Due to recent discussions I have had, I decided to do a deep study of the doctrine of penal substitutionary atonement. This has included reading some writings of the early church on the atonement. I know a common line of argument against PSA is that it must be a novelty because it "came into existence" in the 1500s. But, as I read several ECF's, I found that although they do not articulate a fully refined rendition of PSA, much of what they wrote seems to contain "building blocks" that indicate that PSA is a theme that would not have raised eyebrows in much of the early church. In particular, I did a bit of a deep dive on some of Augustine's writings in his book, "On the Holy Trinity", and I would like to share some notes I took to invite discussion. Please note, I am not arguing that Augustine preached a fully developed PSA view, I just find it interesting how many building blocks there are in his view.
In Book 4, Chapter 3, Augustine talks about death in the soul and death in the body, which he defines (I am bolding these because I think it is important to remember his definitions for these two ideas). He says that death in the soul is ungodliness, which comes about when God leaves it because it has become sinful. This, he says, is the death the devil suffered. Meanwhile, death in the body is corruptibility and death, the punishment of sin. This, he says, is the death that Christ suffered. He indicates that death in the soul is becoming ungodly and sinful, while death in the body is the punishment of sin. Now, this is interesting because he places being left by God in death in the soul, the type of death that Christ did not suffer, which PSA would qualify differently. But, he affirms that Christ suffered death in the body, which he says is the punishment of sin. It seems like we have some common ground: that Christ suffered the punishment of sin, whatever that was (and we may disagree on what that was). It also seems like the death in the soul category is a bit different here, even though it includes being left by God:
I also find it interesting that he says that Jesus died in the flesh alone (remember, death in the flesh is the punishment of sin), which seems very similar to the distinction PSA makes: that Jesus experienced death and punishment according to his human nature. So, it seems to me that the main place where PSA might disagree with Augustine is in what precisely death in the body consists of, but in most other respects, including that Jesus suffered the punishment of sin without himself being sinful, and in that Jesus experienced death according to his human nature only.
In Book 4, Chapter 12, things start to get really interesting. Augustine brings the devil into the picture, and does seem to start to connect himself to a ransom atonement view. He says the devil persuaded us to sin, and so brought about our double death (death in the body, and death in the soul). He says of the devil:
Then, after explaining how the devil brings us to death, he goes on to talk about how Christ brings about our healing:
Finally, in Book 4, Chapter 13, it looks to me like there are both PSA building blocks, and things that, as adherents to PSA, we would reject. The chapter begins with Augustine affirming that the death of Christ was willing. He was not forced to die, but rather, he died willingly. This is another important aspect of PSA, that Christ willingly died, and was not a helpless victim of the Father's temper tantrum. Although Augustine here is saying that the devil did not take Christ's life from him unwillingly, he still affirms the willing nature of Christ's death.
It is true that in this chapter, Augustine goes on to elaborate what is basically a ransom theory of the atonement, where the devil holds the power of death, and then kills Jesus, the innocent one, and that sort of blows up his whole operation, since Jesus did not deserve to die, and thus man is freed from him. But even here, I see some trappings and elements of a PSA-like view.
For one thing, when describing the mechanism by which man is freed from the devil, he says:
Furthermore, we see sacrificial language about Christ's death:
In spite of this misplaced statement of the object of the payment, I think there is grounds to claim that Augustine in some sense new that there was some kind of cosmic justice above the devil that was involved in this payment. We see this in some allusions to legal principals:
I also like the phrase "by blotting out the handwriting" that he uses. This seems to echo the language in Colossians 2:14, where Christ's work on the cross cancels the record of debt against us. This debt is sin, which is biblically bound up in issues of law. For Augustine, blotting out the record of debt against us seems to be the fundamental way Jesus frees us from the power of the devil. PSA says that Christ's death solves the legal problem of our sin, the legal indebtedness, or the "handwriting" if you will.
So, in review, here are some of the building blocks in these chapters of Augustine's work:
In Book 4, Chapter 3, Augustine talks about death in the soul and death in the body, which he defines (I am bolding these because I think it is important to remember his definitions for these two ideas). He says that death in the soul is ungodliness, which comes about when God leaves it because it has become sinful. This, he says, is the death the devil suffered. Meanwhile, death in the body is corruptibility and death, the punishment of sin. This, he says, is the death that Christ suffered. He indicates that death in the soul is becoming ungodly and sinful, while death in the body is the punishment of sin. Now, this is interesting because he places being left by God in death in the soul, the type of death that Christ did not suffer, which PSA would qualify differently. But, he affirms that Christ suffered death in the body, which he says is the punishment of sin. It seems like we have some common ground: that Christ suffered the punishment of sin, whatever that was (and we may disagree on what that was). It also seems like the death in the soul category is a bit different here, even though it includes being left by God:
Jesus did not himself need to be renewed in his inner man or to repent, so of course, by Augustine's definition, he did not suffer death in the soul. PSA agrees with this idea, that Jesus was not sinful in himself such that he needed to repent of his own sins.For He was not a sinner or ungodly, that, as though dead in spirit, He should need to be renewed in the inner man, and to be recalled as it were to the life of righteousness by repentance; but being clothed in mortal flesh, and in that alone dying, in that alone rising again, in that alone did He answer to both for us;
I also find it interesting that he says that Jesus died in the flesh alone (remember, death in the flesh is the punishment of sin), which seems very similar to the distinction PSA makes: that Jesus experienced death and punishment according to his human nature. So, it seems to me that the main place where PSA might disagree with Augustine is in what precisely death in the body consists of, but in most other respects, including that Jesus suffered the punishment of sin without himself being sinful, and in that Jesus experienced death according to his human nature only.
In Book 4, Chapter 12, things start to get really interesting. Augustine brings the devil into the picture, and does seem to start to connect himself to a ransom atonement view. He says the devil persuaded us to sin, and so brought about our double death (death in the body, and death in the soul). He says of the devil:
I don't see anything inherently disagreeable in this. The devil persuaded us to sin, which brought about our alienation from God (death in the soul), and caused us to deserve the punishment of sin (death in the body). He goes on to make clear that death is a punishment from God as a judge in retribution against the guilty:...he indeed died in the spirit through ungodliness, but certainly did not die in the flesh: yet both persuaded us to ungodliness, and thereby brought it to pass that we deserved to come into the death of the flesh.
So, Augustine connects death to the justice of God, and calls it a just punishment, and uses a courtroom metaphor. In my view, this is one of the quintessential building blocks of PSA: that death is a just punishment for sin.We desired therefore the one through wicked persuasion, the other followed us by a just condemnation; and therefore it is written, “God made not death,”508 since He was not Himself the cause of death; but yet death was inflicted on the sinner, through His most just retribution. Just as the judge inflicts punishment on the guilty; yet it is not the justice of the judge, but the desert of the crime, which is the cause of the punishment.
Then, after explaining how the devil brings us to death, he goes on to talk about how Christ brings about our healing:
The medicine of correction was administered "by a hidden and exceeding mysterious decree of divine and profound justice". Healing comes about by means of a decree of divine justice, by Christ's dying a death in the flesh (the punishment of sin), which he did not deserve. Here is another building block: the cross as a mysterious decree of divine justice.Whither, then, the mediator of death caused us to pass, yet did not come himself, that is, to the death of the flesh, there our Lord God introduced for us the medicine of correction, which He deserved not, by a hidden and exceeding mysterious decree of divine and profound justice. In order, therefore, that as by one man came death, so by one man might come also the resurrection of the dead;509
Finally, in Book 4, Chapter 13, it looks to me like there are both PSA building blocks, and things that, as adherents to PSA, we would reject. The chapter begins with Augustine affirming that the death of Christ was willing. He was not forced to die, but rather, he died willingly. This is another important aspect of PSA, that Christ willingly died, and was not a helpless victim of the Father's temper tantrum. Although Augustine here is saying that the devil did not take Christ's life from him unwillingly, he still affirms the willing nature of Christ's death.
It is true that in this chapter, Augustine goes on to elaborate what is basically a ransom theory of the atonement, where the devil holds the power of death, and then kills Jesus, the innocent one, and that sort of blows up his whole operation, since Jesus did not deserve to die, and thus man is freed from him. But even here, I see some trappings and elements of a PSA-like view.
For one thing, when describing the mechanism by which man is freed from the devil, he says:
So, by the loosing of the bonds of many sins through the death of Christ, the way the devil's power is broken. I think that fundamental to PSA is the idea that our sins are the problem: they bind us and hold us in opposition to God. He further says,For it was brought to pass that the bonds of many sins in many deaths were loosed, through the one death of One which no sin had preceded.
Jesus rendered a death on our behalf so that the death we deserved could not hurt us. Here is the fundamental idea of exchange, of Christ discharging our obligations for us, instead of our discharging them ourselves, that is so fundamental to PSA. If you pay a debt for me, you do it instead of me, so we can say you pay it in substitution for me.Which death, though not due, the Lord therefore rendered for us, that the death which was due might work us no hurt.
Furthermore, we see sacrificial language about Christ's death:
Also, in this quote, Augustine says that Christ's death paid a penalty. Now, the object of this payment is principalities and powers, which is a problem, obviously. Why does God have to pay principalities and powers?For whereas by His death the one and most real sacrifice was offered up for us, whatever fault there was, whence principalities and powers held us fast as of right to pay its penalty, He cleansed, abolished, extinguished; and by His own resurrection He also called us whom He predestinated to a new life; and whom He called, them He justified; and whom He justified, them He glorified.
In spite of this misplaced statement of the object of the payment, I think there is grounds to claim that Augustine in some sense new that there was some kind of cosmic justice above the devil that was involved in this payment. We see this in some allusions to legal principals:
andAnd so the devil, in that very death of the flesh, lost man, whom he was possessing as by an absolute right...
He talks about the devil acting against us by an "absolute right" and a "just right". He says our captivity "just on account of sin". Where does this "absolute right" or "just right" come from? If the devil's power over us is just, this seems to me to ground the power of the devil over us in the righteousness and justice of God. In PSA, the righteousness and justice of God is the very thing that man has violated, and so fallen under wrath. Now, I am not sure Augustine makes this connection explicit here in this writing, but I think it is significant that he seems to detect it, at least in a hazy way.so that He, being Himself put to death, although innocent, by the unjust one acting against us as it were by just right, might by a most just right overcome him, and so might lead captive the captivity wrought through sin,517 and free us from a captivity that was just on account of sin, by blotting out the handwriting, and redeeming us who were to be justified although sinners, through His own righteous blood unrighteously poured out.
I also like the phrase "by blotting out the handwriting" that he uses. This seems to echo the language in Colossians 2:14, where Christ's work on the cross cancels the record of debt against us. This debt is sin, which is biblically bound up in issues of law. For Augustine, blotting out the record of debt against us seems to be the fundamental way Jesus frees us from the power of the devil. PSA says that Christ's death solves the legal problem of our sin, the legal indebtedness, or the "handwriting" if you will.
So, in review, here are some of the building blocks in these chapters of Augustine's work:
- Jesus suffered death in the body (the punishment of sin).
- Jesus did not suffer death in the soul (actually becoming sinful such that he needed to repent).
- Because humans have sinned, we deserve to be punished by God with death. Indeed, death is retribution from God.
- The cross was a mysterious decree of divine justice which brought about our reconciliation.
- Jesus breaks the power of the devil by dealing with sins.
- Jesus rendered his own death on our behalf for us, so that we would not be harmed by the death we deserved.
- The cross served to blot out the record of debt that stood against us.
- What death in the body consists of (notion of Godforsakeness experienced by Christ according to his human nature).
- He directs the payment to powers and principalities.
- In failing to explicitly connect the power of the devil over man to God's justice some places, he could be seen as giving too much power to the devil.