Doubts about deacons

Status
Not open for further replies.

lucascoral

Puritan Board Freshman
Hello, I'm Lucas C Mendes, this is my first time asking here, so I don't know if I'm in correct place for resolve a doubt that I have.

My doubt is simple, we can choice for deacon a woman? I know for a Elder is not correct, but and about Deacon? is possible?


That's it, thank you.
 
Most believe that Paul's requirement in I Tim 3 for a deacon to be the husband of one wife, which mirors the requirement for an elder, makes this a male office.

However Paul does use the same word to refer to Phoebe in Romans. The word simply means servant in Greek, so in Phoebe's case, Paul may not have intended the church office by his usage.
 
The short answer is no. The qualification for a deacon is virtually the same as the qualifications for an elder. See 1 Timothy 3:1-13.
Note that each should be the husband of one wife who manages his household well. In addition to that verse 11 describes the character of a deacon's wife.
 
The PCA says no, which I agree with. But I do admit the Greek wording could indicate that being an office for women as well. I just personally don't believe that's what the Bible is saying, but I wouldn't consider somebody a heretic for coming to a different conclusion than myself.
 
Before we go too far down this road, let's not forget that a number of NAPARC denominations do have women deaconesses, and virtually all Korean Presbyterians have them.

Right or wrong, it's allowed by some in the Reformed world.

I happen to think John Calvin's idea of women deaconesses working only among women is a good idea. But I'm not prepared to fight on it or divide churches over the issue.

Any woman qualified to be a deaconess will have a servant heart and won't care about the title. Any woman who cares about the title is by definition disqualified from being a deaconess. In the modern feminist environment, we'd better be very careful to assess motives.
 
The word is prevailingly used in a non-official sense, so the argument from Romans 16:1 is exceedingly weak.
 
If you study the work of women in the Diaconate of Calvin's Geneva it looks nearly identical to the idea of Assistants to the Deacons in the PCA BCO.
 
If you study the work of women in the Diaconate of Calvin's Geneva it looks nearly identical to the idea of Assistants to the Deacons in the PCA BCO.

Likewise, Calvin's women deaconesses were not unlike the Korean deaconesses and jondosanim and kwonsanim which existed in the Korean Presbyterian denominations, to my knowledge without any objections or protests from OPC missionary Bruce Hunt, or from the subsequent OPC missionaries to Korea. Now if I'm wrong and the OPC objected to Korean women in those three roles, fine. I'm sure there are people on the Puritan Board who can correct me if I'm wrong. But if not, maybe the silence of the OPC should give some pause to people who consider women in the diaconate to be totally out of bounds.

As I said before, because we live in a society with a major problem of feminism, I don't push the issue. Women deacons can be, and have been, used as a wedge to get women elders. A woman qualified to be a deaconess will care about service, not titles, and won't care if she doesn't have a title. If she cares about titles, she by definition isn't interested in or qualified for an office of service.

A hard line must be drawn between women in the diaconate and the eldership. If a local church or a denomination can't do that, this is a subject that should not be considered. It's just too dangerous in the modern ecclesiastical context to open a door without VERY clear understandings of what is behind the door.
 
Note also that in both the ARP and RPCNA, the topic of a female diaconate is under scrutiny, with not inconsiderable pressure in both denominations to return to a more traditional view here, the idea of females in the office of deacon proper dating, if I'm not mistaken, to the feminist movement of the 1910s and 1920s.
 
Note also that in both the ARP and RPCNA, the topic of a female diaconate is under scrutiny, with not inconsiderable pressure in both denominations to return to a more traditional view here, the idea of females in the office of deacon proper dating, if I'm not mistaken, to the feminist movement of the 1910s and 1920s.
I may be mistaken but I had thought female deacons in the RPCNA is late 19th century?
 
I may be mistaken but I had thought female deacons in the RPCNA is late 19th century?
You are correct

The PCA says no, which I agree with. But I do admit the Greek wording could indicate that being an office for women as well. I just personally don't believe that's what the Bible is saying, but I wouldn't consider somebody a heretic for coming to a different conclusion than myself.
I don’t thing anyone is bandying about the idea of heresy with respect to women deacons.
 
Note also that in both the ARP and RPCNA, the topic of a female diaconate is under scrutiny, with not inconsiderable pressure in both denominations to return to a more traditional view here, the idea of females in the office of deacon proper dating, if I'm not mistaken, to the feminist movement of the 1910s and 1920s.
I can't speak to the RPCNA situation and while I have direct information on the ARP situation it's secondhand. Eliminating deaconesses is still officially under study in the ARP, but my understanding is that one of the largest churches in the denomination has made clear that they joined the ARP because it allowed deaconesses and if that changes, the church will leave.

I don't think anyone has an inerrant crystal ball to predict future synodical decisions, but we're not talking about a liberal church, or even a moderate church, and it's one that has had several very big names as pastors. Any recommendation by the study committee to completely eliminate women from the diaconate is likely dead on arrival.

If I were on a study committee addressing women in the diaconate in a denomination like the ARP, RPCNA, or PCA, and I am not, I might recommend distinguishing between male deacons and female deaconesses and adopting language taken directly from Calvin's Institutes on the matter. I think that might address the legitimate concerns that women in the diaconate can be, and has been, a trojan horse for women elders, while simultaneously dealing with the reality that most if not all of the Korean churches in both the ARP and PCA have women in the diaconate, and a significant number of English-speaking ARP churches that cannot be accused of liberalism do so as well.

But that's one person talking, and my opinions are purely my own.

I said above that this is not an issue on which I am going to fight, and it is not worth dividing churches.
 
I can't speak to the RPCNA situation and while I have direct information on the ARP situation it's secondhand. Eliminating deaconesses is still officially under study in the ARP, but my understanding is that one of the largest churches in the denomination has made clear that they joined the ARP because it allowed deaconesses and if that changes, the church will leave.

I don't think anyone has an inerrant crystal ball to predict future synodical decisions, but we're not talking about a liberal church, or even a moderate church, and it's one that has had several very big names as pastors. Any recommendation by the study committee to completely eliminate women from the diaconate is likely dead on arrival.

If I were on a study committee addressing women in the diaconate in a denomination like the ARP, RPCNA, or PCA, and I am not, I might recommend distinguishing between male deacons and female deaconesses and adopting language taken directly from Calvin's Institutes on the matter. I think that might address the legitimate concerns that women in the diaconate can be, and has been, a trojan horse for women elders, while simultaneously dealing with the reality that most if not all of the Korean churches in both the ARP and PCA have women in the diaconate, and a significant number of English-speaking ARP churches that cannot be accused of liberalism do so as well.

But that's one person talking, and my opinions are purely my own.

I said above that this is not an issue on which I am going to fight, and it is not worth dividing churches.
For what it's worth, women deacons far preceeds the modern egalitarian movement. The Council of Chalcedon itself canonizes women deacons, though under a certain rubric.
 
For what it's worth, women deacons far preceeds the modern egalitarian movement. The Council of Chalcedon itself canonizes women deacons, though under a certain rubric.

Agreed. I remember my Greek professor at Calvin College pointing out, during the Christian Reformed fight over women in the diaconate, that secular records of Roman imperial officials in Greek-speaking territories show that within a century of Christ's death, two deaconesses were put under torture to reveal the supposed evil crimes of Christians. Even after torturing the deaconesses, the imperial officials couldn't get any evidence of crimes they could use to prosecute Christians.

I already knew what I thought about women in the diaconate before I took his class, but I wouldn't be surprised if that Greek professor's teaching over many years to future seminarians affected the CRC debate on the role of women in the diaconate.

Now I'm the first one to say that secular post-canonical history is not authoritative. The church in that era was also in the process of turning the "episkopos" from an "overseer" or "senior pastor" into something that was beginning to look like a bishop. Just because the first and second century church had deaconesses doesn't mean we should, and it doesn't mean the apostolic church necessarily had a formal office of deaconesses.

I do think it means we need to show some latitude to people on both sides of the question of whether women can be in the diaconate, and if so, how.
 
Agreed. I remember my Greek professor at Calvin College pointing out, during the Christian Reformed fight over women in the diaconate, that secular records of Roman imperial officials in Greek-speaking territories show that within a century of Christ's death, two deaconesses were put under torture to reveal the supposed evil crimes of Christians. Even after torturing the deaconesses, the imperial officials couldn't get any evidence of crimes they could use to prosecute Christians.

I already knew what I thought about women in the diaconate before I took his class, but I wouldn't be surprised if that Greek professor's teaching over many years to future seminarians affected the CRC debate on the role of women in the diaconate.

Now I'm the first one to say that secular post-canonical history is not authoritative. The church in that era was also in the process of turning the "episkopos" from an "overseer" or "senior pastor" into something that was beginning to look like a bishop. Just because the first and second century church had deaconesses doesn't mean we should, and it doesn't mean the apostolic church necessarily had a formal office of deaconesses.

I do think it means we need to show some latitude to people on both sides of the question of whether women can be in the diaconate, and if so, how.
What the historical evidence does do, is move the discussion outside of the complementarian (an egregious misnomer) and egalitarian debate into a full orbed discussion and exegesis of the issue. I'm one who took an exception to the RPCNA position. But, while disagreeing with the position, I can recognize the discussion is not a 19th century discussion as far as the broader church is considered.
 
What the historical evidence does do, is move the discussion outside of the complementarian (an egregious misnomer) and egalitarian debate into a full orbed de iscussion and exegesis of the issue. I'm one who took an exception to the RPCNA position. But, while disagreeing with the position, I can recognize the discussion is not a 19th century discussion as far as the broader church is considered.
That makes sense to me.

BTW, the Waldensians, until the majority merged with the Reformed at the Synod of Chanforan in 1532, had women who were doing itinerant preaching among other women. That allowance for women teaching other women is part of why the Waldensians were accused during the Middle Ages by the Inquisition of being "witches," and were one of several things the Waldensians gave up after discussions with the Swiss Reformed.

I need to spend more time researching that part of Italian Reformed history, and what effect (if any) it had on Calvin's views of women in the diaconate.
 
Likewise, Calvin's women deaconesses were not unlike the Korean deaconesses and jondosanim and kwonsanim which existed in the Korean Presbyterian denominations, to my knowledge without any objections or protests from OPC missionary Bruce Hunt, or from the subsequent OPC missionaries to Korea. Now if I'm wrong and the OPC objected to Korean women in those three roles, fine. I'm sure there are people on the Puritan Board who can correct me if I'm wrong. But if not, maybe the silence of the OPC should give some pause to people who consider women in the diaconate to be totally out of bounds.

As I said before, because we live in a society with a major problem of feminism, I don't push the issue. Women deacons can be, and have been, used as a wedge to get women elders. A woman qualified to be a deaconess will care about service, not titles, and won't care if she doesn't have a title. If she cares about titles, she by definition isn't interested in or qualified for an office of service.

A hard line must be drawn between women in the diaconate and the eldership. If a local church or a denomination can't do that, this is a subject that should not be considered. It's just too dangerous in the modern ecclesiastical context to open a door without VERY clear understandings of what is behind the door.
I think you are missing my point. The practice of a male-led Diaconate with women who assist the Diaconate is not only something in Calvin's Geneva but goes back to early Church history. They were typically the "Widows". The issue has less to do with what one calls them but whether they are part of the leadership of the Diaconate. Biblically and historically, those ordained to the Diaconate were men with the Scriptural qualifications. Women (often the widows) performed diaconal work and could be called deaconesses, but they were under a Diaconate led by the men. Appeals to Calvin's Geneva only confirm how the PCA insists upon the ordination of men with the appointment of assistants to the deacons who are not ordained but perform essential work under the care and authority of the Diaconate.

The problem we have today are those who insist upon an egalitarian Diaconate. If women are to be part of the Diaconal work then, Biblically, they are to serve under the authority of ordained officers in the Diaconate. I'm less concerned about them being called Deaconesses as long as it is understood they are not ordained and not leading the Diaconal work.
 
I think you are missing my point. The practice of a male-led Diaconate with women who assist the Diaconate is not only something in Calvin's Geneva but goes back to early Church history. They were typically the "Widows". The issue has less to do with what one calls them but whether they are part of the leadership of the Diaconate. Biblically and historically, those ordained to the Diaconate were men with the Scriptural qualifications. Women (often the widows) performed diaconal work and could be called deaconesses, but they were under a Diaconate led by the men. Appeals to Calvin's Geneva only confirm how the PCA insists upon the ordination of men with the appointment of assistants to the deacons who are not ordained but perform essential work under the care and authority of the Diaconate.

The problem we have today are those who insist upon an egalitarian Diaconate. If women are to be part of the Diaconal work then, Biblically, they are to serve under the authority of ordained officers in the Diaconate. I'm less concerned about them being called Deaconesses as long as it is understood they are not ordained and not leading the Diaconal work.

I can't find anything you wrote here with which I disagree. If I understand you correctly, we're saying the same thing though perhaps with a different emphasis.

My background is not the PCA, but rather the Christian Reformed fight in which women in the diaconate turned into a wedge issue to get women elders. The result is that a fair number of Dutch Reformed conservatives have taken a hard stance against anything that looks, smells, or tastes like women in leadership, and my position on women in the diaconate looks suspect to both sides in that fight. I think I can make a fair claim that my position is that of John Calvin and of Geneva, and is close to if not identical to that of modern Korean Presbyterianism, but that's not "good enough" for the egalitarians and raises legitimate concerns by the conservatives that I am a "compromiser." I don't think so, but it's a fair concern and I do not at all object to being challenged on that point.

I think we would be in a much better place if everybody in the confessionally Reformed world could agree on these points:

1. Teaching and ruling the church are the responsibilities of biblically qualified men. No woman can serve as a pastor or elder, and that should also apply to de-facto elder roles in the church in which she teaches or rules over men.
2. Women, particularly older women, are encouraged by Scripture to mentor other women in a number of ways. (I'm avoiding being specific here on what ways because I know some in the Reformed world take the position that Proverbs 31 applies only to domestic duties and oppose women even teaching other women. I disagree but don't want to get into that debate.)
3. Certain types of interaction with women, in the culture of the ancient and late medieval world, simply could not be done with propriety by men. Some sort of role for "women serving women" was an absolute necessity in the First Century and in the Reformation era.
4. To argue, as some do, that our modern culture makes John Calvin's deaconesses unnecessary is backwards. On the contrary, we have a major problem in the modern evangelical church world with immorality and a fair case can be made that we need to be more careful, not less careful, about male-female interactions.
5. Whatever we call women working with other women, their work needs to be under the oversight of biblically qualified men, not independent of church authority. The category of "female assistants to male deacons" is fine with me. In the English language, I think it's best to avoid calling them "women deacons." If we're going to use that type of terminology at all, "deaconess" works better because it shows there is a difference between male deacons with authority and women whose role is purely service and not authority. But I'm fine with calling them "female assistants to male deacons" or avoiding any title at all. Encouraging women to serve without formal status may be the best approach in a lot of modern American contexts due to the problems caused by feminism. A woman who has the heart of a servant won't care about a title, and a woman who wants the title is already looking at things the wrong way.

Does that make sense? I think we agree, at least mostly so.
 
Last edited:
Acts 6:3, "Wherefore, brethren, look ye out among you seven men [ἀνήρ] of honest report, full of the Holy Ghost and wisdom, whom we may appoint over this business."
 
The case for women in the diaconate seems to frequently center around the alleged obscurity of certain Scripture passages and church tradition. I find this very telling.
 
I can't find anything you wrote here with which I disagree. If I understand you correctly, we're saying the same thing though perhaps with a different emphasis.

My background is not the PCA, but rather the Christian Reformed fight in which women in the diaconate turned into a wedge issue to get women elders. The result is that a fair number of Dutch Reformed conservatives have taken a hard stance against anything that looks, smells, or tastes like women in leadership, and my position on women in the diaconate looks suspect to both sides in that fight. I think I can make a fair claim that my position is that of John Calvin and of Geneva, and is close to if not identical to that of modern Korean Presbyterianism, but that's not "good enough" for the egalitarians and raises legitimate concerns by the conservatives that I am a "compromiser." I don't think so, but it's a fair concern and I do not at all object to being challenged on that point.

I think we would be in a much better place if everybody in the confessionally Reformed world could agree on these points:

1. Teaching and ruling the church are the responsibilities of biblically qualified men. No woman can serve as a pastor or elder, and that should also apply to de-facto elder roles in the church in which she teaches or rules over men.
2. Women, particularly older women, are encouraged by Scripture to mentor other women in a number of ways. (I'm avoiding being specific here on what ways because I know some in the Reformed world take the position that Proverbs 31 applies only to domestic duties and oppose women even teaching other women. I disagree but don't want to get into that debate.)
3. Certain types of interaction with women, in the culture of the ancient and late medieval world, simply could not be done with propriety by men. Some sort of role for "women serving women" was an absolute necessity in the First Century and in the Reformation era.
4. To argue, as some do, that our modern culture makes John Calvin's deaconesses unnecessary is backwards. On the contrary, we have a major problem in the modern evangelical church world with immorality and a fair case can be made that we need to be more careful, not less careful, about male-female interactions.
5. Whatever we call women working with other women, their work needs to be under the oversight of biblically qualified men, not independent of church authority. The category of "female assistants to male deacons" is fine with me. In the English language, I think it's best to avoid calling them "women deacons." If we're going to use that type of terminology at all, "deaconess" works better because it shows there is a difference between male deacons with authority and women whose role is purely service and not authority. But I'm fine with calling them "female assistants to male deacons" or avoiding any title at all. Encouraging women to serve without formal status may be the best approach in a lot of modern American contexts due to the problems caused by feminism. A woman who has the heart of a servant won't care about a title, and a woman who wants the title is already looking at things the wrong way.

Does that make sense? I think we agree, at least mostly so.
Yes. It makes sense. You need to have women working with the Deacons to handle sensitive issues. As long as it is understood that Deacons are an ordained office and that men are called to that ordained office, I think terms could be confusing to some and so it's better to just use Assistants to the Deacons as the PCA does.
 
Would the qualifications for deacons' wives in 1 Timothy 3:11 seem to indicate/prefer (if not require) that these female assistants to the deacons be their wives? Or at least that this would be the ideal, if not necessarily a requirement.
 
Would the qualifications for deacons' wives in 1 Timothy 3:11 seem to indicate/prefer (if not require) that these female assistants to the deacons be their wives? Or at least that this would be the ideal, if not necessarily a requirement.
That's where it gets tricky. Verse 11 is very much debatable in what the Greek is saying. The ESV translates it as "their wives", but the Greek could be translated to be talking about "the women deacons." This is where the main interpretation issues come from when it comes to women deacons.
 
That's where it gets tricky. Verse 11 is very much debatable in what the Greek is saying. The ESV translates it as "their wives", but the Greek could be translated to be talking about "the women deacons." This is where the main interpretation issues come from when it comes to women deacons.
I fully understand the debate over the word meaning "wives" or "women". However, for those of us who interpret it as "wives" wouldn't this indicate that if a church wants to have "assistants to the deacons" that this role would ideally be filled by the deacons' wives?
 
That could be a way of understanding it as far as I'm concerned. The way I typically think of it is that the wives of deacons are normally involved in helping them, whereas elders have to keep a lot of things confidential from their spouses.
 
That could be a way of understanding it as far as I'm concerned. The way I typically think of it is that the wives of deacons are normally involved in helping them, whereas elders have to keep a lot of things confidential from their spouses.
So...the wives are normally involved in helping them, i.e. they are "assistants to the deacons"...so why does the church need to designate a specific role and call it "assistants to the deacons"? Why not just call them the deacons' wives? ;)
 
So...the wives are normally involved in helping them, i.e. they are "assistants to the deacons"...so why does the church need to designate a specific role and call it "assistants to the deacons"? Why not just call them the deacons' wives? ;)
Amen!
 
I think you are missing my point. The practice of a male-led Diaconate with women who assist the Diaconate is not only something in Calvin's Geneva but goes back to early Church history. They were typically the "Widows". The issue has less to do with what one calls them but whether they are part of the leadership of the Diaconate. Biblically and historically, those ordained to the Diaconate were men with the Scriptural qualifications. Women (often the widows) performed diaconal work and could be called deaconesses, but they were under a Diaconate led by the men. Appeals to Calvin's Geneva only confirm how the PCA insists upon the ordination of men with the appointment of assistants to the deacons who are not ordained but perform essential work under the care and authority of the Diaconate.

The problem we have today are those who insist upon an egalitarian Diaconate. If women are to be part of the Diaconal work then, Biblically, they are to serve under the authority of ordained officers in the Diaconate. I'm less concerned about them being called Deaconesses as long as it is understood they are not ordained and not leading the Diaconal work.
Aren't all deacons and the diaconal work under the male leadership of the elders regardless? Likewise, isn't their authority limited to the authority of servants to do the bidding of masters, and their ordination, such as it is, to a role not of leadership but of service?

Historically, the wives of deacons have often performed service to the church under the headship of their husbands, but is there a scriptural example of a hierarchy beneath the elders within the diaconate, whether the term be confined to men or not?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top