My kingdom is not of this world: if my kingdom were of this world, then would my servants fight, that I should not be delivered to the Jews: but now is my kingdom not from hence." John 18:36
To date, I am an Establishment Principle man.
Yet, I wonder...
if a soft critique of the Establishment Principle developed in Reformed Christian ecclesiology is in order. I want to argue, for my own benefit, that the Establishment Principle is not directly derived from the Scriptures as much as it is a product of historical and cultural circumstances, specifically the conversion of the Roman Empire to Christianity under Constantine and then later, under Emperor Theodosius I, where the Christian/Roman synergism was established (380 A.D.). Read more
My kingdom is not of this world: if my kingdom were of this world, then would my servants fight, that I should not be delivered to the Jews: but now is my kingdom not from hence." John 18:36
To date, I am an Establishment Principle man.
Yet, I wonder...
if a soft critique of the Establishment Principle developed in Reformed Christian ecclesiology is in order. I want to argue, for my own benefit, that the Establishment Principle is not directly derived from the Scriptures as much as it is a product of historical and cultural circumstances, specifically the conversion of the Roman Empire to Christianity under Constantine and then later, under Emperor Theodosius I, where the Christian/Roman synergism was established (380 A.D.). Read more
My kingdom is not of this world: if my kingdom were of this world, then would my servants fight, that I should not be delivered to the Jews: but now is my kingdom not from hence." John 18:36
To date, I am an Establishment Principle man.
Yet, I wonder...
if a soft critique of the Establishment Principle developed in Reformed Christian ecclesiology is in order. I want to argue, for my own benefit, that the Establishment Principle is not directly derived from the Scriptures as much as it is a product of historical and cultural circumstances, specifically the conversion of the Roman Empire to Christianity under Constantine and then later, under Emperor Theodosius I, where the Christian/Roman synergism was established (380 A.D.). Read more
A few questions that popped in my (admittedly post-mil, establishmentarian) head as I read your article:
Why the focus on "America"? ("It also raises important questions about how the Church should relate to the state and how Christian principles should be applied in the political sphere, especially in a secular and pluralistic America.") Wasn't the Roman Empire (and many others in between) just as "secular and pluralistic"?
If you intend to show that establishmentarianism is not directly derived from the Scriptures but is instead a product of historical and cultural circumstances, it seems odd that you have established that it was a principle held in the Church for 1,263 years. Doesn't that rather show that it transcends the varied circumstances of various nations, cultures, and empires?
Doesn't the fact that many of our wisest forefathers have "taken the concept of a state church as rather de facto, than systematically proving its origins and validity from... the New Testament" parallel similar issues (infant baptism, for example) that are likewise rather de facto in the early new covenant Church?
What is the balance between Christ proclaiming "My kingdom is not of this world" while teaching us to pray that "Thy kingdom come. Thy will be done even in earth as in heaven."? Is the Kingdom of Christ different than the Kingdom of the Father? If a dominion is established throughout all the earth by the Spirit (as it is in heaven), how would that not also bring with it massive (though perhaps incremental) positive physical/political/social changes (on earth)?
Yes, these are all the questions that I am working through as an EP man as my article indicates. Essentially I'm 'talking out loud' on my Substack, opening up my process. Thanks for taking the time to comment.
Yes, these are all the questions that I am working through as an EP man as my article indicates. Essentially I'm 'talking out loud' on my Substack, opening up my process. Thanks for taking the time to comment.
My kingdom is not of this world: if my kingdom were of this world, then would my servants fight, that I should not be delivered to the Jews: but now is my kingdom not from hence." John 18:36
To date, I am an Establishment Principle man.
Yet, I wonder...
if a soft critique of the Establishment Principle developed in Reformed Christian ecclesiology is in order. I want to argue, for my own benefit, that the Establishment Principle is not directly derived from the Scriptures as much as it is a product of historical and cultural circumstances, specifically the conversion of the Roman Empire to Christianity under Constantine and then later, under Emperor Theodosius I, where the Christian/Roman synergism was established (380 A.D.). Read more
"I want to argue, for my own benefit, that the Establishment Principle is not directly derived from the Scriptures as much as it is a product of historical and cultural circumstances, specifically the conversion of the Roman Empire to Christianity under Constantine and then later, under Emperor Theodosius I, where the Christian/Roman synergism was established (380 A.D.)."
"It appears that they uncritically assumed the validity of the State Church model and only later, much later, imported the Old Testament framework to justify a concept that originated in a very different spiritual, historical, and cultural context."
Pastor Lewis, this sounds much like the 20th century 'Verduin paradigm', maybe not intentionallly or knowlingly, but in essence it is the same?
Verduin’s (who was, I heard, one of the main figures in the CRC that helped change the ‘constantinian-christendom’ BC art. 36 view, rewriting or changing the so-called controversial 21 words …) main thesis in his book, ‘Reformers and their Stepchildren’, is that:
the Magisterial Reformers (MR) did not break fully with Rome/medievalism in their ‘church and statemedievalismand therefore later also not with the ‘monument’ of medievialism and Rome = infant baptism) = the MR were not ‘sola Scriptura’ in kingdom-calling view in terms of the relation of believers/church with the world, more important as Verduin clearly shows his own anabaptists like OT-NT view of Scripture, the MR did not follow proper “NT only”- sola Scriptura ethics and worldview, they were ‘unfortunately’ “victims” of their times…. they did not return to 'apostolic NT churchianity (as I will call it)
Now today, many ‘radical 2K's’' (dr. Robert Letham sees the dispensational problem: ) and others follow this Verduin paradigm for different reasons and explanations, but we should ask: why not go all the way, why stop with only ‘church and state’, why not see the MR's covenant, baptism, church and then … infant baptism views as also "a product of historical and cultural circumstances, specifically Rome's sacramentalism who wants to 'Christianize' everyone into Christendom via the sacraments....?
That is what Verduin does in his above mentioned book, it goes like this: Zwingli was not convinced of infant baptism as such, he went along with the Anabaptists in the 'radical reformation' and only when he ‘unfortunately’ sided with the 'State/town council', because of the radicalism of the Anabaptist, then he started with his ‘reading INTO Scripture’ covenant, infant baptism ideas, etc. = the MR were not ‘sola Scriptura in both baptism and kingdom views… can we not also say then, and tell the baptists we are both wrong in Christendom and infant baptism theology, which "only later, much later, were imported from the Old Testament framework of circumcision to justify a infant baptism concept that originated in a very different spiritual, historical, and cultural context.".... all to serve Rome's and now the new sacralists, the MR 'reformed Christendom'?
And yes, the rest of history followed, most if not all, even ‘reformed baptists’ following this paradigm… and since end of 19th century, more and more pro paedobaptist but anti-BC art. 36 reformed Christendom folks that keeps on revising the Dordt and Westminster Confessions....
Now, my problem from Scripture, confessions and church history with this kind of reasoning and re-interpretation of church history and the Magisterial Reformers (maybe because we are victims of our pluralistic times?), were given in a lecture I did a week ago at the Theological Seminary of the GKSA, for some their theological students (June 16, 2023).
It can be found here in the following link, unfortunately the lecture was in Afrikaans, but most quotes in the power point presentation were in English, and I think you will see my evaluation of Verduin’s books … and also the modern reformers following his idea/thesis = the Magisterial Reformers ‘church and state’ view were not build on Scripture, but constantianism, christendom, sacralism, etc (I am not saying all who think like that is following Verduin knowingly, but what I hear from modern day ‘radical two kingdoms’ ideas is what I read more or less already in Verduin’s book’s main thesis):
TSV LESING: GEREFORMEERDES, ANABAPTISTE EN HUL STIEFKINDERS – WIE IS DIE NASATE VAN DIE REFORMASIE?, S. Le Cornu
English: TSV Lecture - The Reformers, the Anabaptists and their Stepchildren - Who is the true children of the Reformation (discussion on two books: L. Verduin’s, Reformers and their Stepchildren, and, dr. Nigel Lee’s The Anabaptists and their Stepchildren)
a) the MR ‘reacted’ to Anabaptism in their view of infant baptism and Christendom (= both church and state must serve the Lord in their own sphere according to God’s Word), and/or
b) that ‘reactionary’ theology could be dangerous, and/or
c) that their and our times could have a big influence on our theology, bible interpretation, etc (I wonder if we moderns think we any better and more 'objkective' than our reformed forefathers in terms of the ideologies of our days influencing and determining our reading of Scripture?)
THEN, still it does not neccesarily follow that the MR could not be ‘sola Scriptura’, in both infant baptism and Christendom/kingdom views, why not?
Can someone say in 500 years time that us reformers today was pro-abortion, just because the majority of people today and liberal churches are pro abortion? Of course not, we all are children our times, past and present, but not necessarily victims of it, we and all reformers of all times can be 'contra mundum sola scriptura', why not? Same with MR?
Also, does the Lord not use times and heresies and battles to formulate true doctrine according to Scripture?
Are all our confessions and further reformations not in some sense always .... reactionary to our times, but it does not make it not 'sola et tota Scriptura'?
Does he not force his children, churches through all history through false teachers and teaching to do AD FONTES always in our times = back to Scripture to give a even more thorough in-depth biblical justification for covenant, infant baptism, and yes, a Christian biblical magistrate’s calling in His kingdom?
Was Nicene and Athanasius Creeds not in answer/reaction to heresies about the Godhead and Christ in first few centuries?
Was the Three Forms of Unity and WCF Standards not in reaction to many heresies?
Or can Rome claim against the MR that our ‘solas’ was only reactionary to some misuses in Rome, and that we therefore in reaction start to read justification by faith 'alone ‘ back into scripture’ or that ‘sola Scriptura’ was never in the Scripture as such, 'we' invented it in reacrtion to Rome, we read all the solas back into the OT/NT as reactionaries, not reformers?
Therefore, yes, semper reformanda for all times we can always agree on the basis of ‘sola Scriptura’ with our and any times and all views past and present, even with our MR brothers of the 16/17th centuries, as we indeed confess in BC art. 7 we must always do, but I find it very difficult to be convinced of the ‘Verduin paradigm’ and also what I now call, the “R2K paradigm”, which basically says ... dualistically in terms of the past:
Yes, in infant baptism the MR were great and very careful to answer the anabaptists with ‘sola scriptura’ and were thorougly ‘biblical’ in using both the OT and NT…. but when it comes to church - state relations, kingdom views, etc these same ‘modern RTK reformers’ go all the way to .... ‘Anabaptism dispensational hermeneutics in terms of relation OT-NT when we talk 'church and state', etc’ =
The reasoning is suddenly then: the MR’s (Calvin, Knox, Zwingli, BC ART. 36; WCF 23, etc) were all suddenly then "products of historical and cultural circumstances" that led to .... sola practica or sola constintiana or sola christendom or sola roma or whatever political ideas that were alive in their times, they were not biblical anymore.
Can we really say that of the MR, is that a honest assessment?
Tragic how many modern reformerssuddenly work, like Verduin calls it, a ‘NT only’ hermeneutic for ‘church state religions’, we just 'forget' the OT wisdom as confessed in WCF chapter 19; BC art. 25 et and taught by many many MR since Calvin to this day. .... In the words of dr. Mark Beach (emphasis added):
"Wind correctly points to the major conflict on the relationship of biblical covenants, stemming from the theories of Meredith Kline. He highlights the point that VanDrunen makes continual contrasts between various covenants (creation and Noachic, Noachic and Abrahamic, Abrahamic and Mosaic, Mosaic and new, new covenant inaugurated and new covenant consummated). To my mind, this is a type of Reformed dispensationalism."
The main issue is not the specific ‘church state model’ or even the detail of theocracy/theonomy (what specificallly is the magistrates tasks, or which laws still apply, this is a good 'general equity debates through all the centuries), the main issue is the acknowledgment of Meditorial Kingship of Christ for all of life, including the magistrates.
Does Ps. 2:10-12 apply also today, or was that a bygone ‘dispensational’ times that do not apply to ‘NT only’ times anymore?
Does Ps. 150:6 apply to all peoples, all authorities, all creation or not?
What is our calling everywhere, should the Law and Gospel preached, teached and applied only to some or everyone and all of live in their different task, callings, areas, etc., is the big question, which must determine our view of all these related question in the light of Acts 17:11 principle that we must seek also for our times and future.
In the words of BC art. 36 itself, does Scripture only call the church to glorify him or the whole creation and every person and all tasks and offices? Question is not what all people going to do, but what should they do (ethics, morals), etc = calling.
…. that God may be honored and worshipped by every one, as He commands in His Word.
Do we believe that is what Scriptures teach, if not, then the Anabaptists and their theology was right and we should repent.
But I don't think they were, and so did the MR also not believe.
I am a major rookie when it comes to these discussions but in my mind, it comes down to this: is God's law universal? Does everyone have to follow it? Yes. What is the role of the civil magistrate? To punish the evil and reward the good. According to what standard? God's law. What is God's law? The 10 commandments, not just commandments 6 and 8. Of course, the civil authorities can't punish coveting, it's in the mind. And they can't punish other secret things. But the things that are open, should be governed according to the 10 commandments. This means, in my mind that if I'm a civil government then I don't provide a building permit so that some muslims or buddhists can build a place of worship. That is prohibited in my land. I also make laws that say businesses must be closed on Sundays. I also make laws that make cursing God's name punishable. The exact punishments and how you go about these things is up for debate. But for me, the underlying principles are not, and they are a simple logical outworking of a) the universality of God's law and b) the role of the civil magistrate. The fact that we we or do not have a government who is willing to accept their role is besides the point.
But, if you think about it, the other 9 commandments are all outward expressions of covetousness in some way. Wasn't that (covetousness) our first parent's original sin?
The Establishment Principle is one that has generated much debate and controversy in the past and, in view of the introduction of the European Convention of Human Rights into Scottish [Read more...]
But, if you think about it, the other 9 commandments are all outward expressions of covetousness in some way. Wasn't that (covetousness) our first parent's original sin?
When does a government ever punish thoughts unless they are translated into actions? The government doesn't know my thoughts unless I express them in word or deed...
When does a government ever punish thoughts unless they are translated into actions? The government doesn't know my thoughts unless I express them in word or deed...
The Western elite liberal governments will most definitely attempt to punish and have punished thoughts - when those thoughts are expressed in words - in relation to identity politics etc. They are essentially punishing ideas that do not conform to their own ideas. The separation between thoughts and deeds can be separated too much - that's Jesus point in Matthew 5 isn't it...the hateful thought is an expression of murder, the lustful thought an expression of adultery.
In the UK a woman was recently arrested for praying silently outside a (closed!) abortion clinic - she was asked were you praying? She said yes - inward prayer was viewed, wrongly as a crime or potential crime. The case was dismissed I believe, but nevertheless the attempt was made to arrest someone for thinking inwardly towards God!
So they are punishing words and deeds, not thoughts. I don't mean to belabor the point, but you simply cannot punish thoughts - it is impossible. I followed the case you mentioned regarding the woman in England who was arrested (twice) for praying silently outside an abortion clinic. How did they know she was praying? Because she was standing there with her head bowed and her eyes closed which prompted the police to ask if she was praying (because she looked like she was) and she said, "Yes." I am not saying the law that makes it illegal to pray inside of an arbitrary buffer zone around an infanticide facility is in any way just, moral, or lawful - I am just pointing out that it was her external deeds and words that led to her arrest, not because the police were reading her mind. She was arrested for civil disobedience, and I personally applaud her.
Please don't think that I don't empathize - I am on the frontline on this issue as a public school teacher in New York State (the new guidelines we were given last week from the State Education department - 42 pages of instruction on "Creating a Safe, Supportive, and Affirming School Environment for Transgender and Gender Expansive Students" - includes measures like mandating gender inclusive math word problems, a requirement to reprint yearbooks if a student changes their gender identity, and making misgendering a student a human rights violation under NYS law). But this is a thread about the establishment principle which was summarized pretty succinctly above:
What is the role of the civil magistrate? To punish the evil and reward the good. According to what standard? God's law. What is God's law? The 10 commandments, not just commandments 6 and 8. Of course, the civil authorities can't punish coveting, it's in the mind. And they can't punish other secret things. But the things that are open, should be governed according to the 10 commandments.
For me the issue is not whether or not governments have the authority to punish words and deeds. I still subscribe to the original wording of WCF 23: civil magistrates exist for God's "own glory and the public good... for the defense and encouragement of them that are good, and for the punishment of evil-doers." (1.) They "....ought especially to maintain piety, justice, and peace, according to the wholesome laws of each commonwealth...." (.2) and "The civil magistrate... hath authority, and it is his duty, to take order, that unity and peace be preserved in the Church, that the truth of God be kept pure and entire; that all blasphemies and heresies be suppressed; all corruptions and abuses in worship and discipline prevented or reformed; and all the ordinances of God duly settled, administered, and observed...." (.3). This does not in any way recognize a supposed power of the civil magistrate to punish righteous words and deeds, nor to punish thoughts expressed as words/actions that are not related to the peace and unity of the Church, and they are bound by the rule of law in all cases.
The issue is that we do not have civil governments that are in submission to Christ as King, so we should expect to encounter unjust rule. But this is not a new issue, starting with the new covenant Church and Roman rule, which is why WCF 23 concludes with: "It is the duty of people to pray for magistrates, to honor their persons, to pay them tribute and other dues, to obey their lawful commands, and to be subject to their authority, for conscience’ sake. Infidelity or difference in religion doth not make void the magistrate’s just and legal authority, nor free the people from their due obedience to him." (.4) Note the qualifiers (in bold). I cannot obey unlawful commands - either those that oppose God's law and/or that oppose the law of land. This allows for disobeying immoral commands (for example, calling a female "him" opposes God's law in multiple ways) and allows for opposing actions contrary to "the wholesome laws of each commonwealth," which could (should) begin with legal action (as Paul did by appealing to Caesar), and then, failing that, lead to civil disobedience (such as the lady in Birmingham mentioned above), and, if necessary, end with armed rebellion (I won't invite the derailment of this thread with an example....).
And if one is persecuted for righteousness' sake (like being fired, or fined, or imprisoned for refusing to use the wrong pronouns)? Then, "Blessed are they which suffer persecution for righteousness’ sake; for theirs is the kingdom of heaven. Blessed shall ye be when men revile you, and persecute you, and say all manner of evil against you for my sake, falsely. Rejoice and be glad, for great is your reward in heaven: for so persecuted they the Prophets which were before you..... Love your enemies: bless them that curse you: do good to them that hate you, and pray for them which hurt you, and persecute you," (Matthew 5.10-12, 44) "We are afflicted on every side, yet are we not in distress: we are in doubt, but yet we despair not. We are persecuted, but not forsaken: cast down, but we perish not. Everywhere we bear about in our body the dying of the Lord Jesus, that the life of Jesus might also be made manifest in our bodies." (2 Corinthians 4:8-10)
Because she was standing there with her head bowed and her eyes closed which prompted the police to ask if she was praying (because she looked like she was) and she said, "Yes." I am not saying the law that makes it illegal to pray inside of an arbitrary buffer zone around an infanticide facility is in any way just, moral, or lawful - I am just pointing out that it was her external deeds and words that led to her arrest, not because the police were reading her mind. She was arrested for civil disobedience, and I personally applaud her.
I'm not going to belabour the point as it's not the main issue on the thread - for her the prayer was a mental thought process without the use of verbal words.....and it was for the prayer that she was arrested. The state interpreted the law as being prayer was not allowed in that place. Of course it was civil disobedience - for thinking...praying....she did nothing. Was she arrested for closing her eyes in a public place? Was she arrested for standing outside the clinic? No for praying. Silently Praying. Probably not even moving her lips.
When does a government ever punish thoughts unless they are translated into actions? The government doesn't know my thoughts unless I express them in word or deed...
I don't think so - when you stated "the role of the magistrate is not to punish thoughts but actions," I wasn't sure if you were saying that the magistrate could punish thoughts but shouldn't. I was simply stating that I don't believe the former is even possible. I often hear talk of a fear of "thought police" but I do not fear anyone but God ever knowing my thoughts.
"Thought police" most often refers to worded opinions. No one fears literal punishment based on literal "thought reading" since that technology doesn't exist. I think everyone agrees that shared thoughts in the form of self-reporting by social media posts etc should not be policed.
I wonder how all these works with liberal churches. What if there was a liberal christian civil leader? What if reformed churches have to battle liberal churches on what is the law of the land?
I wonder how all these works with liberal churches. What if there was a liberal christian civil leader? What if reformed churches have to battle liberal churches on what is the law of the land?
What's the difference between a liberal Christian civil leader and a secular Civil leader? Honest question since it seems like liberals look to the secular realm for their own adaptations to theology in order to mirror the cultural zeitgeist.
What's the difference between a liberal Christian civil leader and a secular Civil leader? Honest question since it seems like liberals look to the secular realm for their own adaptations to theology in order to mirror the cultural zeitgeist.
I don't think so - when you stated "the role of the magistrate is not to punish thoughts but actions," I wasn't sure if you were saying that the magistrate could punish thoughts but shouldn't. I was simply stating that I don't believe the former is even possible. I often hear talk of a fear of "thought police" but I do not fear anyone but God ever knowing my thoughts.
It is not the role of the magistrate to punish thoughts because it is impossible. My point is simply that they are to enforce the 10 commandments but practically speaking they cannot enforce the 10th commandment. Of course, when covetousness produces theft, then you punish that.
It is not the role of the magistrate to punish thoughts because it is impossible. My point is simply that they are to enforce the 10 commandments but practically speaking they cannot enforce the 10th commandment. Of course, when covetousness produces theft, then you punish that.
I do not think an establishmentarian would agree. As WCF 23.3 points out, "The civil magistrate... hath authority, and it is his duty, to take order, that unity and peace be preserved in the Church, that the truth of God be kept pure and entire; that all blasphemies and heresies be suppressed...." So I could see policing what people post in social media in a land with an established church if people are spreading blasphemy or false doctrines. Not that every such post would be quashed - the magistrate would still have to decide if it rose to the level of threatening the unity, peace, and purity of the Church (the establishment principle does not = no religious freedom). Even in secular law someone can be held liable for libel if their social post states something false about another person, or held accountable for inciting a riot via an online post. Or perhaps I am misunderstanding what you mean by:
shared thoughts in the form of self-reporting by social media posts