Jeff-
I'll briefly try my best. However, this has gone farther than I intended to personally involve myself. I think I have answered these questions already but I'll try again one last time. Thanks for your patience.
Originally posted by Jeff_Bartel
Please tell me what area you disagree with this argument.
-An apologetic that assumes empiricism as it's first principle is evidentialism.
Classical apologetics does not assume empiricism as it's first principle.
A. It assumes that there is common ground among christians and non-christian by virtue of both being created in the image of God; the fall defacing, but not erasing man's ability to reason entirely. Their 3 basic affirmations of what this common ground is: 1)the law of non-contradiction, 2) the law of causality, 3) basic reliability of sense perception. It starts with logic, not empiricism.
B. My original point was that you defined empiricism as: "the senses alone furnish us with truth". I agree that this is the definition of empiricism as a worldview, in its strict sense. This is naked or pure empiricism. What I tried to correct is that Classical apologetics does not hold to empiricism in this sense. I wanted you to show me where in Sproul and Gerstner they take this position as you have stated they do. They hold that we can learn some things from the senses, yes. But they do not hold that we "only" learn truth from the senses. Whether you agree with the merits of sensory knowledge or not is irrelevant to our discussion. I am simply trying to point out that you mischaracterized the position. They would reject pure empiricism just as much as you and Clark would. A modified common sense realism would be a more accurate designation, not empiricism in its pure form.
Here are their own words: "We are convinced that an epistemology established upon a naked empiricism is doomed to travel the road to the graveyard of Hume." (CA, p. 85)
I hope this makes it clear that when you said, "Gerstner/Sproul et. al. presuppose empiricism (the senses alone furnish us with truth)", it was misleading and not true. If you still disagree, can you show me where in the book or related writings they contradict their statement here and actually affirm pure empiricism as you said they do?
Originally posted by Jeff_Bartel
-Sproul et. al's first priniciple is the reliability of the senses. This is their unproved axiom, and hence they attempt to draw conclusions from it (i.e. the existence of God).
Again, it is not the first principle. A basic reading of classical apologists in their own words should make this clear. It is at most
a first principle, but not
the first principle. (as an aside, just to make this clear also, they do not feel they have to prove this "axiom", rather they try to show that denying this "axiom" is self-refuting and thereby proves its truth. Just like one cannot disprove the law of contradiction without enaging in contradiction, thereby proving the law. Both "axioms" are self-attesting, they think. I do not wish to debate the merits of this at this time, but merely wish to show what they actually are saying.)
Originally posted by Jeff_Bartel
-In apologetics, assuming empiricism as your first principle and deriving your conclusions from these unproved assertions can rightly be called empricism.
Again, agreed. But this is pure empiricism, not classical apologetics. There is a difference as I tried to show above.
Originally posted by Jeff_Bartel
If you think that this is misrepresenting Sproul et. al, please explain.
I am not proficient at the deep technical discussions, but I hope I have explained it clearly.
Also, I understand what you are saying about classical apologetics being classified as evidentialism. In relation to presuppostionalism I would agree (with a few caveats however, since some forms of presuppostionalism also admit evidence in their method. In that case it it isn't a matter of evidences being legit, but rather a matter of when they can be used in one's method.).
But there is also a distinction between classical and evidential. Classical starts with rational argumentation for theism, then uses historical, material, and biblical evidence for scripture as the sole special revelation of that God, then defends the biblical understanding of who that God is. Evidential apologetics does not agree with starting out making a case for theism, but rather starts with the historical evidence for the humanity, deity, and resurrection of Christ.
So in sum:
-classical apologetics is not pure empiricism, but it is evidential in some of its method.
-classical apologetics is similar to evidential apologetics in that they both use evidence, but they differ in their method of using evidence. Some forms of VanTillianism affirm the use of evidence also, but they differ from classical and evidential in their method.
I don't have the time to go any further, so thanks for the discussion Jeff and your kind demeanor despite our differences. While we disagree about which method is closer to the truth, I just wanted to make clear for the one who said he needed help that CA was represented accurately. I am sure we can both agree that our desire is to destroy the arguments that those who refuse to submit to God bring to the table, so that we can point them to the sole source of salvation, Christ himself and his Gospel for their unbelief. I am thankful that we are of the same purpose in destroying arguments of unbelievers, rather than destroying them or eachother in the process.
Blessings brother,
-Allan