Resources on Re-Baptism

Venator Veritatis

Puritan Board Freshman
I'm looking for some resources that specifically deal with the notion of Re-Baptism from a Presbyterian/Paedobaptist perspective. Specifically dealing with WCF 28:7

To give some background to the question that might lend itself to the discovery of resources. I was shocked to hear a man with a very strong Presbyterian background say that if you were in a situation where:

1. You are a faithful believer, baptized as an infant, and held to the validity of infant baptism
2. Attended a Particular Baptist church due to a lack of good, faithful Presbyterian churches in your area

If you were denied membership in said Particular Baptist church, and therfore denied being able to partake in the Lord's table, then your best option was to submit to the leadership of the church and get "re-baptised" in order to be able to be a faithful member of the church and participate.

John Brown in his explication of the shorter catechism verifies that

"Q. How often is baptism to be administered to the same person.
A. Only once. Tit.3:5, 1 Pet. 3:21"

And additional, perhaps longer, treatments of the issue would be greatly appreciated.
 
... submit to the leadership of the church and get "re-baptised" in order to be able to be a faithful member of the church and participate.

No Reformed Baptist who knows what they are talking about would ever counsel someone who was moistened as a baby to be "re-baptized". Although we would certainly tell someone they need to get baptized for the first time.
 
No Reformed Baptist who knows what they are talking about would ever counsel someone who was moistened as a baby to be "re-baptized". Although we would certainly tell someone they need to get baptized for the first time.

I'm aware of that. The "re-baptized" language was not verbage coming from the Reformed Baptists.

I know that it's the Reformed position that you can only truly be baptized once. So I apologize if I was unclear.
 
I'm looking for some resources that specifically deal with the notion of Re-Baptism from a Presbyterian/Paedobaptist perspective. Specifically dealing with WCF 28:7

To give some background to the question that might lend itself to the discovery of resources. I was shocked to hear a man with a very strong Presbyterian background say that if you were in a situation where:

1. You are a faithful believer, baptized as an infant, and held to the validity of infant baptism
2. Attended a Particular Baptist church due to a lack of good, faithful Presbyterian churches in your area

If you were denied membership in said Particular Baptist church, and therfore denied being able to partake in the Lord's table, then your best option was to submit to the leadership of the church and get "re-baptised" in order to be able to be a faithful member of the church and participate.

John Brown in his explication of the shorter catechism verifies that

"Q. How often is baptism to be administered to the same person.
A. Only once. Tit.3:5, 1 Pet. 3:21"

And additional, perhaps longer, treatments of the issue would be greatly appreciated.
That is very strange. I don't know that I've ever heard any strong Presbyterian suggest something like that.
I don't know how one can get there from the Presbyterian point of view unless they trivialize the matter and think something such as "Well, I think my baptism as a baby counts, but if this is the only church that I could possibly attend, I'll let them dunk me to appease the Baptist requirement".

I'd imagine it'd be far more likely for a strong Presbyterian to suggest:
a) Moving somewhere closer to a solid Presbyterian church
b) Going without weekly (or monthly) Lord's supper until you're able to move
c) Work to see if a Presbyterian plant could come in to the area
d) Give the pastor a copy of John Bunyan's Differences in Judgment About Water-Baptism No Bar to Communion with the hope that the pastor may change his mind on denying The Lord's Table to a paedobaptist

I don't have any resources to suggest on this topic other than the WCF at this time. In essence, it seems that the suggestions of this man are blatantly contrary to Presbyterian views. The options he gives seems to be either becoming a Baptist or a Presbyterian that lies about being a Baptist.

Hopefully some of our Presbyterian brothers and sisters can offer their thoughts and resource suggestions.
 
That is very strange. I don't know that I've ever heard any strong Presbyterian suggest something like that.
I don't know how one can get there from the Presbyterian point of view unless they trivialize the matter and think something such as "Well, I think my baptism as a baby counts, but if this is the only church that I could possibly attend, I'll let them dunk me to appease the Baptist requirement".

I'd imagine it'd be far more likely for a strong Presbyterian to suggest:
a) Moving somewhere closer to a solid Presbyterian church
b) Going without weekly (or monthly) Lord's supper until you're able to move
c) Work to see if a Presbyterian plant could come in to the area
d) Give the pastor a copy of John Bunyan's Differences in Judgment About Water-Baptism No Bar to Communion with the hope that the pastor may change his mind on denying The Lord's Table to a paedobaptist

I don't have any resources to suggest on this topic other than the WCF at this time. In essence, it seems that the suggestions of this man are blatantly contrary to Presbyterian views. The options he gives seems to be either becoming a Baptist or a Presbyterian that lies about being a Baptist.

Hopefully some of our Presbyterian brothers and sisters can offer their thoughts and resource suggestions.

Thank you. I appreciate your input.

The emphasis seemed to be placed on the importance of church membership, and the ability to exercise ones gifts and partake of the Lord's Supper over the importance of the baptism issue.

Is it a wrong or misguided train of thought to conclude that by advising someone in such a manner they are downplaying the importance of the sign and seal of Baptism? If the person followed through, and submitted to the Particular Baptist leadership and got baptized, they would essentially be publicly repudiating the validity of their infant baptism?

Thank you for the reminder of Bunyan's work. I've been meaning to read it for some time.
 
Thank you. I appreciate your input.

The emphasis seemed to be placed on the importance of church membership, and the ability to exercise ones gifts and partake of the Lord's Supper over the importance of the baptism issue.

Is it a wrong or misguided train of thought to conclude that by advising someone in such a manner they are downplaying the importance of the sign and seal of Baptism? If the person followed through, and submitted to the Particular Baptist leadership and got baptized, they would essentially be publicly repudiating the validity of their infant baptism?

Thank you for the reminder of Bunyan's work. I've been meaning to read it for some time.
Your conclusion is not wrong or misguided. What you described in the OP is not something that any P&R person should be suggesting, as proven by his own confession.
 
If the person followed through, and submitted to the Particular Baptist leadership and got baptized, they would essentially be publicly repudiating the validity of their infant baptism?
Yes - it seems to me that is the statement being made. And that’s why it should not be done.
 
Thank you. I appreciate your input.

The emphasis seemed to be placed on the importance of church membership, and the ability to exercise ones gifts and partake of the Lord's Supper over the importance of the baptism issue.

Is it a wrong or misguided train of thought to conclude that by advising someone in such a manner they are downplaying the importance of the sign and seal of Baptism? If the person followed through, and submitted to the Particular Baptist leadership and got baptized, they would essentially be publicly repudiating the validity of their infant baptism?

Thank you for the reminder of Bunyan's work. I've been meaning to read it for some time.
Sure thing!

Yes, from a Presbyterian standpoint it is absolutely downplaying the importance of the sign and the seal of Baptism. A person following through would necessarily be publicly repudiating the validity of their infant baptism, even if they still believed it was valid (that's where it would get into deceitfulness).

Now if they just became a covinced Reformed Baptist, they wouldn't be deceiving others, but I don't know of any solid Presbyterians who would tell people "hey, you should become Reformed Baptist instead of Prebyterian". I know many Reformed Baptists who would though.
 
Okay, here's something different:

While in NYC, around 2014-15 or so, the Presbyterian churches in our area departing from soundness too severely to remain in, my wife and I started going to a 1689 Baptist church. Shortly after that one of the elders (pastors) stepped down, and the remaining pastor was havng a hard time (about 100-120 attenders weekly), so I offered to co-pastor with him until suitable elders coud be raised up. Everyone knew I was staunchly Presbyterian (Continental Reformed, actually, as at some point I had switched) yet respected their doctrines.

My wife, however, had been baptized as an infant in the Greek Orthodox Church. She was much loved in the Baptist church – serving in many areas, wherever a need was – though when they wanted her to help in teaching women's Bible studies, they said she had to be baptized.

And this is what I told them – one and all – I know her baptism as an infant was a true baptism, genuine and acceptable to God, but for the sake of your consciences I will allow her to go under the water. Our consciences were at rest in this. She'd already been baptized.

There may be some here on PB who will condemn this, I know. But I wanted to share it.
 
Last edited:
Okay, here's something different:

While in NYC, around 2014-15 or so, the Presbyterian churches in our area departing from soundness too severely to remain in, my wife and I started going to a 1689 Baptist church. Shortly after that one of the elders (pastors) stepped down, and the remaining pastor was havng a hard time (about 100-120 attenders weekly), so I offered to co-pastor with him until suitable elders coud be raised up. Everyone knew I was staunchly Presbyterian (Continental Reformed, actually, as at some point I had switched) yet respected their doctrines.

My wife, however, had been baptized as an infant in the Greek Orthodox Church. She was much loved by the church – serving in so many areas, wherever a need was – though when they wanted her to help in teaching women's Bible studies, they said she had to be baptized.

And this is what I told them – one and all – I know her baptism as an infant was a true baptism, genuine and acceptable to God, but for the sake of your consciences I will allow her to go under the water. Our consciences were at rest in this. She'd already been baptized.

There may be some here on PB who will condemn this, I know. But I wanted to share it.
Steve, thank you for posting this. I always appreciate hearing your perspective.
 
Okay, here's something different:

While in NYC, around 2014-15 or so, the Presbyterian churches in our area departing from soundness too severely to remain in, my wife and I started going to a 1689 Baptist church. Shortly after that one of the elders (pastors) stepped down, and the remaining pastor was havng a hard time (about 100-120 attenders weekly), so I offered to co-pastor with him until suitable elders coud be raised up. Everyone knew I was staunchly Presbyterian (Continental Reformed, actually, as at some point I had switched) yet respected their doctrines.

My wife, however, had been baptized as an infant in the Greek Orthodox Church. She was much loved by the church – serving in so many areas, wherever a need was – though when they wanted her to help in teaching women's Bible studies, they said she had to be baptized.

And this is what I told them – one and all – I know her baptism as an infant was a true baptism, genuine and acceptable to God, but for the sake of your consciences I will allow her to go under the water. Our consciences were at rest in this. She'd already been baptized.

There may be some here on PB who will condemn this, I know. But I wanted to share it.

Pastor Steve,

This is an interesting situation. I wouldn't be quick to condemn you in it, I'd have to personally give it a lot of thought (which I don't have time to do). A couple observations: 1) at the very least everyone was open and honest about the situation, 2) Everyone's consciences were respected in that particular case.

Thank you for sharing.
 
Okay, here's something different:

While in NYC, around 2014-15 or so, the Presbyterian churches in our area departing from soundness too severely to remain in, my wife and I started going to a 1689 Baptist church. Shortly after that one of the elders (pastors) stepped down, and the remaining pastor was havng a hard time (about 100-120 attenders weekly), so I offered to co-pastor with him until suitable elders coud be raised up. Everyone knew I was staunchly Presbyterian (Continental Reformed, actually, as at some point I had switched) yet respected their doctrines.

My wife, however, had been baptized as an infant in the Greek Orthodox Church. She was much loved by the church – serving in so many areas, wherever a need was – though when they wanted her to help in teaching women's Bible studies, they said she had to be baptized.

And this is what I told them – one and all – I know her baptism as an infant was a true baptism, genuine and acceptable to God, but for the sake of your consciences I will allow her to go under the water. Our consciences were at rest in this. She'd already been baptized.

There may be some here on PB who will condemn this, I know. But I wanted to share it.
Thanks for sharing Steve.

Given the significance of Baptism it seems odd to me that a Baptist would allow and even encourage someone to go through it, knowing that they didn't think it meant anything significant.

I would not condemn that action, as I'm just a layman and relative novice in the Faith, it just seems inconsistent with the beliefs of both sides.

I am grateful for everyone's input. Thank you.
 
Historically, legality vs. validity matters. It is possible to see a baptism as forensically legal but procedurally invalid. In this case, "re-baptism" is unwarranted.

And it is possible for a "baptism" to be neither legal nor valid. Making it not a baptism at all. In this case, "re-baptism" is not even possible.
 
And it is possible for a "baptism" to be neither legal nor valid. Making it not a baptism at all. In this case, "re-baptism" is not even possible.
Hello Brad, I would say you hit the nail on the head. What my wife underwent was not a baptism at all. And I said as much, just she went "under the water". For her baptism was when she was an infant.

The thing is this: it would have broken her heart – and many in the church – were she not allowed to enter into communion with the church she loved, and was loved by, as a result of – in my eyes – an erroneous understanding. In the church's eyes it was simply a re-baptism, although I said it couldn't be. But their consciences were satisfied, and she was received into membership. It was a matter of love, and truth – for she was a genuinely baptized person, though you may not agree with that, being a Baptist.
 
Last edited:
Your conclusion is not wrong or misguided. What you described in the OP is not something that any P&R person should be suggesting, as proven by his own confession.

@De Jager is right, and I have previously expressed my concern to @Jerusalem Blade on the problems of a person who subscribes to the Three Forms of Unity allowing rebaptism of his wife.

The original poster's comment is appropriate that he was shocked to hear this from "a man with a very strong Presbyterian background:"

I was shocked to hear a man with a very strong Presbyterian background say that if you were in a situation where:

1. You are a faithful believer, baptized as an infant, and held to the validity of infant baptism
2. Attended a Particular Baptist church due to a lack of good, faithful Presbyterian churches in your area

If you were denied membership in said Particular Baptist church, and therfore denied being able to partake in the Lord's table, then your best option was to submit to the leadership of the church and get "re-baptised" in order to be able to be a faithful member of the church and participate.

That's even more so for a person from a Three Forms of Unity background. The Westminster Standards and the TFU are **NOT** the same on this point.

The TFU take a far harder stance against the Baptist position. I can subscribe, and have subscribed to the TFU, but I've been clear from day one that I believe the severe attacks on rebaptizers were intended to attack the original Anabaptists, whose views described in the Belgic Confession are contrary to several things that Reformed Baptists believe. I'm closer to the WCF position on this matter though I can, and have, subscribed to the TFU position. There are TFU people who take a far harder line on modern Baptists, regarding them as being included in the condemnations of the Anabaptists, and I fully grant that the Belgic Confession can be read that way. Historically, the Dutch synods have avoided forcing the issue and coming down with a hard-and-fast "settled and binding" answer on how the specific language is to be understood, at least in part out of recognition that rejecting the orthodoxy of the WCF is probably a really bad idea.

HOWEVER...

Such things do get said, including by confessionally Reformed people. The simple fact of the matter is that the Baptists dominate the modern evangelical world. There are places where there are ABSOLUTELY NO options that are even remotely Reformed. There are places where the only Reformed option is a church that requires believers baptism for membership, Trust me, I know. I live in one of those places, and before that, lived in another one, and drove two hours to church. Hazelgreen would not exist, and there would not be a need for it, if it were not for the fact that the closest Reformed church of any type that will accept infant baptism is an hour and a half away to the west in Springfield, or about two hours to the east in the St. Louis suburbs.

Confessionally Reformed people place a very, very heavy emphasis on church membership, and rightly so.

So what do we do when we're living in a place where no church will accept us into membership?

There are a significant number of Reformed people who will say, "Join the local Missouri Synod Lutherans. They are confessional, though not our confession, and they're closer to us than the Baptists, and while they have different reasons for baptizing babies, they will accept our baptism." I've seen former OPC elders join Lutheran churches because there was no other option in the area where they were living.

I understand that position and I'm not saying I would never do that, but it would take a REALLY extreme situation in which I was living in an area long-term where absolutely the only possible church option was a confessional Lutheran church and I had no viable way to move or drive somewhere else.

So what about a Reformed Baptist church?

Several factors need to be taken into consideration.

One is that not all infant baptisms are the same. The situation with Steve's wife (if I understand correctly, please correct me if I'm wrong) is that she was baptized by unbelieving parents in a church that many Reformed people would consider to be only slightly less problematic than the Roman Catholic Church. I do not agree with the position of some Presbyterians that Roman Catholic baptism is invalid, but that was in fact the position of some in the Southern Presbyterian world in the 1800s. Many of the arguments for the invalidity of Roman Catholic baptism could be used to argue that Steve's wife was never baptized at all in the Eastern Orthodox church. Similar arguments can be, and have been, made against refusing to accept baptisms in liberal churches.

The historic Reformed position is that all Trinitarian baptisms are to be accepted because God is the prime agent in baptism, not the person doing the baptism, or the parents, or the person being baptized. Furthermore, to say that a sacrament administered by an unworthy person is invalid is the Donatist error. (Yes, I understand there is a difference between personal moral failures and heresy, but Donatism is a REALLY serious problem and needs to be avoided.) There is only one example in Scripture of a rebaptism, and that was the disciples of John the Baptist who had never heard of the Holy Spirit. That is why Reformed people baptize people who come from a Mormon, Jehovah's Witness, or Unitarian background, but most accept Roman Catholic or Eastern Orthodox baptism.

In unusual cases, and Steve's case is one of them, an infant baptism may be so irregular that we can understand why not only a Reformed Baptist church but even some Presbyterian churches would reject it, and for that reason, may be willing to accept a requirement of baptism following profession to join that Reformed Baptist church because some Presbyterian churches would make the same requirement.

I can understand why Steve and his wife did what they did. I don't agree. My answer would be that in New York City, they had options, among them being Neighborhood Congregational Church of Greenwich Village or Bronx Household of Faith, both of which are in the 4Cs, Queens Christian Reformed Church, which at that time was pastored by a man who had studied under Cornelis Van Til and was known for his strong commitment to presuppositional apologetics, a United Reformed Churches congregation that at that time was still a church plant in Manhattan rather than an organized church, an OPC in Franklin Square just east of the city, and a long list of Korean Presbyterian churches, some of which have English language services for the second generation, and those that don't, usually have simultaneous translation for American husbands of Korean wives. By driving to New Jersey, the options would have been in the dozens, and at least a half-dozen options farther away than Franklin Square by driving farther out into Long Island.

For people who are living somewhere only temporarily and the only option is a Reformed Baptist church, the answer seems simple: Keep your membership wherever it was before you moved there and attend the Reformed Baptist church without joining. Joining a church at a distance may be an option if you're in a strictly Reformed church that closes, or a church that becomes non-confessional.

Rebaptism should be the last possible choice for a person who believes they were properly baptized as an infant.

I want to be careful attacking people who do that, or who advise it.

But I live in a community where I could name half a dozen families from a Reformed or Presbyterian background who moved here, thanks to the US Army, when they were no Reformed options of any type at all, not even a Reformed Baptist option, and joined Baptist churches that are not Reformed. I know them because some of them listen to my sermons each Sunday online since I really can't ask them to leave a church where they've been for decades and may be married to a Baptist. There are probably many others in that situation who I don't know.

Sometimes there really are no good options and the choice is the least bad of the bad options.

My personal opinion?

I spent most of my adult life in the Conservative Congregational Christian Conference where both positions on baptism are accepted, at local church discretion. Some 4Cs would require rebaptism of those baptized as infants. A few, usually the most strictly Reformed ones, refuse to accept Baptists into membership at all. The common position is for a local church to allow both views.

I agree with that. I support infant baptism, but if the biggest difference I have with a brother is not whether to raise children in the nurture and admonition of the Lord, but rather, when to administer water baptism, quite bluntly, I have a lot bigger problems to worry about in the rural Ozarks.

Sovereign grace is the most important thing.
 
Last edited:
As Brad in post 13 said, it was not a rebaptism. Darrell, the other churches you mentioned were not in the running; and I was aware of them. There was one church we loved and were knitted into. My wife had been baptized as an infant. I said to the church (in effect), if it eases your conscience feel free to dunk her, it is not a baptism – it is a flaw in understanding the Lord's view of baptism – and she, in reality, is already a member of this church: "For by one Spirit are we all baptized into one body..." (1 Cor 12:13).

When it came down to it she was already a member of the church, although their error blinded them to it. This is the mess that credobaptism brings upon the church(es) of God. Earlier, when we were in the Presbyterian church, her baptism as an infant was recognized and accepted.

I, from the get-go, said some would condemn me for my actions; what is to be condemned understood is the error that perpetrates the pain and damage done to the body of Christ. It is not a "mere" doctrinal error and difference. I simply refused to acknowledge the validity of the error.

I know some among both paedo and credo will not agree with me: but, "There is one body, and one Spirit, even as ye are called in one hope of your calling; One Lord, one faith, one baptism" (Ephesians 4:4-5).
 
Last edited:
I sympathize, @Jerusalem Blade . I live in a community where finding a Reformed church of any type is nearly impossible, so I understand why people become Baptists, and not even Reformed Baptists but standard-issue broadly evangelical Baptists.

Your decision isn't the one I would make, but I have a decades-long history of being more sympathetic to and patient with Baptists than many in the Reformed world. You know the local situation, you know your family, and it isn't my place to make decisions for you.

I think a lot of people who live in an area with not only a large number but also a wide variety of Reformed churches don't realize how hard things are in some places, not just overseas in Cyprus but also right here in the USA.
 
Hello Brad, I would say you hit the nail on the head. What my wife underwent was not a baptism at all. And I said as much, just she went "under the water". For her baptism was when she was an infant.

The thing is this: it would have broken her heart – and many in the church – were she not allowed to enter into communion with the church she loved, and was loved by, as a result of – in my eyes – an erroneous understanding. In the church's eyes it was simply a re-baptism, although I said it couldn't be. But their consciences were satisfied, and she was received into membership. It was a matter of love, and truth – for she was a genuinely baptized person, though you may not agree with that, being a Baptist.
To me they place too much emphasis on the water and not Christ. It’s really a kissing cousin to the Church of Christ baptism.
 
To me they place too much emphasis on the water and not Christ. It’s really a kissing cousin to the Church of Christ baptism.

While I agree with you, if I were a Baptist, I think I'd have to say that a person who was baptized without prior personal profession of faith has not been baptized and needs to be, at least if he (or she) wants to join a Baptist church, since joining a Baptist church means voting rights in selection of elders and setting church policy.

Presbyterians get around that issue because the elders, not the congregational meeting, run the church and make the decisions on who is allowed to be a candidate for the eldership. Also for Presbyterians -- the Dutch Reformed operate differently -- the presbytery can step in if a group of members start advocating a direction that is contrary to the confessions of the church. That's why Presbyterians allow Baptists to be church members because their vote doesn't raise the same sorts of problems that it would under congregational church polity, or for that matter, under Dutch Reformed polity. The Dutch have other reasons of principle for (usually) not allowing Baptists to join their churches, but in addition to the reasons of principle, there are also reasons of practice. The classis doesn't have the same level of authority over a consistory that a presbytery has over a session.

My own position on this issue doesn't fall into the usual categories since historic Congregationalism did operate somewhat different than either the Presbyterians or Dutch Reformed -- there are reasons why John Owen worked with John Bunyan and other Baptists -- but I understand and respect the usual Baptist refusal to allow people like me to join their churches. If I were in their shoes, I'd probably do the same.

The consequences of a Baptist admitting someone to membership who doesn't agree with believer's baptism are far greater than for a Presbyterian to do that. At most, a Reformed Baptist can only do it in cases where there really are no other churches that share their belief in sovereign grace, and should help Reformed people who believe in infant baptism to organize a non-Baptist church that is Reformed, accepting non-Baptists into membership only as a temporary necessity out of graciousness, not a permanent solution that normalizes allowing people to be members who they firmly believe are not baptized.
 
Back
Top