(Bringing this over from the other thread)I have been a member for a while of a PCA church, which, while conservative/traditional, does practice some things I cannot in good conscience participate in (hymns, unison readings, etc.). There's no sin as long as not participating in what one thinks is not prescribed for public worship by Scripture. To say one sins by being present while these things occur but are not participated in is basically the separatist position that Presbyterians opposed in the 17th century; see James Durham's treatise concerning scandal and Rutherford against separatism. See some literature here.
Questions for those who hold to a "strict" view of the RPW...
How does one define "participating"? And is there always a clear distinction between just being there (attending a service, observing, etc.) versus participating in the service?
Examples:
- If one holds to acapella exclusive Psalmody, is it OK to sing Psalms to instrumental accompaniment as long as you are not the one playing the instrument?
- Is it OK to observe an Advent candle lighting ceremony as long as you are not the one lighting the candle?
- If one holds to a strict view of congregational singing only, is it OK to sit through a choral anthem as long as you do not sing in the choir?
- If one does not believe in the observance of holy days, is it OK to attend an Advent Sunday service...does this imply consent to or condone all that is going on in these services such as candle lighting ceremonies, Christmas trees in the meeting place, etc.?
These are just a few examples...I'm sure there are numerous others.
Thank you!