Sincere free offer

Status
Not open for further replies.

Username4000

Puritan Board Freshman
When talking about the sincere free offer, how would we define "sincere" from the scriptures?
  • How can an offer (repent and trust and Christ will be saved) be sincere to someone incapable of answering it? (Unlike an Arminian, we don't affirm that the Spirit gives them the power to believe. We also don't believe that God does wrong by not giving this offer to them at all.)
  • If God does something outwardly kind to a non-elect sinner, such as raining on their crops, their guaranteed response will be to sin more, incurring yet more wrath. If God knows their response to this patience, how is this a response of love rather than wrath?
Basically, my wife and I certainly see plenty of examples of the scriptures describing God's action as patient, kind, and loving even to the unbeliever. We believe in common grace because the scripture is clear. We believe that God's intention is truly to lead to repentance (Romans 2:4). We've read through a good chunk of Reformed Books Online, but this doesn't fit in The System, and so we're wondering how The System needs to change.
 
Perhaps this... https://philosophical-theology.com/2020/08/01/the-free-offer-of-the-gospel/


WSC Q&A 31:
Q. What is effectual calling?
A. Effectual calling is the work of God’s Spirit, whereby, convincing us of our sin and misery, enlightening our minds in the knowledge of Christ, and renewing our wills, he doth persuade and enable us to embrace Jesus Christ, freely offered to us in the gospel.

image-1.jpeg

Canons of Dort 2.5:
Moreover, it is the promise of the gospel that whoever believes in Christ crucified shall not perish but have eternal life. This promise, together with the command to repent and believe, ought to be announced and declared without differentiation or discrimination to all nations and people, to whom God in his good pleasure sends the gospel.

The free offer of the gospel (abbreviated “free offer”) has meant different things at different times. From a confessional standpoint, it can only mean that God sincerely offers salvation to all who repent and believe. The meaning is at best narrow. The confessions do not speak in terms of God’s desire for all men to be saved; they merely teach that God promises the gift of everlasting life to all who would turn from self to Christ. This promise of life through faith is sincere. It is a genuine offer. If you believe, you will be saved. This gospel is to go out to all men everywhere.

Arminians are often quick to point out that the free offer is inconsistent with Calvinism. They reason that if the offer of the gospel is sincere and to go out to all people without exception, then God must desire the salvation of all people without exception. Otherwise, they say, the offer isn’t sincere. How can God desire the salvation of all men without exception if God as the ultimate decider of man’s salvation chooses to pass over some? In other words, Arminians reason that unless God desires to save all men, which they observe does not comport with Calvinism, the free offer of life through faith is insincere when given to the reprobate. Their axiom is that a sincere gospel offer implies a sincere desire to see the offer accepted, a well-meant offer. More on that in a moment.

The OPC’s Majority Report

The Orthodox Presbyterian Church (OPC), representative of possibly most Calvinists today on the matter of the free offer, under the leadership of John Murray and Ned Stonehouse, adopted as a majority position the Arminian view that God desires the salvation of all men. While still holding fast to the Reformed view of predestination, the OPC affirmed the view that that the free offer cannot adequately be disassociated from a divine desire of salvation for all men without exception. In other words, such Calvinists assert that the genuineness of the gospel offer presupposes God’s desire that all embrace Christ.

Subsequently, the free offer has taken on the additional meaning of a well-meant offer, or desire, that the reprobate turn and be saved. Accordingly, a major difference between Arminians and such Calvinists as these is on the question of consistency. Arminians find the free offer inconsistent with unconditional election, whereas these sorts of Calvinists (who hold to an expanded view of “free offer”) do not.

Back to first principles. What makes an offer genuine or sincere?

Can we judge whether an offer is genuine or sincere simply based on whether it is true or not? If God intends to keep his promise, then isn’t the offer genuine? With respect to the gospel, if one meets the condition of faith, he will one day enter the joy of Lord. Isn’t that enough to make the offer of salvation sincere?

Let’s do some basic theology…

What does it mean that God desires the salvation of the reprobate? Are we to believe that God desires the reprobate to do something he cannot do, namely regenerate himself and grant himself union with Christ? Or, is that to check our Calvinism at the door? Isn’t it Jesus who saves? Isn’t salvation of God after all? At best, if we are to remain consistent with our Calvinism, then wouldn’t it follow that to argue for a well-meant offer of the gospel we’d have to posit that God desires that he himself would regenerate the reprobate unto union with Christ and salvation?

Simply stated, since Calvinism affirms total depravity and compatibilism, wouldn’t it stand to reason from a Calvinistic perspective that if God desires someone’s salvation, God must desire that he save that person? Accordingly, the question that should be considered in this regard is either (a) “Does God desire the reprobate to turn himself and live?” Or (b), “Does God desire that he himself turn the reprobate so that he can live?” Given that man is blind and deaf to spiritual things and cannot do anything to to turn himself Godward, how are we not strictly dealing with the theological plausibility of (b), that God desires to turn the reprobate contrary to what he has already decreed? If TULIP is true, then (a) is a non-starter.

Now then, is it reasonable to think that the Holy Spirit desires to turn the reprobate Godward when the Father, in eternity, did not choose the reprobate in Christ? Moreover, if Christ did not die for the reprobate and does not pray that the efficacy of the cross would be applied to the reprobate, then in what sense does God desire the reprobate’s salvation? Does God desire that for which Christ does not pray? Does the Trinity desire that persons of the Godhead work at cross purposes? Does God desire true contradictions after all? Or is this a matter of mystery? Does God have multiple wills, let alone multiple wills that are at cross-purposes? Or is this a matter of two truths that we should accept by faith? Apparent contradiction or true contradiction?

Not only can God not save the reprobate whom he did not elect in Christ; 2000 years ago didn’t God act in time sealing that inability by securing salvation only for the elect? If so, then does it not follow that for God to desire the salvation of the reprobate, we should be willing to say that God, today, desires that Jesus would have died for the reprobate 2000 years ago? Or is there a third way of living looking at this? Does God live with a sense of regret or un-fulfillment?

The OPC is quick to point out that they are not advocating a position entailing God both desiring and not desiring his decree. Fine, but then what does it mean for God to desire that men act contrary to his decree? Can God desire his decree while also desiring men to act in such a way that would thwart it? Moreover, aside from the question of whether God desires that man act contrary to God’s decree, what does it mean for God to desire that he himself act contrary to how he decreed he would act? Of course, I know no Calvinist who affirms the well-meant offer of the gospel who would also say that God desires that he elected more unto salvation, or anything like that. Yet if man cannot turn himself, as Calvinism clearly affirms, then isn’t the implication of a well-meant offer that God desires to save those he has determined not to save? So much for a well meant offer.

Competing desires and unfulfillment…

John Piper has posited that God desires the salvation of the reprobate but that he desires their damnation for his own glory even more. There’s something attractive about Piper’s theory. It makes no apology for God positively desiring his decree, which includes his decree of reprobation. The downside is that it implies competing desires within the Godhead, a priority or ordering of pleasures within the same decree. Although perhaps an improvement upon John MacArthur’s view that in some sense God is “unfulfilled“ in his desire for the reprobate’s salvation, it nonetheless leaves God wanting. It’s an affront on God’s impassibility.

Abstractions, perhaps a useful tool…

If I desire to go to the doctor but it requires I get soaking wet in the rain, which ordinary I would not desire, then in one sense I do not desire to go out in the rain but in another sense I do. I do not want to go out in the rain if we consider going out in the rain as an abstraction from the overall plan of going to see the doctor. Yet I do desire to go out in the rain given that is what is necessary to get to see the doctor. The notion of abstracting particulars from the whole can be useful in this context. Although God does not take pleasure in the death of the wicked, God most certainly takes pleasure in his eternal decree coming to pass. He desires all the components of his comprehensive plan because it serves his purposes. As a matter of an isolated instance, God takes no pleasure in punishment. As an abstraction without purpose salvation is pleasurable, judgment is not. Yet in the context of all things – Godhimself, his plan, his glory etc., God takes the highest pleasure in himself, which includes his just indignation against the impenitent who have been ordained to judgment (Jude verse 4) for his own glory. God answers to no one.

God does not consider isolated instances outside the whole. In isolation we can consider something evil, but God who transcends time and space ordains evil for good. Therefore, as an abstraction, God does not desire reprobation for the mere sake of reprobation. Rather, God desires reprobation for his own glory and the good of the elect in the context of his one plan and purpose for this world.

God’s love and ours…



God hates the reprobate (Psalm 5:5; 11:5) and, therefore, has an active love only for those who love him. We may safely say that a necessary condition1 for God’s love to be presently active in the life of a sinner is for the sinner to love God (Proverbs 8:17) and love the Savior (John 14:21,23; 15:10; 16:27). But for sinners to love God, they must first be loved of God (1 John 4:19), which is the cause of the love relationship. Therefore, for the sinner to love God in order for her to experience God’s love in her life, she must first be the object of God’s predestinating love (Ephesians 1:4). Does God desire to grant predestinating love to those he has ordained to wrath (Jude 4)? If not, then in what sense does God desire to save them?




1. Condition in this context is not causal. The converted sinner’s love for God does not cause or produce God’s love for the sinner. Neither is the relationship between the two a quid pro quo. It’s a relationship predicated on pure grace. To say that the believer’s love for God (x) is a necessary condition for God’s active love in the life of the converted sinner (y) is simply to say that it is impossible to have y without x. Which is to say, the absence of x guarantees the absence of y. It’s also to say that the presence of y guarantees x.



God’s active love in the life of the sinner, which is a transforming love, is also biconditional. Not just only if the sinner loves God does the sinner experience God’s Iove but also if the sinner loves God. (The latter being the prima facie rendering of the texts.) The sinner’s love for God are necessary and sufficient conditions for receiving God’s love (and likewise for God’s active love in the sinners’s life as it relates to the believer’s love for God). And again, conditions pertain not to cause but state of affairs.
 
When talking about the sincere free offer, how would we define "sincere" from the scriptures?
  • How can an offer (repent and trust and Christ will be saved) be sincere to someone incapable of answering it? (Unlike an Arminian, we don't affirm that the Spirit gives them the power to believe. We also don't believe that God does wrong by not giving this offer to them at all.)
  • If God does something outwardly kind to a non-elect sinner, such as raining on their crops, their guaranteed response will be to sin more, incurring yet more wrath. If God knows their response to this patience, how is this a response of love rather than wrath?
Basically, my wife and I certainly see plenty of examples of the scriptures describing God's action as patient, kind, and loving even to the unbeliever. We believe in common grace because the scripture is clear. We believe that God's intention is truly to lead to repentance (Romans 2:4). We've read through a good chunk of Reformed Books Online, but this doesn't fit in The System, and so we're wondering how The System needs to change.
Was the offer to you free or conditional? Do you know the hidden things of God? The offer to repent and believe is free, don’t worry about the response, thats God’s business.
 
Was the offer to you free or conditional? Do you know the hidden things of God? The offer to repent and believe is free, don’t worry about the response, thats God’s business.
Both free and conditional. Free because you didn't merit it. Conditional because you cannot accept it without faith and repentance. There's lots of confusion on this point and it's not a good sign.
 
Calvin on the gospel as a conditional promise:
"The gospel also does indeed promise righteousness under condition; but it has no respect to the merits of works. What then? It is only this, that they who are condemned and lost are to embrace the favor offered to them in Christ."
John Owen:
"I say, then, that even the conditional promises of God are absolutely made good. The truth of any promise consists in this, that that whereof it speaks answers the affirmation itself. For instance, ‘He that believeth shall be saved.’ This promise doth not primarily affirm that any one shall be saved, and notwithstanding it no one might so be; but only this it affirms, that there is an infallible connection between faith and salvation, and therein is the promise most true, whether any one believe or no."
Samuel Rutherford:
"When we beleeve a conditionall promise (if I beleeve, I am saved) faith relyes not fiducially upon the (if I beleeve) or upon the condition, Its a weak pillar to a sinner to stay his unquiet heart upon, to wit, his own beleeving, but faith rests upon the connexion (if thou beleeve thou shalt be saved) and it stayes upon the connexion, as made sure by the Lord, who of grace gives the condition of beleeving, and of grace the reward conditioned, so that faith binds all the weight upon God only, even in conditionall Gospel-promises."
 
"Ye have lived in pleasure on the earth, and been wanton; ye have nourished your hearts, as in a day of slaughter." James 5:5

Dr. John Gill comments, when beasts were slain for some extraordinary entertainment, or for the solemn festivals and sacrifices the Jews, when they lived more deliciously than at other times; and then the sense is, that these rich men fared sumptuously every day; every day was a festival with them; they indulged themselves in intemperance; they ate and drank, not merely what was necessary, and satisfying, and cheering to nature, but to excess, and gorged, and filled themselves in an extravagant manner: the Syriac version, instead of "hearts", reads "bodies" and one copy reads, "your flesh": and the last phrase may be rendered, as it is in the same version, "as unto", or "for the day of slaughter"; and so the Arabic version, "ye have nourished your hearts, as fattened for the day of slaughter": like beasts that are fattened in order to be killed, so were they preparing and fitting up by their sins for destruction.

"But thou, O LORD, knowest me: thou hast seen me, and tried mine heart toward thee: pull them out like sheep for the slaughter, and prepare them for the day of slaughter." Jeremiah 12:3

Again, John Gill, either out of the fold, or from a fat pasture; so fat sheep are plucked from the rest, in order to be killed: this shows that their riches, affluence, and plenty, served but to ripen them for ruin and destruction, and were like the fattening of sheep for slaughter; which the prophet, by this imprecation, suggests and foretells would be their case, as a righteous judgment upon them;

Yours in the Lord,

jm
 
Both free and conditional. Free because you didn't merit it. Conditional because you cannot accept it without faith and repentance. There's lots of confusion on this point and it's not a good sign.
No, that’s a covenant of works. Grace is free. I think you can get hung up on faith and repentance up front as an outward precondition. If it be true, it will be there from the beginning, even as small as a mustard seed and will ebb and flow, etc.

I think a better question or consideration is what does a free offer consist of?
 
Last edited:
I’ve heard of the free offer. The “sincere”bit is strange. Is it ever insincere?
 
No, that’s a covenant of works. Grace is free. I think you can get hung up on faith and repentance up front as an outward precondition. If it be true, it will be there from the beginning, even as small as a mustard seed and will ebb and flow, etc.

I think a better question or consideration is what does a free offer consist of?
The covenant of works does not offer forgiveness of sins. Any covenant that does is straight away not a covenant of works.
 
No, that’s a covenant of works. Grace is free. I think you can get hung up on faith and repentance up front as an outward precondition. If it be true, it will be there from the beginning, even as small as a mustard seed and will ebb and flow, etc.

I think a better question or consideration is what does a free offer consist of?
I understood Charles to mean that God graciously (freely) provides the faith and repentance (conditions) required for salvation according to the kind intentions of his will.
 
I understood Charles to mean that God graciously (freely) provides the faith and repentance (conditions) required for salvation according to the kind intentions of his will.
Yeah I'd affirm this.
Just to clarify what I mean by the gospel being a conditional promise of eternal life,(along with Calvin, Owen, and Rutherford), the gospel is not an absolute promise in that no one has a word from God that he in particular will partake of eternal life before he believes. I can't walk up to any notorious sinner and tell time God has elected him to eternal life. That would be absolute. I can, however, tell him that God will graciously given him eternal life if he only repents and believes the gospel. The "if he repents and believes" part is conditional language. Of course, God will fulfill that condition in his elect, but they are still participants. When he makes them to repent and believe, they do repent and believe. They're not inert, inactive, or dead. Going to heaven isn't God tossing a corpse in the hearse and driving it to the pearly gates. It's God making a corpse a living man that believes and repents and walks down the narrow path to heaven. He doesn't do it in his own power or merits, but he better do it.
The free bit is that you can't merit the gospel being preached to you, and you can't merit the gift of faith God gives you. Many won't hear the gospel at all, and of those who do, God will work in some and leave others in their sin.
 
Robert Rollock

A Brief Instruction on the Eternal Approval and Disapproval of the Divine Mind, & for Explaining the Nature of so Difficult a Thing, 1593/4​

​
"Approval without the decree is when God approves something simply, yet He does not decree that it be chosen or followed after.​
​
Approval without the decree belongs to all good things with respect to themselves, though they are not at any time realized, of which sort are the conversion, faith, and salvation of reprobates; which God surely approves of simply, but does not decree to come about; thus He decrees them not to come about, as we shall see in the doctrine of disapproval. Concerning approval without the decree, see Deut. 5:29, “O that there were such a heart in them, that they would fear me and keep all my commandments always, that it might be well with them, and with their children forever!” 1 Tim. 2:4, “Who will have all men to be saved, and to come unto the knowledge of the truth.” 1 Tim. 4:10, “…who is the Savior of all men, specially of those that believe.”
...​
​
Disapprobation in general is either bare and without the decree, or it is with the decree.​
​
Disapprobation without the decree is when God disapproves of something simply, yet does not decree it to be repudiated or fled from.​
​
Disapproval without the decree is of evil things in themselves, which for some reason are permitted to occur; nevertheless, as culpable evils, the hardening and perdition of reprobates are disapproved of simply, of which God simply disapproves; yet for some reason He permits them to occur; namely, because they serve for his glory. On disapproval without the decree, see Eze. 18:23, “Have I any pleasure at all that the wicked should die? saith the Lord God: and not that he should return from his ways, and live?” Rom. 9:22, “What if God, willing to shew his wrath, and to make his power known, endured with much longsuffering the vessels of wrath fitted to destruction?”"​


The work, newly translated from the Latin, is hopefully going to be published this week on ReformedBooksOnline.

​
​
 
But isnt the offer to repent and believe in itself gracious? That is an undeserved and gracious free offer of salvation and divine favor. Men are still by and large resistant but that does not make the message of the gospel any more or less gracious and maybe a better word, freeing...

Eternal life and fellowship with God is freely offered. (Faith and repentance are characteristics of conversion). And often freely rejected. God will receive His glory regardless. But doesn’t a preconditional offer elicit a dead response rather than a miraculous one.

To repent and believe is a hopeful call not an insurmountable mountain or a stumbling block.
 
Last edited:
But isnt the offer to repent and believe in itself gracious? That is an undeserved and gracious free offer of salvation and divine favor.
Yes, that's what I was saying when I said it was unmerited.
But doesn’t a preconditional offer elicit a dead response rather than a miraculous one.
I didn't call it a preconditional offer, but a conditional offer. You don't repent and believe, and that earns you the right to receive the gospel. You hear the preached gospel, that "whosoever believes in him shall not perish", and then you apply it to yourself by believing.
 
A lot of confusion arises because we are not distinguishing between the use of the term condition in a proper and an improper sense. Saving faith is the condition of the covenant of grace in an improper sense as a means or a requirement; it is not a condition in the proper sense of a moving or meritorious cause.
 
The covenant of works does not offer forgiveness of sins. Any covenant that does is straight away not a covenant of works.

The Covenant of Works didn't need to offer forgiveness of sins, because if the Covenant of Works had been kept, there would be no sins to forgive.

As a counter to your claim, I would say that any covenant, no matter how gracious, that has works as a requirement to receive the blessings is a covenant of works.
 
@koenig

This is an important topic. As a proponent of the WMO, I would simply ask you to consider the following:

1. God desires good, not evil-- obedience, not disobedience. If He commands all men everywhere to repent (Acts 17:30), does He also not desire obedience to that command?

2. God's desire for His decree is not a desire for evil of and for itself. Rather, it is a desire for a greater good (e.g. justice) which in His infinite wisdom is often brought about through the instrumental means of evil (e.g. Christ's death on the cross).

3. God's will is manifold, not contradictory. Sometimes scripture speaks of His will in relation to His law, even when it is disobeyed. Sometimes it relates to His decree, which may include disobedience. If you'd like a list of verses that prove both of these uses, I'd be happy to provide them.

4. As God can will something that does not come to pass and also will everything that comes to pass (in different senses), and desire His will that does not come to pass as well as desiring His will that comes to pass (again, in different senses), is it unreasonable to say that in one sense He desires (wills) the salvation of all? If so, the offer of the gospel is well meant as it proceeds from God and reveals His desire (will) for sinners.

I hope this helps.
 
The Covenant of Works didn't need to offer forgiveness of sins, because if the Covenant of Works had been kept, there would be no sins to forgive.

As a counter to your claim, I would say that any covenant, no matter how gracious, that has works as a requirement to receive the blessings is a covenant of works.
And what of the covenant of grace, that requires obedience to the moral law of God as a law of faith and repentance? No one will inherit the blessings who does not produce fruit in keeping with repentance.
"Nor thieves, nor covetous, nor drunkards, nor revilers, nor extortioners, shall inherit the kingdom of God."
"But the fearful, and unbelieving, and the abominable, and murderers, and whoremongers, and sorcerers, and idolaters, and all liars, shall have their part in the lake which burneth with fire and brimstone: which is the second death."
 
And what of the covenant of grace, that requires obedience to the moral law of God as a law of faith and repentance? No one will inherit the blessings who does not produce fruit in keeping with repentance.
"Nor thieves, nor covetous, nor drunkards, nor revilers, nor extortioners, shall inherit the kingdom of God."
"But the fearful, and unbelieving, and the abominable, and murderers, and whoremongers, and sorcerers, and idolaters, and all liars, shall have their part in the lake which burneth with fire and brimstone: which is the second death."

This portion of the conversation is, in part, helped by @Reformed Covenanter who spelled out that the conditions of the CoG do not merit. Once this distinction is made, there is not an issue about conditions.
 
This portion of the conversation is, in part, helped by @Reformed Covenanter who spelled out that the conditions of the CoG do not merit. Once this distinction is made, there is not an issue about conditions.
I agree that they don't merit. I'm just pointing at that the claim that a covenant that requires works is a "covenant of works" is not viable. In order to be a covenant of works, it must require works in a particular way.
 
The Covenant of Grace does not "require" works on the part of the sinners that are saved under the Covenant of Grace. If it did, no one would be saved.
 
The Covenant of Grace does not "require" works on the part of the sinners that are saved under the Covenant of Grace. If it did, no one would be saved.
"From that time Jesus began to preach, and to say, Repent: for the kingdom of heaven is at hand." (Matthew 4:17)
"Thus it is written, and thus it behooved Christ to suffer, and to rise from the dead the third day: And that repentance and remission of sins should be preached in his name among all nations, beginning at Jerusalem."(Luke 24)
"Then Peter said unto them, Repent, and be baptized every one of you in the name of Jesus Christ for the remission of sins, and ye shall receive the gift of the Holy Ghost. For the promise is unto you, and to your children, and to all that are afar off, even as many as the Lord our God shall call." (Acts 2:38)
"let us go on unto perfection; not laying again the foundation of repentance from dead works, and of faith toward God" (Heb. 6:1)
From the catechism of William Twisse:
Q. What doth the Law require?
A. That we should be without sinne.
Q. What doth the Gospel require?
A. That we should confesse our sinnes, amend our liues, and then through faith in Christ, we shall be saued.
Q. The Law requires what?
A. Perfect obedience.
Q. The Gospel what?
A. Faith, and true repentance.
From the Westminster Shorter Catechism:
Q. 85. What doth God require of us that we may escape his wrath and curse due to us for sin?
A. To escape the wrath and curse of God due to us for sin, God requireth of us faith in Jesus Christ, repentance unto life, with the diligent use of all the outward means whereby Christ communicateth to us the benefits of redemption.
From the Larger Catecism:
Q. 76. What is repentance unto life?
A. Repentance unto life is a saving grace, wrought in the heart of a sinner by the Spirit and Word of God, whereby, out of the sight and sense, not only of the danger, but also of the filthiness and odiousness of his sins, and upon the apprehension of God's mercy in Christ to such as are penitent, he so grieves for and hates his sins, as that he turns from them all to God, purposing and endeavoring constantly to walk with him in all the ways of new obedience.
 
I understood Charles to mean that God graciously (freely) provides the faith and repentance (conditions) required for salvation according to the kind intentions of his will.
And yet it is not preached: hope God may enable you to repent and believe. I actually sat in a church like that for 10 years. Do you know what that amounts to? Drudgery.
 
"From that time Jesus began to preach, and to say, Repent: for the kingdom of heaven is at hand." (Matthew 4:17)
"Thus it is written, and thus it behooved Christ to suffer, and to rise from the dead the third day: And that repentance and remission of sins should be preached in his name among all nations, beginning at Jerusalem."(Luke 24)
"Then Peter said unto them, Repent, and be baptized every one of you in the name of Jesus Christ for the remission of sins, and ye shall receive the gift of the Holy Ghost. For the promise is unto you, and to your children, and to all that are afar off, even as many as the Lord our God shall call." (Acts 2:38)
"let us go on unto perfection; not laying again the foundation of repentance from dead works, and of faith toward God" (Heb. 6:1)
From the catechism of William Twisse:
Q. What doth the Law require?
A. That we should be without sinne.
Q. What doth the Gospel require?
A. That we should confesse our sinnes, amend our liues, and then through faith in Christ, we shall be saued.
Q. The Law requires what?
A. Perfect obedience.
Q. The Gospel what?
A. Faith, and true repentance.
From the Westminster Shorter Catechism:
Q. 85. What doth God require of us that we may escape his wrath and curse due to us for sin?
A. To escape the wrath and curse of God due to us for sin, God requireth of us faith in Jesus Christ, repentance unto life, with the diligent use of all the outward means whereby Christ communicateth to us the benefits of redemption.
From the Larger Catecism:
Q. 76. What is repentance unto life?
A. Repentance unto life is a saving grace, wrought in the heart of a sinner by the Spirit and Word of God, whereby, out of the sight and sense, not only of the danger, but also of the filthiness and odiousness of his sins, and upon the apprehension of God's mercy in Christ to such as are penitent, he so grieves for and hates his sins, as that he turns from them all to God, purposing and endeavoring constantly to walk with him in all the ways of new obedience.
And a non-coerced public confession is a sign of spiritual life.
 
Yes, that's what I was saying when I said it was unmerited.

I didn't call it a preconditional offer, but a conditional offer. You don't repent and believe, and that earns you the right to receive the gospel. You hear the preached gospel, that "whosoever believes in him shall not perish", and then you apply it to yourself by believing.
I agree we should be taught we are dead in our sins. That is part of the gospel message. We are dead in our sins but Jesus is Mighty to save!
 
I agree that they don't merit. I'm just pointing at that the claim that a covenant that requires works is a "covenant of works" is not viable. In order to be a covenant of works, it must require works in a particular way.
That’s strange semantics. It’s a type of covenant of works. I believe it’s semi-pelagian.———————————————————-
Q. 85. What doth God require of us that we may escape his wrath and curse due to us for sin?
A. To escape the wrath and curse of God due to us for sin, God requireth of us faith in Jesus Christ, repentance unto life, with the diligent use of all the outward means whereby Christ communicateth to us the benefits of redemption.
Q. 76. What is repentance unto life?
A. Repentance unto life is a saving grace, wrought in the heart of a sinner by the Spirit and Word of God, whereby, out of the sight and sense, not only of the danger, but also of the filthiness and odiousness of his sins, and upon the apprehension of God's mercy in Christ to such as are penitent, he so grieves for and hates his sins, as that he turns from them all to God, purposing and endeavoring constantly to walk with him in all the ways of new obedience.

This is all part of the active and passive Christian experience. We are taught and instructed in what we need, what we do, who we are, and why that is. .... One truth does not negate the other. There is the paradox, the compliment and the balance. So we offer, we command, we hope, we expect.... I don’t think we need to place any limits. I don’t believe the command for a dead sinner to believe and repent places limits. To not do so does.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top