Pilgrim's Progress

Status
Not open for further replies.

satz

Puritan Board Senior
I chance i came across an old copy of this and have gone about 80% of the way though.

Anyone want to comment on this?

The theology? accurate? any...shifty parts?

As a novel/story? How entertaining?
 
It is said that Pilgrim's Progress is the most read Christian book after the Bible.

It is very profitable.
 
hmmm....

looks like rave reviews so far...

hai..the copy doesn't belong to me...so i really rushed though it...but those glowing reviews now make me regret that...:banghead:
 
I have yet to read it. Are the updated versions acceptable? I mean in modern language, not the ones that tweak the story.
 
Well, the first review makes it sound pretty safe!

Hazelbaker has done an exceptional job of making Bunyan's beautiful classic more appealing to the modern audience. This unabridged version is suitable for readers from middle and upper elementary ages to adults. I am glad to see that Hazelbaker has taken the time and made the effort to offer his audience a version of Pilgrim's Progress that is not watered-down and compromised. It definitely deserves a place in any library.

Thanks Andrew.
 
The book is GREAT!! It has been many years since I've read the book and I should read it again.

It comes HIGHLY recommended! :up:
 
I honestly cannot see what educated adult should not read it in the original version. I think that modern updates lose something....

Rather like comparing some of the grander passages of the KJV with the NASB.

I have a lovely one from about 1850 with the full Pilgrim's Progress, parts 1 and 2, and the Holy War.

Love it, just love it. It was said that Spurgeon read it once every year of his adult life. It would honestly do us no harm to do the same!

All this said, of course it is a bit tough for children, but there is a wonderful adaptation called 'Little Pilgrim's Progress' by Helen Taylor, which I read to my son, who is 7. He loves it. I can hardly contain myself sometimes, reading it to him.

JH
 
Originally posted by JonathanHunt

I honestly cannot see what educated adult should not read it in the original version. I think that modern updates lose something....

I agree. Go with the original. It will be worth it. If you are reading the Puritans from that era it won't be a problem for you.

It was said that Spurgeon read it once every year of his adult life. It would honestly do us no harm to do the same!

That is true of Spurgeon. We could follow far worse examples and not many better!
 
Originally posted by JonathanHunt
All this said, of course it is a bit tough for children, but there is a wonderful adaptation called 'Little Pilgrim's Progress' by Helen Taylor, which I read to my son, who is 7. He loves it. I can hardly contain myself sometimes, reading it to him.

JH

Are there any editions for even younger children, like, say, 3-4 years old? Board books? Good illustrations, perhaps?
 
Highly recommended reading, read it, read it again, read it again, then read it to your kids, read it to your wife. I ussually keep a few copies around for people I meet who haven't read it. It's my third favorite book, 1. the Bible, 2. Guthrie "The Christians Great Interest", 3. Bunyan's Pilgrim's Progress.
 
I don't want to make you guys too jealous, but...
at the church I attend they have it on cassette format, read in the original version. I checked it out and could listen to it as I was going to bed. Talk about "redeeming the time!"

I need to get it back and copy it since I'm moving soon.
I'm also copying to DVD Gerstner's tape series on "The Westminster Confession of Faith" and his "Lectures on Church History."

Gerstner is good! Its AMAZING how much he sounds like RC Sproul! (I know, I know, RC sounds like HIM, not the other way around!)
 
The Pilgrim's Progress is outstanding. I first read the book in college along with Langland's Piers the Ploughman, The Book of Margery Kempe, and Showings by Julian of Norwich.

I had just gotten saved when I first read them and didn't care for them as much as when I re-read them all a few years later. Great literature!
 
Originally posted by VirginiaHuguenot
Originally posted by JonathanHunt
All this said, of course it is a bit tough for children, but there is a wonderful adaptation called 'Little Pilgrim's Progress' by Helen Taylor, which I read to my son, who is 7. He loves it. I can hardly contain myself sometimes, reading it to him.

JH

Are there any editions for even younger children, like, say, 3-4 years old? Board books? Good illustrations, perhaps?

I would say that Little Pilgrim's Progress is perfectly readable to a 3 or 4 year old. It does have some pictures. I think that to simplify the tale too much, loses too much!

JH
 
I think Bunyan reminds me of Langland more than anyone else, I'm surprised the reviewer didn't mention Langland.
 
Yes, Pilgrim's Progress is wonderful! But don't stop there! Read Bunyan's The Holy War and Grace Abounding. Both of those are great books as well. I actually perfer the perspecitve he takes in the Holy War over the Pilgrim's Progress at many points.

Bryan
SDG
 
Was it after John Bunyan died that it became popular?In a way I hope so as a way to have him come before Christ and glorify Christ completely for what work he did through him(JB).And not to ever know while alive in the flesh because of his own sinfulness could have led him to pride for his work.If you understand what I am saying.
 
I think he probably heard of it - it's a literary genre we don't have any more. Langland probably would have sympathised with the Lollards, but he was still pretty Catholic.
 
I have to say...I don't think this is in the modern versions but....the copy I have of the original version has verses listed in the sidebars all throughout the book. Each section, paragraph, thought, or even sentence is referenced with a verse. Wonderful for looking things up.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top