Thoughts on Tithing

Where does the offertory belong in the Order of Worship?

  • Beginning

    Votes: 1 1.9%
  • Middle

    Votes: 8 14.8%
  • End

    Votes: 9 16.7%
  • Does not matter

    Votes: 10 18.5%
  • Other (and I will explain)

    Votes: 2 3.7%
  • Doesn't belong in the Public Worship Service

    Votes: 24 44.4%

  • Total voters
    54
Status
Not open for further replies.
We have offering boxes on the back wall of the church building. I always refer to our offerings in public prayer from the pulpit and ask God's blessing upon them. We announce the existence of the offering boxes each week also. So, the whole subject of offering is still in the congregation's minds without a bag or plate being passed around.

JH
 
With all due respect Pastor, 1 Corinthians 16 makes no mention of Corporate worship, nor a corporate act.. It only said that the collection was to be done on the first day of the week. It makes no reference to "during worship". As far as we can tell it could be done at any time on the first day of the week. Before Worship, After Worship, Mid Day, etc... And since it is never listed as a element of worship, that according to the RPW precludes it from worship. And since Matthew 6 tells us that our alms is to be done without display that also precludes it from worship. It also makes it a private worship matter. There is a big difference with a box in the back and quickly droping some your offering into it without display then passing a tray down the rows of pews for everyone can to see you put money into the plate and also your neighbors who just passed you the tray.... Trust me, I have tried dropping in the plate without display... It does not work that way with tray passing and since the trays are open people around you can pretty much see how much you just dropped in....

Just my :2cents:

Michael


The real concern is that 1 Corinthians 16 makes it clear that we are to set aside as the Lord has prosper us on the first day of the week. Paul makes this command a corporate act. As a corporate act, it is no longer just a private matter, but a matter of corporate worship. Now, as to what the offering is used for, that is another discussion altogether...
 
I do believe it has been nullified in the New Testament with II Corinthians 9:6-7 But this I say: He who sows sparingly will also reap sparingly, and he who sows bountifully will also reap bountifully. So let each one give as he purposes in his heart, not grudgingly or of necessity; for God loves a cheerful giver."

A tenth is no longer required but let each one give as he purposes in his heart, not grudgingly or of necessity.

I think this is right. There are a couple of places in the New Testament where Paul had a golden opportunity to reinforce the tithing laws of the Old Testament; it is significant that he did not do so. Tithing belonged to the structural laws of the Israelite community, whereas freewill giving is more consistent with the much more structurally fluid picture we find in the New Testament, in my opinion.
 
With all due respect Pastor, 1 Corinthians 16 makes no mention of Corporate worship, nor a corporate act.. It only said that the collection was to be done on the first day of the week. It makes no reference to "during worship". As far as we can tell it could be done at any time on the first day of the week. Before Worship, After Worship, Mid Day, etc... And since it is never listed as a element of worship, that according to the RPW precludes it from worship. And since Matthew 6 tells us that our alms is to be done without display that also precludes it from worship. It also makes it a private worship matter. There is a big difference with a box in the back and quickly droping some your offering into it without display then passing a tray down the rows of pews for everyone can to see you put money into the plate and also your neighbors who just passed you the tray.... Trust me, I have tried dropping in the plate without display... It does not work that way with tray passing and since the trays are open people around you can pretty much see how much you just dropped in....

Just my :2cents:

Michael


The real concern is that 1 Corinthians 16 makes it clear that we are to set aside as the Lord has prosper us on the first day of the week. Paul makes this command a corporate act. As a corporate act, it is no longer just a private matter, but a matter of corporate worship. Now, as to what the offering is used for, that is another discussion altogether...

Great. Except for one thing.

1 Corinthians 16:1-2 - Now concerning the collection for the saints, as I have given orders to the churches of Galatia, so you must do also: 2 On the first day of the week let each one of you lay something aside, storing up as he may prosper, that there be no collections when I come.

1 Corinthians 16 was not written to individual believers. It was written to the church that was expected to have gathered on the first day of the week. As they gathered they were to collect so that they didn't have to have a quick collection when Paul showed up on Tuesday or whatever day he showed up on. And these orders were not just for Corinth. They were for the churches in Galatia as well.

So, just what were these churches gathered for on the first day of the week (where they would do these collections) if not for corporate worship?

BTW, if you notice my last sentence, I hinted that another discussion that needed to be held was what this particular "collection" was used for, which would determine if it were normative or not. Since this one in chapter 16 was for a specific need, it is possible to say that here Paul is only talking about special offerings for saints in need and not the ones that are used to pay the church's staff and electric bill. But it is NOT possible to say that it didn't take place when the church gathered for corporate worship.

P.S. - I tend to agree with you on the tithing issue.
 
Last edited:
Based on the premise that the tenth has been done away with (which I think there is some evidence for), I find it interesting that many evangelicals repeatedly talk about the repealment of the ceremonial law (and some even of the moral law), but hang on slavishly to the tithing of a tenth.

Because hey, what's the alternative? "Sell all that you have and give it to the poor." or at least selling income properties, etc. to help fund the church's ministries. That's simply too radical, so we pick and choose. :2cents:
 
Based on the premise that the tenth has been done away with (which I think there is some evidence for), I find it interesting that many evangelicals repeatedly talk about the repealment of the ceremonial law (and some even of the moral law), but hang on slavishly to the tithing of a tenth.

Because hey, what's the alternative? "Sell all that you have and give it to the poor." or at least selling income properties, etc. to help fund the church's ministries. That's simply too radical, so we pick and choose. :2cents:

Interesting evaluation, Kevin, and I agree.
 
Regarding the legitimacy of the tithe, Jesus said:

Woe unto you, scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites! for ye pay tithe of mint and anise and cummin, and have omitted the weightier matters of the law, judgment, mercy, and faith: these ought ye to have done, and not to leave the other undone. (Matthew 23:23)

Does He not commend the Pharisees for their meticulous observation of their tithe? It is certainly true that the NT principle is liberality in which the Christian says, "Only a tithe?" But it seems quite clear here that "these ought ye to have done".
 
Regarding the legitimacy of the tithe, Jesus said:

Woe unto you, scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites! for ye pay tithe of mint and anise and cummin, and have omitted the weightier matters of the law, judgment, mercy, and faith: these ought ye to have done, and not to leave the other undone. (Matthew 23:23)
Does He not commend the Pharisees for their meticulous observation of their tithe? It is certainly true that the NT principle is liberality in which the Christian says, "Only a tithe?" But it seems quite clear here that "these ought ye to have done".

Excellent point, Pastor Dyck. I find it odd that giving is often the one area in which many Christians view the redeemed person's response to God to be less under the New covenant than the Old.
 
I find it odd that giving is often the one area in which many Christians view the redeemed person's response to God to be less under the New covenant than the Old.

This is an argument that works against the defenders of the tithe, because the reality is that the Israelites gave more than one tenth. People look at the tithe, see one tenth, and conclude that is how much God requires per capita. The fact is, however, that Israel were required to pay numerous tithes. To make a proper application of this principle to the New Testament -- we should teach the Christian is bound to give his whole self to the Lord first (2 Cor. 8:5), and having devoted all one has to the Lord to give liberally as occasion presents itself. See Thomas Peck's Moral Obligation of the Tithe, Writings, 1:146-157; and John Owen's Exposition of Hebrews, 5:323-327.
 
I find it odd that giving is often the one area in which many Christians view the redeemed person's response to God to be less under the New covenant than the Old.

This is an argument that works against the defenders of the tithe, because the reality is that the Israelites gave more than one tenth. People look at the tithe, see one tenth, and conclude that is how much God requires per capita. The fact is, however, that Israel were required to pay numerous tithes. To make a proper application of this principle to the New Testament -- we should teach the Christian is bound to give his whole self to the Lord first (2 Cor. 8:5), and having devoted all one has to the Lord to give liberally as occasion presents itself. See Thomas Peck's Moral Obligation of the Tithe, Writings, 1:146-157; and John Owen's Exposition of Hebrews, 5:323-327.

I heard somewhere the actual percentage required was closer to 33%.
 
The Isrealites were required to give the tenth, and yes, some gave more, but those were special offerings or peace offerings that Christians today may still give, though in different ways. This was the case with the giving of alms as well. We may still offer God praise, or offer alms by aiding those in need.
With respect to the place of the offering plate in worship, I voted not in the service at all because "when thou doest alms, let not thy left hand know what thy right hand doeth." If we are to be so private about our giving, that even our other hand does not see, how much more ought we to privatise our giving from other people. How can we avoid making giving a spectacle when it is done during the called worship service in the presence of the entire congregation?
 
The Isrealites were required to give the tenth, and yes, some gave more, but those were special offerings or peace offerings that Christians today may still give, though in different ways. This was the case with the giving of alms as well. We may still offer God praise, or offer alms by aiding those in need.
With respect to the place of the offering plate in worship, I voted not in the service at all because "when thou doest alms, let not thy left hand know what thy right hand doeth." If we are to be so private about our giving, that even our other hand does not see, how much more ought we to privatise our giving from other people. How can we avoid making giving a spectacle when it is done during the called worship service in the presence of the entire congregation?

Not to quench a Berean spirit, but have you considered applying your logic to our Lord's prescription with relation to prayer? On the basis that you have suggested we would not be permitted to pray in public. I think rather our Lord was addressing the attitude with which our acts of worship are performed, whether in public or private. The only basis for not having an "offering" is the fact that ceremonial offerings are done away with under the New Testament. That they are not a part of the ordinary worship of God is clear from what the apostle states in 1 Cor. 16:2.
 
Not to quench a Berean spirit, but have you considered applying your logic to our Lord's prescription with relation to prayer? On the basis that you have suggested we would not be permitted to pray in public. I think rather our Lord was addressing the attitude with which our acts of worship are performed, whether in public or private. The only basis for not having an "offering" is the fact that ceremonial offerings are done away with under the New Testament. That they are not a part of the ordinary worship of God is clear from what the apostle states in 1 Cor. 16:2.[/QUOTE]

My logic, Sir Armorbearer, was in reference to private worship as I believe tithing to be an act thereof. Public prayer falls under the category of Public worship and I never meant for my statement to apply to both public and private prayer and praise. If I was unclear about this I apologize. The public/private distinction is the substance of this debate, because if tithing is truely an act of private worship, it has no place in the public worship service. What other ellements of the public worship service are considered private? Certainly not public prayer, the congregational singing, the reading, expounding and preaching of the word. However, when we pray privately that should be done in relative secrecy, consider Matt 6:5-6, "but when thou prayest, thou shalt not be as the hypocrites; for they love to pray standing in the synagogues, and in the corners of the streets that they may be seen of men. Verily I say unto you that they have their reward. Ver 6. But thou, when thou prayest, enter into thy closet, and when thou hast shut thy door, pray to thy Father which is in secret, and thy Father who seeth in secret shall reward thee openly." I believe that tithing, and all other acts of private worship should be done with a similar privatism and my concern is that having an offering plate passed during a Public service places tithing, an act of private worship on a public pedestal.
On a different note, I would appreciate your prayers today. I broke my leg and tore a ligament in an auto accident in May and have been forbidden to walk since. Today I have a visit with the doctor in which LW he will give me permission to walk again. He will also set a date for the second surgery at which time he will take the pin out of my ankle. The Lord has been gracious and merciful to me in all my afflictions and I would appreciate your prayers, together with mine that all may go well.
 
I find it odd that giving is often the one area in which many Christians view the redeemed person's response to God to be less under the New covenant than the Old.

This is an argument that works against the defenders of the tithe, because the reality is that the Israelites gave more than one tenth. People look at the tithe, see one tenth, and conclude that is how much God requires per capita. The fact is, however, that Israel were required to pay numerous tithes. To make a proper application of this principle to the New Testament -- we should teach the Christian is bound to give his whole self to the Lord first (2 Cor. 8:5), and having devoted all one has to the Lord to give liberally as occasion presents itself. See Thomas Peck's Moral Obligation of the Tithe, Writings, 1:146-157; and John Owen's Exposition of Hebrews, 5:323-327.

I heard somewhere the actual percentage required was closer to 33%.

That probably comes from the fact that there are 3 different tithes mentioned. The Levitical Tithe, the Festival Tithe, and the Poor Tithe. But the Poor Tithe was only brought in every 3 years, I believe and I am not sure whether it was a seperate tithe or tooke the place of the Levitical Tithe on those occasions. Does anybody have any good resources on the different tithes in the OT?
 
I can understand why some would want to put a box in the back so that 'the right hand does not know what the left hand is doing' etc. and more power to them. But bringing tithes and offerings in absolute secrecy goes beyond what Jesus had in mind, In my humble opinion. If you read Deut 26 and other places where the bringing of tithes and offerings and firstfruits to the priests is described it is a very public affair. How can you hide your basket or your donkey that is bearing your offering? What would we do if someone wanted to actually bring the firstfruits of their almond grove today? How would we handle that? How could that be secret?

Just 'food' for thought.:lol:
 
The fact is, the tithe is not compleatly secret. Sure somone might see you dropping your money in the plate at the back of the church, this is incindental as I believe most of your objections are. Sure somone might see your donkey laden with firstfruits, but this cannot really be avoided, and so is acceptable. But here is where the secrecy plays in, it is our duty not to make tihes more public than is necessary. The fact is, in some churches, passing the plate is a means of using peer pressure to get more out of the flock than would have been gathered had the plate been left in a place of relative privacy.
just food for thought
 
The fact is, in some churches, passing the plate is a means of using peer pressure to get more out of the flock than would have been gathered had the plate been left in a place of relative privacy.
just food for thought

That may be true but I have never seen it.

BTW, are you the son of the great Rev Todd Ruddell, church-planter extraordinaire?
 
I couldn't agree more with those who have stated that tithe is merely a starting place. Jesus told us that in giving our right hand is not to know what our left hand is doing. This signifies an open hand and an open heart in giving. We are to give completely of ourselves, our possessions and money as the need arises. There are many who cannot give large chunks of funds to God's work but are able to volunteer numerous man hours laboring for the gospel and God's work that far exceed any money that could be paid out. That, too, is a part of giving. All that we have should be as water running through our open fingers when it comes to God's work and His people.

Since the church is where we gather, giving boxes should be placed in the back of the church. Needs should be made known, and believers should give as the Lord leads them cheerfully.

Another issue that is rarely mentioned in this discussion of tithing is that of keeping track of giving for tax deductions. I believe this goes completely against the attitude of giving with a whole heart and freely and cheerfully. Seems that keeping track of giving on a sheet to be turned into the IRS at the end of the year is the right hand knowing what the left hand is doing. GIving should be from a cheerful, free heart, and it should be private.
 
My logic, Sir Armorbearer, was in reference to private worship as I believe tithing to be an act thereof. Public prayer falls under the category of Public worship and I never meant for my statement to apply to both public and private prayer and praise. If I was unclear about this I apologize. The public/private distinction is the substance of this debate, because if tithing is truely an act of private worship, it has no place in the public worship service. What other ellements of the public worship service are considered private? Certainly not public prayer, the congregational singing, the reading, expounding and preaching of the word. However, when we pray privately that should be done in relative secrecy, consider Matt 6:5-6, "but when thou prayest, thou shalt not be as the hypocrites; for they love to pray standing in the synagogues, and in the corners of the streets that they may be seen of men. Verily I say unto you that they have their reward. Ver 6. But thou, when thou prayest, enter into thy closet, and when thou hast shut thy door, pray to thy Father which is in secret, and thy Father who seeth in secret shall reward thee openly." I believe that tithing, and all other acts of private worship should be done with a similar privatism and my concern is that having an offering plate passed during a Public service places tithing, an act of private worship on a public pedestal.
On a different note, I would appreciate your prayers today. I broke my leg and tore a ligament in an auto accident in May and have been forbidden to walk since. Today I have a visit with the doctor in which LW he will give me permission to walk again. He will also set a date for the second surgery at which time he will take the pin out of my ankle. The Lord has been gracious and merciful to me in all my afflictions and I would appreciate your prayers, together with mine that all may go well.

Friend, I agree the offering plate is unwarranted. It just appeared to me that you were providing an argument as to *why* the almsgiving should be private. If you are showing that our Lord's words give instruction as to the best way to manage a private act of worship, then I fully concur. But our Lord's words cannot be made the basis for keeping the action private because the same reasoning would then apply to prayer.

I rejoice with you in all the Lord's tender mercies in affliction, and pray He will guide your consultation and subsequent surgery to His glory and your good. Blessings!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top