False Modesty

Ezekiel

Puritan Board Freshman
This is an interesting topic and I'd like to go more into it, though it may be better for another thread so as to not get off topic on this one, but that's your call.

Could you give some examples? I think there's a way to dress respectfully and modestly as a man without looking like a 17th century puritan (as much as I'd like to dress like that...) or 19th century farmhand and drawing a ton of attention to ourselves. I suppose my question is, what is meant by "plain dress". I'm used to the matching black denim broadfall trousers, braces, and jackets of the Amish in that category, but I do see you mentioned it not being that.
I do wear these for the weather, and I wear a flannel shirt tucked into dungarees with a belt and boots too: IMG_0572.webp IMG_0573.jpeg

When that is your response to me inquiring about a set-apart life, a holy life, it came across as snarky. Maybe I misinterpreted.
It was really, really specific, because I didn't know how to send a picture. A picture sure is worth a thousand words. :)
 
Last edited:
So, the broad topic at hand is dressing modestly and respectfully as a man, without drawing attention to oneself. Would that be a fair assessment @Ezekiel ?

Here's a previous thread for context.

You mentioned you don't like the attention you get from dressing the way you do, but you also don't want to be extravagant or vain in how you dress. You can let me know whether you think this is a good question for the thread or not, but perhaps a question for this thread could be this:

How should a man dress that wants to be modest and respectful, but also doesn't stick out?
 
Sorry, I meant would that be a good question to ask.

In other words, is that a question you'd like others to answer for this thread?
Of course, nobody dresses modestly anymore, so it'll always stick out.

I forgot to add that the book said, "True fashion does not profess to distort the seasons, although the style authorities would often have us believe so for their own material gain." Nobody dresses for the weather anymore either. They wear a baseball cap instead of a straw hat or a felt hat.

You know what, I'll just wear my grandfather's old straw hat for the heat instead. People can tell I'm protecting my head from the sun. I wear a lightweight denim shirt in this weather too.

IMG_0579 2.jpeg

By the way, my grandfather's old felt hat looks just like this but it's black and made of wool.

I was surprised when I was in Philadelphia, I saw white-collar men with a hat like that in the sun. I was told nobody wears straw hats anymore. :)
 
Last edited:
I think this is an interesting topic, would wearing jewelry like a chain, watch, bracelet etc, be immodest, like I try to dress well according to my own style when I go out and I wear jewelry, but would that count as immodest?
 
I think the clothes you have listed (dungarees (jeans), flannels, and boots) are perfectly fine as far as modesty goes. Same goes for the hat and jacket. Now, they are far more common in agrarian communities and some may think it stands out as looking a bit Amish or Hutterite at times. You mention having a lot of Amish nearby. Is any of your family Amish? You don't have to answer that in this thread if you don't want to. You could do so on the Introduce Yourself Forum.

Anyways, what a man wears can have a bit to do what what he does in life. For instance, a man doing manual labor raising cattle will dress differently from a man who is a full time student at a college.

For my own typical work, I typically wear some sort of dress pants, a collared buttoned shirt and a knit cardigan or sports jacket along with leather dress shoes.

(edited)
Of course, nobody dresses modestly anymore, so it'll always stick out.

I forgot to add that the book said, "True fashion does not profess to distort the seasons, although the style authorities would often have us believe so for their own material gain." Nobody dresses for the weather anymore either. They wear a baseball cap instead of a straw hat or a felt hat.

You know what, I'll just wear my grandfather's old straw hat for the heat instead. People can tell I'm protecting my head from the sun. I wear a lightweight denim shirt in this weather too.

View attachment 13316

By the way, my grandfather's old felt hat looks just like this but it's black and made of wool.

I was surprised when I was in Philadelphia, I saw white-collar men with a hat like that in the sun. I was told nobody wears straw hats anymore. :)
 
Last edited:
I think this is an interesting topic, would wearing jewelry like a chain, watch, bracelet etc, be immodest, like I try to dress well according to my own style when I go out and I wear jewelry, but would that count as immodest?
Wearing jewelry like a chain, watch, bracelet etc. is not immodest in and of itself.

Here's something helpful William Perkins wrote in his work, The Right, Lawful, and Holy Use of Apparel

"For the honoring of the body with outward ornaments, we must remember this distinction; some ornaments are inward, and some are borrowed: Inward, are the graces and gifts of God; these are our own: Borrowed, are gold, silver, pearls, and precious stones; and these are outward: And of the two, more special care ought to be had of the inward, than of the outward and borrowed; for these are indeed fair and honorable in the opinion and estimation of men, but the other are far more honorable in the sight of God. And therefore Saint Peter exhorteth women, that their apparel be not outward, as with broidered hair, and gold set about, or in sumptuous garments; but that the hidden man of the heart be uncorrupt, with a meek and quiet spirit, which is before God a thing precious. I Pet 3:3,4."
 
I think the clothes you have listed (dungarees (aka bib overalls), flannels, and boots) are perfectly fine as far as modesty goes. Same goes for the hat and jacket. Now, they are far more common in agrarian communities and some may think it stands out as looking a bit Amish or Hutterite at times. You mention having a lot of Amish nearby. Is any of your family Amish? You don't have to answer that in this thread if you don't want to. You could do so on the Introduce Yourself Forum.

Anyways, what a man wears can have a bit to do what what he does in life. For instance, a man doing manual labor raising cattle will dress differently from a man who is a full time student at a college.

For my own typical work, I typically wear some sort of dress pants, a collared buttoned shirt and a knit cardigan or sports jacket along with leather dress shoes.
Dungarees is another word for jeans in my country, but that's what old people usually call them. I'm not old! :)
 
I think the clothes you have listed (dungarees (aka bib overalls), flannels, and boots) are perfectly fine as far as modesty goes. Same goes for the hat and jacket. Now, they are far more common in agrarian communities and some may think it stands out as looking a bit Amish or Hutterite at times. You mention having a lot of Amish nearby. Is any of your family Amish? You don't have to answer that in this thread if you don't want to. You could do so on the Introduce Yourself Forum.

Anyways, what a man wears can have a bit to do what what he does in life. For instance, a man doing manual labor raising cattle will dress differently from a man who is a full time student at a college.

For my own typical work, I typically wear some sort of dress pants, a collared buttoned shirt and a knit cardigan or sports jacket along with leather dress shoes.

Interesting!
Yep.

By the way, I decided to wear my grandfather's old straw fedora mentioned above instead of the other hat.
 
Back
Top