Expressive Worship

Status
Not open for further replies.

Ryan&Amber2013

Puritan Board Graduate
I would be interested to get some feedback that I can better think through this. I have found that it is much easier for my heart to be engaged in worship, when I am able to physically be expressive. And I mean this in a decently and orderly, reverent way. Like when I am praying, sometimes I will look up, sometimes I will get on my knees, sometimes I will bow my head and close my eyes, sometimes I will lift up my hands. But I've noticed lately, when worshipping in song, what my hands and arms are doing really help me focus and engage my heart moreso. I looked into some passages that seem to justify this. I would appreciate some thoughts, especially pushback, so I can better reason in my mind. Thanks!
 
I think posture and position are important in worship. Regrettably, few Reformed churches practice any position besides sitting or standing. I think it would make sense to adopt kneeling as a common posture in prayer for example, or using outstretched arms to receive a benediction. I think the fear is often that these are either Romish or Pentecostal depending on your perspective, but you can find historic Reformed voices that advocate for such.
 
1 Timothy 2:8 KJV comes to mind.

Sadly I once heard of a man at a Reformed church being privately rebuked for lifting up his hands.

We say “Semper Reformanda” but do we believe it?

Have Reformed churches “overcorrected” when swerving to avoid any appearance of Pentecostalism? If church history is any indication, maybe. Maybe..
 
These are some passages that stand out to me.

Psalm 63:4 I will bless you as long as I live; in your name I will lift up my hands.

Psalm 141:2 Let my prayer be counted as incense before you, and the lifting up of my hands as the evening sacrifice!

Nehemiah 8:6 Then Ezra blessed the Lord the great God. And all the people answered, “Amen, Amen!” while lifting up their hands; then they bowed low and worshiped the Lord with their faces to the ground.

Psalm 134:2 Lift up your hands to the sanctuary and bless the Lord.

Lamentations 3:41 We lift up our heart and hands toward God in heaven;
 
I for one know that I have over compensated, being reared in the rather charismatic side of the Nazarene church.
 
You know, I was the frozenest of the chosen for a long, long while, and that in pride.
Now that I am an old woman, my mind and heart skips and leaps so during worship, and that in adoration of our good Lord.
Our congregation is very staid overall, so I keep my outward expressions such as few would notice.
I do love raising my face upward during the benediction, though.
 
Calvin on 1 Timothy 4:8

“8. For bodily exercise is of little profit. By the exercise "of the body," he does not mean that which lies in: hunting, or in the race-course, or in wrestling, or in digging, or in the mechanical occupations; but he gives that name to all the outward actions that are undertaken, for the sake of religion, such as watchings, long fasts, lying on the earth, and such like. Yet he does not here censure the superstitious observance of those things; otherwise he would totally condemn them, as he does in the Epistle to the Colossians, (Colossians 2:21,) but at present he only speaks slightingly of them, and says that they are of little advantage. So, then though the heart be altogether upright, and the object proper, yet, in outward actions, Paul finds nothing that he can value highly.”
 
Calvin on 1 Timothy 4:8

“8. For bodily exercise is of little profit. By the exercise "of the body," he does not mean that which lies in: hunting, or in the race-course, or in wrestling, or in digging, or in the mechanical occupations; but he gives that name to all the outward actions that are undertaken, for the sake of religion, such as watchings, long fasts, lying on the earth, and such like. Yet he does not here censure the superstitious observance of those things; otherwise he would totally condemn them, as he does in the Epistle to the Colossians, (Colossians 2:21,) but at present he only speaks slightingly of them, and says that they are of little advantage. So, then though the heart be altogether upright, and the object proper, yet, in outward actions, Paul finds nothing that he can value highly.”
Thanks for this. How would you sum this up?
 
These don't relate in the least with the passages referenced in post #4

Then, please explain the above-referenced passages (without relying on the unrelated exegesis of 1 Tim 4:8)
1. Not related at all? I think you’re overstating.

2. Let me rephrase: The sincerity and attitude of the heart (internal) towards God holds much more weight than external actions in worship almost to the point where they are useless. Almost. I think this is what Calvin thinks Paul is getting at in - Timothy 4:8. The verses in post #4 prove that they must have some benefit but when compared to the sincerity/attitude of the heart they ‘profiteth little’. Is that more palatable?

3. It’s possible Calvin’s wrong about what Paul is saying, and it’s possible I’m misunderstanding Calvin’s comment. The OP was looking for feedback. This seemed like an interesting counterpoint to what was said in the other posts. Just trying to add to the conversation is all, not trying to pick a fit in case you were wondering.
 
1. Not related at all? I think you’re overstating.

2. Let me rephrase: The sincerity and attitude of the heart (internal) towards God holds much more weight than external actions in worship almost to the point where they are useless. Almost. I think this is what Calvin thinks Paul is getting at in - Timothy 4:8. The verses in post #4 prove that they must have some benefit but when compared to the sincerity/attitude of the heart they ‘profiteth little’. Is that more palatable?

3. It’s possible Calvin’s wrong about what Paul is saying, and it’s possible I’m misunderstanding Calvin’s comment. The OP was looking for feedback. This seemed like an interesting counterpoint to what was said in the other posts. Just trying to add to the conversation is all, not trying to pick a fit in case you were wondering.
Thanks for this. I now see what you are saying.
 
Thank you. I appreciate that.
I think I agree with you. Would you say that raising hands, for example, if it being a natural flow from the affectionate heart towards God, is legitimate? So it's really the heart that matters, but the body expresses naturally what is in the heart.
 
I think I agree with you. Would you say that raising hands, for example, if it being a natural flow from the affectionate heart towards God, is legitimate? So it's really the heart that matters, but the body expresses naturally what is in the heart.
We’ll post 4 seems to prove it is legitimate. The question to me is “how helpful is it? Is there a better place to spend my energy? It turns out there is according to 1 Tim 4:8, Maybe? What do you think?
 
How is 1 Tim 2:8 to be understood, when Paul encourages men to "lift up holy hands"? Literally? Or is there another meaning?

I have found that for me, an appropriate physical posture can often be helpful, but I need to be careful. The moment my focus is more on whether I will or will not kneel / lift my hands / stand / bow my head etc. than the presence of the Lord, it has lost its meaning. Nothing special about the external act itself.
 
The Puritan George Newton in his exposition of John 17 has a section dealing with gesture in worship and is quite helpful.

Some quotes:

As for the gesture of your bodies, I shall commend these few things.

We are not bound to all the self-same gestures, which were in use among the people of the Lord of old; we read that Joshua and the Elders when they were routed at the Siege of Ai, and came before the Ark of God to pray, they rent their cloaths and put dust upon their heads, Joshua 7.16. And Hezekiah when he came into the house of God to pray, at the time when Sennacherib besieged Jerusalem, he rent his clothes, and put on Sack-cloth, Isa. 37.1. And this they did, not that these fashions were appropriated to the worship of the Lord, but because they were in use in those times and those places, to express their grief by; So in the self-same place in Joshua, they fell down to the ground upon their faces when they prayed. And so did Jesus Christ himself, as you may see, Mat. 26.39. Not that this gesture was peculiar to this piece of service, but it was taken from the civil usage of the Country, because this was their way of shewing reverence to superiors, as you may see, Ruth 2.10. And therefore we do well and suitably to the directions and examples of the Scripture, that we take up such gestures only in our prayers as are usual in our Country, to express our sorrow and dejection, or else our civil reverence and respect by.

Those reverend gestures which we use in prayer should be most observed in public. There may more liberty be taken in private, and in secret, then there may in public and open prayer, both in the use of outward gesture, and in the forbearance of them. Some gestures may be used in private prayer which would become us ill in public, in which we should not go remarkably beyond the rest of the Assembly for fear and danger of hypocrisy: And gestures on the other side may be forborne in some case in private prayer, which yet in public ought not to be so; For evermore in public (as far as it is possible) our gesture must be such as may express some reverence, and devotion, that we may honour God before the People, and that our outward posture may not carry in it an appearance of a slight esteem of God, and of his service; whereas in private there is greater freedom, because indeed there is no need of such Caution.

But thirdly this must be continually heeded both in public, and in private, that the gestures which we use be such, as that we do not hinder, but rather further the spiritual service. It were far better to abate of the reverence of our gesture, then the affection of our heart. It were far better for a man to stand in prayer, than that by the disease and trouble of the other posture he should be distracted, and consequently his devotion, and his heart should fall. That may be allowed the weak in this regard, which would not be convenient in the strong. The bodily exercise; be it of what kind it will, is but a means to the spiritual service. The end is better then the means; and must be more regarded then the means. I must not use the means but for the end, so far as they are serviceable to the end. And much less, must I use the means against the end.

We must be very wary that the outward gesture (especially in public prayer) do not exceed the inward affection, and that we make not shew of more without then there is indeed within; for if we do, there is hypocrisy; Such duties are not done in truth, when there is more in shew, and in appearance, then there is in substance. If either of the two be lower then the other, it were far better that the outward expression were lower then the inward affection, then that the inward, &c. It were far better that the gesture came short of the heart, then that the heart, &c. It is not good to compass God about with lies, mere shows do never please in his service.

Full section here: https://quod.lib.umich.edu/e/eebo2/A52249.0001.001/1:7.2.1?rgn=div3;view=fulltext
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Dr. James Tour kneels when he prays prior to presenting his materials at various churches. He does so from the stage or podium, but doesn’t encourage anyone else to follow suit. He strikes me as much more sincere than showy. I think we ought to be charitable as it relates to external expressions in worship, lest we be guilty of evil surmising. Hearts are unknowable, after all, and as much as possible we ought to not make judgments by mere appearance.
 
Dr. James Tour kneels when he prays prior to presenting his materials at various churches. He does so from the stage or podium, but doesn’t encourage anyone else to follow suit. He strikes me as much more sincere than showy. I think we ought to be charitable as it relates to external expressions in worship, lest we be guilty of evil surmising. Hearts are unknowable, after all, and as much as possible we ought to not make judgments by mere appearance.
I’ve noticed that from Tour also. He has never struck me as an insincere man. Rather courageous in my opinion.
 
I’ve noticed that from Tour also. He has never struck me as an insincere man. Rather courageous in my opinion.
I agree. I think we ought to see more externally expressive worship in Reformed circles. I don’t think we ought to stir it up in ourselves or others in a fleshly or emotional way, or in a forced and mechanical way. I think that would be entirely inappropriate.

But where ever there is authentic external expressions based on what is to be found internally in heartfelt abundance, it ought to be tolerated at the very least, if not regarded warmly. I respect the position of the man who said it’s of little value, but I somewhat disagree. I think that it’s certainly of little value compared to what is inwardly heartfelt and unexpressed, but I don’t think it needs to be an either/or. I think it ought to be a both/and.

When we have our various prayer meetings, with our heads bowed and eyes closed, are we not lifted up by the zealous and heartfelt external expressions of our brothers and sisters in Christ? Can we not discern the difference between a cold prayer meeting and a warm one? Are we not rather more encouraged by the warm ones? Now here we are dealing with external expressions also, aren’t we? But instead of what is apprehended with the eye (such as lifting up holy hands), we are in part dealing with what is apprehended by the ear.

Elijah stretched his body over the son of the widow’s body. We know it profited little, in one sense, because trying to warm the boy’s body with his body would scarcely put the boy’s soul back in his body. Yet as an expression of heartfelt sympathy and earnestness, doing everything he could in a creaturely way to convey his sincere desire before the Lord, in accompaniment with strong pleading, I think it is a wonderful picture and example for us.

So I really think these things ought to be tolerated at the very least, friends, if not encouraged. Let the Pentecostals say what they may - much spoken in their tongue is unintelligible anyway.

:2cents:
 
I don't think anyone has yet mentioned the distinction (sorry if I missed it), but it may be helpful to distinguish between private and public worship. I think Reformed folk are often accused of being the frozen chosen, but actually, hopefully, principles derived from the RPW are what's at work; with the glory of God and the good of his people as the desired end. Uniformity in public worship is a great blessing.
 
I don't think anyone has yet mentioned the distinction (sorry if I missed it), but it may be helpful to distinguish between private and public worship. I think Reformed folk are often accused of being the frozen chosen, but actually, hopefully, principles derived from the RPW are what's at work; with the glory of God and the good of his people as the desired end. Uniformity in public worship is a great blessing.
@Jeri Tanner the quote in post #22 addresses this.
 
Someone reconcile for me a denial of hand actions but an acceptance for outstretched hands of the minister in the benediction
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top