Isaiah's perspective

Status
Not open for further replies.

Ploutos

Puritan Board Graduate
I've read numerous articles and study Bible notes from a Reformed perspective that talk about a "double fulfillment" when it comes to some of Isaiah's prophecies - as for instance with the "young maiden" of Isaiah 7 referencing a near-term fulfillment of some unknown historical figure born around that time, and then a long-term fulfillment in the birth of Jesus.

I have not yet done a deep dive into Isaiah or read commentaries on it as I have with a few other Bible books. Based on my own personal familiarity with the book from repeated readings, and nothing more, I have sometimes found that type of approach to be contrived. Instead, I have wondered if Isaiah has something of a 'telescoped' perspective of redemptive history. I have struggled to figure out how to put this into words. It seems that, particularly starting with the vision of Isaiah 6, he has a very long and far-seeing view into redemptive history and God's plan. In light of that, I have wondered if Isaiah got a glimpse of the relationship between the historical events of his present day and the unfolding of God's redemptive history - if he saw, more clearly than we do, the correspondence between types and anti-types. In light of that, I have wondered if he sometimes blurred the lines between the two, shifting back and forth between contemporary events and key points in redemptive history. So whereas it might seem to us somewhat strange to respond to Ahaz's lack of faith by prophesying an event 700 years away, from Isaiah's perspective this might have been that much of a leap. Likewise, in Isaiah 14, he could be seamlessly moving back and forth between talking about Babylon and referencing Satan's fall - or even talking about both at the same time. It's as if Isaiah is seeing contemporary history and redemptive history all at once, unfolded in some panorama before his eyes, enabling him to jump around and make connections in a way that wouldn't seem terribly intuitive or obvious to many of us.

I'm not trying to discover something new here (what is new is not true...), but am just wondering, from the more educated OT interpreters on here, if this line of thinking is way off-base, and if others have had similar ideas before. I don't intend to use y'all as a substitute for my own study, though at the same time I don't currently have bandwidth to add an Isaiah commentary to the two Romans commentaries and all the other books I'm currently reading.
 
It seems that, particularly starting with the vision of Isaiah 6, he has a very long and far-seeing view into redemptive history and God's plan. In light of that, I have wondered if Isaiah got a glimpse of the relationship between the historical events of his present day and the unfolding of God's redemptive history - if he saw, more clearly than we do, the correspondence between types and anti-types. In light of that, I have wondered if he sometimes blurred the lines between the two, shifting back and forth between contemporary events and key points in redemptive history. So whereas it might seem to us somewhat strange to respond to Ahaz's lack of faith by prophesying an event 700 years away, from Isaiah's perspective this might have been that much of a leap. Likewise, in Isaiah 14, he could be seamlessly moving back and forth between talking about Babylon and referencing Satan's fall - or even talking about both at the same time. It's as if Isaiah is seeing contemporary history and redemptive history all at once, unfolded in some panorama before his eyes, enabling him to jump around and make connections in a way that wouldn't seem terribly intuitive or obvious to many of us.
Good morning, brother.

Having had the immensely satisfying privilege of meticulously working through Isaiah over the course of a year and some change, I'd say your intuition is spot on here. Reverend Brian Borgman, who has uploaded the most exhaustive series of expository sermons on Isaiah available at SermonAudio, has I think accurately described the prophet's perspective as effectively a truncated or telescopic view in which two sets of mountain ranges, corresponding to contemporary and future events respectively, are equally visible from his vantage point, such that they appear side-by-side with little to no distance discernible between them. From our own perspective, who, as it were, reside in the valley and have a greater appreciation for the vast breadth of distance between those two mountain ranges, the ease with which the prophet shifts from discoursing on one set of events to another with such facility is remarkable. From Isaiah's point of view, events that were to occur within his lifetime or a century or so after the terminus of his ministry, such as the conquest of Samaria by Shalmaneser V and Sargon II, the devastation of Moab and Edom by Assyria, the siege of Jerusalem by Sennacherib, or even the fall of Babylon to the Medo-Persians and the return of the Exiles to Judah by the decree of Cyrus, are all interwoven with events that to our perspective are wholly eschatological in their character; such as the downfall of the worldly city in chapters 14 and 24-27 , the foretelling of Assyria's and Egypt's coming to a saving, covenantal knowledge of the LORD (chapter 19), the in-gathering of the peoples to worship atop Mount Zion and partake in the great banquet (chapter 25), the New Heavens and the New Earth (chapter 65), and, of course, the virgin birth of the savior and His vicarious death. Having said this, I think that Isaiah is best read as both the blueprint to Old Testament eschatology, in much the same way that Revelation functions both as a blueprint for the sorts of judgments, spiritual trials, and comforts that saints can expect to brave in this present life and as a source of hope for the consummation of the age, as well as a dramatic presentation of the gospel spoken in the idiom of the Old Testament types and shadows that the LORD was pleased to institute through Moses.

Isaiah is about many things, running the gamut from God's holiness and sovereignty over history, His righteous judgment against the nations, the hope of restoration and mercy not only for the Jewish remnant but also the surviving diaspora of the Gentile nations (such as Moab and Tyre), etc., but the commentaries that I have had the privilege of working through, such as Alec Motyer and E.J. Young, alongside the fruitful expository sermons that have supplemented my reading, have cemented the notion that it is first and foremost about the glory of the Messiah, His estate of humiliation and triumphant exaltation, the deliverance and righteousness wrought by His exemplary life and atoning death, and the kingdom upon whose throne He sits, and whose extent overspreads the earth and receives the allegiance of the nations.

I know that you mentioned your busy reading itinerary JP, but if I could recommend any resource as a complementary guide that helped enrich my studies of Isaiah, it was Motyer's commentary. Masterful handling of the chiastic structure and the thematic elaborations that recur throughout the book, as well as in terms of parsing original language exegesis within OT theological concepts. Very good integration of historical and contemporary cultural context as well. I highly commend it to you.
 
Last edited:
The observation that Isaiah often conjoins the near and the far is right. But the idea of two separate fulfilments in Isaiah 7 would end up giving us two Immanuels, which the text cannot sustain. Isaiah 7-12 presents a single Immanuel whose identity unfolds across the section. And the name "Immanuel" is not a casual label for a merely human child. As a title it points directly to the Messianic figure fulfilled in Christ.

It is better to see this as one prophecy with a typological structure rather than two fulfilments. V. 14 speaks of the virgin‑born Christ, the true Immanuel. The verses that follow speak of a contemporary child who serves as an immediate sign to Ahaz. This sets up an historical type that stands in organic relation to the greater fulfilment. In this way Isaiah can speak of the near and the far together without multiplying Immanuels.
 
Also worth noting is that with respect to the circumstances of Immanuel's birth, the description provided by the following verses (e.g. Isaiah 7:17-25), which concerns the time period into which He shall be born, is such as could only apply after the Babylonian exile, as the razing of Judah by both Assyria/Babylonia and Egypt is therein described, particularly the poverty and desolation of the land (Immanuel eating curds and honey, the reduced agricultural yields, limited livestock, etc.) in comparison to its former abundance. As Judah did not come under such extreme devastation until the closing days of Josiah's reign, with Pharaoh Neco and the subsequent invasion by Egypt in 609 BC, followed by the Babylonians in 605 BC in the aftermath of the Battle of Carchemish, all of which caused much hardship and the destruction of vineyards, olive orchards, and fields, neither Maher-shalal-Hashbaz, Hezekiah, or any other infant born in the days of Ahaz or the kings of Judah could have qualified so as to fulfill the specifics of the child's uprearing described in chapter 7. Rather, only after the razing of Judah by Babylon and the deportation of the people, in which the land is desolate and left to languish, do such conditions set in. It may be a bit of a pedantic point to make, but it goes quite a ways to narrowing the focus on a future-oriented fulfillment of Isaiah's prophecy.
 
As a “coincidence”, I just happen to be reading Dale Ralph Davis’s book “Stump Kingdom”. It is a short (127 pages) and very readable commentary on just chapters 6-12 in Isaiah.

Davis has an interesting take on the Immanuel prophecy in Isaiah 7.

He says that verse 15b refers to purpose or result, not time:

"The Hebrew verb form in verse 15b is an infinitive of the verb ‘to know’ (the form used is leda to). Most English versions translate this verb form in a temporal, time-oriented sense. Typical renderings are: ‘by the time he knows,’ ‘when he knows,’ ‘until he knows.’ …However…whenever this infinitive is used with the prefixed preposition le (as here), it always expresses result or purpose and never time (more than forty occurrences involved).* That means no ‘when’ or ‘until’ or time-element should be used when translating verse 15b. Rather the child eats curds and honey ‘so that he may know rejecting evil and choosing good …there is no time indicator. …When verse 15 is freed of a time-element one no longer needs to grub around in a fruitless search to dig up some child contemporary with Ahaz. …Immanuel is someone beyond Ahaz and removed from Ahaz.** …If this is correct, then we needn’t mess with ‘double fulfillment’ schemes nor scurry around trying to dredge up some contemporary (8th century B.C.) 'almah' – or Immanual – candidate to fill the need of a non-existent relevance for Ahaz." (pages 33-36)

*Footnote 9 on page 33: “I checked sixteen English versions on Isaiah 15 – only two (AV/KJV and the NKJV) got it right.” (Keep in mind that this is not coming from a TR/KJV only guy. Davis is conservative and Reformed, but he has no issues with using CT versions of the Bible and when using his own translations, he almost always uses ‘Yahweh’ instead of ‘LORD’ or ‘Jehovah’ – there is another thread about this…)

**Footnote 14 on page 35: "I am not denying that, in general, the Immanuel prophecy is good news; I am only saying that in this context it is bad news for Ahaz in that, clearly, this ‘Immanuel’ is someone not available to Ahaz. Biblical prophecy may do this – use a positive message in a negative way."

Obviously, I'm oversimplifying and omitting parts of his argument/position. For the full defense of his position refer to chapter 2 in his commentary, pages 21-45. Also, this position is not original/unique to Davis. He is following other commentators identified in the footnotes in the book.
 
Last edited:
Garrick,

Thank you so much for... well, I'm not here for validation, but I do tend to have a certain inherent mistrust of "original" ideas in myself. That's one reason I sometimes bring them here! Of course, you put it so much more eloquently than I could, and I appreciate you doing so. Yes, Isaiah is not looking at time and history the same way we do.

A musical analogy that comes to mind is the first movement of Bruckner's 9th symphony. Formal analyses of this piece almost invariably use the word "telescope" (yes, even Wikipedia!) in describing the way Bruckner handles the elements of sonata form. When one listens to the piece and grasps its transcendent, almost other-worldly sense of time and progression, and the way Bruckner blurs the different components of sonata form together into an irresistible and compelling cathedral of sound... this is very much what I feel like Isaiah does.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top