Ploutos
Puritan Board Graduate
I've read numerous articles and study Bible notes from a Reformed perspective that talk about a "double fulfillment" when it comes to some of Isaiah's prophecies - as for instance with the "young maiden" of Isaiah 7 referencing a near-term fulfillment of some unknown historical figure born around that time, and then a long-term fulfillment in the birth of Jesus.
I have not yet done a deep dive into Isaiah or read commentaries on it as I have with a few other Bible books. Based on my own personal familiarity with the book from repeated readings, and nothing more, I have sometimes found that type of approach to be contrived. Instead, I have wondered if Isaiah has something of a 'telescoped' perspective of redemptive history. I have struggled to figure out how to put this into words. It seems that, particularly starting with the vision of Isaiah 6, he has a very long and far-seeing view into redemptive history and God's plan. In light of that, I have wondered if Isaiah got a glimpse of the relationship between the historical events of his present day and the unfolding of God's redemptive history - if he saw, more clearly than we do, the correspondence between types and anti-types. In light of that, I have wondered if he sometimes blurred the lines between the two, shifting back and forth between contemporary events and key points in redemptive history. So whereas it might seem to us somewhat strange to respond to Ahaz's lack of faith by prophesying an event 700 years away, from Isaiah's perspective this might have been that much of a leap. Likewise, in Isaiah 14, he could be seamlessly moving back and forth between talking about Babylon and referencing Satan's fall - or even talking about both at the same time. It's as if Isaiah is seeing contemporary history and redemptive history all at once, unfolded in some panorama before his eyes, enabling him to jump around and make connections in a way that wouldn't seem terribly intuitive or obvious to many of us.
I'm not trying to discover something new here (what is new is not true...), but am just wondering, from the more educated OT interpreters on here, if this line of thinking is way off-base, and if others have had similar ideas before. I don't intend to use y'all as a substitute for my own study, though at the same time I don't currently have bandwidth to add an Isaiah commentary to the two Romans commentaries and all the other books I'm currently reading.
I have not yet done a deep dive into Isaiah or read commentaries on it as I have with a few other Bible books. Based on my own personal familiarity with the book from repeated readings, and nothing more, I have sometimes found that type of approach to be contrived. Instead, I have wondered if Isaiah has something of a 'telescoped' perspective of redemptive history. I have struggled to figure out how to put this into words. It seems that, particularly starting with the vision of Isaiah 6, he has a very long and far-seeing view into redemptive history and God's plan. In light of that, I have wondered if Isaiah got a glimpse of the relationship between the historical events of his present day and the unfolding of God's redemptive history - if he saw, more clearly than we do, the correspondence between types and anti-types. In light of that, I have wondered if he sometimes blurred the lines between the two, shifting back and forth between contemporary events and key points in redemptive history. So whereas it might seem to us somewhat strange to respond to Ahaz's lack of faith by prophesying an event 700 years away, from Isaiah's perspective this might have been that much of a leap. Likewise, in Isaiah 14, he could be seamlessly moving back and forth between talking about Babylon and referencing Satan's fall - or even talking about both at the same time. It's as if Isaiah is seeing contemporary history and redemptive history all at once, unfolded in some panorama before his eyes, enabling him to jump around and make connections in a way that wouldn't seem terribly intuitive or obvious to many of us.
I'm not trying to discover something new here (what is new is not true...), but am just wondering, from the more educated OT interpreters on here, if this line of thinking is way off-base, and if others have had similar ideas before. I don't intend to use y'all as a substitute for my own study, though at the same time I don't currently have bandwidth to add an Isaiah commentary to the two Romans commentaries and all the other books I'm currently reading.