Review - 15" MacBook Air

Status
Not open for further replies.

Phil D.

Puritan Board Senior
A few weeks ago my 4-1/2 year old 16" MacBook Pro (a generous gift) died on me. Literally just died. Turned out the logic board (the heart of the computer) had some kind of random catastrophic failure, something the tech told me has less than a 1 in 10,000 chance of happening...

I should probably have been mad enough at Apple to switch to a PC of some kind, but with everything I have synched between my various Apple devices that wasn't a practical option. It definitely would have been quite therapeutic, but not at all sensible...

Over the last few years I've determined that the way I use a laptop doesn't warrant a Pro version of MacBook anyway, so for a replacement I opted for a much less expensive AirBook. Of course the conventional rule is that means a lot less performance. However, to my very pleasant surprise, the new 15" Air is noticeably superior to my older Pro in almost every aspect - speed, display, sound, pretty much everything is appreciably better. For example, my fairly sizable Logos program and library updates and fully syncs in less than 30 seconds, rather than the 20 minutes or more it took on the older Pro. Webpages and programs load in about 1/3 the time (in many cases instantly), etc...

As I've read more about it, this impressive performance is primarily due to Apple's relatively new Silicone processors, the M1 and now the M2. Rather than using adapted Intel chips as they had prior to 2020, the Silicone chips are designed and produced by Apple, which allows for optimization with their OS, with pretty amazing results.

Another thing I really like is that the the efficiency of the M2 allows the Air to be fan-less, as cooling is achieved passively by dissipating any heat through the body of the computer. A downside to this is that if the processor does start to heat up, then instead of kicking on a fan, the CPU is throttled back to keep it from overheating. But in just running basic programs and browsing general web content, most folks such as myself are unlikely to realize any appreciable reduction in performance when this might occur. What I like most about the fan-less design is that it allows the Air to be used as a true laptop. I don't have to worry about blocking any air vents, or having my lap get uncomfortably warm.

Bottom line, I think Apple has hit a sweet spot with the new 15" Air. Size/weight, performance, display, sound and price point, altogether create a new and impressive standard in laptop computers. I expect it will quickly come to dominate within the MacBook market space. And hopefully it will last longer than 4-1/2 years...
 
Last edited:
I do think Logos performance on a Silicon Mac is really pretty much peak performance. Any further upgrades will have lesser margins that are negligible
 
I do think Logos performance on a Silicon Mac is really pretty much peak performance. Any further upgrades will have lesser margins that are negligible

Agreed. It's hard to see how it could really run any better. Having an 8-core CPU and 10-core GPU probably has a lot to do with it as well.
 
You may want to invest in a 4k monitor which can be gotten around 200 plus or so. Dell 2722 qc is what I use. Reading Logos on a 4k is really efficient in terms of how much material you can swath through.
 
Bottom line, I think Apple has hit a sweet spot with the new 15" Air. Size/weight, performance, display, sound and price point, altogether create a new and impressive standard in laptop computers. I expect it will quickly come to dominate within the MacBook market space. And hopefully it will last longer than 4-1/2 years...
:agree:
 
I recently purchased a 16GB / 1 TB 15" Air. Even for my software developer workload, it is more than sufficient, and I can run Windows 11 ARM under Parallels for Windows based development work. Light and fan-less. Runs Logos exceedingly well too.

I have it docked to my 5K UltraWide LG monitor. Doesn't miss a beat - does it all. With phenomenal battery life - can run it confidently all day. I have no real need for a MacBook Pro anymore.

Way faster than my old Intel MacBook Pro which was a hot mess - literally.
 
This is helpful. I want to work a macbook into the budget. This gives me confidence when the time comes.
 
Can one swap Word Perfect and/or Word docs back and forth between a MacBook and a PC? Or are there compatibility differences?
Microsoft Word exists on both platforms and they use the same file format in modern versions. Practically I have not had a problem working in an office that uses Word documents sometimes and has a mix of PC and Mac. In theory, there are some differences if you're a heavy user or doing layout work.

As for WordPerfect, I haven't used it in many years. It looks like there is not a current version of WordPerfect for macOS, only Windows. I imagine you could find a way to read your WordPerfect files on Mac.
 
Microsoft Word exists on both platforms and they use the same file format in modern versions. Practically I have not had a problem working in an office that uses Word documents sometimes and has a mix of PC and Mac. In theory, there are some differences if you're a heavy user or doing layout work.

As for WordPerfect, I haven't used it in many years. It looks like there is not a current version of WordPerfect for macOS, only Windows. I imagine you could find a way to read your WordPerfect files on Mac.
Can’t modern Word versions read WordPerfect? I haven’t used WordPerfect since the 80s I don’t think.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top