Is cursing a sin?

Ezekiel

Puritan Board Freshman
I struggle with foul language when I watch college football, but I read someone say that it is more about the intent than the word itself. Is this true?
 
The subject of this thread and the OP are talking about two different things. Cursing is not always and everywhere a sin. Foul language (cussing, profanity, vulgarity, coarse jesting, obscene speech) is a sin: it's unseemly and unbecoming.

Ephesians 4:29: Let no corrupt communication proceed out of your mouth, but that which is good to the use of edifying, that it may minister grace unto the hearers.

Ephesians 5:3-4: But fornication, and all uncleanness, or covetousness, let it not be once named among you, as becometh saints; neither filthiness, nor foolish talking, nor jesting, which are not convenient: but rather giving of thanks.

Colossians 3:8: But now ye also put off all these; anger, wrath, malice, blasphemy, filthy communication out of your mouth.

Colossians 4:6: Let your speech be always with grace, seasoned with salt, that ye may know how ye ought to answer every man.

That was my main point. I'll offer two further thoughts by way of explication: first, coarse language is not exactly the same as taking the Lord's name in vain, though the two overlap. If watching college football causes you to use the names of God and Jesus as interjections, or in any other trivial manner, then let me unequivocally urge you to stop that behavior right now, "for the Lord will not hold him guiltless that taketh his name in vain".

Second: the topic of coarse language is debated in some parts of the Reformed world. You have people like Doug Wilson and Mark Driscoll making varied arguments for the permissibility of strong or "edgy" language in certain circumstances. The kernel of truth here is that we as a society have been pushed into a feminized "niceness" and "winsomeness" which is wholly unbiblical. But graphic or explicit language and coarse jesting is not the Bible's answer. It might, perhaps, be the answer of a pagan Roman or Greek society that esteems domination and subjugation as marks of manliness. The Bible calls us to true manhood and so we ought to despise the castrated mode of speech which our culture imposes on conservative Christians but nobody else, but we ought to respond to it with the Bible's conception of true manhood.

In my estimation, the Bible's conception of true manhood is respectful and self-controlled: meek, like a powerful horse tamed by bit and bridle. In such a conception, doctrinal clarity and forthrightness of speech are essential. In such a conception, foul language, cussing, coarse jesting, demeaning or graphic humor: none of these have any place in the Christian's life, whether in a traffic jam, a college football game, or any other setting. They are habits to be broken.

Lest I seem to be moralizing, I will state that I am preaching to myself here. For years I regularly practiced all the sins listed in those Bible passages and took pleasure in shocking even unbelievers with the vulgarity of my tongue. I was unbelievably profane. I lament that, far too often, traces of such vocabulary flit across my mind. I would not want to be in the presence of a mind-reader when I stub my toe or drop something made of glass. Years of cussing and obscenity shaped my mind, and I would gladly undo that. I do not wish to moralize nor do I wish in any way to assert that a squeaky clean tongue makes one a better Christian. I only wish to state that I think it is a clear teaching of Scripture that foul language is incompatible with the way of life to which Christ calls his children, and for your spiritual benefit I encourage you to break the habit.
 
What sounds count as foul is dependent on spoken language and culture. Hence the signs at the border between Guatemala and Mexico asking Mexicans not to use some characteristic language in Guatemala.

But you speak a particular language and are immersed in a particular culture. In that setting, these sounds have certain associations. You can't just be Humpty Dumpty and mean something different by them; there's a reason your brain sends those words to your tongue under certain circumstances.

I concur with JP that it's time to stop using that kind of language. Addressing that more fully may include asking why you mean certain things under the condition of watching college football that apparently you don't mean in other settings.
 
A section from George Herbert’s The Church Porch. He is specifically speaking about using the Lord’s name in vain, but I think it can be applied to other filthy language as well. His conclusion: sins of the tongue are sins which do not even bring the sinner temporal benefits (unlike theft or lust).

“Take not his name, who made thy mouth, in vain:
It gets thee nothing, and hath no excuse.
Lust and wine plead a pleasure, avarice gain:
But the cheap swearer through his open sluce
Lets his soul runne for nought, as little fearing.
Were I an Epicure, I could bate swearing.

When thou dost tell anothers jest, therein
Omit the oathes, which true wit cannot need:
Pick out of tales the mirth, but not the sinne.
He pares his apple, that will cleanly feed.
Play not away the vertue of that name,
Which is thy best stake, when griefs make thee tame.

The cheapest sinnes most dearely punisht are;
Because to shun them also is so cheap:
For we have wit to mark them, and to spare.
O crumble not away thy souls fair heap.
If thou wilt die, the gates of hell are broad:
Pride and full sinnes have made the way a road.“
 
What sounds count as foul is dependent on spoken language and culture. Hence the signs at the border between Guatemala and Mexico asking Mexicans not to use some characteristic language in Guatemala.

But you speak a particular language and are immersed in a particular culture. In that setting, these sounds have certain associations. You can't just be Humpty Dumpty and mean something different by them; there's a reason your brain sends those words to your tongue under certain circumstances.

I concur with JP that it's time to stop using that kind of language. Addressing that more fully may include asking why you mean certain things under the condition of watching college football that apparently you don't mean in other settings.
I don't mean it in other settings, because it's the regional norm to curse only with other men (obviously not in front of the elderly, women, and children), but even then, I wouldn't say the Lord's name in vain at all.

Sorry, but I don't understand what you're trying to say.
 
Last edited:
I don't mean it in other settings, because it's the regional norm to curse only with other men (obviously not in front of the elderly, women, and children), but even then, I wouldn't say the Lord's name in vain at all.

Sorry, but I don't understand what you're trying to say.

No problem, I can try again. It sounds to me like you have two solid steps already taken here. 1) You've identified the situation (college football) and 2) You've identified the dynamic (only other men).

At this point, I see three options.
a) Consider that it is within adequate boundaries and carry on.
b) See if that awareness of the situation and dynamic is enough for you to be able to break it off just through catching yourself.
c) Dig a little deeper, and ask: "Why does this situation and this dynamic tend to elicit this behavior?"

From my point of view, Option C has the potential to identify room for growth that Option A bypasses and Option B minimizes. For example, Option C might highlight that the restraints on your language in other situations are chafing a bit and so it's a relief to take a break from them; or it might show that a desire to fit in with others is exerting undue pressure on you. Or it might show something completely different, it's hard to anticipate since people are complicated. But whatever it is, knowing that about yourself brings some clarity to what kind of issue you are facing.
 
No problem, I can try again. It sounds to me like you have two solid steps already taken here. 1) You've identified the situation (college football) and 2) You've identified the dynamic (only other men).

At this point, I see three options.
a) Consider that it is within adequate boundaries and carry on.
b) See if that awareness of the situation and dynamic is enough for you to be able to break it off just through catching yourself.
c) Dig a little deeper, and ask: "Why does this situation and this dynamic tend to elicit this behavior?"

From my point of view, Option C has the potential to identify room for growth that Option A bypasses and Option B minimizes. For example, Option C might highlight that the restraints on your language in other situations are chafing a bit and so it's a relief to take a break from them; or it might show that a desire to fit in with others is exerting undue pressure on you. Or it might show something completely different, it's hard to anticipate since people are complicated. But whatever it is, knowing that about yourself brings some clarity to what kind of issue you are facing.
I might be the desire to fit in with others exerting undue pressure on me, and I doubt saying "same [blankety-blank], different day" is a sin.
 
Here is what Wise tells Attentive about cursing in "The Life and Death of Mr. Badman".

This evil of Cursing ariseth, in general, from the desperate wickedness of the heart, but particularly from, 1. Envy, which is, as I apprehend, the leading sin to Witchcraft. 2. It also ariseth from Pride which was the sin of the fallen Angels; 3. It ariseth too from Scorn and contempt of others: 4. But for a man to curse himself, must needs arise from desperate Madness.

The dishonour that it bringeth to God, is this. It taketh away from him his Authority, in whose power it is only, to Bless and Curse; not to Curse wickedly, as Mr. Badman, but justly, and righteously, giving by his Curse to those that are wicked, the due Reward of their deeds. Besides, these wicked men, in their wicked cursing of their Neighbour, &c. do even Curse God himself in his handy work. Man is God's Image, and to curse wickedly the Image of God is to curse God himself.
 
I might be the desire to fit in with others exerting undue pressure on me, and I doubt saying "same [blankety-blank], different day" is a sin.
Are these friends believers? If not in your speech, in what ways are you living a "set-apart" life in the presence of your unbelieving friends? Or are you just like them?
 
Are these friends believers? If not in your speech, in what ways are you living a "set-apart" life in the presence of your unbelieving friends? Or are you just like them?
I just went cursing, so it might be easy for me to nip it in the bud.

I dress Plain, but I don't have on barn-door britches and galluses. I'm not the only one doing this; some ladies at church have on caps and dresses.
 
Last edited:
I dress Plain, but I don't wear barn-door britches and galluses. In fact, I just went to cursing, so it might be easy for me to break it off just through catching myself.
Why did you bother bringing this up on the forum? You come off as totally disinterested in what anyone has to say. You've clearly already decided whether it's okay for you to curse.
 
Why did you bother bringing this up on the forum? You come off as totally disinterested in what anyone has to say. You've clearly already decided whether it's okay for you to curse.
I just answered your question, and I realized you all are right that cursing is a sin.
 
Last edited:
I struggle with foul language when I watch college football, but I read someone say that it is more about the intent than the word itself. Is this true?

A few questions:

Would you feel comfortable using the type of language you use when watching college football with the fellas if your grandmother was present? What about if Christ were present? Why or why not?

Why do you specifically use it when watching football and not other times? Do you think it'd be appropriate at other times, say at a Bible study? If not, then why would it be appropriate in one situation and not another?

I dress Plain, but I don't have on barn-door britches and galluses. I'm not the only one doing this; some ladies at church have on caps and dresses.
Physical modesty is a good thing, but plain dress does not a Christian make. It may be one element that can set the Christian apart from unbelievers, but it is not something particular to Christians. There have been and continue to be people who are outwardly modest in what they wear, but do not know Christ.
 
A few questions:

Would you feel comfortable using the type of language you use when watching college football with the fellas if your grandmother was present? What about if Christ were present? Why or why not?

Why do you specifically use it when watching football and not other times? Do you think it'd be appropriate at other times, say at a Bible study? If not, then why would it be appropriate in one situation and not another?


Physical modesty is a good thing, but plain dress does not a Christian make. It may be one element that can set the Christian apart from unbelievers, but it is not something particular to Christians. There have been and continue to be people who are outwardly modest in what they wear, but do not know Christ.
I thought it was appropriate to curse with other men, and then I realized that the sixth commandment requires courteous speeches and behavior no matter what.

Also, I did not say plain dress makes a Christian. Faithhopelove24 was asking me other ways I live set apart from my unbelieving friends. I don't know how I came off as totally disinterested in what anyone has to say.
 
Last edited:
Also, I did not say plain dress makes a Christian. Faithhopelove24 was asking me other ways I live set apart from my unbelieving friends.
I know, I didn't think you were saying that.

I was just merely mentioning that in living set apart from unbelievers, modesty or plain dress aren't definitive marks particular to the Christian. For context, there are many in my state, and throughout the south who dress modestly and hold that as a sort of "badge" of Christianity, though they do not love their neighbor. In considering the topic of living set apart compared to our unbelieving friends, I was reminded of this.
 
Physical modesty is a good thing, but plain dress does not a Christian make. It may be one element that can set the Christian apart from unbelievers, but it is not something particular to Christians. There have been and continue to be people who are outwardly modest in what they wear, but do not know Christ.
I hate that it draws attention. I read in a book that's why dressing weird is bordering on vulgar, but on the other hand, the book is against immodesty. saying that "extravagance is the greatest vulgarity."
 
I hate that it draws attention. I read in a book that's why dressing weird is bordering on vulgar, but on the other hand, the book is against immodesty. saying that "extravagance is the greatest vulgarity."
This is an interesting topic and I'd like to go more into it, though it may be better for another thread so as to not get off topic on this one, but that's your call.

Could you give some examples? I think there's a way to dress respectfully and modestly as a man without looking like a 17th century puritan (as much as I'd like to dress like that...) or 19th century farmhand and drawing a ton of attention to ourselves. I suppose my question is, what is meant by "plain dress". I'm used to the matching black denim broadfall trousers, braces, and jackets of the Amish in that category, but I do see you mentioned it not being that.
 
I doubt saying "same [blankety-blank], different day" is a sin.

A bit of analysis is useful here. The sounds aren't sinful. The connotations and flavor of words are a matter of expectation, which is influenced by culture. That's why a list of proscribed words isn't really the point. Rather, there are questions of intent and communication.

You've already ruled out blasphemous language, which is good. What's left under the general heading of "cursing," "foul language," and other blanket terms that are used with some elasticity, can fall into a couple of different categories:
1. There is contemptuous language, where words and expressions are used to belittle.
2. There is hostile language, where words and expressions are used to express malevolence.
3. There is vulgar language, where words and expressions are chosen that refer to actual things, but in an unnecessary or crude way.
4. There is obscene language, where words and expressions referent to sexual matter are brought in unnecessarily or crudely.

One can do all of these things without resorting to particular words, but of course, there are words that are linked to these kinds of language by default. Each of these is a little bit different, and obviously things can overlap. One might contemptuously express malevolence towards another by the use of crude expressions, for instance.

But there are three general points here:
1. One can quote or allude to improper language without intending it, if necessary for the sake of making things clear (1 Cor. 12:3).
2. Although there may be times (verifiable in different parts of Scripture) when these different kinds of language have an appropriate use, it can't be all the time. Because their effectiveness depends on shock value, and the more they are used the less value of that kind they have.
3. The use of language with shock value has various purposes, as:
a. To emphasize
b. To agitate
c. To express or relieve strong feeling
d. To amuse

For each category, one can ask whether the situation warrants the deployment of such language, and the condition of heart from which it arises. If I stub my toe, why would scatological language be the proper way to express the pain and frustration I feel? What does that say about me?

Perhaps this seems like a lot of effort expended on a minor area, but Matthew 12:33-37 indicates that speech reflects the heart (and so it's very illuminating about our own condition), and that our use of language is not a minor matter.
 
I thought it was appropriate to curse with other men, and then I realized that the sixth commandment requires courteous speeches and behavior no matter what.

Also, I did not say plain dress makes a Christian. Faithhopelove24 was asking me other ways I live set apart from my unbelieving friends. I don't know how I came off as totally disinterested in what anyone has to say.
Here's what my email notification says you originally said, which you then updated 2 or 3 times:

"In this weather, I wear a henley underneath my flannel, and a denim coat with just quilted lining, a lay-down collar, and snap closure, but all year round, I wear a optimo-crown hat and a full-button shirt (chambray in the heat) tucked into my dungarees with a belt.

I don't use the TikTok or anything like that."



When that is your response to me inquiring about a set-apart life, a holy life, it came across as snarky. Maybe I misinterpreted.

Are you from the States originally? Perhaps there are some cultural differences coming through that are causing confusion.
 
Here's what my email notification says you originally said, which you then updated 2 or 3 times:

"In this weather, I wear a henley underneath my flannel, and a denim coat with just quilted lining, a lay-down collar, and snap closure, but all year round, I wear a optimo-crown hat and a full-button shirt (chambray in the heat) tucked into my dungarees with a belt.

I don't use the TikTok or anything like that."



When that is your response to me inquiring about a set-apart life, a holy life, it came across as snarky. Maybe I misinterpreted.

Are you from the States originally? Perhaps there are some cultural differences coming through that are causing confusion.
I am from the States originally, but there might be some cultural difference. We speak bluntly, but you still need context. The Amish are common here, and for religious reasons, they dress like that but with barn-door britches and galluses. Are you from a region where the Amish aren't a thing?
 
Last edited:
Back
Top