Paedo-Baptism Answers John Owen's Argument

Status
Not open for further replies.

DanM

Puritan Board Freshman
Hello all,
I was reading John Owen "of Infant baptism" and in it he says:
"Fifthly, God having appointed baptism as the sign and seal of regeneration, unto whom he denies it, he denies the grace signified by it. Why is it the will of God that unbelievers and impenitent sinners should not be baptized? It is because, not granting them the grace, he will not grant them the sign."
And I was wondering how this relates specifically to the children of unbelievers. Is Owen arguing for a universal damnation of the children of unbelievers who die in their infancy?
Or how else might it be understood that unto whom God denies the sign He denies also the grace when children of unbelievers are not to be baptised?
Similarly it seems inconsistent to say that infants should be baptised because they may be granted the grace signified, yet unbelievers should not be baptised because they do not yet have the grace signified although they may in future be converted.

Am I misunderstanding this section of Owen's argument?

Would any of you ever use this sort of argument?

(Just to clarify, I do hold to paedobaptism and the other arguments Owen puts forth in this document are seem much more convincing)
 
I was reading John Owen "of Infant baptism" and in it he says:
"Fifthly, God having appointed baptism as the sign and seal of regeneration, unto whom he denies it, he denies the grace signified by it. Why is it the will of God that unbelievers and impenitent sinners should not be baptized? It is because, not granting them the grace, he will not grant them the sign."
Here's a few quotes mostly from Owen volume 16, and one from volume 3:
~~~~~~~​

“The church is taken in Scripture either for the whole number of the elect, or for the visible professors of the faith of the gospel; in which latter sense, the infants of believers are members of the church.”
— Of the Nature of a Gospel Church (Works, vol. 16)

“The covenant made with Abraham is the same for substance with that whereinto believers are now taken; and the privilege of the infants of believers is not cut off by the coming of Christ.”
— The Works of John Owen, vol. 16

“Baptism succeeds in the room of circumcision, as the sign and token of the covenant of God.”
— Of the Administration of the Covenant (Works, vol. 16)

“The holiness of children mentioned by the apostle is not internal and inherent, but federal and relative, arising from their relation unto the covenant.”
— Of Infant Baptism (Works, vol. 16)

“We do not ascribe unto baptism the conferring of grace, nor the regeneration of the baptized.”
— Discourse on the Holy Spirit (Works, vol. 3)

“The rejection of infant baptism hath no foundation in Scripture, nor in the practice of the church of God in any age.”
— Works, vol. 16 (paraphrased summary; Owen makes this claim repeatedly in polemic)
 
Hello all,
I was reading John Owen "of Infant baptism" and in it he says:
"Fifthly, God having appointed baptism as the sign and seal of regeneration, unto whom he denies it, he denies the grace signified by it. Why is it the will of God that unbelievers and impenitent sinners should not be baptized? It is because, not granting them the grace, he will not grant them the sign."
And I was wondering how this relates specifically to the children of unbelievers. Is Owen arguing for a universal damnation of the children of unbelievers who die in their infancy?
Or how else might it be understood that unto whom God denies the sign He denies also the grace when children of unbelievers are not to be baptised?
Similarly it seems inconsistent to say that infants should be baptised because they may be granted the grace signified, yet unbelievers should not be baptised because they do not yet have the grace signified although they may in future be converted.

Am I misunderstanding this section of Owen's argument?

Would any of you ever use this sort of argument?

(Just to clarify, I do hold to paedobaptism and the other arguments Owen puts forth in this document are seem much more convincing)

He says: "If you say infants should not be baptised, then you deny that infants can be saved."

He argues for infant baptism. He says the reason unbelievers are not to be baptised is because they do not have the grace signified by baptism. And so, by implication, you put infants into the same category of unbelievers if you deny them baptism; that is, in essence you are saying God denies them too (the infants) the grace signifed by baptism, by denying them baptism.
 
He says: "If you say infants should not be baptised, then you deny that infants can be saved."

He argues for infant baptism. He says the reason unbelievers are not to be baptised is because they do not have the grace signified by baptism. And so, by implication, you put infants into the same category of unbelievers if you deny them baptism; that is, in essence you are saying God denies them too (the infants) the grace signifed by baptism, by denying them baptism.
Thanks!
That's a very helpful summary
But if we took your first sentence and substitute "infant" for "infant born to unbelievers" we would get: "If you say infants of unbelievers should not be baptised, then you deny that infants of unbelievers can be saved" so does this particular argument for infant baptism end up arguing for the universal damnation of infants of unbelievers dying in infancy as well?
 
Last edited:
But if we took your first sentence and substitute "infant" for "infant born to unbelievers" we would get: "If you say infants of unbelievers should not be baptised, then you deny that infants of unbelievers can be saved" so does this particular argument for infant baptism end up arguing for the universal damnation of infants of unbelievers dying in infancy as well?

Owen only has in view infants of believers. He argues for their baptism.

Owen reasons upon Scripture. In his view, God says, "I will be a God unto you and unto your children", meaning, believers and their children.

You ask if he implies to say the children of unbelievers are going to hell. Knowing his writings a bit, I would say that yes, generally speaking, that would be the case. Although the puritans acknowledged special situations and exceptions. It's like, generally speaking, people who never heard of Christ preached unto them go to hell, too. Nevertheless, God may do some wonderful things at times (maybe dreams, visions, all kind of mediums which may be used outside the word preached), and work outside his usual procedure.

It's just reasoning from Scripture. If God will be a God unto believers and their children, then not upon unbelievers and their children.
 
You ask if he implies to say the children of unbelievers are going to hell. Knowing his writings a bit, I would say that yes, generally speaking, that would be the case.
Thank you,
This is what I was asking for, I understand that Owen is only speaking about infants of believers. I was merely trying to understand the logic and subsequent conclusions of this particular argument as it is the first time I have come across it.
 
Thank you,
This is what I was asking for, I understand that Owen is only speaking about infants of believers. I was merely trying to understand the logic and subsequent conclusions of this particular argument as it is the first time I have come across it.

He is speaking of an ordinance of God, in which God signifies His will to us and gives us ordinary expectations of what He will do. On that level of human expectancy Owen is making the argument of what God will and will not do, that is, ordinarily. It is not limiting what God will actually do, but what we as believers can expect Him to do in accord with His revealed will. In Reformed theology we say that there is no "ordinary" possibility of salvation outside the catholic church. The word "ordinary" is expressing what we can expect on the human level. It leaves room for God to work above and beyond our expectations.
 
Thank you,
This is what I was asking for, I understand that Owen is only speaking about infants of believers. I was merely trying to understand the logic and subsequent conclusions of this particular argument as it is the first time I have come across it.
Arguably unbelievers (children or otherwise) are generally in a separate category of those in the covenant (children or otherwise). So the covenant sign is baptism, hence the verse quoted above.
Many years ago I ventured into an error in thinking about baptism, that may be helpful here, that something could happen to the child whatever that is at the moment of baptism. As long as we don't demand that it happens (contra the confessions) at the moment of baptism (baptismal regeneration).
My error was in trying (and this was pointed out to me by many good friends on here) to speculate beyond what scripture said. Yes baptism is a means of grace but without the covenant context that we place the sign of the covenant upon professing believers (examined by the session) and their children we get lost in speculation beyond scripture.
So because unbelievers should not be, but maybe, in the external covenant then the sign is not to be placed upon them or their children. Can God act outside His ordinary ways? Yes but it's extra ordinary.
So the internal covenant is where the grace of baptism is actually applied to the believer (child or otherwise). But we as humans don't have any control over the internal covenant but are commanded of how to operate the external covenant relations and rites.
 
Arguably unbelievers (children or otherwise) are generally in a separate category of those in the covenant (children or otherwise). So the covenant sign is baptism, hence the verse quoted above.
Many years ago I ventured into an error in thinking about baptism, that may be helpful here, that something could happen to the child whatever that is at the moment of baptism. As long as we don't demand that it happens (contra the confessions) at the moment of baptism (baptismal regeneration).
My error was in trying (and this was pointed out to me by many good friends on here) to speculate beyond what scripture said. Yes baptism is a means of grace but without the covenant context that we place the sign of the covenant upon professing believers (examined by the session) and their children we get lost in speculation beyond scripture.
So because unbelievers should not be, but maybe, in the external covenant then the sign is not to be placed upon them or their children. Can God act outside His ordinary ways? Yes but it's extra ordinary.
So the internal covenant is where the grace of baptism is actually applied to the believer (child or otherwise). But we as humans don't have any control over the internal covenant but are commanded of how to operate the external covenant relations and rites.
Wouldn't it be better to speak of internal and external administrations of the same covenant, rather than an internal covenant and an external covenant? Surely there is no covenant of God that entails only external particpation.
 
Wouldn't it be better to speak of internal and external administrations of the same covenant, rather than an internal covenant and an external covenant? Surely there is no covenant of God that entails only external particpation.
You're correct. I was just focused on the internal/external aspects.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top