James on both sides of the Jerusalem Council

chuckd

Puritan Board Junior
Acts 15:5 But some believers who belonged to the party of the Pharisees rose up and said, “It is necessary to circumcise them and to order them to keep the law of Moses.”

Acts 15:13 After they finished speaking, James replied, “Brothers, listen to me.

Acts 15:19-21 Therefore my judgment is that we should not trouble those of the Gentiles who turn to God, 20 but should write to them to abstain from the things polluted by idols, and from sexual immorality, and from what has been strangled, and from blood. 21 For from ancient generations Moses has had in every city those who proclaim him, for he is read every Sabbath in the synagogues.”

James and the rest of the apostles send Paul and Barnabas to Antioch with the letter.

Years later, Paul returns to Jerusalem and meets James. Acts 21:18 On the following day Paul went in with us to James, and all the elders were present.

James tells Paul in Acts 21:20-22 And when they heard it, they glorified God. And they said to him, “You see, brother, how many thousands there are among the Jews of those who have believed. They are all zealous for the law, 21 and they have been told about you that you teach all the Jews who are among the Gentiles to forsake Moses, telling them not to circumcise their children or walk according to our customs. 22 What then is to be done? They will certainly hear that you have come.

What did he expect? He's the one that sent Paul and Barnabas to the Gentiles with that message in the first place. Was Paul supposed to teach the Jews one thing (keep circumcision and the customs) and the Gentiles another (don't circumcise or keep the customs)?
 
Acts 15:5 But some believers who belonged to the party of the Pharisees rose up and said, “It is necessary to circumcise them and to order them to keep the law of Moses.”

Acts 15:13 After they finished speaking, James replied, “Brothers, listen to me.

Acts 15:19-21 Therefore my judgment is that we should not trouble those of the Gentiles who turn to God, 20 but should write to them to abstain from the things polluted by idols, and from sexual immorality, and from what has been strangled, and from blood. 21 For from ancient generations Moses has had in every city those who proclaim him, for he is read every Sabbath in the synagogues.”

James and the rest of the apostles send Paul and Barnabas to Antioch with the letter.

Years later, Paul returns to Jerusalem and meets James. Acts 21:18 On the following day Paul went in with us to James, and all the elders were present.

James tells Paul in Acts 21:20-22 And when they heard it, they glorified God. And they said to him, “You see, brother, how many thousands there are among the Jews of those who have believed. They are all zealous for the law, 21 and they have been told about you that you teach all the Jews who are among the Gentiles to forsake Moses, telling them not to circumcise their children or walk according to our customs. 22 What then is to be done? They will certainly hear that you have come.

What did he expect? He's the one that sent Paul and Barnabas to the Gentiles with that message in the first place. Was Paul supposed to teach the Jews one thing (keep circumcision and the customs) and the Gentiles another (don't circumcise or keep the customs)?

As providence would have it, I am in this area in my personal studies so I think I may be able to help here.

The tension you are feeling in Acts 21 is the exact historical crisis Owen was just describing in my other thread: how Paul and James navigated those thousands of believing Jews in Jerusalem who were still fiercely attached to the Mosaic customs during the transitional decades before the Temple fell in A.D. 70.

The key to untangling the passage is noticing the sharp distinction James makes between what was taught to believing Gentiles versus what was rumored about Paul's teaching to believing Jews. If you drop down just three verses further to Acts 21:25, James actually brings up the Acts 15 council himself:

"But as touching the Gentiles which believe, we have written and concluded that they observe no such thing, save only that they keep themselves from things offered to idols, and from blood, and from strangled, and from fornication."

In other words, James and the Jerusalem elders were not backtracking on Acts 15 at all. As John Gill points out on verse 21, the fact that Paul taught Gentiles to disregard the rituals of Moses gave the Jerusalem church no uneasiness whatsoever. That was settled law among the apostles.

What had the thousands of Jewish believers in Jerusalem up in arms was a very specific rumor about what Paul was telling ethnic Jews living outside Judea. Look closely at the wording in verse 21:

"They have been informed about you that you teach all the Jews who are among the Gentiles to forsake Moses, telling them not to circumcise their children or walk according to our customs."

Notice the charge: Paul's enemies were claiming that wherever Paul went in the Gentile world, he forbade Jewish Christians from circumcising their boys or practicing any of their ancestral customs. That was the claim.

Was that rumor true? Not at all.

Literally right after leaving the Jerusalem Council, while delivering the Acts 15 decrees to the churches, Paul arrived in Derbe and Lystra and had Timothy circumcised because his mother was Jewish (Acts 16:1-4). Compare that with Galatians 2:3-5, where Paul flatly refused to circumcise Titus.

Why the difference? Because Titus was a Greek, and the Judaizers were demanding his circumcision as necessary for salvation; whereas Timothy was half-Jewish, and Paul used circumcision freely as a matter of cultural accommodation so Timothy could minister in the synagogues.

Later on, Paul himself shaved his head in Cenchreae because he had taken a Jewish vow (Acts 18:18), and he hurried to Jerusalem to keep the feast of Pentecost (Acts 18:21; 20:16).

In 1 Corinthians 9:20-21, Paul explains his missionary principle in plain terms: to the Jews he became as a Jew in order to win Jews, and to those outside the law he became as one outside the law in order to win them.

So to answer your second question: was Paul supposed to teach the Jews one thing and the Gentiles another?

When it came to how a sinner is justified and saved before God, Paul preached the exact same message in every synagogue and every Gentile marketplace: nobody, whether Jew or Gentile, is justified by the works of the law or by circumcision (Galatians 2:15-16; Acts 15:11). If any man, Jew or Gentile, trusted in circumcision for salvation, Paul warned that Christ would profit him nothing (Galatians 5:2).

However, when it came to whether a first-century Jewish believer could continue practicing his ancestral customs out of national heritage or weakness of conscience (without trusting in them for salvation or forcing them on Gentiles), Paul treated those customs as adiaphora, or things indifferent (Romans 14:1-6; 1 Corinthians 7:18-20).

John Gill explains what was going on in the hearts of those Jerusalem believers on Acts 21:20: though they truly believed in Jesus as the Messiah, they did not yet have enough light to see that all the Mosaic ceremonies were abolished in Him. God in His patience gave the Jewish church a forty-year transition period between the Cross and the destruction of the Temple in A.D. 70.

As Augustine famously put it, before the Gospel was fully established and the Temple fell, the Mosaic ceremonies were like a beloved parent who had died: they were dead (no longer binding or life-giving), and once buried they would be deadly to dig back up, but during the apostolic transition they were being given an honorable burial so as not to needlessly shock devout Jewish consciences.

So... James has an idea in verses 23 and 24: four poor Jewish Christians in the Jerusalem church had taken a temporary Nazarite vow (Numbers 6).

As Gill notes from the Jewish canons in Maimonides, it was a common, recognized act of charity among the Jews for a visiting brother to pay the temple fees ("be at charges with them") so that poor Nazarites could afford to shave their heads and conclude their vow.

Note very closely here: James was not asking Paul to retract a single syllable of Galatians or Acts 15.

He was simply advising Paul, as a matter of brotherly prudence (1 Corinthians 9:20), to sponsor these four men in their customary purification so the crowd in Jerusalem would see with their own eyes that Paul was not some anti-Jewish radical forbidding Jewish families from honoring their heritage. And ten years later, when God Himself used the Roman armies in A.D. 70 to tear down the Temple and writes the book of Hebrews to prepare them for it, God finally took the scaffolding down for good.

Do you have Turretin? Look up Locus 11, Question 25, "On the Abrogation of the Ceremonial Law".

If the Ceremonial Law of Moses was abrogated by the death of Christ on the Cross (Colossians 2:14; Ephesians 2:15), how could James advise and Paul practice the Nazarite purification rituals in the Temple in Acts 21:24-26 without sinning or building again what they had destroyed?

A skeptic might object:

"Either the Mosaic ceremonies were still binding on ethnic Jews (which contradicts Hebrews 7:12 and 8:13, and creates a two-peoples dispensationalism), or they were completely abolished at the Cross, in which case James and Paul compromised the Gospel by participating in Temple rites in Acts 21."

But we must distinguish between the abrogation of the Ceremonial Law as to its legal right and obligation (de jure) versus its cessation as to actual practice and public fact (de facto).

First, de jure (by right and conscience), the entire Old Covenant and its ceremonial law were legally abolished the moment Christ cried "It is finished" and the veil was torn in two. From that hour forward, no ceremony had any power to typify a Messiah yet to come, to bind the conscience, or to make anyone righteous.

Second, de facto (in outward practice), the exercise of those ceremonies passed through three distinct stages (borrowing Augustine's famous triad from his correspondence with Jerome, Epistle 82):

a) before Christ's passion, the ceremonies were viva (living and obligatory);

b) after the destruction of the Temple in A.D. 70 and the full publication of the Gospel (such as the Epistle to the Hebrews), they became mortifera (deadly to anyone who revived them);

c) but in the middle window between the Cross and A.D. 70, they were mortua (dead, yet indifferent as to outward use when practiced out of charity toward weak Jewish brethren who had been raised under the Sinaitic economy).

Third, because circumcision and the Mosaic ordinances belonged strictly to the national Old Covenant made with Abraham's fleshly seed (and not to the New Covenant of Grace as an abiding mark for believers' children), Gentile believers never had any tie to them (Acts 15:19; 21:25), while ethnic Jewish believers were gently weaned off them until God visibly terminated the Old Covenant nation in A.D. 70.
 
Last edited:
Wait actually think about this:

This is Paul. By this moment in time in Acts 21, you could say he is THE Paul.

The one who Christ blinded and called directly on the Damascus road, the greatest theologian the church has ever known, the one who called out THE Peter to his face in Antioch when the truth of the gospel was threatened, the one who was taken up to the third heaven, THE Paul.

And yet, when he walks into the room with James and the elders in Jerusalem, and hears that thousands of weak, poorly taught Jewish believers are suspicious of him because they are still clinging to their childhood ceremonies, what does Paul do?

He does not slam his fist on the table or demand that every weak brother instantly match his own mature grasp of covenant theology. Because the truth of justification is safe (verse 25), Paul gladly opens his own purse, walks into the Temple courts with four weak brothers, and stoops down to wash his hands beside them so that he might win their hearts to Christ!
 
Excellent thoughts, brother!

There is a passage in George Gillespie's English Popish Ceremonies in which he contrasts Paul's conduct at Antioch vs. his conduct at Jerusalem. Much along the lines of brother Brad's thoughts. It's in Part II, Chapter 6, Section 4. In the Naphtali Press 2013 edition, it's on page 97.
 
Back
Top