Ortlund

Status
Not open for further replies.

Herman

Puritan Board Freshman
In Holland three books of Dane Ortlund are recently published (in translation). Can you recommend books from this author?

On the backflip there are references to Edwards, Goodwin, Bunyan, so it must be good stuff, but maybe these references are not suitable to the whole.
 
You may be interested to know that there are numerous Ortlunds - father and sons - who are authors. Dane is one one of the brothers who wrote 'Gentle and Lowly' which has proved very popular, an attempt to bring certain doctrines about the Person of Christ, especially using Thomas Goodwin's 'Heart of Christ' (shortened title of course), to the modern audience. However this book has not been without criticism from several reformed reviewers.

Therefore to your question I would not unreservedly recommend his books, but they are evangelical and probably quite edifying.
 
Last edited:
Links to reviews?

Mere observation: it seemed to me that Gentle and Lowly became a big hit solely due to a successful marketing campaign by the publisher (pre-publication even). I.e., it was raved about before it was actually assessed by the public. Kind of like a Stanley tumbler, I wonder if it’s popularity is nothing more than hype.
 
In Holland three books of Dane Ortlund are recently published (in translation). Can you recommend books from this author?

Greetings Herman,

Dane's the real deal -- get all three.

So far, I only have four audiobooks by Ortland, I.e., Gentle and Lowly, Deeper, In the Lord, I Take Refuge, and Surprised by Jesus.

Here's another author with a similar burden to Ortland that I highly recommend. Dr. Michael Reeves.
Here's a link to a Spotify podcast by Dr. Reeves called Delighting in the Trinity. I devoured every message in order, plus re-listening to many of his messages a second or third time.

May our common Lord and King bless your days, showing you His beautiful face,

Ed Walsh
 
Gentle and Lowly is very well written (at least, in English it is), deserving the attention it has received. It will be helpful to believers who live with a sense that they must perform for God, who is usually grumpy with them over their failures. A lot of believers struggle with this even if they know better.

Perhaps you can read the four-page introduction online. It's one of the best introductions I've ever read, clearly and compellingly telling the reader why he should read the rest of the book. If you resonate with what the introduction says, get the whole book.

I haven't read Dane Ortlund's later books, but I would expect they are also quite good.
 
Links to reviews?

Mere observation: it seemed to me that Gentle and Lowly became a big hit solely due to a successful marketing campaign by the publisher (pre-publication even). I.e., it was raved about before it was actually assessed by the public. Kind of like a Stanley tumbler, I wonder if it’s popularity is nothing more than hype.
Please don't pass judgment if you haven't actually read the book. That rings of slander, friend.

Gentle and Lowly is the best book I've read in years.
 
Please don't pass judgment if you haven't actually read the book. That rings of slander, friend.

Gentle and Lowly is the best book I've read in years.

Reading the book does not take away the act of slander. Either the matter is true or it isn't. The book might be excellent, but the underlying issue might still be true.
 
You might be guilty of great sin. With no evidence I'm not going to accuse you of that (why would I?).

Just tired of self righteous attitudes around here
 
Last edited:
You might be guilty of great sin. With no evidence I'm not going to accuse you of that (why would I?).

Just tired of self righteous attitudes around here

Perhaps (though I actually never made that claim), but there is no logical connection between a) the book's being good, b) actually reading the book, and c) whether Ortlund engaged in a marketing campaign.
 
You might be guilty of great sin. With no evidence I'm not going to accuse you of that (why would I?).

Just tired of self righteous attitudes around here

Just my take but you seem a little harsh on Reed.

I was given the book and I started the book but never finished it. The one who gave it to me struggles to this day with quietism. And I am not talking about laziness but a direct denial of the existence of "will" (also a big Piper fan). I don't judge Mr. Ortlund's work and don't hold it against him that the guy's attitude soured me on Mr. Ortlund's book.

It is probably not Mr. Ortlund's fault his book seems to be used by many to go too far in one direction only.

But I also have no desire to pick it back up again simply because there seems to be nothing in it that makes some quietists pause and reflect deeper on the issue of will and sovereignty. So count me with Reed among those who haven't read it but I also wonder if its popularity may be attributed to causes deeper than the book's own inherent merits.
 
I highly recommend picking up Gentle and Lowly, Herman. I don't know about the other books. But that one helped me a great deal, and I recommended it widely to friends after it first came out. It's certainly not the only thing one should read about the Christian life, but it's a solid one.
 
I was given a copy of Gentle and Lowly and was initially skeptical because it was so hyped. I quickly got over that skepticism once I started reading. It was very good, not least because it draws heavily on riches from the Puritans.
 
Know God's word, then read with discernment. No one author is 100 percent correct but may offer insights that are helpful. I read Gentle and Lowly after seeing others recommend it here on PB and found it helpful.
 
You might be guilty of great sin. With no evidence I'm not going to accuse you of that (why would I?)

Just my take but you seem a little harsh on Reed.

I was given the book and I started the book but never finished it. The one who gave it to me struggles to this day with quietism. And I am not talking about laziness but a direct denial of the existence of "will" (also a big Piper fan). I don't judge Mr. Ortlund's work and don't hold it against him that the guy's attitude soured me on Mr. Ortlund's book.

It is probably not Mr. Ortlund's fault his book seems to be used by many to go too far in one direction only.

But I also have no desire to pick it back up again simply because there seems to be nothing in it that makes some quietists pause and reflect deeper on the issue of will and sovereignty. So count me with Reed among those who haven't read it but I also wonder if its popularity may be attributed to causes deeper than the book's own inherent merits.
That's fine. Count me as one who thinks it's one of the best books I've ever read.
 
Last edited:
That's fine. Count me as one who thinks it's one of the best books I've ever read.

Only on Puritanboard can someone write a book that expounds the riches of the Puritans in rich devotional format and be slandered, misrepresented and unfairly criticized by people who didn't even read it. Good night.

Strictly speaking, no one criticised the book itself, only the circumstances surrounding its release.
 
That I thought it was a great book has little bearing on its true quality, but I will testify that it prompted me to go read Thomas Goodwin's Heart of Christ. Goodwin's book is fantastic. So I'm glad, for no other reason, that Dane wrote it.
 
The one who gave it to me struggles to this day with quietism. And I am not talking about laziness but a direct denial of the existence of "will" (also a big Piper fan).
While I have a little bit of familiarity with the term "quietism", could you help me understand your post by elaborating on what you mean when you use that word, and also what is meant but denial of the existence of "will"?
 
While I have a little bit of familiarity with the term "quietism", could you help me understand your post by elaborating on what you mean when you use that word, and also what is meant but denial of the existence of "will"?

Standard definitions for each. Quietism reflects a devotional contemplation that over-emphasizes personal piety at the expense of personal activity.

Denying the existence of will is exactly what it seems to mean. I think it comes from an overly heavy leaning towards sovereignty to the point of a wholly monergistic view of sanctification. Not being confessional, he doesn't really understand secondary causes and incorrectly views the primary cause - being ultimate - means no other causes really matter. Kind of a Bible-based fatalism.
 
You might be guilty of great sin. With no evidence I'm not going to accuse you of that (why would I?).

Just tired of self righteous attitudes around here
Really? Self-righteous? Slander?
All I did was opine on marketing hype.
Didn’t say anything about the book yea or nay.

(really makes me want to read the book.)
 
Last edited:
In Holland three books of Dane Ortlund are recently published (in translation). Can you recommend books from this author?

On the backflip there are references to Edwards, Goodwin, Bunyan, so it must be good stuff, but maybe these references are not suitable to the whole.
I've read "Zachtmoedig en nederig van hart" (Gentle and lowly). I liked it, there are a lot of beautiful quotes of Puritans in it. It focusses primarily on the love of Christ for sinners, which is good, but I think there could be more balance in this book (it's a little bit one-sided). That is also the reason John MacArthur was critical of it: https://www.gty.org/library/blog/B210315

The book "Dieper" (Deeper) was given last month by friends to my wife, but we did not read it yet.
 
Last edited:
I've read "Zachtmoedig en nederig van hart" (Gentle and lowly). I liked it, there are a lot of beautiful quotes of Puritans in it. It focusses primarily on the love of Christ for sinners, which is good, but I think there could be more balance in this book (it's a little bit one-sided). That is also the reason John MacArthur was critical of it: https://www.gty.org/library/blog/B210315

The book "Dieper" (Deeper) was given last month by friends to my wife, but we did not read it yet.
Was the “Bruised Reed” “off balance?”Most books do not need to be everything to everyone in every moment. I am sure a libertine antinomian would be better served by something else.
 
That review is on GTY.org but it's by Jeremiah Johnson rather than MacArthur.

I find it interesting that his first critique is that it is unbalanced---specifically he thinks Ortlund should have spent more time talking about Jesus' wrath against he Pharisees and notes that Warfield spent a lot of time talking about that in his "Emotional Life of Our Lord."

I'm not sure this is really a fair criticism though. Ortlund states up front that this is just one aspect of Christ's character, and one that many of us think little about. So the purpose of the book is to correct that deficiency but he certainly doesn't deny the need for balance or claim that the book is the final word in everything relating to Christ's person. Comparing to Warfield is equally unfair because Warfield's stated subject was "The Emotional Life" of our Lord. One might as well criticize Warfield for not being so balanced regarding the physical bodily life of our Lord and focusing just on the emotional side! A book that spends too much time trying to be balanced in every single aspect will often end up diluting its message to the point of being useless.

I'm not saying the book is perfect by any means but it seems odd to me that the first criticism of a book dealing with the "gentle and lowly" aspect of Christ's relationship to his church, would be that the author "fails to acknowledge how much space the gospels devote to Jesus' endless public battles with the Pharisees, His occasionally stern rebukes of the disciples, and His dire prophetic warnings."

Perhaps we could say that the review itself is unbalanced because it didn't also talk in equal measure about all the other books that have been written on this topic. It just strikes me as an odd stance to take up as the leading critique.
 
Really? Self-righteous? Slander?
All I did was opine on marketing hype.
Didn’t say anything about the book yea or nay.

(really makes me want to read the book.)
Maybe some of my words were off, and if that's the case, I'm sorry and ask for your forgiveness. There were a good bit of heavy implications though from what you said. You did write that it seemed to you that the book took off largely because of its marketing campaign rather than the fact that its content was actually good. And you didn't actually read the book. Just as an example, if there was a large church and the pastor of that church belonged to this board. If there was a post about the church and I chimed in and said something to the effect of: I've never been there or heard him preach, but from what I've heard from other people, it really seems to me that the reason people are going there is to get an emotional experience, I don't think the preaching itself is actually solid, that's my impression. What would you think? Specifically, what would you think if you were actually that pastor? That's all I'm trying to get at.
 
Maybe some of my words were off, and if that's the case, I'm sorry and ask for your forgiveness. There were a good bit of heavy implications though from what you said. You did write that it seemed to you that the book took off largely because of its marketing campaign rather than the fact that its content was actually good. And you didn't actually read the book. Just as an example, if there was a large church and the pastor of that church belonged to this board. If there was a post about the church and I chimed in and said something to the effect of: I've never been there or heard him preach, but from what I've heard from other people, it really seems to me that the reason people are going there is to get an emotional experience, I don't think the preaching itself is actually solid, that's my impression. What would you think? Specifically, what would you think if you were actually that pastor? That's all I'm trying to get at.
But in your illustration, I didn’t say anything about the man’s preaching. I didn’t say anything about the content of the book. I didn’t even say that the marketing hype (e.g., the recommendations) was wrong in some manner. I simply panned the process used by the publisher.

You’ve inferred something I didn’t say, and then on that basis, inferred that I’ve sinned.

Maybe the problem is in you brother. You might have asked me a question or two before posting the assumption about my (possible) slander.

Whether your “if” is needed is for you to decide. Be assured I will forgive/forget regardless.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top