The Myth of Multiculturalism

Status
Not open for further replies.
I guess I didn't get the article. So because Starbucks is available across most of the United States, we are not multicultural?
 
I can agree that we aren't as multi-cultural as we might think, but I think he focuses too narrowly on the conformity of franchises and corporations. And the Interstate itself is an exercise in unity and conformity, it was designed that way. You can travel all the way across the country on it and see almost nothing. It is only when you get off the Interstate and see the small towns and talk to the people do you see the diversity in people and local culture. It can be truly shocking how different places are. I moved to Iowa for college with my car with a faulty gas gauge, and I learned something I never expected when I ran out of gas on a state highway: people in central Iowa will stop and offer you a ride until you give in and accept. There was not a single car that passed me as I walked toward the gas station that did not stop, and the same thing happened on the way back to my car. And that was just in a different part of the Midwest than I grew up in. Washington DC was a whole different culture. People were the same, but the social expectations were entirely different.

I do agree with the overall gist of the article that the diversity of the world allows us to better see God's glory in eternity. And from our vantage point within the U.S. we are not here seeing the diversity of the world. America has been called "the great melting pot" for a reason. But we are not devoid of diversity even in a small town like mine (about 25,000). We have an Indian restaurant (among others) and a mosque we didn't have 10 years ago. We have many more International students at the University than we did even a decade ago and even our grocery stores show it, something I'm quite happy about. So yes, there is great uniformity in the U.S. but there is a lot more diversity than there used to be. Yes, I'm not seeing the glory Christians from other continents will bring to heaven, but I see a little more than I did of the rest of the world.
 
Last edited:
I think I lament many of the things that this author does. But I think he may be overstating just a little. You may be able to get a caramel macchiato in Chattanooga or Seattle, but I challenge you to find any restaurant in Seattle serving sweet tea or grits. Last I checked, it's hard to find gumbo and po boys in my area. If we're going by just road signs and cuisine, I can point to as many counterexamples as he can.

The fact is that the US has been multicultural ever since its founding. If the US didn't at some level truly celebrate diversity, you wouldn't be able to order Italian pizza in an Irish pub around the corner from Chinatown and across the street from a Hispanic grocer. What's a myth is that these various cultures and subcultures don't coexist: they do, and then we borrow from them. Our very language is peppered with other languages (I've heard my dad, born and raised in rural Appalachia, use the phrase "Oy vey"---I doubt he ever knew anyone who spoke Yiddish growing up).

Again, I see the author's point, but it's a bit overstated.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top