is a wife with a side hustle or part time, but that’s only doable to a certain point when little ones are introduced. Older kids make it easier, and expenses may be higher making that second income nice for some breathing room.

I work full time, my wife tries to get 20 hours in a week remote. We have a 14 month old. All I want is to make enough so she doesn’t have to work. And buy a house.
 
I heard that we ought to have two incomes because of inflation.

Maybe it is not the same, but my great-grandfather and mother were really poor, and they had seven children (only he worked).

May I ask, are two incomes actually necessary, or is inflation simply being used as an excuse?
I am convinced that two incomes are not needed. Our current economic climate certainly makes it much more difficult to survive on one income, though.

With that said, I still maintain that the biggest reasons for "needing" two incomes are materialism/poor financial stewardship and wives who are not content being at home raising their children full-time; not the economy.

We have three children and make far less money on my single income than many men who claim it is necessary for their wives to work outside the home.
 
Last edited:
It is, generally speaking, possible to squeeze by on one income.

Whether that is what one wishes to do is a personal question.

You may not have enough for a second car, a house in the part of town you'd like, health insurance, and so on. You may have to put in extra hours. You may not be able to take a vacation. You may have to rent instead of purchasing a house. Etc. But you may think that the wife staying home with the kids, or keeping out of the public school, is worth the trade off.

And, of course, one can always make more. It's easier said than done, of course, but I know car salesmen making upwards of 200k a year just because they know their family relies on them and so they get to it and sell some cars.
 
I think it is safe to say that if you want to live like everyone else, you will need either one really high salary or two average salaries. A dual income household is the normal state of affairs in our society.

I try to remind myself and my wife that "they" don't value what we value. We are going to say "no" to many things in order to say "yes" to more important things. This will make us different than most & we need to be okay with that. I would posit that the three areas where people unintentionally force themselves into a dual income corner are:
1: Student Debt
2: House/Mortgage
3: Car Loans (or just paying too much)

You don't even have to avoid these entirely, you just need to take far less than they will loan you.
 
It is something I’ve stressed to my sons: if they want to be able to have their wives stay home and raise their kids, and do so comfortably without the spectre of poverty hanging over their heads, then they need to work hard to develop the skills to land them the kind of job that will enable them to bring home sufficient funds to make that possible.
 
It is something I’ve stressed to my sons: if they want to be able to have their wives stay home and raise their kids, and do so comfortably without the spectre of poverty hanging over their heads, then they need to work hard to develop the skills to land them the kind of job that will enable them to bring home sufficient funds to make that possible.
And not take on so much debt in securing those skills as to negate the income they bring in
 
My household has only had one income since my first child was born 15 years ago and my wife left the workforce. We are a family of six. We own a home. We own two vehicles. Other than a mortgage, we are debt free. We actually live on 78% of my income as I tithe 10% gross and presently invest 12% pre-tax of my wages. My suggestions to young men are, enter the workforce early, as in a teenager. Work full-time when you graduate high school. Find a career you can advance in. Find an employer with good benefits (health, retirement, etc.) Find an employer who will pay for your college. Tithe. Don't spend money you don't have. Avoid debt as much as possible.
I think it's doable, the bigger issue than inflation, low wages, etc. seems to be the consumer mindset of Americans who think they must have a brand new vehicle, 2,000+ sq ft home, new iPhones, designer clothes, etc. Nothing wrong with those things if a person can afford them but don't covet and try to keep up with the proverbial Joneses. Live as unto the Lord. Hold to this world (including it's possessions) very loosely.
Proverbs 16:3 "Commit thy works unto the Lord, and thy thoughts shall be established."
 
Maybe it is not the same, but my great-grandfather and mother were really poor, and they had seven children (only he worked).
Well, it today's economy, if one has 7 children, one isn't going to be able to afford a two income household. Childcare costs are going to far exceed the second income. Worst case scenario, the second income would raise you out of the income band for having the taxpayers subsidize your lifestyle.

Dual income probably works best at mid to upper five figure incomes for both and at most two children. Income disparity becomes a factor, and at some points becomes a lifestyle choice - weighing the lower income against the cost of childcare. Employer subsidized childcare can also be a factor.
 
There are many variables that come into play with this topic. I think that we can all agree though that it is becoming more challenging to be a single income family.
 
and do so comfortably without the spectre of poverty hanging over their heads
Wise counsel from a father to his sons!

As the head of a household of only three (myself, my wife, and our tween daughter), I make a very average salary at a job I love. For the time being, my wife and I have chosen to forego things like homeownership and savings for the future in order to allow my wife to homeschool our daughter while working very part-time at our daughter's hybrid homeschool as a teacher and aide.

We're continually facing the "specter of poverty hanging over our heads." While we value certain things and are comfortable with the decisions we've made, I can tell you that it isn't easy. It really feels like I need to do more to bring home some additional income so that every time something goes wrong, we aren't sinking underwater. The challenge is that I have health and energy issues that make doing much more than my full-time job all but a pipe dream at the moment.

The easy solution would be to send my daughter to public school and have my wife return to work. That's what most of my unbelieving family thinks we should do, and they're right that it would certainly go a long way toward fixing our financial dilemma. But my wife and I have placed greater value on having her home with our daughter and being able to care for our aging parents while I'm at work.

My wife might be able to add some babysitting into the mix, and I'm grateful that she's even willing to do that. I may need to find some side work which doesn't take too much out of me physically, which is probably easier said than done (given my blend of health conditions).

Prayers for wisdom as we navigate these things, and that I might look to Christ while loving and leading my family well, would be much appreciated, brothers and sisters.
 
My dad was in the army and was able to buy a home and raise 4 kids including a holiday once a year in Ireland.

I make more than he ever did and had to move back home with my wife to try save to get a house in a worse area. (Speaking of Ireland) it’s tough but at least here multi generational households are normal enough.
 
One income is enough. Just live within your means. There are not many things we actually need, just a lot of stuff we want. We need to change our wants in some cases. I would say these days, home schooling is essential as the government schools are purely their to radicalize the next generation. There are exceptions of course. Most of the women in my church do not work and family sizes are 3-5 children, so it is doable.
 
Back
Top