A petty relationship question.

Status
Not open for further replies.

dog8food

Puritan Board Freshman
I met a Christian girl during a mission trip. We remained friends afterwards, but her responses would come less and less. Probably to my detriment I expressed my feelings towards her, and she responded with rejection, "you'll find someone some day" and the verse from Solomon "Do not stir up now awaken love until it pleases." So that pretty much flat lined all communication with her.

A year later, after my emotions were settled, I was curious about what was going on on her side of the globe, I thought I'd offer my friendship. Again she responded shortly and included another verse "In the Bible it says to live peaceably with all men as much as it depends on you so remaining friends sounds good to me." Wasn't quite sure what to make of it but almost sounded as if she would be my friend against her will, but only out of Biblical obligation.

Any attempt to communicate with her afterwards was completely ignored (she is still single). Now I know this sounds petty, and it's fine if she wants nothing to do with me, but I wish I knew why I'm being treated like a disease (especially painful because we got along so well before). I would even appreciate harsh honesty, because, honestly this has become a stumbling block for me. I often find it hard to shake feelings of inadequacy. if at least she could be truthful with me, maybe there's a character flaw that I could pray about so that God could mature me in that area.

My question: Am I at liberty to confront her with this? Or should I just continue bringing it to the Lord? I really don't want to "bother" her anymore, or corner her... it just seems like her honest response could help me heal.
 
I'm no Dear Abby, but it sounds like she just doesn't want to lead you on or give you false hope about having a relationship that's anything more than a friendship.
I often find it hard to shake feelings of inadequacy. if at least she could be truthful with me, maybe there's a character flaw that I could pray about so that God could mature me in that area.
Don't know you at all, but maybe it has nothing to do with inadequacy or a character flaw. Maybe she just realizes that you "aren't the one".
 
I would say you should just move on man.

Her responses sound weird, and yes she does sound like she's trying to justify everything she does with verses as if under some obligation. I think the problem may be with her, perhaps she goes to a church that has a weird way of using scripture. Sounds a bit fanatical.

Anyway I would say move on, it's nothing to do with a character flaw but probably to do with the fact she just doesn't like you in that way and you don't need to confront her.

Just because one girl rejects you doesn't mean your inadequate.
 
I’d also recommend moving on. If she’s not interested then so be it. There are plenty of other young women out there. When it’s God’s time, you’ll find her.
 
I would agree that it is time to move on, but I also understand that it can be painful. Perhaps the words of Lyle Lovett can be helpful. Here are the lyrics to the song If I were the man you wanted. Enjoy.

They all sat around in a circle
They were all laughing and all telling lies
Then the tall one he bumped in a dollar
He said boys I've got nothing to hide
Now if the King and the Queen stood together
Then the ace he would not be to blame
And if the cards were all laid on the table
Then love could be more than a game

And if the stars didn't shine on the water
Then the sun wouldn't burn on the sand
And if I were the man you wanted
I would not be the man that I am

And I have seen my share of long nights
And I have told my share of lies
And I have run into the darkness
When I saw the look in your eyes
But if the night didn't lie in the darkness
Then the daylight would be hard to find
And if the truth didn't turn to a weakness
I would have never have spoken my mind

And if the stars didn't shine on the water
Then the sun wouldn't burn on the sand
And if I were the man you wanted
Then I would not be the man that I am

So if you're going out to Carolina
Then don't linger in New Mexico
And if you think of the one there behind you
Then you might not feel so alone

And if the stars didn't shine on the water
Then the sun wouldn't burn on the sand
And if I were the man you wanted
I would not be the man that I am
 
As others have said, I think wisdom would say to cover any perceived offenses with love and move on. I don't think verses about confronting another's sin apply in this situation since you guys aren't in a local church together, and this isn't a previously established, solid friendship from all that I can see (which is not much). Move ahead, grow in wisdom, trust the Lord, and be faithful where he's called you. Return not hardness of thoughts for whatever hardness of heart has been dealt to you.
 
I completely sympathize with this situation---I've been there (in a situation very similar to yours). The problem is that once the cat's out of the bag, it's hard to have a real friendship. I would echo the sentiments of those who say move on---if you can. You shouldn't try to bring this up---take it to the Lord, find a Christian brother who can help you bear the burden, but don't try to salvage the situation. Part of the problem is that you are still talking about it: "can I just be your friend?" sounds like you're still hoping that something might come of it.

As for feelings of inadequacy, you need time, encouragement, and (if I may say so) good Godly platonic female friends. There are plenty of Godly young ladies out there and a slightly smaller number of Godly young gentlemen---most likely you will find someone, it may just take a while.
 
The young lady may not be adept at saying no thanks diplomatically, but she hasn't been mean, just terse. From a father's point of view, that's almost what I'd want my daughter to do in that situation. Young men are emotional and obsessive. I'd want her to leave no doubt in his mind that she is not interested in pursuing marriage with him, which is the only aim any relationship beyond friendship should have.

Don't obsess. It's not just about you. She's probably nervous and didn't reply as well as she might. She's your sister, cut her some slack. Or maybe you're poring too closely over every word. The sting is pride, and it will subside. Your Father in heaven has other plans for you. Chomping against that happy bit is completely pointless.
 
Bottom line is that she just isnt interested, for whatever reason. Pray about this and ask God to both guide and provide and someday you'll be so thankful this one was not interested. Our God always does it best and He knows them that are His and also what their needs and desires are! Many blessings in your search!
 
If you and she were in the same church, then you might need to continue to to pester her for some sort of better closure for the sake of church fellowship. But you aren't. So there's no real harm to church fellowship by just letting it go.

It sounds like it hurts for you to let it go. But it also sounds pretty clear that she's not interested in you. That's too bad, but you need to accept it and move on. And while it may seem as if a neater sort of closure to the relationship would be less painful, that's not necessarily the case.
 
Get over it an move on. She clearly does not think there is any future in it. I would not say she is treating you as if you had some disease. She is probably trying not to encourage any further communication from you and feels this is the best way to go about it. I always felt that if you made it known to a girl you wanted a relationship with her and she said no, regardless of how good a friendship you may have had things just are not the same afterwards. I know it maybe hard to take but forget her and move on.
 
Often times when women get the impression you're seeking out a relationship beyond frendship, its an impression that is difficult (if not impossible) for them to shake, especially if they are not interested in a relationship with you. This is regardless of whether or not your intentions are such.

This is one of those cases where I would advise that you move on and find other pastures to tend to. It's doubtful that you may get a straight answer from her, and you may end up driving yourself insane trying to make heads or tails of it. If you two were members of the same church, then I would implore a resolution to come about so there isn't any division between saints in the congregation. However, since you're not, it would be best if you simply cut her loose.
 
From a woman's perspective ... Often times, when you tell a guy that you aren't interested, he returns with the "Well, let's just be friends," answer and then continues to try to make the relationship into something more. Maybe this has happened to her before or she's seen it happen to someone else and she just doesn't want to risk leading you on.

Also, all of these exchanges have been over email, correct? Its difficult to know exactly what someone means in an email or im when you can't see their face or tone of voice - so I wouldn't judge her to harshly.

Honestly, this sounds like something I would have done back in the day...
 
The problem is that once the cat's out of the bag, it's hard to have a real friendship.
This makes a lot of sense (as well as everyone here who echoed it). We had good times together, should've left well enough alone. Plus, culturally, Japanese (she's Okinawan) in general communicate in a much more high-context manner than I'm used to. I could see how "letting the cat out of the bag" could be overwhelming to her. Dang. And there's probably only a handful of Okinawan Christians :doh:

Thank you all. I had accepted that it's time to move on, I guess I couldn't understand why she suddenly began treating me so differently.

Looking forward to whatever else the Lord has in store--thankful for what He's giving me now.
 
Last edited:
Good advice above. Also, would you please fix your signature block just as soon as possible.

[Can't believe we're 18 posts into this thread and no one has brought that to your attention.]

See the link below under my name.
 
I would echo the same "move on" advice as others. I would like to speak to the feelings of inadequacy. My friend, no one can make you any less of an image bearer of God by their lack of desire. You don't need to seek human approval.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top