Scott
Puritan Board Graduate
I am reading D.G. Hart's Recovering Mother Kirk right now. (Hart is a church historian at Westminster Seminary). He uses Frame's book on worship ("Worship in Spirit and Truth") as an example of the liturgical liberalism that has been introduced into the church since the 1970s. He observes that some of the most doctrinally conservative churches are also some of the most liturgically liberal. Ironically, liberal mainline churches are often liturgically conservative. You are more likely to find the liturgy of Calvin's Geneva in a mainline PCUSA church than a PCA church (of course, the doctrine will be abominable). The PCUSA's recent hymnbook, for example, includes an almost complete psalter. Many people in the PCA do not even know what a psalter is, in spite of its centrality to the Reformation (and the fact the every NT command to sing refers to psalms (not exclusively), a doctrine that somehow eludes otherwise doctrinaire conservative Presbyterians who seldom sing or pray psalms). Anyway, this reversal of roles has been a strange phenomenon since the 1970s.
What do people think about that?
What do people think about that?