We get Consumer Reports and they do in-depth car reports going back many years. Their reliability reports for this year going back to 2003 show the models that earned better than average over the last 5-6 years overall were:
Acura (all models), Ford F150's, Ford Escape, Ford Focus, Ford Fusion (only been around 3 yrs), all Honda models, Hyundia Santa Fe, Hyundai Sonata, Hyundai Tucson (3yrs), Infiniti (exc.Qx56), Jeep Patriot (2yrs), Kia Optima, Kia Spectra, Kia Sportage, Lexus all models, Lincoln Town car, Lincoln MkZ Zephyr, Mazda Miata, Mazda Tribute, Mazda Sedan, Mini Cooper hatchback, Mercury Milan (3yrs), Mitsubishi Outlander, Nissan 35 OZ, Nissan Frontier, Nissan Murano, Nissan Xterra, Pontiac Vibe, All Scion models, All Subarus, All Toyotas, Volvo s60and s80.
The stand outs that earned Much Better than Average ratings over the last 5-6yrs (except where they aren't that old) were:
The Ford Fusion(the model is only 3yrs old), Honda CR-V, Honda Civic, Honda Element, Honda Ridgeline(3yrs old), Honda S2000, Hyundai Elantra, Infiniti G35 Sedan, Infiniti M35, Kia Optima, Lexus SC, Mazda 3 Sedan, Mercury Milan (3yrs old), Nissan 35OZ, Nissan Ultima Hybrid (2yrs old), Pontiac Vibe(Yay! Jessica), Scion tC, Scion xA xD, Scion xB, Suzuki SX4 (2yrs old), Toyota 4Runner, Toyota Camry Hybrid (2yrs old), Toyota Echo Yaris Sedan, Toyota FJ Cruiser, Toyota Navigator, Toyota Highlander Hybrid (3yrs old), Toyota Matrix, Toyota Prius, and the Toyota RAV4,