My thread was not asking about various points of textual criticism, but highlighting two very recent and related podcasts on the topic. Anything in them is fair game. I found White’s presentation to be woefully deficient for several reasons—not just his demeanor but also his argumentation, both of which I pointed out. For the opposite reasons, I found the GPTS podcast to be more compelling.I was hoping this thread was to be interaction on the points of textual criticism (Is this not the Translation sub and not General discussion) But it seems not to be so. Sorry for being disappointed. I didn’t think we were to be discussing the manner of interaction (which you yourself said you are turned off by, so why would you want to continue talking about something you are turned off by?)
If you want to discuss some other points in the podcasts, no one is stopping you. Again, I’m not sure why you are requesting the thread be shut down, unless you just like James White and don’t like seeing him criticized.