Opinions on a book

Status
Not open for further replies.

berechiah2025

Puritan Board Freshman
I'm currently going through a bit of a tough time and came across the book Spurgeon’s Sorrows: Realistic Hope for those who Suffer from Depression by Zack Eswine. I’m wondering if anyone here has read it and found it helpful? I’d really appreciate any thoughts or guidance. I'm looking for honest opinions or suggestions—just trying to find something that might help.

Thank you
 
I'm currently going through a bit of a tough time and came across the book Spurgeon’s Sorrows:

Many years ago, I read about Spurgeon's troubles with "causeless" depression. I don't think I read this book, though.
~~~~~~~

AI Overview

Charles H. Spurgeon, the renowned 19th-century preacher, was known for his powerful sermons and prolific writings. However, he also openly struggled with depression throughout his life. He spoke and wrote frankly about his experiences with "causeless depression," or as he described it, a deep despondency that could come over him even without an apparent reason. His struggles with depression were sometimes so severe that he contemplated suicide.

Factors Contributing to Spurgeon's Depression:
  • Trauma: A significant event that deeply affected him was the Surrey Gardens Music Hall disaster in 1856, where a false fire alarm during one of his sermons caused a stampede, resulting in deaths and injuries.
  • Physical Illnesses: Spurgeon suffered from various painful conditions, including gout, rheumatism, and Bright's disease, which often left him bedridden.
  • Overwork and Stress: His demanding ministry, which included leading a large church, writing, and addressing pastoral concerns, contributed to physical and mental fatigue.
  • Loneliness: He experienced a certain loneliness as a leader and bearer of others' burdens.
  • Controversy and Criticism: The "Downgrade Controversy," in which he opposed the liberalization of Baptist theology, sparked significant opposition and pain.
  • Possible Predisposition: Spurgeon himself alluded to a possible natural inclination towards melancholy, stating, "Some are touched with melancholy from their birth".
Spurgeon's Perspective and Coping Mechanisms:
  • Sovereignty of God: A central element of Spurgeon's ability to endure was his firm belief in God's sovereignty, seeing his suffering as ordained by God for his good and the glory of Christ.
  • Purpose in Suffering: He believed that his depression and other struggles made him a better-prepared and more compassionate pastor, enabling him to sympathize with others going through similar trials.
  • Communion with Christ: Spurgeon emphasized the importance of intimate fellowship with Christ through prayer and meditation.
  • Rest and Nature: He also recognized the value of rest and finding solace in nature as aids for his mental and physical well-being.
Legacy:
Spurgeon's open and honest accounts of his depression offer comfort and encouragement to others who struggle with mental health issues, demonstrating that one can be a faithful Christian and still experience such difficulties. He advocated for compassion towards those who are depressed and warned against hasty judgments. His willingness to share his vulnerabilities, coupled with his unwavering faith in Christ, makes his ministry and life story a valuable resource for anyone wrestling with similar challenges.
 
Personally, I wouldn't want to read an author's summary of Spurgeon's struggles in what looks like biographical formatting no matter how often he cites Spurgeon's letters, sermons, etc.

His sermons on sorrows, fainting, etc are all online for free.

And no one can express his thoughts better than the man himself:

"A Frail Leaf (Job 13:25)" https://www.spurgeongems.org/sermon/chs3269.pdf

"Sweet Stimulants for the Fainting Soul (Ps. 42:6)" https://www.spurgeon.org/resource-library/sermons/sweet-stimulants-for-the-fainting-soul/#flipbook/

"Faintness and Refreshing (1 Kings 19:8)" https://www.spurgeon.org/resource-library/sermons/faintness-and-refreshing/#flipbook/

"Man of Sorrows (Is. 53:3)" https://www.spurgeon.org/resource-library/sermons/the-man-of-sorrows/#flipbook/

"Healing for the Wounded (Ps. 147:3)" https://www.spurgeon.org/resource-library/sermons/the-man-of-sorrows/#flipbook/
 
I thought it was helpful and encouraging. It's less about Spurgeon himself and more about biblical lessons he teaches on suffering & "melancholy."
 
I want to be very clear. I was making no comment one way or the other on the author himself who is simply unknown to me.

My comment was based on what I would do (have done in the past when I felt I was drowning spiritually into despair):

1) Not spend money lest the act of spending be a kind of mirage of healing where no healing occurs.

2) Go to Spurgeon's sermons directly and connecting my own circumstances with the Biblical text and his pastoral guidance that I know comes from similar straits.

3) Only after dealing with the text and sermon in my own context and reaching a culmination of sorts, only then would I buy or not buy an author's biographical assessment of the sorrows of Spurgeon and another perspective on how he approached and dealt with it or tried to deal with it.
 
Brother, thank you for reaching out. We all go through seasons of life in which we cry out with the Psalmist: "You have put me in the depths of the pit,
in the regions dark and deep." (Psalm 88:6)

And yet our God and Savior Jesus Christ is also the one " who redeems your life from the pit,
who crowns you with steadfast love and mercy," Psalm 103:4

Reach out to your local body, to your pastor, to a brother in Christ. Do not struggle alone. If nothing else, direct message your brothers here on the board.

Grace to you and peace from God our Father and the Lord Jesus Christ (Ephesians 1:2)
 
Thank you very much everybody for your replies. I appreciate the care and thought went into your comments. By God's grace I am fine. I decided to read that book and while I do agree with you, reading a book about someone's thoughts doesn't really make sense when I can read the person's thoughts themselves, but when I say thoughts I mean messages and talks and sermons. So yes, totally, but believe it or not there is actually a great part in the book where this book references to many different things Spurgeon says things I may never pick up an read. Or even have found. So I feel that this book is good, but also with your comments earlier, I went to read what Spurgeon actually wrote, and there is a sermon from the Metropolitan Tabernacle, Volume 47. The sermon is called "Elijah's Fainting". It was actually a very powerful message and I thoroughly enjoyed reading it. It ministered greatly to my soul. So I took everything on board that you guys have said and I will speak to my pastor. I have mildly or slightly spoken to a friend. But I do want to try many things for it, like exercise, diet, sleeping, all these kinds of things which this book suggests. But most of all prayer and godly counsel, and also from God's Word itself. Thanks everybody for your real concern. God bless you all.
[automerge]1749496823[/automerge]
Metropolitan tabernacle vol 47.
Elijah's fainting

Last section of the sermon I felt I'd like to share

....
And, lastly, there is one more practical lesson for us to learn that is, you and I have not the slightest idea of what is in store for us on earth. “Eye hath not seen, nor ear heard, neither have entered into the heart of man, the things which God hath prepared for them that love him” up yonder; and you do not know what he has prepared for you even here. Elijah says, “Let me die.” But, Elijah, would you not like to live to veil your face in the presence of God on Horeb? “Oh, yes!” he would say, “let me live till then.” And, Elijah, would you not like to live to rebuke Ahab for his sin against Naboth? “Oh, yes! I should like to live till then” Would you not like to live till you have cast your mantle over that blessed servant of God, Elisha, who is to succeed you? “Oh, yes!” he would say, “let me live till then.” And would you not like to live, Elijah, till you have seen the schools of the prophets, raised by your influence, which shall live, after both you and Elisha are gone, to keep alive the work of God? I think I hear the old man say, “Oh, yes! let me live till then. Happy shall I be if I can see schools instituted for the training of ministers who shall go and preach in God’s name. Yes, let me live till then.” And you do not know, brother, how much there is for you yet to live for; and you, my sister, do not talk about dying, for you also have a great deal more to do before you get to heaven, service for your Savior that will make heaven all the better when you get there.
God has such blessings in store for some of you that, when they come to you, you will be like men that dream; and your mouth shall be filled with laughter, and your tongue with singing, and you will say, “The Lord hath done great things for us; whereof we are glad.” Wherefore, be of good courage, and strengthen your hearts, and wait still upon the Lord until he cometh; and may his blessing be with you forever! Amen.
 
Personally, I wouldn't want to read an author's summary of Spurgeon's struggles in what looks like biographical formatting no matter how often he cites Spurgeon's letters, sermons, etc.

His sermons on sorrows, fainting, etc are all online for free.

And no one can express his thoughts better than the man himself:

"A Frail Leaf (Job 13:25)" https://www.spurgeongems.org/sermon/chs3269.pdf

"Sweet Stimulants for the Fainting Soul (Ps. 42:6)" https://www.spurgeon.org/resource-library/sermons/sweet-stimulants-for-the-fainting-soul/#flipbook/

"Faintness and Refreshing (1 Kings 19:8)" https://www.spurgeon.org/resource-library/sermons/faintness-and-refreshing/#flipbook/

"Man of Sorrows (Is. 53:3)" https://www.spurgeon.org/resource-library/sermons/the-man-of-sorrows/#flipbook/

"Healing for the Wounded (Ps. 147:3)" https://www.spurgeon.org/resource-library/sermons/the-man-of-sorrows/#flipbook/
Can I ask. How did you find these topics? I really have no clue how it is done. So you know of some easy site or way ?
 
Can I ask. How did you find these topics? I really have no clue how it is done. So you know of some easy site or way ?

Simple google search for "Spurgeon on fainting, sorrows, melancholy," - it helps to know the archaic use of the terms for depression and anxiety.

Now you can do this for many other Puritan preachers as well - whose sermons should also be free online.

I heartily recommend Richard Baxter's sermon on "overmuch sorrow and melancholy". I don't remember the full title - only that those exact words are included.

God bless you brother.
 
Last edited:
Also, all of Spurgeon's Sermons can be listened to here for free as well:
View attachment 12038
This was my go to till i got use to YouTube. But sermon audio is such a great site. When I was very young it was the only site available I think.

Thanks again for sharing
[automerge]1749584225[/automerge]
Simple google search for "Spurgeon on fainting, sorrows, melancholy," - it helps to know the archaic use of the terms for depression and anxiety.

Now you can do this for many other Puritan preachers as well - whose sermons should also be free online.

I heartily recommend Richard Baxter's sermon on "overmuch sorrow and melancholy". I don't remember the full title - only that those exact words are included.

God bless you brother.
I will. It will be my next sermon to listen to. I appreciate the recommendation.

An the tips in searching.
 
Simple google search for "Spurgeon on fainting, sorrows, melancholy," - it helps to know the archaic use of the terms for depression and anxiety.

Now you can do this for many other Puritan preachers as well - whose sermons should also be free online.

I heartily recommend Richard Baxter's sermon on "overmuch sorrow and melancholy". I don't remember the full title - only that those exact words are included.

God bless you brother.
Could this the the title of that book you mentioned

"The Cure of Melancholy and Overmuch Sorrow"
I tried to search for it. This is the only one I can seem to find
 
Charles Spurgeon Pancakes Print – RefToons
 
There are some excellent works by Puritans for those who are going through tough times.

The Bruised Reed by Richard Sibbes a Puritan Paperback
A Lifting Up for the Downcast by William Bridge
Spiritual Comfort by John Colquhoun
The Crook in the Lot by Thomas Boston
The Bow in the Clouds: Springs of Comfort in Times of Deep Affliction by Various writers including John Newton and Octavius Winslow
All Things for Good by Thomas Watson
Christians get Depressed Too by David Murray
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top