Building blocks of PSA in Augustine

ho88it

Puritan Board Freshman
Due to recent discussions I have had, I decided to do a deep study of the doctrine of penal substitutionary atonement. This has included reading some writings of the early church on the atonement. I know a common line of argument against PSA is that it must be a novelty because it "came into existence" in the 1500s. But, as I read several ECF's, I found that although they do not articulate a fully refined rendition of PSA, much of what they wrote seems to contain "building blocks" that indicate that PSA is a theme that would not have raised eyebrows in much of the early church. In particular, I did a bit of a deep dive on some of Augustine's writings in his book, "On the Holy Trinity", and I would like to share some notes I took to invite discussion. Please note, I am not arguing that Augustine preached a fully developed PSA view, I just find it interesting how many building blocks there are in his view.

In Book 4, Chapter 3, Augustine talks about death in the soul and death in the body, which he defines (I am bolding these because I think it is important to remember his definitions for these two ideas). He says that death in the soul is ungodliness, which comes about when God leaves it because it has become sinful. This, he says, is the death the devil suffered. Meanwhile, death in the body is corruptibility and death, the punishment of sin. This, he says, is the death that Christ suffered. He indicates that death in the soul is becoming ungodly and sinful, while death in the body is the punishment of sin. Now, this is interesting because he places being left by God in death in the soul, the type of death that Christ did not suffer, which PSA would qualify differently. But, he affirms that Christ suffered death in the body, which he says is the punishment of sin. It seems like we have some common ground: that Christ suffered the punishment of sin, whatever that was (and we may disagree on what that was). It also seems like the death in the soul category is a bit different here, even though it includes being left by God:
For He was not a sinner or ungodly, that, as though dead in spirit, He should need to be renewed in the inner man, and to be recalled as it were to the life of righteousness by repentance; but being clothed in mortal flesh, and in that alone dying, in that alone rising again, in that alone did He answer to both for us;
Jesus did not himself need to be renewed in his inner man or to repent, so of course, by Augustine's definition, he did not suffer death in the soul. PSA agrees with this idea, that Jesus was not sinful in himself such that he needed to repent of his own sins.

I also find it interesting that he says that Jesus died in the flesh alone (remember, death in the flesh is the punishment of sin), which seems very similar to the distinction PSA makes: that Jesus experienced death and punishment according to his human nature. So, it seems to me that the main place where PSA might disagree with Augustine is in what precisely death in the body consists of, but in most other respects, including that Jesus suffered the punishment of sin without himself being sinful, and in that Jesus experienced death according to his human nature only.


In Book 4, Chapter 12, things start to get really interesting. Augustine brings the devil into the picture, and does seem to start to connect himself to a ransom atonement view. He says the devil persuaded us to sin, and so brought about our double death (death in the body, and death in the soul). He says of the devil:
...he indeed died in the spirit through ungodliness, but certainly did not die in the flesh: yet both persuaded us to ungodliness, and thereby brought it to pass that we deserved to come into the death of the flesh.
I don't see anything inherently disagreeable in this. The devil persuaded us to sin, which brought about our alienation from God (death in the soul), and caused us to deserve the punishment of sin (death in the body). He goes on to make clear that death is a punishment from God as a judge in retribution against the guilty:
We desired therefore the one through wicked persuasion, the other followed us by a just condemnation; and therefore it is written, “God made not death,”508 since He was not Himself the cause of death; but yet death was inflicted on the sinner, through His most just retribution. Just as the judge inflicts punishment on the guilty; yet it is not the justice of the judge, but the desert of the crime, which is the cause of the punishment.
So, Augustine connects death to the justice of God, and calls it a just punishment, and uses a courtroom metaphor. In my view, this is one of the quintessential building blocks of PSA: that death is a just punishment for sin.

Then, after explaining how the devil brings us to death, he goes on to talk about how Christ brings about our healing:
Whither, then, the mediator of death caused us to pass, yet did not come himself, that is, to the death of the flesh, there our Lord God introduced for us the medicine of correction, which He deserved not, by a hidden and exceeding mysterious decree of divine and profound justice. In order, therefore, that as by one man came death, so by one man might come also the resurrection of the dead;509
The medicine of correction was administered "by a hidden and exceeding mysterious decree of divine and profound justice". Healing comes about by means of a decree of divine justice, by Christ's dying a death in the flesh (the punishment of sin), which he did not deserve. Here is another building block: the cross as a mysterious decree of divine justice.

Finally, in Book 4, Chapter 13, it looks to me like there are both PSA building blocks, and things that, as adherents to PSA, we would reject. The chapter begins with Augustine affirming that the death of Christ was willing. He was not forced to die, but rather, he died willingly. This is another important aspect of PSA, that Christ willingly died, and was not a helpless victim of the Father's temper tantrum. Although Augustine here is saying that the devil did not take Christ's life from him unwillingly, he still affirms the willing nature of Christ's death.

It is true that in this chapter, Augustine goes on to elaborate what is basically a ransom theory of the atonement, where the devil holds the power of death, and then kills Jesus, the innocent one, and that sort of blows up his whole operation, since Jesus did not deserve to die, and thus man is freed from him. But even here, I see some trappings and elements of a PSA-like view.

For one thing, when describing the mechanism by which man is freed from the devil, he says:
For it was brought to pass that the bonds of many sins in many deaths were loosed, through the one death of One which no sin had preceded.
So, by the loosing of the bonds of many sins through the death of Christ, the way the devil's power is broken. I think that fundamental to PSA is the idea that our sins are the problem: they bind us and hold us in opposition to God. He further says,
Which death, though not due, the Lord therefore rendered for us, that the death which was due might work us no hurt.
Jesus rendered a death on our behalf so that the death we deserved could not hurt us. Here is the fundamental idea of exchange, of Christ discharging our obligations for us, instead of our discharging them ourselves, that is so fundamental to PSA. If you pay a debt for me, you do it instead of me, so we can say you pay it in substitution for me.

Furthermore, we see sacrificial language about Christ's death:
For whereas by His death the one and most real sacrifice was offered up for us, whatever fault there was, whence principalities and powers held us fast as of right to pay its penalty, He cleansed, abolished, extinguished; and by His own resurrection He also called us whom He predestinated to a new life; and whom He called, them He justified; and whom He justified, them He glorified.
Also, in this quote, Augustine says that Christ's death paid a penalty. Now, the object of this payment is principalities and powers, which is a problem, obviously. Why does God have to pay principalities and powers?

In spite of this misplaced statement of the object of the payment, I think there is grounds to claim that Augustine in some sense new that there was some kind of cosmic justice above the devil that was involved in this payment. We see this in some allusions to legal principals:
And so the devil, in that very death of the flesh, lost man, whom he was possessing as by an absolute right...
and
so that He, being Himself put to death, although innocent, by the unjust one acting against us as it were by just right, might by a most just right overcome him, and so might lead captive the captivity wrought through sin,517 and free us from a captivity that was just on account of sin, by blotting out the handwriting, and redeeming us who were to be justified although sinners, through His own righteous blood unrighteously poured out.
He talks about the devil acting against us by an "absolute right" and a "just right". He says our captivity "just on account of sin". Where does this "absolute right" or "just right" come from? If the devil's power over us is just, this seems to me to ground the power of the devil over us in the righteousness and justice of God. In PSA, the righteousness and justice of God is the very thing that man has violated, and so fallen under wrath. Now, I am not sure Augustine makes this connection explicit here in this writing, but I think it is significant that he seems to detect it, at least in a hazy way.

I also like the phrase "by blotting out the handwriting" that he uses. This seems to echo the language in Colossians 2:14, where Christ's work on the cross cancels the record of debt against us. This debt is sin, which is biblically bound up in issues of law. For Augustine, blotting out the record of debt against us seems to be the fundamental way Jesus frees us from the power of the devil. PSA says that Christ's death solves the legal problem of our sin, the legal indebtedness, or the "handwriting" if you will.

So, in review, here are some of the building blocks in these chapters of Augustine's work:
  • Jesus suffered death in the body (the punishment of sin).
  • Jesus did not suffer death in the soul (actually becoming sinful such that he needed to repent).
  • Because humans have sinned, we deserve to be punished by God with death. Indeed, death is retribution from God.
  • The cross was a mysterious decree of divine justice which brought about our reconciliation.
  • Jesus breaks the power of the devil by dealing with sins.
  • Jesus rendered his own death on our behalf for us, so that we would not be harmed by the death we deserved.
  • The cross served to blot out the record of debt that stood against us.
And here are some of the glaring things I think PSA would disagree with Augustine on from these chapters in regard to the Atonement:
  • What death in the body consists of (notion of Godforsakeness experienced by Christ according to his human nature).
  • He directs the payment to powers and principalities.
  • In failing to explicitly connect the power of the devil over man to God's justice some places, he could be seen as giving too much power to the devil.
Of course, this is all constrained to these three chapters I read. I have more notes on other chapters, but I think this is enough to get the conversation started. In particular, I think Augustine is strong on connecting Christ's work to sin, which is something that in my experience tends to be glossed over by those who reject PSA. But, I am also aware of the fact that Augustine did not articulate the full theory of PSA. Still, I see many building blocks even in his primarily ransom-based view of the atonement. I have seen other threads on this site that show church fathers saying that Christ took our penalty, which seem to show that they would not have been utterly opposed to the idea of PSA, and I wanted to contribute some thoughts and get some feedback on this idea in these sections of Augustine in particular. So what do you all think? Do you see some of the building blocks I mentioned? Am I overstating similarities? Am I missing something significant? Thank you all.
 
Yes, I have actually read that article, it is very good. And yes, I think it is fair to say that Anselm was a major step in articulating the atonement. I wanted to show that even earlier on than that, though, most of the concepts in PSA were present, while at the same time seeing that there were some areas where more thought and clarity was needed. Thus, the charge of novelty can be avoided. This line of thinking was in response to someone telling me that because the early church did not teach a full-throated articulation of PSA like we see in the Reformation, to say that PSA is important and ought not to be rejected is to say that the early church "missed the heart of the gospel for 1000 years".
 
Are you asking if Anselm is the place to go instead of Augustine when the OP is asking if Augustine had the germ of the thing?
Good point but off the top of my head I thought it was pretty early. I should have elaborated that. Did Anselm get it from Augustine? Maybe. But he also said that (the people he's conversing with) it was not until the "1500's", that's what prompted my response.
I think it's beyond dispute that Anselm in 1000's had already worked it out and that's a bit earlier than the 1500's. So that would be my first response to anyone who said that PSA didn't exist until the Reformation, that's just not true and Anselm proves it.
His case is that we can push it back, if I understand him correctly, to Augustine. And his question is can we push it back to the ECF? I hope that makes more sense.
 
Yes, I have actually read that article, it is very good. And yes, I think it is fair to say that Anselm was a major step in articulating the atonement. I wanted to show that even earlier on than that, though, most of the concepts in PSA were present, while at the same time seeing that there were some areas where more thought and clarity was needed. Thus, the charge of novelty can be avoided. This line of thinking was in response to someone telling me that because the early church did not teach a full-throated articulation of PSA like we see in the Reformation, to say that PSA is important and ought not to be rejected is to say that the early church "missed the heart of the gospel for 1000 years".
That's just bad historiography on their part. Jordan Cooper wrote a book on the seeds of Justification by Faith in the ECF's. Their theology wasn't worked out. The history of the Church has been, in general, that we didn't draw lines until we had to.
The early Church had it's own problems and they dealt with those first but the seed-form of this doctrine was there. I mean going all the way back to the OT sacrifices, if we want to be thorough.
 
This line of thinking was in response to someone telling me that because the early church did not teach a full-throated articulation of PSA like we see in the Reformation, to say that PSA is important and ought not to be rejected is to say that the early church "missed the heart of the gospel for 1000 years".

I have a lot of thoughts about a lot of what you wrote (which is good stuff btw in my opinion), but I wanted to mention a point on this branch here:

Think about how a small town uses its water well.

For generations, the townspeople walk out to the pump every morning, draw up cold, clean water, drink it, and live on it. They do not have a framed chemical chart bolted to the side of the well listing the molecular ratio of hydrogen to oxygen or the parts-per-million mineral count.

Why? Because nobody is attacking the water.

Then one day, a group of men rides into town trying to dump arsenic into the aquifer while claiming that sand is just as good for thirst as water.

All of a sudden, the town elders have to bring in chemists who study the properties and invent microscopes, test the water, write down the exact chemical formula of pure water, and bolt a warning sign onto the wellhead.

Now did the town start drinking water for the first time on the day the chemists wrote down the formula? Of course not.

They had been drinking the exact same water all along; the crisis simply forced them to define what they were already drinking so counterfeiters could not poison their children.

In Reformed scholastic theology, this is the distinction between two things:

1) holding a truth in its lived substance (in actu exercito, in the actual practice of faith, preaching, and worship) and

2) stating that truth in its refined definition (in actu signato, in formal dogmatic boundaries drawn against heresy).

During the first five centuries, the heretics knocking on the church door (Arians, Apollinarians, Nestorians, and Eutychians) were attacking the Person of the Mediator, either denying Christ's true deity or denying His true humanity.

Consequently, the early church fathers spent their energy writing massive treatises on the Trinity and the Incarnation.

Yet how did they prove against those heretics that Jesus had to be both truly God and truly man?

By appealing with Scripture to what every Christian in the pews already believed about the cross: that if Christ were not truly man, He could not stand in our place to pay our human penalty of death, and if He were not truly God, His sacrifice would lack the infinite worth needed to satisfy divine justice and abolish our guilt.

When the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries arrived, the Roman church obscured Christ's finished satisfaction behind human penances and indulgences, while Faustus Socinus and his Rationalist followers launched a direct courtroom attack on the very idea of retributive divine justice and vicarious punishment.

That period's assault forced the Reformers and the Reformed scholastics to draw out the "chemical chart" of Penal Substitution in sharper and fuller forensic detail.
 
@jwright82 I see the point you were making. I do recognize differences between PSA and what Anselm taught, but on the whole, Anselm is certainly an important step forward in atonement articulations well before the Reformation.

@No Other Name Thanks for that analogy, I agree 100%. What I am trying to do in this thread is document the "building blocks" or "germ" of PSA in someone like Augustine before the controversy that forced the clear articulation came about, to show that it is all from the same good well, like you mentioned.

I want to share this, both to invite other perspectives on my reading of the source material, and to share this information with people working through historical questions about PSA. At some point, I've got a whole bunch of other notes I'd like to post about several other chapters in On the Holy Trinity, where, in my opinion, Augustine gets even closer.
 
I want to share this, both to invite other perspectives on my reading of the source material, and to share this information with people working through historical questions about PSA. At some point, I've got a whole bunch of other notes I'd like to post about several other chapters in On the Holy Trinity, where, in my opinion, Augustine gets even closer.

Like 3, and 12 and 13? That is what I am thinking.
 
In my view, Chrysostom's Homilies on Galatians and
Due to recent discussions I have had, I decided to do a deep study of the doctrine of penal substitutionary atonement. This has included reading some writings of the early church on the atonement. I know a common line of argument against PSA is that it must be a novelty because it "came into existence" in the 1500s. But, as I read several ECF's, I found that although they do not articulate a fully refined rendition of PSA, much of what they wrote seems to contain "building blocks" that indicate that PSA is a theme that would not have raised eyebrows in much of the early church. In particular, I did a bit of a deep dive on some of Augustine's writings in his book, "On the Holy Trinity", and I would like to share some notes I took to invite discussion. Please note, I am not arguing that Augustine preached a fully developed PSA view, I just find it interesting how many building blocks there are in his view.

Excellent work, brother!

In my research (and you may already be aware of this), Chrysostom's Homilies on Galatians and 2 Corinthians give some of the leading points of PSA and the gospel in very clear and concise language. For example, his treatment of Christ "becoming a curse for us" is masterful, and reaches to the level of later exegesis in terms of Christ becoming a curse in the place of sinners.

I believe that Gregory the Great also has some statements that approach to PSA in his Morals on Job.

I have not researched this, but one of my parishioners has claimed to find hints at PSA in Irenaeus and Athanasius.

If you are interested in quotations, please let me know, and I'll dig them up and post them to this thread.

Keep up the good work!
 
Like 3, and 12 and 13? That is what I am thinking.

Well, I posted my notes on those chapters of Book 4 in my first message. I have some other notes on Book 13, chapters 11-16 that I plan to post here on this thread once I have a chance to go through and synthesize them. My goal is for it to be similar to my initial post.

In my view, Chrysostom's Homilies on Galatians and


Excellent work, brother!

In my research (and you may already be aware of this), Chrysostom's Homilies on Galatians and 2 Corinthians give some of the leading points of PSA and the gospel in very clear and concise language. For example, his treatment of Christ "becoming a curse for us" is masterful, and reaches to the level of later exegesis in terms of Christ becoming a curse in the place of sinners.

I believe that Gregory the Great also has some statements that approach to PSA in his Morals on Job.

I have not researched this, but one of my parishioners has claimed to find hints at PSA in Irenaeus and Athanasius.

If you are interested in quotations, please let me know, and I'll dig them up and post them to this thread.

Keep up the good work!
Thank you very much! I will have to check out the Chrysostom passages you mention. I have seen other threads on this site with quotations that seem to demonstrate the same thing I am trying to show here.

I'm always interested in seeing quotations from early Christians that support PSA, so by all means please do feel free to share them when it is convenient for you! I think compiling this information into these threads is useful (especially for people who read this site, but don't post, like myself until recently).
 
"Ver. 13. Christ redeemed us from the curse of the Law, having become a curse for us: for it is written, Cursed is every one that hangs on a tree.
In reality, the people were subject to another curse, which says, Cursed is every one that continues not in the things that are written in the book of the Law. Deuteronomy 27:26 To this curse, I say, people were subject, for no man had continued in, or was a keeper of, the whole Law; but Christ exchanged this curse for the other, Cursed is every one that hangs on a tree. As then both he who hanged on a tree, and he who transgresses the Law, is cursed, and as it was necessary for him who is about to relieve from a curse himself to be free from it, but to receive another instead of it, therefore Christ took upon Him such another, and thereby relieved us from the curse. It was like an innocent man's undertaking to die for another sentenced to death, and so rescuing him from punishment. For Christ took upon Him not the curse of transgression, but the other curse, in order to remove that of others. For, He had done no violence neither was any deceit in His mouth. Isaiah 53:9; 1 Peter 2:22 And as by dying He rescued from death those who were dying, so by taking upon Himself the curse, He delivered them from it."

John Chrysostom, Homily 3 on Galatians.
 
Last edited:
"Ver. 8. And the Scripture, foreseeing that God would justify the Gentiles by faith, preached the Gospel beforehand unto Abraham, saying, In you shall all the nations be blessed.
If then those were Abraham's sons, not, who were related to him by blood, but who follow his faith, for this is the meaning of the words, In you all the nations, it is plain that the heathen are brought into kindred with him.
Hereby too is proved another important point. It perplexed them that the Law was the older, and Faith afterwards. Now he removes this notion by showing that Faith was anterior to the Law; as is evident from Abraham's case, who was justified before the giving of the Law. He shows too that late events fell out according to prophecy; The Scripture, says he, foreseeing that God would justify the Gentiles by faith, preached the Gospel beforehand unto Abraham. Attend to this point. He Himself who gave the Law, had decreed, before He gave it, that the heathen should be justified by Faith. And he says not revealed, but, preached the Gospel, to signify that the patriarch was in joy at this method of justification, and in great desire for its accomplishment.
Further, they were possessed with another apprehension; it was written, Cursed is every one that continues not in all things that are written in the book of the Law, to do them. Deuteronomy 27:26 And this he removes, with great skill and prudence, turning their argument against themselves, and showing that those who relinquish the Law are not only not cursed, but blessed; and they who keep it, not only not blessed but cursed. They said that he who kept not the Law was cursed, but he proves that he who kept it was cursed, and he who kept it not, blessed. Again, they said that he who adhered to Faith alone was cursed, but he shows that he who adhered to Faith alone, is blessed. And how does he prove all this? For it is no common thing which we have promised; wherefore it is necessary to give close attention to what follows. He had already shown this, by referring to the words spoken to the Patriarch, In you shall all nations be blessed, Genesis 12:4 at a time, that is, when Faith existed, not the Law; so he adds by way of conclusion,
Ver. 9. So then they which be of faith are blessed with the faithful Abraham."


John Chrysostom, Homily 3 on Galatians.
 
Last edited:
"'I say nothing of what has gone before, that you have outraged Him, Him that had done you no wrong, Him that had done you good, that He exacted not justice, that He is first to beseech, though first outraged; let none of these things be set down at present. Ought ye not in justice to be reconciled for this one thing only that He has done to you now?' And what has He done? Him that knew no sin He made to be sin, for you. For had He achieved nothing but done only this, think how great a thing it were to give His Son for those that had outraged Him. But now He has both well achieved mighty things, and besides, has suffered Him that did no wrong to be punished for those who had done wrong. But he did not say this: but mentioned that which is far greater than this. What then is this? Him that knew no sin, he says, Him that was righteousness itself , He made sin, that is suffered as a sinner to be condemned, as one cursed to die. For cursed is he that hangs on a tree. Galatians 3:13 For to die thus was far greater than to die; and this he also elsewhere implying, says, Becoming obedient unto death, yea the death of the cross. Philippians 2:8 For this thing carried with it not only punishment, but also disgrace. Reflect therefore how great things He bestowed on you. For a great thing indeed it were for even a sinner to die for any one whatever; but when He who undergoes this both is righteous and dies for sinners; and not dies only, but even as one cursed; and not as cursed [dies] only, but thereby freely bestows upon us those great goods which we never looked for; (for he says, that we might become the righteousness of God in Him; what words, what thought shall be adequate to realize these things? 'For the righteous,' says he, 'He made a sinner; that He might make the sinners righteous.' Yea rather, he said not even so, but what was greater far; for the word he employed is not the habit, but the quality itself. For he said not made [Him] a sinner, but sin; not, 'Him that had not sinned' only, but that had not even known sin; that we also might become, he did not say 'righteous,' but, righteousness, and, the righteousness of God. For this is [the righteousness] of God when we are justified not by works, (in which case it were necessary that not a spot even should be found,) but by grace, in which case all sin is done away. And this at the same time that it suffers us not to be lifted up, (seeing the whole is the free gift of God,) teaches us also the greatness of that which is given. For that which was before was a righteousness of the Law and of works, but this is the righteousness of God."

John Chrysostom, Homily 11 on 2 Corinthians.
 
I have a lot of thoughts about a lot of what you wrote (which is good stuff btw in my opinion), but I wanted to mention a point on this branch here:

Think about how a small town uses its water well.

For generations, the townspeople walk out to the pump every morning, draw up cold, clean water, drink it, and live on it. They do not have a framed chemical chart bolted to the side of the well listing the molecular ratio of hydrogen to oxygen or the parts-per-million mineral count.

Why? Because nobody is attacking the water.

Then one day, a group of men rides into town trying to dump arsenic into the aquifer while claiming that sand is just as good for thirst as water.

All of a sudden, the town elders have to bring in chemists who study the properties and invent microscopes, test the water, write down the exact chemical formula of pure water, and bolt a warning sign onto the wellhead.

Now did the town start drinking water for the first time on the day the chemists wrote down the formula? Of course not.

They had been drinking the exact same water all along; the crisis simply forced them to define what they were already drinking so counterfeiters could not poison their children.

In Reformed scholastic theology, this is the distinction between two things:

1) holding a truth in its lived substance (in actu exercito, in the actual practice of faith, preaching, and worship) and

2) stating that truth in its refined definition (in actu signato, in formal dogmatic boundaries drawn against heresy).

During the first five centuries, the heretics knocking on the church door (Arians, Apollinarians, Nestorians, and Eutychians) were attacking the Person of the Mediator, either denying Christ's true deity or denying His true humanity.

Consequently, the early church fathers spent their energy writing massive treatises on the Trinity and the Incarnation.

Yet how did they prove against those heretics that Jesus had to be both truly God and truly man?

By appealing with Scripture to what every Christian in the pews already believed about the cross: that if Christ were not truly man, He could not stand in our place to pay our human penalty of death, and if He were not truly God, His sacrifice would lack the infinite worth needed to satisfy divine justice and abolish our guilt.

When the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries arrived, the Roman church obscured Christ's finished satisfaction behind human penances and indulgences, while Faustus Socinus and his Rationalist followers launched a direct courtroom attack on the very idea of retributive divine justice and vicarious punishment.

That period's assault forced the Reformers and the Reformed scholastics to draw out the "chemical chart" of Penal Substitution in sharper and fuller forensic detail.
Great post my friend! You explained it quite well.
 
Here are some things I found in Book 13, chapters 10-16 of Augustine's On the Holy Trinity. As I mentioned before, I think Augustine gives us, as adherents to PSA, even more than he did in the previous book to point to and say "That's where we got this from."

Beginning in Book 13, chapter 10, Augustine is discussing the necessity of the Incarnation. In the midst of his discussion, while meditating on scripture, he recognizes a grounding aspect of PSA: that our sins made us enemies of God:
We were not, therefore, before that grace merely anyhow sinners, but in such sins that we were enemies of God
This is significant, and is something we will see him restate elsewhere: that our sins are against God. Our sins are not just generic bad things, but they specifically have the effect of making us enemies of God.

In Book 13, chapter 11, Augustine poses the question "... what is meant by "being reconciled by the death of His Son?" He then poses a hypothetical:
Was it indeed so, that when God the Father was wroth with us, He saw the death of His Son for us, and was appeased towards us? Was then His Son already so far appeased towards us, that He even deigned to die for us; while the Father was still so far wroth, that except His Son died for us, He would not be appeased?
He goes on to reject this:
Pray, unless the Father had been already appeased, would He have delivered up His own Son, not sparing Him for us? Does not this opinion seem to be as it were contrary to that?
At first glance, this looks like a pretty strong repudiation of the assumptions of PSA. He is denying that the Father was angry with us, but then saw the death of his Son, and was appeased. But if you look at what he goes on to explain, it becomes clear that he is not rejecting any of the assumptions of PSA, but is instead denying something that PSA also denies: that the Father and the Son were in some sense at odds on the Cross. He cites verses affirming both the Father's (Romans 8:31-32, Ephesians 1:4) and the Son's (Galatians 2:20) love for us even before Christ's death, demonstrating a unity in their love, and that they were working together on the Cross. This is all designed to maintain the unity of the Trinity, and to avoid casting the wrath of God in the image of human wrath. So really, he does not seem to be denying anything that PSA affirms, even if these sections could be quoted out of context to make that case (and even if we would have qualified our language more carefully).

Then, in Book 13, chapter 12, Augustine goes back to the Garden, seeking to show what it means to be justified by the blood of Christ. He opens with a strong point of traction for those of us who believe PSA:
By the justice of God in some sense, the human race was delivered into the power of the devil; the sin of the first man passing over originally into all of both sexes in their birth through conjugal union, and the debt of our first parents binding their whole posterity.
Remember that Augustine has expressed a ransom-based view of the atonement in Book 4. But, it seemed like he recognized that any power the devil had over man came from some principal of divine justice. Here, he makes it explicit: that the power of the devil over man is derived from the justice of God. It is not as though the devil went to God, overpowered him, and plundered him, taking the souls of man by force. He makes this abundantly clear:
But the way in which man was thus delivered into the power of the devil, ought not to be so understood as if God did this, or commanded it to be done; but that He only permitted it, yet that justly. For when He abandoned the sinner, the author of the sin immediately entered. Yet God did not certainly so abandon His own creature as not to show Himself to him as God creating and quickening, and among penal evils bestowing also many good things upon the evil.
and
If, therefore, the commission of sins through the just anger of God subjected man to the devil, doubtless the remission of sins through the merciful reconciliation of God rescues man from the devil.
His case is that original sin, through the just anger of God, is what gave the devil power over human souls. He also seems to recognize some notion of abandonment as the punishment of sin, which comes about immediately, but only in part. Living humans do not experience complete abandonment by God. Finally, salvation and rescue from the devil comes about through the remission of sins.

With all that in mind, PSA has several touch points. Sin is man's fundamental problem. Part of the divine punishment of sin is abandonment by God. And the problem of sin is solved by the remission of sins through some sort of merciful reconciliation. If human beings are a like a cliff face, our sins are the handholds the devil uses to take hold of us. When sins are remitted and removed, the cliff face becomes smooth, and the devil can no longer get any hold on us.

In Book 13, chapter 13, Augustine starts to comment on the merciful reconciliation of God, and opens with something PSA can affirm:
But the devil was to be overcome, not by the power of God, but by His righteousness.
Indeed, PSA sees the cross as an objective display of the righteousness of God (Romans 3:26).

But, as I see it, he veers off into left field a little bit by presenting a sort of fork in the road between power and righteousness as means to conquer the devil and rescue man. He says that God could have chosen to conquer the devil by power, that is, by using his omnipotent strength to overpower him and break his power, but instead, because the devil himself was a lover of power, he chose to overthrow him through righteousness instead, to demonstrate the value of righteousness:
For what is more powerful than the Omnipotent? Or what creature is there of which the power can be compared to the power of the Creator? But since the devil, by the fault of his own perversity, was made a lover of power, and a forsaker and assailant of righteousness,—for thus also men imitate him so much the more in proportion as they set their hearts on power, to the neglect or even hatred of righteousness, and as they either rejoice in the attainment of power, or are inflamed by the lust of it,—it pleased God, that in order to the rescuing of man from the grasp of the devil, the devil should be conquered, not by power, but by righteousness;
He goes on to talk about the human will and how it can be good/bad and strong/weak in a reflection that is very worth the time it takes to read, but is beside our present purpose.

He says that it pleased God to rescue man from the devil by righteousness, rather than by power. PSA, in contrast, does not treat righteousness as optional, as though God could choose to forgo righteousness and just display power. For God, a being righteous in nature, to forgo righteousness would just be nonsensical. We must affirm that anything God did would be maximally righteous. PSA, then, might present the real "choice" as whether righteousness would be displayed by condemning the sinful creatures, or in some other way (hopefully with a better result for them). And because God is Love, God gives the Son for the life of the world, saving men from their sins, and showing God to be both just (in displaying righteousness) and justifier (the one who saves his people from their sins).

So, I admit there seems to be some real disagreement between PSA and Augustine, in spite of other similarities. And yet, I would like to stress the fact that Augustine is just one simple shift in logic away from PSA: he views righteousness as an option among others for God in his saving work, while PSA views it as indispensable. If this was demonstrated to Augustine, it seems to me that many other aspects of the Atonement would fall into place for him.

Moving on to Book 13, chapter 14, Augustine gives us some good quotes that we can use to show continuation between PSA and earlier centuries of the Church:
18. What, then, is the righteousness by which the devil was conquered? What, except the righteousness of Jesus Christ? And how was he conquered? Because, when he found in Him nothing worthy of death, yet he slew Him. And certainly it is just, that we whom he held as debtors, should be dismissed free by believing in Him whom he slew without any debt. In this way it is that we are said to be justified in the blood of Christ.821 For so that innocent blood was shed for the remission of our sins.
And hence He proceeds to His passion, that He might pay for us debtors that which He Himself did not owe.
But the reason is really a different one, why we are justified in the blood of Christ, when we are rescued from the power of the devil through the remission of sins: it pertains to this, that the devil is conquered by Christ by righteousness, not by power.
The devil was conquered by the righteousness of Christ, and we, whom he held as debtors, are freed from him by believing in Christ. And this is just in some sense. On the cross, Christ paid a debt that he did not owe for us debtors. And, we are rescued from any power the devil might have over us by the remission of sins, through the righteousness of Christ.

Now, in this chapter, we also see a lot of ransom theory, and he sticks to his dichotomy between power and righteousness (Although he does say that Christ did both, conquering the devil by righteousness in his death, and by power in his resurrection), where righteousness is seen as an option God wished to commend rather than as something essential to everything God does. We are definitely missing some things, like why it is just that Christ's undeserved death should result in our freedom from the devil, and other answers to the valid criticisms of ransom theory on its own. But nevertheless, we have the notion of righteousness as the way of salvation, Christ paying a debt he did not owe for us, and the clearing of sins as the way the devil's power is broken.

In Book 13, chapter 15, Augustine continues on the same subject. He says of the blood of Christ:
For then that blood, since it was His who had no sin at all, was poured out for the remission of our sins; that, because the devil deservedly held those whom, as guilty of sin, he bound by the condition of death, he might deservedly loose them through Him, whom, as guilty of no sin, the punishment of death undeservedly affected.
The devil "deservedly" held those guilty of sin under death. When Christ suffered the punishment, death, that he did not deserve, he "deservedly" freed men. Again, I acknowledge ransom theory. But, what is this notion of "deservedly"? Does it not suggest that Augustine detects some principal of cosmic justice at play here that creates the "deserving" of the devil to hold those under sin, and Christ's "deserving" rescuing? Even in expositing this ransom view, there seems to me to be tacit acknowledgement of such justice, which PSA gives a fuller treatment of.

He goes on to say:
In this redemption, the blood of Christ was given, as it were, as a price for us, by accepting which the devil was not enriched, but bound: that we might be loosened from his bonds, and that he might not with himself involve in the meshes of sins, and so deliver to the destruction of the second and eternal death, any one of those whom Christ, free from all debt, had redeemed by pouring out His own blood unindebtedly; but that they who belong to the grace of Christ, foreknown, and predestinated, and elected before the foundation of the world should only so far die as Christ Himself died for them, i.e. only by the death of the flesh, not of the spirit.
The blood of Christ was given as a price for us. This is true, and PSA affirms this. And yet, as we saw before, he makes the devil the object of the payment, which, as I have said several times, is a problem, since it suggests that the devil can compete with God, and extract concessions and a price from him. But, setting that aside, the result of this transaction is that he delivers those form whom he poured out his blood from the second and eternal death, and that those elected before the foundation of the world would only die the death Christ died, the death in the flesh, and not death in the Spirit. Broadly, the PSA adherent can affirm this, although, as I mentioned in the original post, we may wish to define the content of death in the flesh and death in the Spirit differently. I wonder if the differing views of what death in the flesh consists of arise from differing views of to whom the payment of Christ's blood was made, and for what reasons?

Finally, we reach Book 13, chapter 16, where Augustine reminisces on why evil still happens in the world, even after Christ's death, in ways which are very amenable to reformed confessions.

Then, he concludes by restating the question of why Christ died, and, in answer, makes a moving statement that seems to me to capture a glimpse of the cosmic courtroom drama behind the Cross.
The devil was holding fast our sins, and through them was fixing us deservedly in death. He discharged them, who had none of His own, and who was led by him to death undeservedly. That blood was of such price, that he who even slew Christ for a time by a death which was not due, can as his due detain no one, who has put on Christ, in the eternal death which was due.
Then, he returns to an even earlier question, that of what it means to be justified by Christ's blood:
Justified, he says, in His blood,—justified plainly, in that we are freed from all sin; and freed from all sin, because the Son of God, who knew no sin, was slain for us.
Beautiful. The sinless Son of Man was slain for us, and because of that, we are justified, freed from all sin.

Then, Augustine reflects on being saved from the wrath of God, and in doing so, gives almost a word-for-word understanding of the wrath of God from robust accounts of PSA:
Therefore “we shall be saved from wrath through Him;” from the wrath certainly of God, which is nothing else but just retribution. For the wrath of God is not, as is that of man, a perturbation of the mind; but it is the wrath of Him to whom Holy Scripture says in another place, “But Thou, O Lord, mastering Thy power, judgest with calmness.” If, therefore, the just retribution of God has received such a name, what can be the right understanding also of the reconciliation of God, unless that then such wrath comes to an end? Neither were we enemies to God, except as sins are enemies to righteousness; which being forgiven, such enmities come to an end, and they whom He Himself justifies are reconciled to the Just One.
There are several points to consider. First, look at the definition of divine wrath he gives. It is not like human wrath, which is a mental perturbation, but rather, it is a calm, steady judgment of and opposition to sin. This understanding of divine wrath is something Augustine shares with proper articulations of PSA. With this understanding, we can say that we are saved from God's wrath, contra those who would claim that we are saved from something other than God's wrath. Secondly, he just straight-up affirms that we are saved from the wrath of God. So, we have Augustine, an early Christian, recognizing that Christ saved us from the wrath of God.

The chapter ends with reflection on the end of Romans 5, with the first and second Adams. In this dialog, he says:
the one the first Adam, through whose sin and death we, his descendants, are bound by, as it were, hereditary evils; and the other the second Adam, who is not only man, but also God, by whose payment for us of what He owed not, we are freed from the debts both of our first father and of ourselves.
Christ, the second Adam, paid for us a debt he did not owe, so that we ourselves are freed from the debts of sin. Amen to that.

Just like before, here is a list of "building blocks" of PSA in this section of Augustine:
  • Our sins make us enemies of God.
  • The Father and the Son were working together in the Atonement at every step.
  • The power of the devil over man comes from our sins through the justice of God.
  • Part of the penalty of sin for men is abandonment by God.
  • Man is saved from the devil through the remission of sins, brought about by Christ's blood being poured out.
  • God overcame the devil through righteousness.
  • Christ paid a debt for us he did not owe.
  • We are freed from our sins because the sinless one was slain for us.
  • We are saved from the wrath of God.
  • God's wrath is not like human wrath, but it his steady opposition to sin.
And here are the points of disagreement:
  • He makes the devil the object of the payment.
  • He seems to present righteousness as an option for God in defeating the devil, rather than essential.
  • In chapter 11, he seems to reject what could pass as a casual expression of PSA. Though, as I noted, he actually had something far different in mind.
  • He does not make explicit in all places how the devil's actions against us are done "deservedly" or justly. We don't necessarily disagree here, but acknowledge that he leaves more ambiguity than we are comfortable with, as this ambiguity can lead some to attribute more power to the devil than he really has.
  • In some places, it seems like the devil lost his power of death over us by behaving unjustly. Jesus tricked him into acting unjustly, and so he justly lost all his rights and power. This notion of ransom theory seems wrongheaded.

As I did this study, something I came away with is that Augustine is strong on identifying the problem, which is our sins, and how they alienate us from God, and give the devil power over us. He seems comparatively murky on the solution, adopting a ransom position that does recognize true things (the substitutionary transaction, the devil's power contingent on sin, etc.), but also has glaring, unaddressed problems which are common to the bare ransom position. And this is not surprising, for in this work, he was not laboring to precisely dictate the mechanics of the Atonement, but to comment on the Trinity, and the necessity of the Incarnation, which were bigger issues during his life.

What I want to highlight is that PSA has far more in common with Augustine than it has against him. Augustine's writings contain threads and ideas that demonstrate that PSA was not a complete novelty, but rather is rooted in the ancient church, even if it is not identical to what Augustine wrote. Even on the things he got wrong from my list above, some of them are matters of emphasis, and others would require comparatively small shifts in understanding for him to accept.

It also occurs to me that, really, we can take many instances of ransom theory in the early church as early witnesses to key aspects of PSA, because articulations of ransom theory like Augustine's seems to me to have significant overlap with PSA. He recognized that a payment was made by the innocent Christ for us, the guilty. He recognized the problem, which is our sin, which makes us enemies of God, brings us under his wrath, and gives the devil power over us. And, he recognized the perfect unity of the Godhead in all their saving work. And even on the things he missed, there is indication that he might have been close. He made the devil the object of the payment, but grounded the devil's power in divine justice. He seemed to present righteousness in too optional a light, yet he recognized that Christ conquered the devil through righteousness. It seems to me we ought to keep the good of such views, ignore the bad, and synthesize the ideas divine justice being satisfied, with sin being handled at the cross, and the triumph of Christ over the spiritual powers, even as Paul does in Colossian 2:13-15.

I really do think that all the pieces of PSA are present for Augustine, they just hadn't quite been arranged into their proper form. Kind of like a puzzle, I guess. And even then, he has the puzzle well on the way to being complete, it just isn't quite all the way there. I think these writings of Augustine adequately demonstrate that PSA, far from being a novelty, has ancient roots, and therefore should not be set aside as a wholesale invention of the Medieval/Reformation western church.
 
I went over my old notes on this, but another criticism of Anselm is that you don't need the resurrection to make his model work. That's kind of a problem.
I see the point, though I doubt Anselm would have said the resurrection was unnecessary. But that is why we would say PSA is an improvement though, because the resurrection shows conclusively that there is now no condemnation, no more indebtedness. Does that sound right?
 
I see the point, though I doubt Anselm would have said the resurrection was unnecessary. But that is why we would say PSA is an improvement though, because the resurrection shows conclusively that there is now no condemnation, no more indebtedness. Does that sound right?
Of course he thinks it is necessary, but his model doesn't require it.
 
Of course he thinks it is necessary, but his model doesn't require it.
I don't disagree, and that is why I think PSA is a better articulation. I have my reasons for thinking PSA solves the problem of the resurrection not being necessary, but I would be interested to hear yours, and from others as well.
 
Would be very curious to hear your exposition of Book 14 of his anti-Manichean polemical work Against Faustus. He seems to lay out a doctrine of PSA there from Gal. 3:13 that is very similar (though maybe not without some minor differences) to how we would articulate it today.
 
Also, Derek Rishmawy referenced Cyril of Jerusalem’s Catechetical Lectures in a Mere Fidelity episode about PSA, and I found this quote from Cyril that also seems to articulate some building blocks of the doctrine.

“These things the Saviour endured, and made peace through the Blood of His Cross, for things in heaven, and things in earth. For we were enemies of God through sin, and God had appointed the sinner to die. There must needs therefore have happened one of two things; either that God, in His truth, should destroy all men, or that in His loving-kindness He should cancel the sentence. But behold the wisdom of God; He preserved both the truth of His sentence, and the exercise of His loving-kindness. Christ took our sins in His body on the tree, that we by His death might die to sin, and live unto righteousness. Of no small account was He who died for us; He was not a literal sheep; He was not a mere man; He was more than an Angel; He was God made man. The transgression of sinners was not so great as the righteousness of Him who died for them; the sin which we committed was not so great as the righteousness which He wrought who laid down His life for us — who laid it down when He pleased, and took it again when He pleased.” (Lecture 13, section 33)
 
If you are going to quote bomb, a few things to keep in mind:
1) Have ALL your quotes ready.
2) Be prepared to come across Fathers who clearly disagree with you.
3) Be clear on what you are claiming contra Rome or EO.
4) Rome or EO might simply say, "That Father doesn't represent the consensus," and they would probably be right. So the argument is going to move.
 
Back
Top