Bicycle question

Status
Not open for further replies.

Edward

Puritanboard Commissioner
Any bicycle users out there?

I've got a Canadian made Peugeot hybrid about 15 years old that gets fairly light use. Today, when riding to pick up my daughter at school, I heard a noise like the chain had jumped. I stopped to check, and found that one of the gears had broken roughly in half and was on the ground (don't know where the other half went) One of the other gears spins freely on the hub. (The gear set is 3x7). By not shifting gears, I got there and back, although the chain would occasionally slip.

Question - would it be better (cheaper) to try to replace the broken gear(s), replace the whole set, or replace the bike? And should I try this myself, or use a professional.
 
Terminology:

I think you are saying that one sprocket broke and fell off, leaving only six of the seven sprockets. The sprockets are stacked to comprise the cassette.

I suggest you replace the entire cassette because this may indicate that one or more of the other sprockets are weakened enough to break. Take it to a bike shop for a frustration-free experience because this job requires specific tools. There is no need to replace the bike. You will be tempted to spend more money on a new bike than it will take to replace the cassette.
 
I think you are saying that one sprocket broke and fell off, leaving only six of the seven sprockets. The sprockets are stacked to comprise the cassette.

I suggest you replace the entire cassette because this may indicate that one or more of the other sprockets are weakened enough to break. Take it to a bike shop for a frustration-free experience because this job requires specific tools. There is no need to replace the bike. You will be tempted to spend more money on a new bike than it will take to replace the cassette.

Thanks. That's helpful.

---------- Post added at 05:01 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:59 PM ----------

You were picking up your daughter from school on a bicycle?

Yes, If I'm off on a nice day, I'll drop off her bike at midday, then ride up and ride back with her.
 
I think you are saying that one sprocket broke and fell off, leaving only six of the seven sprockets. The sprockets are stacked to comprise the cassette.

I suggest you replace the entire cassette because this may indicate that one or more of the other sprockets are weakened enough to break. Take it to a bike shop for a frustration-free experience because this job requires specific tools. There is no need to replace the bike. You will be tempted to spend more money on a new bike than it will take to replace the cassette.

Thanks. That's helpful.

---------- Post added at 05:01 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:59 PM ----------

You were picking up your daughter from school on a bicycle?

Yes, If I'm off on a nice day, I'll drop off her bike at midday, then ride up and ride back with her.

That's lovely, great idea. From time to time I threaten my daughters with picking them up on a bicycle built for two while wearing my pajamas.
 
Unless you really know bikes, this is a case for a bike mechanic. They're far cheaper than auto mechanics, generally passionate about their work, and nearly always worth more than you pay.

Take it to the bike shop. After 15 years, it's high time you get a pro make it hum again. Or if it isn't worth repairing, they're the ones who'll be able to tell you that.
 
I would take in the whole bike. There might be some incorrect alignment or other defect in the chain or derailleur that has put undue stress on the rear sprockets, causing the breakage. You might be under a bit more pressure to get a full tune up or something, but just ask them to explain why something is needed and you can make your own decision, depending on how important it is to you to have a bike in excellent repair.
 
Thanks again. Probably easier to put on the rack and take the whole bike than it would be to pull the wheel anyway. A tune up might be in order, anyway. the cables have probably stretched a bit.
 
The sprockets are stacked to comprise the cassette.

I suggest you replace the entire cassette
Tim's right, you need a special tool, which you're unlikely to have, to replace the cassette,

Turned out to be a free wheel instead of cassette. $5 labor to pull off the old one and put on the new one; no charge for the special order, just full retail price. - I'm letting them do it. Nice folks there - I think I'll look at a new bike for my daughter when I go in to pick up mine.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top