I've always been a little ambivalent about these "growth reports". It's interesting to me how the problem with growth is that everyone is doing something wrong at a local Church except the pastors of local Churches who are articulating that the PCA is doing something wrong or we would see more growth.
Given the hemorrhaging in most Christian denominations, one might look at the fact that the PCA's numbers are flat as remarkable. I'm not saying we're perfect or that we cannot be more faithful. I'm simply noting that where some denoinations (even conservative) are losing numbers, even small growth can be looked at as pretty remarkable since we're replacing more than we lose in some cases.
I don't disagree with what you said.
But we always need to keep in mind that 1) data capture is grossly incomplete. 2) the data that is capture is of questionable accuracy - rolls probably need to be purged every 5 years, and not all churches are doing that. 3) What we are doing now at the denominational level may not be working as well as what we were doing then.