Ad-blocking

Status
Not open for further replies.

Ploutos

Puritan Board Graduate
What methods have you tried for eliminating ads on computers and smartphones - not just pop up and website ads but that entirely different beast of YouTube ads? I'm contemplating various options for our home from DNS sinkholes to using privacy browsers like Brave. Browser extensions are also something I'm looking into. I'd also consider paid subscriptions (such as to YouTube) as a viable option.
 
I second this question. And I want also to observe how devilish it is that gas stations now have TV's that play obnoxious, Tik-Tok generation-esque fodder.
 
IDK about smartphones, but on the computer (i use Google Chrome) i have "PIE Adblocker" and it works wonders. No ads anywhere, including youtube. I used to use Adblock Plus but it stopped working on YouTube.
 
I'm always shocked when I look at something on my phone and see popup ads.

Here's a Brave trick - they normally substitute one of their ads for a regular ad. But if you run Win7, they won't serve an ad at all. So when your Win10 expires of old age in a few months, see if they provide that same service to Win10 users.

I used to use Adblock Plus
They sold out to 'the man' and shows "acceptable" ads now - meaning ones where they've been paid off.
 
I have pi-holes on my local network, but I also use NextDNS.io.

NextDNS has content filtering and other security guards and allows you to add Privacy Adlists in the settings. I use the OISD and the Hagazi Multi-Normal blocklists.
 
Ublock origin works well on desktop and phone browsing. It also works for YouTube on the internet. If you want a YouTube app that blocks ads, get revanced.
 
Last edited:
I have pi-holes on my local network, but I also use NextDNS.io.

NextDNS has content filtering and other security guards and allows you to add Privacy Adlists in the settings. I use the OISD and the Hagazi Multi-Normal blocklists.
Do you know how NextDNS compares to OpenDNS? I've used the latter before.
 
You should allow pop up ads to not deny the content creator their potential revenue that comes when if you do click on it
 
You should allow pop up ads to not deny the content creator their potential revenue that comes when if you do click on it
Nope. I'm happy to contribute in my small way to the demise of the ad economy, especially with the 7th-commandment violations I come across on an almost daily basis. My devices know that I'm a near-middle-aged male, but apparently don't know that I'm married, have children, and subscribe rather strictly to the Westminster Standards. You'd think just based on my posting history here that I'd at least be getting ads for PuritanMingle.com or DutchReformedMingle.com or MicroDenominationMingle.com.
 
You should allow pop up ads to not deny the content creator their potential revenue that comes when if you do click on it
Nope.

I'll take statics and banners. Multiple layers of popups that I have to chase on my phone, I just abandon the website. No website is valuable enough for me to put up with that. I'll just wait and use a real computer where I can control the experience.

I'm more than happy to help bankrupt a web site that makes its money by hijacking my device.
 
I second this question. And I want also to observe how devilish it is that gas stations now have TV's that play obnoxious, Tik-Tok generation-esque fodder.
I hate those embedded displays. However, I get a good kick out of switching languages and turning up the volume to max before I leave. It actually makes the videos more tolerable when you can't understand what they're rambling on about.
 
You should allow pop up ads to not deny the content creator their potential revenue that comes when if you do click on it
I agree, especially with sites whose only revenue for its creators are based on the ad content. If you do not want deal with ads, fork over the money for the no-ad experience many of these sites have. Otherwise, that is how the content creators are getting paid.
 
I agree, especially with sites whose only revenue for its creators are based on the ad content. If you do not want deal with ads, fork over the money for the no-ad experience many of these sites have. Otherwise, that is how the content creators are getting paid.
As I said above, I will gladly and wilfully contribute to the demise of the ad economy. I want the content creators to see the return on their ad-based investments go away. I'm more than happy to be one of the thousand cuts to that whole wicked ecosystem. If it's replaced by a paid-subscription ecosystem, I am great with that and I'm happy to hasten the process by blocking ads.
 
As I said above, I will gladly and wilfully contribute to the demise of the ad economy. I want the content creators to see the return on their ad-based investments go away. I'm more than happy to be one of the thousand cuts to that whole wicked ecosystem. If it's replaced by a paid-subscription ecosystem, I am great with that and I'm happy to hasten the process by blocking ads.
But knowing that you 1. Are not required to use these sites, and 2. That the content creators on these sites are getting paid by the ads that are in the service you voluntarily use, how do you not think that this is a form of theft? If the sites themselves wanted ads disabled, like Youtube who offers an ad-free experience for a fee, and I think Facebook as well, wouldnt they create their platform like that?

I'm right there with you. I hate ads as well. But if I dont pay for the ad-free experience, I cant complain. For instance I pay add-free on Netflix, and Max, but not Hulu. I can pay for it on Youtube and Facebook, but dont. And when I dont, this also affects many of the brethren who put out awesome content, and only make revenue from the ads.
 
Last edited:
But knowing that you 1. Are not required to use these sites, and 2. That the content creators on these sites are getting paid by the ads that are in the service you voluntarily use, how do you not think that this is a form of theft? If the sites themselves wanted ads disabled, like Youtube who offers an ad-free experience for a fee, and I think Facebook as well, wouldnt they create their platform like that?
I'm not required to use the sites, and I'm not forbidden by any law to use ad-blockers on them. It is within my right to refuse to buy into the ad ecosystem, with all the invasions of privacy that it entails. Google may not want me to do this, but Google's wishes are not law and I am not bound by them. It is also within the right of the content creator to withdraw from the ad ecosystem altogether and to go exclusively to a subscription model. You will not hear me complain if and when that happens and you can hold me to that. In the meantime, I have absolutely no qualms about consuming content without the barrage of what is at worst soft-core pr0n and explicit enticement to adultery and at best godless materialism. When the US government or the government of my state forbids ad blockers, DNS sinkholes, parental control routers, and privacy browsers, then I will adjust my behavior accordingly and not before.
 
I'm not required to use the sites, and I'm not forbidden by any law to use ad-blockers on them. It is within my right to refuse to buy into the ad ecosystem, with all the invasions of privacy that it entails. Google may not want me to do this, but Google's wishes are not law and I am not bound by them. It is also within the right of the content creator to withdraw from the ad ecosystem altogether and to go exclusively to a subscription model. You will not hear me complain if and when that happens and you can hold me to that. In the meantime, I have absolutely no qualms about consuming content without the barrage of what is at worst soft-core pr0n and explicit enticement to adultery and at best godless materialism. When the US government or the government of my state forbids ad blockers, DNS sinkholes, parental control routers, and privacy browsers, then I will adjust my behavior accordingly and not before.
I stand corrected. After looking it up, there is no law against ad-blockers. So you are most certainly within your rights.
 
I am not sure what irks me more--the ads or the fact that companies use "negative reinforcement" to earn money. My husband is the savvy one with all of this stuff, and he has also talked about getting a pi-hole. However, we haven't needed to because we watch most of our YouTube videos on our smart TV because he found a crowd-sourced "YouTube" app that automatically blocks ads and even skips the author's sponsored ads that are part of the video itself. I also second @retroGRAD3 in recommending uBlock Origin--that seems to work well on our computers. I do not watch many videos on my phone simply because I prefer not to get into the habit of using my phone for everything. The only subscription service we pay for is Spotify, and we are part of a family plan, which means we don't pay as much per month.

I am spoiled to the point where I am brought back to reality when I am at someone else's house, and they do not have any form of ad blocker when pulling up a YouTube video. The other day, I brought our daughter over to the home of my elder and his wife, and my elder frequently likes to pull up YouTube videos to share music--mostly old country--with me. I could only hear the audio, and I was repulsed just by the degenerate audio content of the ad that played before my elder could skip the rest of the ad to get to the actual video.
 
Ublock origin works well on desktop and phone browsing. It also works for YouTube on the internet.
I just checked this out as an extension for Chrome, which gives the warning:
This extension may soon no longer be supported because it doesn't follow best practices for Chrome extensions.
That means I might have to switch browsers too. Which browser do you use?
 
I am not sure what irks me more--the ads or the fact that companies use "negative reinforcement" to earn money. My husband is the savvy one with all of this stuff, and he has also talked about getting a pi-hole. However, we haven't needed to because we watch most of our YouTube videos on our smart TV because he found a crowd-sourced "YouTube" app that automatically blocks ads and even skips the author's sponsored ads that are part of the video itself. I also second @retroGRAD3 in recommending uBlock Origin--that seems to work well on our computers. I do not watch many videos on my phone simply because I prefer not to get into the habit of using my phone for everything. The only subscription service we pay for is Spotify, and we are part of a family plan, which means we don't pay as much per month.

I am spoiled to the point where I am brought back to reality when I am at someone else's house, and they do not have any form of ad blocker when pulling up a YouTube video. The other day, I brought our daughter over to the home of my elder and his wife, and my elder frequently likes to pull up YouTube videos to share music--mostly old country--with me. I could only hear the audio, and I was repulsed just by the degenerate audio content of the ad that played before my elder could skip the rest of the ad to get to the actual video.
You raise a good point that my wife and I were talking about just the other day, which is that all of this discussion, valid as it is, only applies within our home. A big part of the reason that we're thinking about this is so that we can monitor and guide device usage once our children come of age. But we have already started talking with our oldest daughter about the dangers of technology and how to handle certain situations outside the home - and we're also going through (as time permits) confessional teaching on the 10 commandments. Our hope and prayer is that when she comes of age she will have tools to recognize and discern when she's out of range of our ad-blockers and our watchful eyes.
 
Do you know how NextDNS compares to OpenDNS? I've used the latter before.
It's way better. OpenDNS provides for category filtering but I've really appreciated NextDNS features and the ability to set it up easily on all devices.

It's also pretty inexpensive. I set up another account for the Church.

You can set up multiple profiles within an account so you can decide what profile applies to certain devices.

Here is a setup guide:

 
I run pihole on a raspberry pi, but I also pay for adguard for my laptop, and it blocks even embedded YouTube ads.
 
uBlock Origin works great, especially on Firefox. While uBlock Origin is also published on Chrome, Google has crippled its functionality on that browser. I'm not sure about Brave, which is based on Chrome, but I stick with Firefox. You can get Firefox with uBlock Origin on all major desktop operating systems and on Android. It blocks Youtube ads and pretty much everything else too.
 
I probably ought to have noted this when I commended https://nextdns.io, but focusing only on Ad Blocking is a low priority for your system and your home network (especially if you have kids). I have been using pi-holes for years to block not only websites but URL's that devices and apps will "home" to without your knowledge. NextDNS is another level of protection. I can add the same blocklists and it is the DNS server for every device on my network. It has a tone of security features that will keep my devices from "homing" to places I donw't want them to as well as keeping websites from connecting to places I don't want my network connecting to.
 
I probably ought to have noted this when I commended https://nextdns.io, but focusing only on Ad Blocking is a low priority for your system and your home network (especially if you have kids). I have been using pi-holes for years to block not only websites but URL's that devices and apps will "home" to without your knowledge. NextDNS is another level of protection. I can add the same blocklists and it is the DNS server for every device on my network. It has a tone of security features that will keep my devices from "homing" to places I donw't want them to as well as keeping websites from connecting to places I don't want my network connecting to.
Hi Rich,

Thanks for that feedback. I will definitely look into this. I've already been testing Brave Browser on some of our devices, which so far seems to be a step in the right direction for ad blocking. And I'm pricing a Raspberry Pi as well for use as a sinkhole.
 
I second this question. And I want also to observe how devilish it is that gas stations now have TV's that play obnoxious, Tik-Tok generation-esque fodder.
Oh, I hate these gas station TVs at the pumps so very much. First time I came across one, I about jumped out of my skin, it was so loud. I avoid all gas stations with them, if possible. If I have to stop for gas at one, I'll only put a little gas in the car, just enough to get me where I am going for the day.

I am not a loud or ranting sort of person, but those screens at the pump bring out a bellicosity I didn't know I had. I talk back to them, telling them to 'shut-up'.
[automerge]1740485080[/automerge]
I am allergic to all ads. I don't see them if I can avoid it, and mainly I can, unless someone has a TV blaring at their home.
I use AdBlocker Ultimate and Ghostery on my desk top(brave browser) and Chromebook(chrome browser).
Don't see ads on either. I don't use my phone for any browsing, so that isn't an issue for me.
 
Hi Rich,

Thanks for that feedback. I will definitely look into this. I've already been testing Brave Browser on some of our devices, which so far seems to be a step in the right direction for ad blocking. And I'm pricing a Raspberry Pi as well for use as a sinkhole.
Raspberry Pi's are a lot of fun to put together and set up.
 
I get zero adds on my iPad using DuckDuckGo app + Proton mail. I also have a free Norton app which is dated but I think it still works. At least that’s what FoxNews says sometimes. Then I just refresh the page and it’s gone. Google is not your friend as you are tracked everywhere.

DuckDuckGo also has a separate YouTube app that removes adds for free.
 
Raspberry Pi's are a lot of fun to put together and set up.
I got one to play with when I was retired. I did get it set up and working but never did anything productive with it before going back to work. Good result, however, I had a spare monitor, keyboard, and mouse when I had to start working from home on short notice.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top