Knoxienne
Puritan Board Graduate
It's too bad that Jane Austen it thought of as girly writing. I think men miss good literature by not reading her. I don't think a secular book should be read primarily for the story line. You miss so much good lit if that's why you read. One should read primarily to enjoy the artistic ability the writer has. You will find great artistic ability in the writings of the Bronte sisters, for example...especially Emily!
I've tried to get into Jane Austen and I just can't. I even tried reading Persuasion after seeing The Lake House and still couldn't enjoy it. And it's frustrating, because everyone loves her!

-----Added 5/29/2009 at 06:50:49 EST-----
I tend to love Jane Austen and Elizabeth Gaskell novels. Also, there's a great little book by Elizabeth Prentiss called Stepping Heavenward! Its wonderful, you would really love it based on the books you already mentioned!
Stepping Heavenward is great! I highly recommend that one.