DanM
Puritan Board Freshman
Hello all,
I was reading John Owen "of Infant baptism" and in it he says:
"Fifthly, God having appointed baptism as the sign and seal of regeneration, unto whom he denies it, he denies the grace signified by it. Why is it the will of God that unbelievers and impenitent sinners should not be baptized? It is because, not granting them the grace, he will not grant them the sign."
And I was wondering how this relates specifically to the children of unbelievers. Is Owen arguing for a universal damnation of the children of unbelievers who die in their infancy?
Or how else might it be understood that unto whom God denies the sign He denies also the grace when children of unbelievers are not to be baptised?
Similarly it seems inconsistent to say that infants should be baptised because they may be granted the grace signified, yet unbelievers should not be baptised because they do not yet have the grace signified although they may in future be converted.
Am I misunderstanding this section of Owen's argument?
Would any of you ever use this sort of argument?
(Just to clarify, I do hold to paedobaptism and the other arguments Owen puts forth in this document are seem much more convincing)
I was reading John Owen "of Infant baptism" and in it he says:
"Fifthly, God having appointed baptism as the sign and seal of regeneration, unto whom he denies it, he denies the grace signified by it. Why is it the will of God that unbelievers and impenitent sinners should not be baptized? It is because, not granting them the grace, he will not grant them the sign."
And I was wondering how this relates specifically to the children of unbelievers. Is Owen arguing for a universal damnation of the children of unbelievers who die in their infancy?
Or how else might it be understood that unto whom God denies the sign He denies also the grace when children of unbelievers are not to be baptised?
Similarly it seems inconsistent to say that infants should be baptised because they may be granted the grace signified, yet unbelievers should not be baptised because they do not yet have the grace signified although they may in future be converted.
Am I misunderstanding this section of Owen's argument?
Would any of you ever use this sort of argument?
(Just to clarify, I do hold to paedobaptism and the other arguments Owen puts forth in this document are seem much more convincing)