On intercession

Status
Not open for further replies.

TryingToLearn

Puritan Board Freshman
The Reformed obviously want to deny that saints are intercessors in the same way Rome does, but I’m having trouble putting my finger on exactly what the difference is. Rome grants that Christ is a mediator/intercessor in a different sense than Christians are and so affirm He is the one mediator in that way. Yet we also grant that while Christ is our one mediator and High Priest, Christians are all priests and all can pray for one another, which is a sort of intercession. So, disregarding merit, how exactly are our claims formally different as it relates to holding Christ to be the one intercessor while at the same time holding all Christians to be intercessors in another way?
 
Praying to dead people and asking them to intercede for me is a fair bit different from asking my live friend to pray for me, isn’t it?
 
I forgot to add, I read Hodge say the difference is that Christ executes his mediation as an office. But 1) do Romanists hold the saints intercede officially? 2) Since we have been made priests and kings, is that not an office?
 
Yes but this isn’t the question.
Your original post mentioned you were having trouble placing your finger on what exactly the difference is.

In my estimation there’s enough differences for at least a whole hand, so I named a few.
 
Your original post mentioned you were having trouble placing your finger on what exactly the difference is.

In my estimation there’s enough differences for at least a whole hand, so I named a few.
The difference specifically between how we apply the name “mediator/intercessor” to both saints and Christ vs how Rome does.

Put simply, how are we justified in using 1 Tim 2:5 against Rome while recognizing that both we and them allow saints to be called mediators in a certain sense?
 
The difference specifically between how we apply the name “mediator/intercessor” to both saints and Christ vs how Rome does.

Put simply, how are we justified in using 1 Tim 2:5 against Rome while recognizing that both we and them allow saints to be called mediators in a certain sense?
I think it’s more helpful to delineate mediator and intercessor as offices from interceding as a function. Also, as my earlier comment suggests, I think the person or people we are attributing that function or office to is also supremely relevant.

The idea of bearing one another’s burdens, as an example, is a command to the saints who are alive and in fellowship with one another. Surely praying for one another would be an extension of that.

Dead saints aren’t commanded to pray for anyone. Living saints are.

Living saints are no where commanded to pray to dead saints.

In short, I’m not seeing the difficulty you’re seeing.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I think it’s more helpful to delineate mediator and intercessor as offices from interceding as a function. Also, as my earlier comment suggests, I think the person or people we are attributing that function or office to is also supremely relevant.

The idea of bearing one another’s burdens, as an example, is a command to the saints who are alive and in fellowship with one another. Surely praying for one another would be an extension of that.

In short, I’m not seeing the difficulty you’re seeing.
For sure, but then the question should be asked, insofar as all Christians have been made priests, does this not count as an office?
 
For sure, but then the question should be asked, insofar as all Christians have been made priests, does this not count as an office?
I made some last minute edits to my post that may be helpful.

Can you define office in this context? Because as I understand it, an Office in the church has qualifications. If it were an office (little ‘o’), there ought to be qualifications as well, presumably. Offices also confer authority. What authority would such an office (little ‘o’) confer?

Such an office would also be held only while living. We are no where commended to pray to dead men, or have dead men pray for us. Lots of differences between Rome and Reformed.
 
I made some last minute edits to my post that may be helpful.

Can you define office in this context? Because as I understand it, an Office in the church has qualifications. If it were an office (little ‘o’), there ought to be qualifications as well, presumably. Offices also confer authority. What authority would such an office (little ‘o’) confer?

Such an office would also be held only while living. We are no where commended to pray to dead men, or have dead men pray for us. Lots of differences between Rome and Reformed.
I’m honestly not sure how to define these which is why I ask. If the difference is that Christ executes intercession officially per Hodge then I’m trying to figure out what that means for believers insofar as they have been “made priests” in the NC which would seem to imply an office but I’m unsure.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top