Separate and distinct elements or some overlap?

Are the elements separate and distinct or are they meshed?


  • Total voters
    23
Status
Not open for further replies.

panta dokimazete

Puritan Board Post-Graduate
Reading John Frame's "A Fresh Look at the Regulative Principle" and came across this paragraph:

According to the Scottish and Puritan view, then, “elements of worship” are the distinct actions performed in worship, all the actions deemed to have “religious significance.” Each is independent of the others in the sense that each requires its own distinct scriptural warrant.

Do you agree or disagree?

Why?

Here is a little visual to help you ponder:

Slide1.JPG


or

Slide2.JPG


and the size is not to influence - it just came out that way! :D

...even though I voted meshed just to get the thread started!
 
Last edited:
oops! missed proclamation! back in a few...

Thar' ya go - I probably should have kept the colors on the mesh view, too - eh - I may fix it later - I think the idea is clear.
 
Moderator Caution. JD, if this is curiosity, fine--but you yourself were concerned about the last outing of this subject toward its end. So, a caution to all at the outset: this will be a pleasant expression of views and a poll. If you commence discussions, keep in mind board rules on the FAQ.
 
forwarned is forearmed :up: :sing: - would like to keep this non-argumentative - just for curiosity's sake...irenic is the word of the day!

anybody got a "P" term for the sacraments?
 
How is reading of Scripture "proclamation?" Does this "proclamation" still tie us to the reading of the canonical Scriptures alone? and if so, how does this mesh with any other part of worship? By "element of worship" are we to understand an external action or an inward disposition? If the elements are meshed is that a simpliciter affirmation that those who do the one are competent to do the others; e.g., if all may praise, does that entail all may preach? Given that praise may be spoken and does not entail a melodic intoning of the voice, may singing be dispensed with altogether? Why are sacraments given such a large range of independence from the other elements?
 
Good questions - I think I'll see if there will be additional participation and if the participants have some input.
 
It should be called the Framean principle of Worship, not the Regulative Principle. :2cents:

Oh, and yes I agree with the Scottish view not Frames. If we blur the definitions like Frame does, then we end up not knowing what we are talking about. It also allows for unbiblical redefinitions of the elements in order to allow for things which would otherwise be forbidden (i.e. dancing) under the Reformed Regulative Principle.
 
Other
Each element should have Scriptural warrant, or at least not be forbidden - but there is a synergism when all the elements are present. Just my opinion.
 
For consideration:

Acts 15

21"For Moses from ancient generations has in every city those who preach him, since he is read in the synagogues every Sabbath."
 
For consideration:

Psalm 120:1
[ Prayer for Deliverance from the Treacherous. ] [ A Song of Ascents. ] In my trouble I cried to the LORD,And He answered me.

Psalm 122:1
[ Prayer for the Peace of Jerusalem. ] [ A Song of Ascents, of David. ] I was glad when they said to me,"Let us go to the house of the LORD."

Psalm 123:1
[ Prayer for the LORD'S Help. ] [ A Song of Ascents. ] To You I lift up my eyes,O You who are enthroned in the heavens!

Psalm 129:1
[ Prayer for the Overthrow of Zion's Enemies. ] [ A Song of Ascents. ] "Many times they have persecuted me from my youth up," Let Israel now say,

Psalm 132:1
[ Prayer for the LORD'S Blessing upon the Sanctuary. ] [ A Song of Ascents. ] Remember, O LORD, on David's behalf,All his affliction;
 
A question before I offer an opinion.

How does God view our worship? Do the scriptures speak of this? When we gather together on the Lord's Day, does God accept our worship in individual elements or as a sum total of all parts?
 
For consideration:

Psalm 120:1
[ Prayer for Deliverance from the Treacherous. ] [ A Song of Ascents. ] In my trouble I cried to the LORD,And He answered me.

Psalm 122:1
[ Prayer for the Peace of Jerusalem. ] [ A Song of Ascents, of David. ] I was glad when they said to me,"Let us go to the house of the LORD."

Psalm 123:1
[ Prayer for the LORD'S Help. ] [ A Song of Ascents. ] To You I lift up my eyes,O You who are enthroned in the heavens!

Psalm 129:1
[ Prayer for the Overthrow of Zion's Enemies. ] [ A Song of Ascents. ] "Many times they have persecuted me from my youth up," Let Israel now say,

Psalm 132:1
[ Prayer for the LORD'S Blessing upon the Sanctuary. ] [ A Song of Ascents. ] Remember, O LORD, on David's behalf,All his affliction;

Are you trying to juxtapose prayer and song? Which translation is that? I checked Biblegateway and it appears to be NASB. However, not every translation has the headings. All the others I checked (NIV, ESV, NKJV) had only "A Song of Ascents." Were the prayer headings added later? If so, I assume that it would have an affect on your usage of those texts.
 
They were editorial comments - not sure if they were in the originals, but I don't think anyone would disagree that the songs of the Psalms were also prayers?

Did Jesus sing the words to Psalms 22 or 31 on the cross?

Not juxtapose - correlate.
 
Other
Each element should have Scriptural warrant, or at least not be forbidden - but there is a synergism when all the elements are present. Just my opinion.

I do not contest the warrant requirement - I contest the absolute clear distinction segregating the elements, so that a rigid ruleset can be applied - I certainly think they can be regulated to some degree that is Scriptural, just not formally regimented - there is no clear evidence that Scripture teaches this.
 
In this instance:

Acts 15

21"For Moses from ancient generations has in every city those who preach him, since he is read in the synagogues every Sabbath."

A correlation between preaching and reading of the Scriptures.

Perhaps you should consult the Greek. If that is not a possibility you may want to consult Calvin.
 
It should be called the Framean principle of Worship, not the Regulative Principle. :2cents:

? - I will confess that I am recently familiar with Frame - has he already been considered and dismissed by the PB?

Oh, and yes I agree with the Scottish view not Frames. If we blur the definitions like Frame does, then we end up not knowing what we are talking about.

you say "blur the definitions" - I say "recognize the correlation" for a fuller understanding - not quench the Spirit.

It also allows for unbiblical redefinitions of the elements in order to allow for things which would otherwise be forbidden (i.e. dancing) under the Reformed Regulative Principle.

Unbiblical redefinitions of the elements? Why is that a necessary consequence ?

If the RPW establishes the elements, which it does, then how does examining the relationships and correlations between the elements cause something like dance to enter into the equation?
 
Perhaps you should consult the Greek. If that is not a possibility you may want to consult Calvin.

I understand, and thank you for the referral - my point being that there is correlation in the proclamation of the Scripture and preaching in public worship. That there is distinctiveness, yes, but not absolute segregation.

For instance -

1. A preacher could read the Scriptures in worship, and that alone, and the Gospel would be preached\the church edified.
2. A preacher could have the Scriptures read in worship, then preach a sermon and the Gospel would be preached\the church edified.

The correlation is Scripture - the difference is exposition.
 
1689 LBC on worship:

The reading of the Scriptures, preaching and hearing the Word of God, the teaching and admonishing of one another in psalms, hymns, and spiritual songs, singing with grace in our hearts to the Lord; as well as the administration of baptism and the Lord's Supper, are all parts of the worship of God. These are to be performed in obedience to Him, with understanding, faith, reverence and godly fear. Also to be used in a holy and reverent manner on special occasions are times of solemn humiliation, fastings, and thanksgivings.

The parts do work together since all are required in corporate worship, but they are separate and distinct.

:2cents:
 
Again - agree on the elements - I just don't see Scriptural support for the separate and distinct with no overlap.
 
Last edited:
If you don't mind, take a look at this matrix - I drew the characteristics as what I consider key considerations -

I will also add what I believe the traditional Scottish/Puritan profile is

please feel free to recommend additional ones or clarify
 
Last edited:
JD - what exactly do you mean by "overlap?"

That the elements have their own segregated distinctiveness, but some overlapping characteristics - take a look at the matrix I started.

In other words - it is permissible (not required) and allowable from the RPW perspective to preach, pray or sing a Psalm.

...or sing a prayer.

...or read the Scriptures as you distribute the sacraments.

...or have reading of Scripture be the sole content of preaching in a certain circumstance.
 
That the elements have their own segregated distinctiveness, but some overlapping characteristics - take a look at the matrix I started.

In other words - it is permissible (not required) and allowable from the RPW perspective to preach, pray or sing a Psalm.

...or sing a prayer.

...or read the Scriptures as you distribute the sacraments.

...or have reading of Scripture be the sole content of preaching in a certain circumstance.

JD - would you consider these things normative in worship?
 
JD - here is my concern. When we blur the lines of the distinctives of worship, I believe we walk a slippery slope. I suppose if a pastor/elders had strong resolve and "meshed" the elements of worship infrequently, but as a general rule maintained a worship model as detailed in the LBC & WCF, it would not be too much of a problem. But in our day and age we are witness to "give an inch and take a yard" in worship. Witness the seeker sensitive and emergent movements.

While I am not directing this next comment directly at you, I wonder if the question, "How far can I go in worship?" is the right question. Perhaps we should ask, "How can I remain biblical in worship?" Having read many of your posts over the last few months I am confident that is your desire. I wonder whether we open a pandoras box when we tinker with the elements of worship.
 
Bill - first - thank you for your gracious response.

On the tinkering - I have 2 motivating principles that drive my view of worship:

The RPW and the Shema - as exegeted by Christ

From what I've seen the RPW, as interpreted by the Scot\Puritan view is mostly about "Thou shalt not"

I believe the RPW should be subservient to the Shema -

Mark 12:29-31 (New American Standard Bible)

29Jesus answered, "The foremost is, 'HEAR, O ISRAEL! THE LORD OUR GOD IS ONE LORD;

30AND YOU SHALL LOVE THE LORD YOUR GOD WITH ALL YOUR HEART, AND WITH ALL YOUR SOUL, AND WITH ALL YOUR MIND, AND WITH ALL YOUR STRENGTH.'

31"The second is this, 'YOU SHALL LOVE YOUR NEIGHBOR AS YOURSELF.' There is no other commandment greater than these."
So - worship should foremost be about loving God with ALL your capabilities, then focused on an environment of loving your neighbor.

I don't believe it is tinkering, but a duty of Semper Reformanda in worship towards the Shema - not developing a rigid, immutable ruleset that may be comfortable but not Scriptural.
 
Last edited:
? - I will confess that I am recently familiar with Frame - has he already been considered and dismissed by the PB?



you say "blur the definitions" - I say "recognize the correlation" for a fuller understanding - not quench the Spirit.



Unbiblical redefinitions of the elements? Why is that a necessary consequence ?

If the RPW establishes the elements, which it does, then how does examining the relationships and correlations between the elements cause something like dance to enter into the equation?

Read Frame's book Worship in Spirit and Truth and you will see. He does not believe in the Regulative Principle of Worship. He beleives the same principles which govern all of life also govern worship. If you're not familiar with his book, I suggest you read it first before reading any of his articles which give a "fresh look" at the Regulative Principle. he does in fact say that dance can somehow be incorporated, along with several other culturally determined things, so long as its done for God's glory.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top